Application of a published methodology for evaluating within-bale repeatability of measurements obtained with standardized instruments for testing cotton: Gossypium hirsutum in Eastern and Southern Africa

Abstract

The possible application of conclusions from a published study concerning cottons from West and Central Africa (WCA), involving an evaluation of the within-bale variability of fiber Micronaire, Length, Uniformity, Strength, Reflectance and Yellowness in cottons from Eastern and Southern Africa (ESA) was investigated.

We took eight cotton samples per bale from 240 bales produced by 32 ginning mills in six ESA countries in two crop seasons. Our representative sample comprised 1920 fiber samples that were centrally analyzed under controlled conditions using standardized instruments for testing cotton (SITC). We evaluated within-bale variability levels for both saw- and roller-ginned cottons and checked the applicability of the published conclusions to ESA.

We found that (1) sampling variance levels were comparable in ESA and in WCA for saw-ginned cottons, (2) WCA recommendations for saw-ginned cottons would also apply in ESA for most fiber characteristics measured by SITC, and (3) for roller-ginned cottons, the higher within-bale variability of roller-ginned cotton fibers compared to saw-ginned cotton would require the definition of a specific sampling and testing method based on an experiment to be designed.

Keywords

cotton fiber within-bale variability sampling testing repeatability classification

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ICAC. Cotton: World statistics, Washington, DC: International Cotton Advisory Committee, 2010, pp. 295–295.

UNCTAD. UNCTAD Handbook of Statistics, New York and Geneva: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, 2008, pp. 512–512.

Estur G and Gergely N. The economics of roller ginning technology and implications for african cotton sectors. World Bank, 2010, p.75.

Townsend

. The importance of cotton in Africa, Washington, DC: The Next Steps for Africa, 2006, pp. 6–6.

ICAC. Report of an expert panel on ginning methods, Washington, DC: ICAC, 2001, pp. 30–30.

Estur G. Quality and marketing of cotton lint in Africa. Africa Region Working Paper Series No 121, 2008, p.82.

ASTM. Standard test methods for measurement of physical properties of cotton fibers by High Volume Instruments. Annual Book of ASTM Standards. Philadelphia, PA, 1996, pp.886-893.

Aboé

Gourlot

Gozé

. New findings on within bale repeatability of measurements obtained with standardized instruments for testing cotton (SITC) in Gossypium Hirsutum Fiber produced in West and Central Africa. Textil Res J 2012; 82: 1469–1484.

ICAC-Secretariat. Instrument Testing of Cotton at the Producer Level for trading purposes. Washington, DC, 2011.

10.

Gourlot

J-P

Drieling

. Final report about the within and between-bales variability studies conducted in Africa - Rapport final des études de variabilité intra et inter-balles en Afrique, Montpellier: CIRAD, 2012, pp. 290–290.