Predicting the Seam Strength of Notched Webbings for Parachute Assemblies Using the Taguchi's Design of Experiment and Artificial Neural Networks

Abstract

Webbings are used in parachute assemblies as reinforcing units for the strength they provide. The strength of these seams is an important characteristic which has a substantial influence on the mechanical property of the parachute assemblies. It is well established that factors such as fabric width, folding length of joint, seam design and seam type will all have an impact on seam strength. In this work, the effect of these factors on seam strength was studied using both Taguchi's design of experiment (TDOE) as well as an artificial neural network (ANN). In TDOE, two levels were chosen for the factors mentioned above. An L8 design was adopted and an orthogonal array was generated. The contribution of each factor to seam strength was analyzed using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and signal to noise ratio methods. From the analysis it was found that the fabric width, folding length of joint and interaction between the folding length of joint and the seam design affected seam strength significantly. Further, using TDOE, an optimal configuration of levels of factors was found. In order to contrast and compare the results from TDOE, an ANN was also used to predict seam strength using the above mentioned factors as inputs. The prediction from TDOE and ANN methodologies were compared with physical seam strength. It was established from these comparisons, in which the root mean square error was used as an accuracy measure, that the predictions by ANN were better in accuracy than those predicted by TDOE.

Keywords

webbing parachute seam strength artificial neural network Taguchi's design of experiment

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Edberg, B. , An Investigation of Stress-strain Curve of Nylon Parachute Cloth, Text. Res. J., 40, 665-676 (1970).

Ericksen, R.H. , Davis, A.C. , and Warren, W.E. , Deflection-Force Measurements and Observations on Kevlar® 49 Parachute Fabrics, Text. Res. J., 62, 628-637 (1992).

Peterson, C.W. , Pepper, W.B.D. , Johnson, W. , and Holt, I.T. , Application of Kevlar to Parachute System Design, J. Aircr., 23, 87 (1986).

Ericksen, R.H. , Effect of Folding on the Strength of Kevlar 29 and Nylon Parachute Materials, Fibre Sci. Technol., 15, 161-172 (1981).

Ericksen, R.H. , and Orear L. , Wet Strength of Kevlar 29 Ribbon Parachute Fabrics, J. Aircr., 17, 267-271 (1980).

Pepper, W.B. , Evaluation of Kevlar 29 vs Nylon for 3.81m Diameter Ribbon Parachutes, J. Aircr., 17, 198-205 (1980).

Horenstein, M.N. , ,Surface Charging Limit For A Woven Fabric On A Ground Plane, J. Electrostat., 35(1), 31-40 (1995).

Li, P. , Lee, C. , and Corner, B. , Computing Surface Area and Volume of Parachutes from 3D Scans, Engineering Computations, 22 (2-4), 393-408 (2005).

Lee, C.K. , and Li, P. , Geometric Properties of Parachutes Using 3-D Laser Scanning, J. Aircr., 44(2), 377-385 (2007).

10.

Ericksen, R.H. , Abbott, N.J. , Donovan , J.G. , and Coskren, R.J. , The Effect of Warp and Filling Variables on the Tensile Failure and Joint Strength of Kevlar® 29 Parachute Webbing, Text. Res. J., 49, 1-8 (1979).

11.

Onal, L. , Mechanical Properties of Ribbon Parachute Fabrics for Cluster Submunitions, Indian J. Fibre Text. Res., 31(2), 309-312 (2006).

12.

Park, C.K. , and Ha, J.Y. , A Process for Optimizing Sewing Conditions to Minimize Seam Pucker Using the Taguchi Method, Text. Res. J., 75(3), 245-252 (2005).

13.

Liasi, E. , Du, R. , Simon, D. , Bujas-Dimitrejevic, J. , and Liburdi, F. , An Experimental Study of Needle Heating in Sewing Heavy Materials Using Infrared Radiometry, Int. J. Clothing Sci. Tech., 11(5), 300-314 (1999).

14.

Park, S-W. , Hwang, Y-G. , Kang, B-C. , and Yeo, S-W. , Applying Fuzzy Logic and Neural Networks to Total Hand Evaluation of Knitted Fabrics, Text. Res. J., 70(8), 675-681 (2000).

15.

Chen, T. , Li, L. , and Huang, X. , Predicting the Fibre Diameter Melt Blown Nonwovens: Comparison of Physical, Statistical and Artificial Neural Network Models, Model. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng., 13, 575-584 (2005).

16.

Majumdar, A. , Majumdar P.K. , and Sarkar, B. , Selecting Cotton Bales by Spinning Consistency Index and Micronaire Using Artificial Neural Networks, AUTEX Res. J., 4(1), 1-8 (2004).

17.

Majumdar, P.K. , and Majumdar A. , Predicting the Breaking Elongation of Ring Spun Cotton Yarns Using Mathematical, Statistical, and Artificial Neural Network Models, Text. Res. J., 74(7), 652-655 (2004).

18.

Yao G. , Guo, J. , and Zhou Y. , Predicting the Warp Breakage Rate in Weaving by Neural Network Techniques , Text. Res. J., 75(3), 274-278 (2005).

19.

Tilocca, A. , Borzone, P. , Carosio , S. , and Durante, A. , Detecting Fabric Defects with a Neural Network Using Two Kinds of Optical Patterns, Text. Res. J., 72(6), 545-550 (2002).

20.

Ertugrul, S. , and Ucar, N. , Predicting Bursting Strength of Cotton Plain Knitted Fabrics Using Intelligent Techniques, Text. Res. J. , 70(10), 845-851 (2000).

21.

Ogulata, S.N. , Sahin, C. , Ogulata , T.O. , and Balci, O. , The Prediction of Elongation and Recovery of Woven Bi-Stretch Fabric Using Artificial Neural Network and Linear Regression Models, Fibres Text. Eastern Europe, 14(2), 46-49 (2006).

22.

Chattopadhyay, R. , and Guha, A. , Artificial Neural networks: Applications to textile, Text. Prog., 3(1), 7-8 (2003).

23.

Zeydan, M. , Modelling the Woven Fabric Strength Using Artificial Neural Network and Taguchi Methodologies, Int. J. Clothing Sci. Tech., 20(2), 104-119 (2008).

24.

Montgomery, D.G. , "Design and Analysis of Experiments", 4th edn, John Wiley, New York, 1997.

25.

Rumelhart D. , and McClelland J. , "Parallel Distributed Processing: Exploration in the Microstructure of Cognition" Vol. 2, MIT Press, Cambridge, 1987.