The flammability hazard and its relationship to price were assessed for 27 styles of women's nightgowns, purchased retail. Though the industry has commonly indicated that higher prices must be paid for safer garments, it was hypothesized that this would not hold among garments for which no mandatory standard beyond CS 191-53 has been imposed. Hazard was measured as the percentage of body area sustaining second degree bum, predicted through burning the nightgowns on a thermally instrumented mannequin. In general, predicted hazard was highest for cotton gowns, followed by ones of polyester/cellulosic and acetate/nylon blends, and lastly by ones of 100% polyester or nylon. Graphical and statistical analysis indicated an inverse but weak relationship between hazard and price, so the conclusion was that little if any necessary relationship exists between flammability hazard and price for the women's nightgowns. An apparent reason was the strong association between hazard and fiber content, but no discernible relationship between price and fiber content.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Anderson, J. , Providing Flame Resistant General Apparel: An Orderly Approach, J. Consumer Prod. Flamm.3, 10-20 ( 1976).
2.
Backer, S., Tesoro, G.C., Toong, T.Y., and Mousa, N.A., "Textile Fabric Flammability," MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass., 1976, pp. 236-265.
3.
Bauer, J., Flammability Laws and Standards: Their Effect on the Apparel Trade, Mod. Textiles52(8), 44-48 (1971).
4.
Bercaw, J.R., Cooperative Program on General Apparel Flammability - Status Report, in "Proc. 11th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1977, pp. 175-190.
5.
Bercaw, J.R., Status Report-Cooperative Program on General Apparel Flammability, in "Proc. 10th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1976, pp. 338-356.
6.
Buchbinder, L.B., Human Behavioral Patterns vs. Injury Severity for Apparel Fire Victims, in "Proc. 7th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1973, pp. 236-253.
7.
Buchbinder, L.B., Relationship of Garment Characteristics and Other Variables to Fire Injury Severity, Nat. Bur. Stand. Tech. Note 867, U.S. Dept. of Commerce, Washington, DC, 1975.
8.
Buettner, K. , Effects of Extreme Heat and Cold on Human Skin, II: Surface Temperature, Pain and Heat Conductivity in Experiments with Radiant Heat, J. Appl. Physiol.3, 703-713 (1951).
9.
Burke, J.F., Burns Among the Elderly, in "Proc. 10th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1976, pp. 290-296.
10.
Colebrook, L., and Colebrook, V., ThePrevention of Burns and Scalds, Lancet257(6570), 181-188 (1949).
11.
College Survey-Part II: Intimate Apparel and Accessories, Clothes Etc. 13(5), 25-26, 28, 30, 32 (1978).
12.
Crikelair, G.F., Symonds, F.C., Ollstein, R.N., and Kirsner, A.I., Burn Causation : Its Many Sides, J. Trauma8, 572-581 (1968).
13.
Dardis, R., Aaronson, S., and Lin, Y., Cost-Benefit Analysis of Flammability Standards, Am. J. Agri. Econ.60, 695-700 (1978).
14.
Dardis, R., and Stremel, J., EconomicAnalysis of a Flammability Standard for Adult Clothing, J. Consumer Prod. Flamm.8, 16-26 (1981).
15.
Dickerson, K.G., Hester, S.B., and Purdy, R.S.How Much Federal Protection Can Consumers Afford? The Case of TRIS, J. Home Econ.74(1), 15-19 (1982).
16.
Duncan, D.J., and Hollander, S.C., "Modem Retailing Management: Basic Concepts and Practices." Richard D. Irwin, Inc., Homewood, IL, 1977, pp. 394-440.
17.
Feck, G., and Baptiste, M.S., Population Data for Injury Prevention, in "Proc. 11th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1977, pp. 191-201.
18.
Goldman, A.S. , Innes, R.L., Larson, D.L., Schmitt, R.C., Abston, S., and Dobrkovsky , M., TheSilent Epidemic: Bum Injuries in Texas, Tex. Med.66, 21-23 ( 1970).
19.
Gustafson, R.J. , Jordan, K.A., Hasselbrack, S.A., Kadolph, S.J., and Johnson, R.F., Estimating Thermal Injury from Clothing Bums on a Mannequin-Finite Element Method, presented at Annual Meeting, North Central Region, Am. Soc. Agri. Engineers and Saskatchewan Region, Can. Soc. Agri. Eng, Saskatoon, Sask., 1978.
20.
Hasselbrack, S.A., In Vitro Mannequin Simulation of In Vivo Clothing Fire Accidents. Doctoral thesis, Univ. of MN, 1977.
21.
Henriques, F.C., Studies of Thermal Injury, V: The Predictability and the Significance of Thermally Induced Rate Processes Leading to Irreversible Epidermal Injury, Arch. Pathol.43, 489-502 (1947).
22.
Hertz, E., Flameproof Sleepwear for Women Set for '76, Women's Wear Daily130(7), 1, 20 (Jan. 10, 1975).
Jirak, Z., Jokl, M., Stverak, J., Techlat, R., and Coufalova, H., Correction Factors in Skin Temperature Measurement, J. Appl. Physiol.38, 752-756 (1975).
25.
