This article finds no evidence to support the contention that moderate rent control over a three- to five-year period has led to a reduction in multifamily residential construction, a decline in maintenance, an erosion of the tax base relative to non-rent-controlled cities, or an increase in abandonments or demolitions. Those studies arguing the reverse are characterized by data rendered suspect because of nonrepresentative sampling and highly selective statistics. While all available data suggest that short-term moderate controls have no measurable negative impact, this does not imply that no such relationship exists. More research is needed to study the long-term effects of moderate controls.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ACHTENBERG, E. (1976) "Evaluation of rent control as a housing policy," pp. 1-45 in Bureau of National Affairs Housing and Development Reporter and the Institute for Professional and Executive Development, Inc. (ed.) Seminar on Rent Controls. Washington, DC: Bureau of National Affairs Housing and Development Reporter.
2.
ACHTENBERG, E. (1975) Critique of the Rental Housing Association Rent Control Study: An Analysis of the Realities of Rent Control in the Greater Boston Area. Boston: Urban Planning Aid.
3.
ACHTENBERG, E. (1974) Why Rent Control is Needed. Boston: Urban Planning Aid.
4.
Apartment and Office Building Association , (1977) "Fact sheet-deterioration and abandonment," pp. 130-140 in National Association of Realtors (ed.) Rent Control Report. Chicago: National Association of Realtors.
5.
ATLAS, J. (1981) "Writing a strong, but legal rent control law," pp. 121-126 in J. Gilderbloom (ed.) Rent Control: A Source Book. Santa Barbara, CA: Foundation for National Progress, Housing Information Center.
6.
BARNES, P. (1981) "Lamenting the rent," pp. 16-20 in J. Gilderbloom (ed.) Rent Control: A Source Book. Santa Barbara, CA: Foundation for National Progress, Housing Information Center.
7.
BLUMBERG, E. , B. Q. ROBBINS, and K. K. BARR (1974) "The emergence of second generation rent control."Clearinghouse Rev. (August): 240-249.
8.
BRENNER, J. and H. FRANKLIN (1977) Rent Control in North America and Europe. Washington, DC: Potomac Institute.
9.
California Housing Council, Inc. (1977) The Case Against Rent Control. San Mateo, CA: Author.
10.
"The cities: Empty homes" (1977) Newsweek (October 10).
11.
Coalition for Housing (1977) "Rent" Control and the Housing Crisis in Southern California. Los Angeles: Author.
12.
DAVIDSON, H. A. (1978) "The impact of rent control on apartment investment."Appraisal J. (October): 270-280.
13.
de JOUVENEL, B. (1948) No Vacancies. Irvington-on-Hudson, NY: Foundation for Economic Education, Inc.
14.
ECKERT, J. (1977) "The effect of rent controls on assessment policies, differential incidence of taxation and income adjustment mechanisms for rental housing in Brookline, Massachusetts." Ph.D. dissertation, Tufts University.
15.
FRIEDMAN, M. and G. STIGLER (1972) "USA: Roofs or ceilings? The current housing problem," pp. 19-32 in A. Seldon (ed.) Verdict on Rent Control. Worthing Sussex, England: Cormorant Press.
16.
GILDERBLOOM, J. I. (forthcoming) "The impact of moderate rent control in New Jersey: An empirical study of 26 rent controlled cities."Urban Analysis: An Int. J.
17.
GILDERBLOOM, J. I. (1980) "Moderate Rent Control: The experience of U.S. cities." Presented at Conference on Alternative State and Local Policies, Washington, D.C.
18.
GILDERBLOOM, J. I. . (1978) the Impact of Moderate Rent Control in the United States: A Review and Critique of Existing Literature. Sacramento: California Department of Housing and Community Development.
19.
GILDERBLOOM, J. I. (1976) Department of Housing and Community Development Report to Donald E. Burns, Secretary of Business and Transportation Agency, On the Validity of the Legislative Findings of A.B. 3788 and the Economic Impact of Rent Control. Sacramento: Department of Housing and Community Development.
20.
GRUEN, C. and N. GRUEN (1977) Rent Control in New Jersey: The Beginnings. San Mateo: CA California Housing Council.
21.
HAYEK, F. A. (1972) "Austria: the repercussions of rent restrictions" pp. 1-16 in A. Seldon (ed.) Verdict on Rent Control. Worthing Sussex, England: Cormorant Press.
22.
