The resurgence of informal street trading poses serious challenges for local officials responsible for the maintenance of public space. This article contextualises the tension between public space recuperation and informality, providing a detailed case study of Bogotá, Colombia (population 7.6 million). From 1988 to 2003, Bogotá's mayors implemented one of the most ambitious public space campaigns in Latin America. The `tipping-points' behind Bogotá's transition are illuminated with emphasis on the introduction of free mayoral elections and the enervation of informal vendor unions. Using a cohort panel design, this research also examines the working conditions and occupational hazards faced by vendors both before and after relocation to government-built markets. It reveals how formalised vendors experienced declining income levels, but improved working conditions. The final section examines public policy implications and the extent to which Bogotá's experience follows traditional models of public space planning in Latin America and the Caribbean.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Alcaldía Mayor de Bogotá D.C., Secretaría de Gobierno, Fondo de Ventas Populares (2001) Informe gerencia junta directivo. Unpublished mimeograph.
2.
Benería, L. (2001) Shifting the risk: new employment patterns, informalization, and women's work, International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society, 15(1), pp. 27—53.
3.
Birkbeck, C. (1978) Self-employed proletarians in an informal factory: the case of Cali's garbage dump, World Development, 6(9/10), pp. 1173—1185.
4.
Bluestone, D.M. (1991) `The pushcart evil' peddlers, merchants, and New York city's streets, 1890—1940, Journal of Urban History , 18(1), pp. 68—92.
5.
Bromley, R. (1978) Organization, regulation and exploitation in the so-called urban informal sector: the street traders of Cali, Colombia, World Development, 6, pp. 1161—1171.
6.
Bromley, R. (2000) Street vending and public policy: a global review , International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 20(1/2), pp. 1—29.
7.
Bromley, R.D.F. (1998) Informal commerce: expansion and exclusion in the historic centre of the Latin American city, International Journal of Urban and RegionalPlanning, 22(2), pp. 245—263.
8.
Cabrales Barajas, L.F. (2005) The historic center of Morelia: a case of successful negotiation, Journal of Latin AmericanGeography, 4(2), pp. 35—56.
9.
Cámara de Comercio de Bogotá (1998) La Bogotá que todos soñamos: resumen del estudio Monitor de competitividad para Bogotá 1997. Bogotá: Cámara de Comercio de Bogotá.
10.
Caracol Radio (2001) Vendedores ambulantes presentan quejas a las FARC . 29 July.
11.
Centeno, M.A. and Portes, A. (2006) The informal economy in the shadow of the state , in: P. Fernández-Kelly (Ed.) Out of the Shadows: Political Action and the Informal Economy in Latin America , pp. 23—48. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
12.
Centro de Estudios de Desarrollo Económico ( 2005) Efecto de las ventas callejeras sobre los establecimientos de comercio en cuatro zonas de la ciudad de Bogotá. Bogotá : Cámara de Comercio de Bogotá.
13.
Cepeda Espinosa, M.J., Córdoba Triviño, J. and Escobar Gil, R. (2003) Sentencia T-772/03. Corte Constitucional de Colombia (http://www.segobdis.gov.co/documentos/juridicas/tutela_772-2003_vendedores_ambulantes.pdf; accessed 6 March 2006).
14.
Contraloría de Bogotá (2004a) Auditoría integral al Fondo de Ventas Populares . Bogotá: Contraloría de Bogotá .
15.
Contraloría de Bogotá (2004b) Evaluación de la política de ventas ambulantes del Distrito Capital, 1998—2003. Bogotá: Contraloría de Bogotá.
16.
Corte Constitucional de Colombia (2007) Datos de Secretaria General a Relatoría: fallos de tutela eventual revisión ( www.constitucional.gov.co/corte; accessed 7 February, 2007).
17.
Cross, J. (1998) Informal Politics: Street Vendors and the State in Mexico City. Stanford. CA: Stanford University Press.
18.
Cross, J. (2000) Street vendors, modernity and postmodernity: conflict and compromise in the global economy, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 20(1/2), pp. 30—52.
19.
Cutsinger, L. (2000) Tips of the trade: street vendors and the state in Barbados, West Indies, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 20(3/4), pp. 64—75.
20.
Davis, M. (2006) Planet of Slums. London: Verso.
21.
Departamento Administrativo Nacional de Estadística and Departamento Administrativo Planeación Distrital (2003) Encuesta de calidad de vida. Bogotá.
22.
Donovan, M.G. (2000) After the smoke clears: the urban survival of Colombia's 1,900,000 displaced persons, Common Sense ( University of Notre Dame), April, p. 4.
