An evaluation was made of the ability of trained observers to visually detect small uniform differences in fabric-reflectance values. Three white 50% polyester/50% cotton broadcloth fabrics, one with no finish, one with a durable-press finish, and one with a flame-retardant finish, were soiled and laundered under varying conditions. Fabric-reflectance values were determined using a reflectometer. Trained observers were then asked to visually rank specimens that differed from each other in small uniform increments of reflectance. Significant rank-order correlation coefficients indicated that the observers were able to discern differences as small as 1.0 ± 0.1 reflectance unit. This translates to detectable differences of 1.1% in soil pickup and 3.5% in soil removal.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aatcc, Progress Report of the Standard Soils Committee, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.45, 946-950 (1956).
2.
Beninate, J.V. , Kelly, E.L., and Drake, G.L., Jr., Influence of Fiber Swellability in Selected Fabrics on Wet Soiling and Ease of Soil Removal, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.52, 752-756 (1963).
3.
Benisek, L. and Crawshaw, G.H., SoilingProperties of Wool Fabrics. Part I: Effect of Physical Factors, Textile Res. J.41, 415-424 (1971).
4.
Berch, J., and Peper, H., Wet Soiling of Cotton. Part I: The Effect of Finishes on Soiling, Textile Res. J.33, 137-145 (1963).
5.
Berch, J., Peper, H., and Drake, G.L., Jr., Wet Soiling of Cotton. Part II: Effect of Finishes on the Removal of Soil from Cotton Fabrics, Textile Res. J.34, 29-34 (1964).
6.
Berch, J., Peper, H., Ross, J., Drake, G.L., Laboratory Method of Measuring the Dry Soilability of Fabrics, Amer . Dyest. Reptr.56, 167-171 (1967).
7.
Blakey, R.R. , The Colorimetry of Whites, J. Soc. Dyers Color.84, 120-124 (1968).
8.
Bubl, J.L., LaunderingCotton Fabric. Part I: Effects of Detergent Type and Water Temperature on Soil Removal, Textile Res. J.40, 637-643 (1970).
9.
Conover, W.J. , "Practical Nonparametric Statistics," John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, 1971.
Cramer, J.J. , Evaluation Methods for Soil Removal and Soil Redeposition, in: " Detergency: Theory and Test Methods, Part I," W. G. Cutler and R. C. Davis, Eds., Marcel Dekker, New York, 1972.
12.
Furry, M.S., Bensing, P.L., and Johnson, M.L., Color Effects Produced in Nearly White Fabrics by Household Detergents , Amer. Dyest. Reptr.50, 50-55 (1961).
13.
Furry, M.S., Bensing, P.L., Tabue, R.K., Poole, N.D., and Ross, E.S., Part II— Naturally Soiled Pillowcases Washed and Dried in Household Equipment, Amer . Dyest. Reptr.48, 67-73 ( 1959).
14.
Galbraith, R.L. , Cleaning Efficiency of Home Laundering Detergents , J. Home Econ.52, 353-359 (1960).
15.
Hardin, I., Treece, A.J., Zeronian, S.H., Galbraith, R.L., and Farthing, B.R., TheEffect of Flame Retardant Finishes on the Soiling and Soil Removal Characteristics of Cotton and Cotton-Polyester Blend Fabrics, J. Cons. Prod. Flamm.4, 121-155 (1977).
16.
Hunter, R.T. , FactorsAffecting the Performance and Appearance of Laundered Synthetic Fabrics, J. Amer. OilChem. Soc.45, 362-366 (1968).
17.
Kennedy, J.M. and Stout, E.E., A Method for Soiling White One-Fiber Test Fabrics, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.57, 2-4 (1968).
18.
Kissa, E., A. Rapid and ReproducibleMethod for the Determination of Dry-Soil Resistance, Textile Res. J.41, 621-629 (1971).
19.
Leob, L. and Shuck, R.O., Soil Removal in Relation to Total Work Input; A Calorimetric Approach for Model Wash Systems, J. Amer. OilChem. Soc.46, 299-302 (1969).