JACOB, M. (1980) Understanding Landlording. Oakland: California Housing Research Foundation.
23.
KAIN, J. (1975) "Testimony on rent control, Local Affairs Committee" (March 21). Boston: State House.
24.
Katz, Biber , and Lawrence, Inc. (1977) Report to Tax Assessor of Fort Lee."Fort Lee, NJ: Tax Assessor's Office.
25.
KEATING, D. (1976) "Rent and eviction controls: A selected annotated bibliography."Council of Planning Librarians, Exchange Bibliography 1136 (October).
26.
LAVERTY, C. (1976) Effect on Property Valuation and Assessed Valuations for Ad Valorem Taxation. Cambridge, MA: Tax Assessor's Office.
27.
LETT, M. (1976) Rent Control: Concepts, Realities, and Mechanisms. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.
28.
LOWRY, I. S. and M. TEITZ (1970) Rental Housing in New York City. New York: Rand Institute and McKinsey Company.
29.
MARCUSE, P. (1981) "Private real estate interests and the details of rent control laws," pp. 129-136 in J. Gilderbloom (ed.) Rent Control: A Source Book. Santa Barbara, CA: Foundation for National Progress, Housing Information Center.
30.
MARCUSE, P. (1979) Rental Housing in the City of New York. New York: Division of Urban Planning, Columbia University Graduate School of Urban Planning.
31.
National Urban League and the Center for Community Change (1971) The National Survey of Housing Abandonment. New York: National Urban League.
32.
New Jersey Department of Labor and Industry (1975) Summary New Jersey Residential Permits. Trenton: Author.
33.
New Jersey Department of Labor and Industry (1974) Summary New Jersey Residential Permits. Trenton: Author.
34.
New Jersey Department of Labor and Industry (1970) Summary New Jersey Residential Permits. Trenton: Author.
35.
New York Temporary State Commission on Living Costs and the Economy (1974) Report on Housing and Rents. New York: Author.
36.
NOTE (1967) "Residential rent control in New York City."Columbia J. of Law and Social Problems (June): 30-65.
37.
PAISH, F. W. (1972) "The economics of rent restriction," pp. 43-60 in A. Seldon (ed.) Verdict on Rent Control. Worthing Sussex, England: Cormorant Press.
38.
PENNANCE, F. G. (1972) "Introduction" p. xi in A. Seldon (ed.) Verdict on Rent Control. Worthing Sussex, England: Cormorant Press.
39.
PENTIFALLO, N. (1977) An Argument for the Equating of Local Property Taxes Among All the Classes of Properties. Borough of Fort Lee, NJ: Tax Assessor's Office.
40.
PHILLIPS, D. (1974) Analysis and Impact of the Rent Control Program in Lynn. Lynn, MA: Mayor's Office.
41.
RYDENFELT, S. (1972) "Rent control thirty years on," pp. 61-78 in A. Seldon (ed.) Verdict on Rent Control. Worthing Sussex, England: Cormorant Press.
42.
SAMUELSON, P. (1967) Economics: An Introductory Analysis. New York: McGraw-Hill.
43.
SELDON, A. (1972) "Preface" pp. viii-x in A. Seldon (ed.) Verdict on Rent Control. Worthing Sussex, England: Cormorant Press.
44.
SELESNICK, H. L. (1976) Rent Control. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
45.
"Sock the landlord!" (1975) Forbes (September 15): 103-105.
46.
South Coast Information Network (1980) "Housing opportunities for all."Santa Barbara, CA: Author.
47.
STERNLIEB, G. (1975) Fort Lee Rent Control. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.
48.
STERNLIEB, G. (1974) The Realities of Rent Control in the Greater Boston Area. New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy Research.
49.
U.S. Bureau of the Census (1974) Construction Reports. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
50.
U.S. Bureau of the Census (1970a) Census of Housing, General Housing Characteristics. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
51.
U.S. Bureau of the Census (1970b) Construction Reports. Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
52.
Urban Land Institute , (1976) "Prospects for rental housing production under rent control: A case study of Washington, D.C.," Research Report 240. Washington, DC: Author.
53.
WILLIS, W. (1950) "Short history of rent control laws."Cornell Law Q.36 (Fall): 54-92.
54.
YOUSEM, J. (1977) "Rent controls destructive in principle and practice," pp. 220-230 in National Association of Realtors (ed.) Rent Control Report. Chicago: Institute of Real Estate Management.