23.
Donovan, M.G. (2002) Space wars in Bogotá: the recovery of public space and its impact on street vendors. MCP thesis, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/16811 ).
24.
Donovan, M.G. (2004) La guerra por el espacio en Bogotá: la recuperación del espacio público y su impacto sobre los vendedores ambulantes (1988—2003) , Territorios:Revista de estudios regionales y urbanos, 12, pp. 109—146.
25.
Dowall, D.E. and Treffeisen, P.A. (1990) Urban development and land and housing market dynamics in Bogotá, Colombia. Working Paper No. 525, Institute of Urban and Regional Development, University of California, Berkeley, CA.
26.
Econometría (1999) Evaluación de los impactos socioeconómicos y ambientales del Proyecto Tercer Milenio . Unpublished mimeograph.
27.
El Tiempo (1993) La seguridad el mayor problema de la ciudad, 4 August, p. 1-D.
28.
El Tiempo (1999) El paso de economía informal a empresarial, 24 November, p. 6-D.
29.
El Tiempo (2001) Ley contra el espacio público, 15 June.
30.
El Tiempo (2005) Así es el perfil de quienes compran y venden en el espacio público, 23 May, p. 2.
31.
Fondo de Ventas Populares (1995) Programa y proyectos de ubicación física de vendedores ambulantes. Unpublished mimeograph.
32.
Fondo de Ventas Populares (2001) Informe Gerencia Junta Directiva—Junio 8-01 . Unpublished mimeograph.
33.
Fondo de Ventas Populares (2003) Reporte del Fondo de Ventas Populares Entregado a Contraloría Distrital. Unpublished mimeograph.
34.
Fondo de Ventas Populares (2004) Encuesta socio-económica línea de base del Fondo de Ventas Populares. Co-ordinated by Alberto Castañeda Cordy.
35.
Freeman, J.P. (2002) Face to face but worlds apart: the geography of class in the public space of Rio de Janeiro. PhD thesis, University of California, Berkeley, CA.
36.
Gehl, J. (2004) Bogotá: la nueva vida urbana en una ciudad reconquistada , in: G. Martin and M. A. Ceballos Arévalo (Eds) Bogotá: Anatomía de Una Transformación: Políticas de Seguridad y Convivencia Ciudadana 1995—2003 , pp. 131— 138. Bogotá: Editorial Pontificia Universidad Javeriana .
37.
Gilbert, A. (1997) Employment and poverty during economic restructuring: the case of Bogotá, Colombia, UrbanStudies, 34(7), pp. 1049—1074.
38.
Gilbert, A. (2006) Good urban governance: evidence from a model city , Bulletin of Latin American Research, 25(3), pp. 392—419.
39.
Gilbert, A. and Dávila, J. (2002) Bogotá: progress within a hostile environment, in: D. J. Myers and H. Dietz (Eds) Capital City Politics in Latin America: Democratization and Empowerment, pp. 29—63. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
40.
Gil Cardenas, C.E. (1998) Etnografía de las organizaciones de la venta informal de la calle en Bogotá. Anthropology thesis, Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá.
41.
Giuliani, R.W. and Bratton, W.J. (1994) Police strategy no. 5: reclaiming the public spaces of New York. Office of the Mayor, New York.
42.
Gómez Alzate, C. (1992) La cara del sector informal. Instituto de Estudios Sociales, Juan Pablo II, Bogotá.
43.
Gómez, L.R., Huertas, G. and Olea, D. (1998) Desafíos de la modernización y sector informal urbano: el caso deColombia. ILO , Lima.
44.
Gonzales, L. (1986) Vendedores ambulantes: aspectos socio-económicos. Sociology thesis, Universidad Nacional de Colombia, Bogotá.
45.
Hansen, K.T. (2004) Who rules the streets? The politics of vending space in Lusaka, in: K. T. Hansen and M. Vaa (Eds) Reconsidering Informality: Perspectives from Urban Africa, pp. 62—80. Uppsala: Nordic Africa Institute.
46.
Harper, M. (1996) Urban planning and the informal sector, Regional Development Dialogue, 17(1), pp. 97—112.
47.
ILO (International Labour Organisation) (2002 a) Report VI: decent work in the informal economy, in: ILO (Ed.) 90th International Labour Conference Proceedings. Geneva: ILO.
48.
ILO (2002b) Women and men in the informal economy: a statistical picture. ILO, Geneva .
49.
ILO (2005) 2005 labour overview: Latin America and the Caribbean. ILO, Lima.
50.