Kaufman, R.G. , The Impact of Proposed Flammability Standards on Adult Sleepwear, Master's thesis, Univ. of MD, 1977.
26.
Knapp, R.G., and Lazar, A.J., Pilot Study of Clothing Ignition, Accident Prevention Laboratory, Univ. of IA, DHEW/PHS contract no. CPF69-35, 1970.
27.
Krasny, J.F. , and Fisher, A.L., LaboratoryModeling of Garment Fires, Textile Res. J.43, 272-283 (1973).
28.
Larson, D.L., and Bolieu, S., Design as a Bum Problem, in "Flame-Free '72, Proc. Flame-Free Design Conf, Houston," 1972 , pp. 22-25.
29.
LeBlanc, R.B. , and LeBlanc, D.A., The Systematic Development of Apparel Flammability Standards, in "Proc. 8th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1974, pp. 261-270.
Lin, Y., Silverman, M., Smith, B.F., and Dardis, R., Cost-Benefit Analysis of Flammability Standards for Children's Sleepwear and Clothing, J. Consumer Prod. Flamm.4, 5-28 (1977).
32.
Lipkin, A., and Hardy, J.D., Measurement of Some Thermal Properties of Human Tissues, J. Appl. Physiol.7, 212-217 (1954).
33.
Macmillan, B.G., Prevention of Postburn Complications in Bums Associated with Flammable Fabrics , in "Proc. 6th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1972 , pp. 158-166.
34.
Mandatory Versus Voluntary, Clothes10(2), 28-29 (1975).
35.
Mehta, A.K., and Wong, F., Measurement of Flammability and Bum Potential of Fabrics, Fuels Res. Laboratory, MIT, Cambridge, NTIS PB-242-582, 1973.
36.
Moyer, C.A. , The Sociological Aspects of Trauma with Particular Reference to Thermal Injury, Am. J. Surg.87, 421-430 (1954).
37.
Nat. Cotton Council of America, Possible Economic Impact of Flammability Standards on Selected Items of Apparel, 1974.
38.
Nolan, L.J., Flame Retardant Sleepwear-The Retailers' Challenge, in " Proc. 7th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1973, pp. 194-197.
39.
Norton, M.J.T. , The Assessment of the Flammability Hazard and Its Relationship to Price for a Set of Women's Nightgowns, Doctoral thesis, Univ. of MN, 1980.
40.
Norton, M.J.T. , Kadolph, S.J., Johnson, R.F., and Jordan, K.A., Design, Construction, and Use of Minnesota Woman, a Thermally Instrumented Mannequin, Textile Res. J. (in press).
41.
Phillips, A.W. , Behavior Problems in Bum Prevention, in "Proc. 8th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1974, pp. 165-172.
Reeves, W.A. , What Next for Fire Resistant Textiles?, . Am. Dyest. Reptr.72(1), 16-17 (1983).
44.
Secy. of Health, Education and Welfare, Third Annual Report to the President and Congress on the Studies of Deaths, Injuries and Economic Losses Resulting from Accidental Burning of Products, Fabrics or Related Materials - Fiscal Year 1971, Washington, DC, 1972.
45.
Segal, L., Clothing Fires: A Tragedy of Continuing Ignorance, Fire J.60(4), 19-24 (1966).
Sixth Annual Report of the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission on Flammable Fabrics Data-1978, Washington, DC, 1979.
48.
Smith, J.E., A Review of the NBS Mushroom Apparel Flammability Tester (MAFT), in "Proc. Symp. on Textile Flammability," Le Blanc Res. Corp., East Greenwich, RI, 1976, pp. 63-88.
49.
Standard for the Flammability of Clothing Textiles; Proposed Enforcement and Administrative Rules, Fed. Regis.47, 21081-21093 (1982).
50.
Stoll, A.M. , and Greene, L.C., Relationship Between Pain and Tissue Damage due to Thermal Radiation, J. Appl. Physiol.14, 373-382 (1959).
51.
Stremel, J., and Dardis, R., Risk Evaluation of Adult Sleepwear, in "Proc. 12th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1978, pp. 202-211.
52.
Trent, L.C. , Resch, W.A., Coppari, L.A., and Finley, D.L., Design and Construction of a Thermally-Instrumented Mannequin for Measuring the Burn Injury Potential of Wearing Apparel, Textile Res. J.49, 639-647 ( 1979).
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. Reports Required by the Flammable Fabrics Act - Fiscal Year 1974, Washington, DC.
55.
U.S. Dept. of Commerce, "Flammability of Clothing Textiles," CS 191-53, revised, Washington, DC, 1954.
56.
Vickers, A., Krasny, J., and Tovey, H., Some Apparel Fire Hazard Parameters, in "Proc. 7th Annual Meeting, Information Council on Fabric Flammability, New York," 1973, pp. 205-226.
57.
Voluntary FRMarketing: A Hobson's Choice? , Clothes10(4), 20-21 (1975).
58.
Word, E.L., An Analysis of Factors Contributing to Nightwear-Associated Bum Injury in the I.T.T. Data Base, in "Proc. Symp. on Textile Flammability," LeBlanc Res. Corp., East Greenwich, RI, 1978, pp. 12-37.
