Vapor Breakthrough from Liquid Drops Impacting Air-Permeable Chemical Protective Fabric

Abstract

The interaction between drop impact and vapor breakthrough for several kinds of air-permeable fabric composites (an outer shell with an adsorbent liner) is determined under convective flow conditions. Vapor breakthrough is measured using methyl sali cylate, a chemical agent simulant, for static and dynamic liquid drop placement on either the shell fabric alone or in combination with an activated carbon-loaded foam liner backing. Vapor concentration, detected by means of a photo-ionizer, is used to determine breakthrough curves, while image analysis provides a quantitative charac terization of the impact behavior of the liquid drops by measuring liquid spreading. splashing, and breakthrough. Drop impact velocities up to 6 m/s are measured on cotton/Kevlar®/nylon and cotton/nylon twill weave outer shell fabrics. For static drops, fabric composites with an outer wicking fabric give much lower total vapor breakthrough than do nonwicking fabrics, whereas for dynamic drops at subterminal impact velocities, the difference between nonwicking and wicking shell fabrics is re duced because of surface spreading and splashing. There is an inverse correlation be tween wetted area and vapor breakthrough due to localized vapor saturation of the adsorbent liner fabric. Below a critical drop velocity of 4.5 m/s, there is no direct liquid penetration through the shell fabric.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Asai, A. , Makoto, S. , Hirasawa, S. , and Okazaki, T. , Impact of an Ink Drop on Paper. J. Imag. Sci. Tech. 37 (2), 205-207 ( 1993).

Beehtel, S.E. , Bogy, D.B. , and Talke, F.E. , Impact of a Liquid Drop Against a Flat Surface, IBM J. Res. Develop. 25 (6), 963-971 (1981).

Berardinelli, S.P. , Micketsen, R.L. , and Roder, M.M. , Chemical Protective Clothing: A Comparison of Chemical Permeation Test Cells and Direct-Reading Instruments, Am Ind. Hyg, Assoc. J. 44 (12), 886-889 (1983).

Chandra, S. , and Avedisian. C.T. , On the Collision of a Droplet with a Solid Surface, Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. A 432, 13-41 ( 1991).

Cheng, L. , Dynamic Spreading of Drops Impacting onto a Solid Surface, Ind. Eng. Chem. Proc. Des. Dev. 16(2). 192-197 (1977).

Coletta, G.C. , Schwope, A.D. , Arons, I.J. , King, J.W. , and Sivak, A. , "Development of Performance Criteria for Protective Chemical Clothing Used Against Carcinogenic Liquids," Arthur D. Little, Cambridge. MA, 1978.

Daugherty, M.L. , Watson, A.P. , and Vo-Dinh. T. , Currently Available Permeability and Breakthrough Data Characterizing Chemical Warfare Agents and Their Simulants in Civilian Protective Chemical Clothing, J. Haz. Mater. 30, 243-267 (1992).

Engel, O.G. , Waterdrop Collisions with Solid Surfaces. J. Res. Nat. Bur. Stand. 54 (5), 281-298 ( 1955).

Levin. Z. , and Hobbs, P.V. , Splashing of Water Drops on Solid and Wetted Surfaces: Hydrodynamics and Charge Separation, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London Ser. A 269, 555-585 (1971).

10.

Madejski, J. , Solidification of Droplets on a Cold Surface, Int. J. Heat Mass Trans. 9, 1009 - 1013 ( 1976).

11.

Miller, B. , Design Criteria for Chemical Protective Clothing with Asymmetric Transport Properties. U.S. Army Natick RD&E Center, Contract No. DAAK60-83-C-0061, Unclassified, Aug. 1987.

12.

Mingheng, S. Behavior of a Liquid Droplet Impinging on a Solid Surface. Acta Mech. Sinica 17 (5), 419-425 (1985).

13.

Mutchler, C.K. , and Larson, C.L. , Splash Amounts from Waterdrop Impact on a Smooth Surface, Water Resour, Res. 7(1), 195-200 (1971).

14.

Oliver, J.F. , Initial Stages of Ink Jet Drop Impaction. Spreading, and Wetting on Paper, Tappi J. 67 (10), 90 (1984).

15.

Pal. T. , Griffin, G.D. , Miller, G.H. , Watson, A.P. , Daugherty. M.L. , and Vo-Dinh, T. Permeation Measurements of Chemical Agent Simulants through Protective Clothing Materials, J. Haz. Mater. 33, 123-141 (1993).

16.

Sansone, E.B. and Jonas, L.A. Resistance of Protective Clothing Materials to Permeation by Solvent Splash, Env. Res. 26, 340-346 (1981).

17.

Scheller, B.L. , Drop Formation and the Spreading Behavior of Newtonian and Shear Thinning Liquid Drops Impacting a Solid Surface, Doctoral thesis, University of Maine-Orono, 1994.

18.

Scheller, B.L. , and Bousfield, D.W. Newtonian Drop Impact with a Solid Surface , AIChE J. 41 (6), 1357-1367 (1995).

19.

Stow, C.D. , and Hadfield, M.G. , An Experimental Investigation of Fluict Flow Resulting from the Impact of a Water Drop with an Unyielcling Dry Surface. Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. A 373, 419-441 (1981).

20.

Stow, C.D. , and Stainer. R.D. , The Physical Products of a Splashing Water Drop, J. Meteor. Soc. Jpn. 55 (5), 518-531 (1977).

21.

Vahdat, N. , Permeation of Polymeric Materials by Toluene. Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 48 (2), 155-159 (1987).

22.

Vo-Dinh, T. , and Pal, T. , Development of a Fluorescence Quenching Technique to Detect Permeation of Chemical Agent Simutants through Protective Chemical Materials, Appl. Spec. 46 (2), 677-681(1992).