ILO (2006) 2006 labour overview: Latin America and the Caribbean. ILO, Lima.
51.
Instituto Distrital de Cultura y Turismo ( 1998) Opinión de los ciudadanos de Santa Fe de Bogotá sobre el centro de la ciudad . Unpublished mimeograph.
52.
Jones, G.A. and Varley, A. (1994) The contest for the city centre: street traders versus buildings, Bulletin of Latin American Research, 13(1), pp. 27—44.
53.
Karides, M. (2000) Whose solution is it? Development ideology and the work of micro-entrepreneurs in Caribbean context, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 25(1/2), pp. 30—62.
54.
Kongtip, P., Thongsuk, W., Yoosook, W. and Chantanakul, S. (2006) Health effects of metropolitan traffic-related air pollutants on street vendors, Atmospheric Environment , 40, pp. 7138—7145.
55.
Lanzetta de Pardo, M., Murillo Castaño, G. and Triana Soto, Á. (1988) The articulation of formal and informal sectors in the economy of Bogotá, Colombia, in: A. Portes, M. Castells and L. Benton (Eds) The Informal Economy: Studies in Advanced and Less Developed Countries, pp. 95—110. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
56.
Latouche, S. (1993) In the Wake of an Affluent Society: An Exploration of Post-Development. London: Zed Books.
57.
Lewinson, A.S. (1998) Reading modernity in urban space: politics, geography, and the informal sector of downtown Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, City & Society, 10(1), pp. 205—222.
58.
López Castaño, H., Henao, M.L. and Sierra, O. (1986) El sector informal enColombia : estructura, dinamica y políticas. Centro de Investigaciones Económicas, Medellín.
59.
Low, S.M. (2000) On the Plaza: The Politics of Public Space and Culture. Austin, TX: University of Texas Press.
60.
Maldonado, C. and Hurtado, M. (Eds) (1997) El sector informal enBogotá: una perspectiva interdisciplinaria. ILO, Bogotá.
61.
Martin, G. and Ceballos Arévalo, M.A. (2004) Bogotá: Anatomía de Una Transformación: Políticas de Seguridad y Convivencia Ciudadana 1995—2003 . Bogotá: Editorial Pontificia Universidad Javeriana.
62.
Marulanda, O. (1976) El sector informal en la economía urbana de Bogotá , D.E. Oficina de Investigaciones Socio-economicas y Legales (OFISEL), Bogotá.
63.
Maruri, E. (2001) Marginality and the informal sector: the Bogotá case. MSc thesis, University College London.
64.
McCullagh, C.B. (1978) Colligation and classification in history, History and Theory, 13, pp. 267—284.
65.
McGee, T.G. (1974) Hawkers in Hong Kong: a study of planning and policy in a Third World City. Monographs and Occasional Papers, No. 17, Centre of Asian Studies, Hong Kong.
66.
Melo Moreno, V. (2001) La calle: espacio geográfico y vivencia urbana en Santa Fé de Bogotá. Instituto Distrital de Cultura y Turismo, Bogotá.
67.
Middleton, A. (2003) Informal traders and planners in the regeneration of historic city centres: the case of Quito, Ecuador, Progress in Planning, 59, pp. 71—123.
68.
Montezuma, R. (2003) La Transformación deBogotá , 1995—2000: Entre Redefinición Ciudadana y Espacial. Bogotá: Fundación CiudadHumana .
69.
Mosca, J. (1987) Bogotá: Ayer, Hoy y Mañana. Bogotá: Villegas Editores.
70.
Moser, C. (1977) The dual economy and marginality debate and the contribution of microanalysis: market sellers in Bogotá, Development and Change, 8(4), pp. 465—489.
71.
Murillo Castaño, G. and Lanzetta de Pardo, M. (1985) The urban informal sector in Colombia: a review of the literature and outline of research priorities , Comparative Urban Research, 11, pp. 126—136.
72.
Murphy, M. (1990) The need for a re-evaluation of the concept `informal sector': the Dominican case, in: M. E. Smith (Ed.) Perspectives on the Informal Economy, pp. 161—181. Lanham, MD: University Press of America .
73.
Nelson, N.L. (1992) Public order and private entrepreneurs: the pocket economy of street vending in Bogotá, Colombia. PhD thesis, University of New Mexico.
74.
Noé Cely, J. (1996) Organizaciones del sector informal en Bogotá: perfil y diagnóstico. Proyecto Interregional sobre el Sector Informal Urbano 7. ILO, Lima.
75.
Olea Suárez, D.M. and Huertas Laverde, G. (1996) Mercados callejeros enBogotá : soluciones integrales del impacto socioeconómico. ILO, Lima.
