Investigating mathematical methods for high-throughput prediction of the critical buckling load of non-uniform wool fibers

Abstract

The sensation of prickle from textile garments is directly related to the force that a fiber protruding from the fabric surface can exert on the skin without buckling – its critical buckling load (CBL). Finite element modeling (FEM) has previously been used in the literature to predict CBLs for a set of 25 fibers with different along-fiber morphology. With a view to high-throughput analysis of fibers, we investigated two analytical methods that were potentially faster and less computationally intensive than FEM and applied them to calculate CBLs for the same set of fibers. In addition, we tested a numerical integration and gradient search (NIGS) method that we developed by adapting a previously published, non-FEM, numerical approach.

The analytical methods that we tested were either inadequately formulated or prone to instability. Our NIGS method was more reliable that the analytical methods (but slower to compute), and its results appeared more accurate than the published FEM results, based on an inconsistency metric that we developed.

The published FEM results and the NIGS predictions agreed within 5% for 60% of the fibers, and within 10% for 72% of the fibers (with differences ranging from 0.4% to 19.1%) and generally showed qualitative agreement on the response of CBL to fiber shape, with some notable exceptions.

The response of CBL to dimensional variation was complex. This, and the inconsistency between methods, highlights the need for caution when analyzing complicated biological structures, such as wool, and the value of verifying the reliability of any predictions from any approach.

Keywords

textile prickle critical buckling load wool fiber finite element modeling numerical modeling Euler–Bernoulli beam theory flexural rigidity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hearle

JWS

. A total model for the structural mechanics of wool. Wool Technol Sheep Breed 2003; 51: 95–117.

Chen

. Modelling and predicting textile behaviour, Cambridge: Woodside Publishing Limited, 2009.

Liu

Bryson

. A three-component model of the wool fibre - effects of morphology, elasticity and intermediate filament arrangement on fibre stiffness. J Text Inst 2002; 93: 121–131.

. The mechanical behaviour of irregular fibre materials, Ph.D. Thesis,: School of Engineering and Technology, Deakin University, 2002.

Wang

. Mechanical behavior of irregular fibers Part III: the flexural buckling behavior. Text Res J 2002; 72: 573–578.

Munro

Carnaby

. Wool fibre crimp, Part I: the effects of micro-fibrillar geometry. J Text Inst 1999; 90: 123–136.

Naylor

GRS

. The role of coarse fibres in fabric prickle using blended acrylic fibres of different diameters. Wool Technol Sheep Breed 1992; 40: 14–18.

Timoshenko

Young

. Elements of strength of materials, 5th ed. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Company, 1968.

Veitch

Naylor

GRS

. The mechanics of fibre buckling in relation to fabric-evoked prickle. Wool Technol Sheep Breed 1992; 40: 31–34.

10.

Asad

RAM

Zheng

Y-H

et al.

Characterization of prickle tactile discomfort properties of different textile single fibers using an axial fiber-compression-bending analyzer (FICBA). Text Res J 2015; 85: 512–523.

11.

Burkhart

Andrews

Dunning

. Finite element modeling mesh quality, energy balance and validation methods: A review with recommendations associated with the modeling of bone tissue. J Biomech 2013; 46: 1477–1488.

12.

Coşkun

Atay

. Determination of critical buckling load for elastic columns of constant and variable cross-sections using variational iteration method. Comput Math Appl 2009; 58: 2260–2266.

13.

Huang

Luo

Q-Z

. A simple method to determine the critical buckling loads for axially inhomogeneous beams with elastic restraint. Comput Math Appl 2011; 61: 2510–2517.

14.

Elishakoff

Rollot

. New closed-form solutions for buckling of a variable stiffness column by Mathematica®. J Sound Vib 1999; 224: 172–182.

15.

Huang

X-F

. An analytic approach for exactly determining critical loads of buckling of nonuniform columns. Int J Struct Stabil Dynam 2012; 12: 1250027-1–1250027-1.

16.

Cao

. Stability analysis of bars with varying cross-section. Int J Solid Struct 1995; 32: 3217–3228.

17.

Cao

. Stability analysis of a bar with multi-segments of varying cross-section. Comput Struct 1994; 53: 1085–1089.

18.

. Exact solutions for buckling of non-uniform columns under axial concentrated and distributed loading. Eur J Mech A/Solids 2001; 20: 485–500.

19.

Wang

Reddy

. Exact solutions for buckling of structural members. CRC Series in Computational Mechanics and Applied Analysis, Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press LLC, 2005.

20.

Totry

Altus

Proskura

. Buckling of non-uniform beams by a direct functional perturbation method. Probabil Eng Mech 2007; 22: 88–99.

21.

Afsharfard

Farshidianfar

. Finding the buckling load of non-uniform columns using the iteration perturbation method. Theor Appl Mech Lett 2014; 4: 041011–041011.

22.

Pinarbasi

. Lateral torsional buckling of rectangular beams using variational iteration method. Sci Res Essays 2011; 6: 1445–1457.

23.

Başbük

Atay

Erilmazza

. Numerical solutions for buckling loads of elastic columns with constant cross-section. Trans IoT Cloud Comput 2 2014; 2: 1–13.

24.

Katsikadelis

Tsiatas

. Non-linear dynamic analysis of beams with variable stiffness. J Sound Vib 2004; 270: 847–863.

25.

Yilmaz

Girgin

Evran

. Buckling analyses of axially functionally graded nonuniform columns with elastic restraint using a localized differential quadrature method. Math Probl Eng http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/793062.

26.

Lee

Carr

Lee

et al.

Elasticas and buckling loads of shear deformable tapered columns. Int J Struct Stabil Dynam 2005; 5: 317–335.

27.

Lee

Carr

Lee

et al.

Buckling loads of columns with constant volume. J Sound Vib 2006; 294: 381–387.

28.

Lee

. Elastica and buckling load of simple tapered columns with constant volume. Int J Solid Struct 2000; 37: 2507–2518.

29.

Rychlewska

. A new approach for buckling analysis of axially functionally graded beams. J Appl Math Comput Mech 2015; 14: 95–102.

30.

J-H

. Variational iteration method - a kind of non-linear analytic technique: some examples. Int J Non Lin Mech 1999; 34: 699–708.