Comment on Whitt and Yago,"Corporate Strategies and the Decline of Transit in U.S. Cities" (Urban Affairs Quarterly 21: 37-65,1985)

Abstract

Whitt and Yago argue that balanced transportation never developed in the United States because consumer options and spatial densities were illegitimately manipulated by an auto-oil-rubber complex. On this basis they criticize the conventional technology-efficiency hypothesis. This comment reviews the principal arguments and sources of evidence offered by Whitt and Yago. Their arguments presume that balanced transportation is feasible and desirable in the United States simply because it exists in Europe, rest on theoretical assumptions of class struggle and rational planning which are not demonstrated, and become internally contradictory in comparing the U.S. and European cases. Because the authors blend together political and economic analysis, evaluation of transportation options winds up depending on whose class interests an investigator proposes to favor. They therefore side-step the methodological problems of ever demonstrating the superiority of balanced transportation, since its existence in Europe is likewise attributed to political struggle.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

BARACH, P. and M. S. BARATZ (1963) "Decisions and non-decisions." Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev. 57: 632-642.

BAUMOL, W. J. , J. C. PANZAR , and R. D. WILLIG (1982) Contestable Markets and the Theory of Industry Structure. New York: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.

BERRY, G.J.L. , J. W. SIMMONS , and R. J. TENNANT (1963) "Urban populations: structure and change." Geographical Rev. 53: 389-405.

FOLLAIN, J. R. , B. RENAUD , and G-C. LIM (1979) "Economic forces underlying urban decentralization trends: a structural model for density gradients applied to Korea." Environment and Planning A 11: 541-551.

GORDON, P. and H. L. WONG (1985) "The costs of urban sprawl: some new evidence." Environment and Planning A 17: 661-666.

GOTTMAN, J. (1967) "Urban sprawl and its ramifications," pp. 3-20 in J. Gottman and R. A. Harper (eds.) Metropolis on the Move: Geographers Look at Urban Sprawl. New York: John Wiley.

HAMER, A. M. (1973) Industrial Exodus from Central City: Public Policy and the Comparative Costs of Location. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.

HAMER, A. M. (1976) The Selling of Rapid Rail Transit: Balanced Urban Transportation. Lexington, MA: D. C. Heath.

KAIN, J. F. (1970) "Postwar changes in land use in the American city," pp. 74-83 in D. P. Moynihan (ed.) Toward a National Urban Policy. New York: Basic Books.

10.

LINN, J. F. (1982) "The costs of urbanization in developing countries." Econ. Development and Cultural Change 30 (April): 625-648.

11.

MANLEY, J. (1983) "Neopluralism: class analysis of pluralism I and pluralism II. " Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev. 77: 368-383.

12.

MEYER, J. R. and J. A. GOMEZ-IBANEZ (1981) Autos, Transit and Cities. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.

13.

MEYER, J. R. , J. F. KAIN , and M. WOHL (1972) The Urban Transportation Problem. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univ. Press.

14.

MUTH, R. F. (1961) "The spatial structure of the housing market." Papers and Proceedings of the Regional Sci. Assn. 7: 207-220.

15.

ROY, W. G. (1984) "Class conflict and social change in historical perspective." Annual Rev. of Sociology 10: 483-506.

16.

SHEPSLE, K. A. and B. R. WEINGAST (1984) "Political solutions to market problems." Amer. Pol. Sci. Rev. 78 (June): 417-434.

17.

SNELL, B. C. (1984) American Ground Transport. Washington, DC: Subcommittee on Antitrust and Monopoly of Judiciary Committee, U.S. Senate.

18.

ST. CLAIR, D. J. (1981) "The motorization and decline of urban public transit, 1935-1950." J. of Econ. History 41 (September): 579-606.

19.

SULLIVAN, A. M. (1984) "Large-lot zoning as second-best policy." J. of Regional Sci. 24 (November): 581-590.

20.

WHITT, J. A. (1979) "Toward a class-dialectical model of power: an empirical assessment of three competing models of political power. " Amer. Soc. Rev. 44 (February): 81-100.

21.

WHITT, J. A. (1982) Urban Elites and Mass Transportation: The Dialectics of Power. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press.

22.

WHITT, J. A. and G. YAGO (1985) "Corporate strategies and the decline of transit in U.S. cities." Urban Affairs Q. 21 (September): 37-65.

23.

YAGO, G. (1980) "Corporate power and urban transportation: a comparison of public transit's decline in the United States and Germany," pp. 296-323 in M. Zeitlin (ed.) Classes, Class Conflict, and the State: Empirical Studies in Class Analysis. Cambridge, MA: Winthrop.

24.

YAGO, G. (1982) "Class politics, mass transit, and the city: Frankfurt/Main and Chicago," pp. 299-338 in R. F. Tomasson (ed.) Comparative Social Research. Greenwich, CT: JAI.

25.

YAGO, G. (1983) "The coming crisis of U.S. transportation." Int. J. of Urban and Regional Research 7: 577-602.

26.

YAGO, G. (1984) The Decline of Transit: Urban Transportation in German and U.S. Cities, 1900-1970. New York: Cambridge Univ. Press.