76.
Ortiz Murillo, M. (2002) El neoambulante en el neoliberalismo: la informalidad del comercio callejero en la Ciudad de México, Acta Sociológica , 34, pp. 92—116.
77.
Otero, M. (1994) The role of governments and private institutions in addressing the informal sector in Latin America, in: C. Rakowski (Ed.) Contrapunto: The Informal Sector Debate in Latin America, pp. 177—198. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press.
78.
Peattie, L.R. (1974) The informal sector: a few facts from Bogotá. Some comments and a list of issues. Mimeograph, Rotch Library of Architecture and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA.
79.
Peattie, L.R. (1982) What is to be done with the informal sector? A case study of shoe manufacturers in Colombia, in: H. Safa (Ed.) Towards a Political Economy of Urbanization in Third World Countries, pp. 208—232. Delhi: Oxford University Press.
80.
Peña, S. (1999) Informal markets: street vendors in Mexico City , Habitat International, 23(3), pp. 363—372.
81.
Perlman, J.E. (2006) The metamorphosis of marginality: four generations in the favelas of Rio de Janeiro, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 606, pp. 154—177.
82.
Personería de Santa Fé de Bogotá (1993) Informe y estadísticas de muertes violentas y otras. Personería de Santa Fé de Bogotá , Bogotá.
83.
Portes, A. and Hoffman, K. (2003) Latin American class structures: their composition and change during the neoliberal era, Latin American Research Review, 38(1), pp. 41—82.
84.
Richardson, H. (1984) The role of the informal sector in developing countries: an overview, Regional Development Dialogue, 5(2), pp. 3—40.
85.
Roy, A. and AlSayyad, N. (Eds) (2004) Urban Informality: Transnational Perspectives from the Middle East, Latin America, and South Asia. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books.
86.
Sánchez López de Mesa, A. (2004) Política del espacio y vendedores informales en el espacio de la política. Universidad Nacional de Colombia , Bogotá.
87.
Sánchez, F., Espinosa, S. and Rivas, Á. (2003) Garrote o zanahoria? Factores asociados a la disminución de la violencia, homicida y el crimen en Bogotá, 1993—2002. Documento CEDE 2003-27.
88.
Sanyal, B. (1988) The urban informal sector revisited, Third World Planning Review, 10, pp. 65—83.
89.
Sassen, S. (2000) The demise of pax Americana and the emergence of informalization as a systemic trend, in: F. Tarak and M. A. Crichlow (Eds) Informalization: Process and Structure, pp. 91—115. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
90.
Scarpaci, J.L. (2005) Plazas and Barrios: Heritage Tourism and Globalization in the Latin American Centro Histórico. Tucson, AZ: University of Arizona Press.
91.
Schneider, F. (2005) Shadow economies around the world: what do we really know?, European Journal of Political Economy, 21, pp. 598—642.
92.
Secretaría de Hacienda de Bogotá (2005) Economía popular, espacio público y vendedores informales en Bogotá, Desarrollo social de Bogotá, D.C. Informe especial: Espacio público. No. 1., pp. 3—20.
93.
Segovia Mora, G. (1994) La Violencia en Santafé de Bogotá. Bogotá: ECOE Ediciones.
94.
Semana (2003) La conquista del espacio, 28 November.
95.
Seppänen, M. (1998) Street vendors in the historic center of Lima: utilitarian space versus a museum city. Working Paper No. 9/98, Helsinki Institute of Development Studies.
96.
Smart, J. (1986) The impact of government policy on hawkers: a study of the effects of establishing a hawker permitted place, AsianJournal of Public Administration, 8(2), pp. 260—279.
Suárez Zúuñiga, Á. (1995) Las ventas callejeras: documento para discusión. UNDP—Alcaldía de Bogotá, mimeograph.
99.
Thomas, J. (2001) What is the informal economy, anyway?, SAIS Review, 21(1), pp. 1—11.
100.
Ward, P.M. (2005) The lack of `cursive thinking' within social theory and public policy: four decades of marginality and rationality in the so-called slum, in: C. H. Wood and B. R. Roberts (Eds) Rethinking Development in Latin America, pp. 271—296. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University .
101.
Willis, E., Garman, C. da C. B. and Haggard, S. (1999) The politics of decentralization in Latin America , Latin American Research Review, 34(1), pp. 7—56.
102.
Wilson, J.Q. and Kelling, G.L. (1982) Broken windows: the police and neighborhood safety , Atlantic Monthly, 249, pp. 29—38.