20.
Lindsey, C.H. , Whiteness Retention By Satin and Crepe Lingerie Fabrics During Normal Wear and Cleaning, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.43, 760-763, 770 (1954).
21.
Mann, H.B. and Morton, T.H., Optical Studies I—Relation of Colour to the Apparent Soilability of Textile Materials, J. Soc. Dyers Color.75, 522-533 (1959).
22.
Mazzeno, W. , Jr., Kullman, R.M.H., Reinhardt, R.M., Moore, H.B., and Reid, J.D., Wet-Soiling Studies on Resin-Treated Cotton Fabrics, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.47, 299-302 (1958).
23.
Morris, M.A. , LaunderingCotton Fabric. Part II: Effect of Detergent Type and Water Temperature on Appearance, Hand, Strength and Cost, Textile Res. J.40, 644-649 (1970).
24.
Nieuwenhuis, K.S., Whiteness and Fluorescence ofFabrics, J. Amer. OilChem. Soc.45, 37-42 (1968).
25.
Nuessle, A.C. , Nageley, L.M., and Heiges, E.O.J., SomeObservations of Wet-Soiling on Resin-Treated Cottons, Textile Res. J.33, 146-160 (1963).
26.
Pigott, W.T. , A New Look at the Gray Scale, Textile Chem. Color.10, 63-69 (1978).
27.
Porter, B.R. , Peacock, C.L., Tripp , V.W., and Rollins, M.L., The Surface of the Cotton Fiber. Part III: Effects of Modification on Soil Resistance , Textile Res. J.27, 833-845 (1957).
28.
Reeves, W.A. , Beninate, J.V., Perkins , R.M., and Drake, G.L., Jr., Soiling and Soil Removal Studies on Cotton and Polyester Fabrics, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.57, 1053-1056 (1968).
29.
Rhode Island Section, AATCC, Instrumental Evaluation of the Color of Fluorescent Textiles in Terms of Average Observer Response, Amer. Dyest. Reptr. 55, 997-1002 (1966).
Schmokla, I.R. and Hensley, J.W., Detergency Testing of Nonionics , Soap and Chemical Specialties41, 47-51, 103-106 (Aug, 1965 ).
32.
Shimauchi, S. and Mizushima, H., Soil Redeposition of Polyester Fiber and Its Test Methods, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.57, 462-469 (1968).
33.
Shimauchi, S., Tsuzuki, R., and Mizushima, H., Soil Redeposition of Polyester Fiber and its Test Methods. Part II: A New Redeposition Test Method, Amer. Dyest. Reptr.58, 15-20 (1969).
34.
Sontag, M.S. , Purchase, M.E., and Smith, B.F., Build-up of Particulate and Organic Soils on Cotton, Polyester, and Polyester/Cotton Fabrics , Amer. Dyest. Reptr.58(26) 19-22, 40 (1969).
35.
Sontag, M.S. , Purchase, M.E., and Smith, B.F., Changes in Appearance of Cotton and Polyester Fabrics, J. Home Econ.62, 251-256 (1970).
36.
Sontag, M.S. , Purchase, M.E., and Smith, B.F., A Method of Low Level, Particulate Soiling of Fabrics, Textile Res. J.39, 976-978 (1969).
37.
Sosis, P. and Burch, W.D., Role of Oily Soils in Detergency Tests, Soap, Cosmetics/Chemical Specialties49, 32, 34, 36, 38 (July 1973).
38.
Tripp, V.W. , Moore, A.T., Porter , B.R., and Rollins, M.L., Surface of Cotton Fibers, Part IV: Distribution of Dry Soil, Textile Res. J.28, 447-452 (1958).
39.
Weatherburn, A.S. and Bayley, C.H., The SoilingCharacteristics of Textile Fibers, Part I, Textile Res. J.25, 549-558 (1955).
40.
Weatherburn, A.S. and Bayley, C.H., The SoilingCharacteristics of Textile Fibers, Part II: The Influence of Fiber Geometry on Soil Retention , Textile Res. J.27, 199-208 (1957).
