The rapid growth of magnet schools in the 1980s introduced the first widely adopted form of public school choice in the United States. Magnet-based choice is supported as a way to expand school choice for parents, bring innovation through specialty schools and programs, and promote voluntary forms of racial integration. Some contend that this form of public school choice is especially helpful to lower-income parents who are trapped in inferior inner-city schools, while others claim that magnet schools may worsen stratification among schools by family income. The study presented here used a large national data set to examine relationships between magnet-based school choice and income-based stratification in school districts. It did not find a difference between school districts with magnet-based school choice and school districts without school choice. Implications for other forms of school choice are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AlvesMichaelWillie.Charles1987. “Controlled Choice Assignments: A New and More Effective Approach to School Desegregation.”Urban Review19(2):67–88.
2.
ArchbaldDouglas. 1988. Magnet Schools, Voluntary Desegregation and Public Choice Theory: Limits and Possibilities in a Big City School System. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Wisconsin-Madison.
3.
ArchbaldDouglas. 1995. “A Longitudinal Cohort Analysis of Achievement Among Elementary Magnet Students, Neighborhood School Students, and Transfer Students.”Journal of Research and Development in Education28:161–69.
4.
ArchbaldDouglas. 1996. “SES and Demographic Predictors of Magnet School Enrollment.”Journal of Research and Development in Education23:152–63.
5.
ArchbaldDouglas. 2000. “School Choice and School Stratification: Shortcomings of the Stratification Critiques and Recommendations for Theory and Research.”Educational Policy14:214–40.
6.
ArsenDavidPlankDavidSykes.Gary2000. “School Choice Policies in Michigan: The Rules Matter.”East Lansing: Education Policy Center, Michigan State University. Available on-line at http://www.epc.msu.edu/publications/publications.htm
7.
ArumRichard. 1996. “Do Private Schools Force Public Schools to Compete?”American Sociological Review61:29–46.
8.
AscherCarolFruchterNormBerneRobert1996. Hard Lesson: Public Schools and Privatization. New York: Twentieth Century Fund Press.
9.
BastianAnne. 1985. Choosing Equality: The Case for Democratic Schooling. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
10.
BlankRolfArchbald.Douglas1992. “Magnet Schools and Educational Quality.”Clearinghouse66(2):81–87.
11.
BlankRolfDentler.Robert1983. Survey of Magnet Schools: Analyzing a Model for Quality Integrated Education. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
12.
BrouilletteMatthew. 1999. School Choice in Michigan: A Primer for Freedom in Education. Midland, MI: Mackinac Center for Public Policy. Available on-line at http://www.mackinac.org/article.asp?ID=2027
13.
BrandlJohn. 1998. “Governance and Educational Quality.” Pp. 55–82 in Learning from School Choice, edited by PetersonPaulHasselBruce. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
ChubbJohnMoe.Terry1990. Politics, Markets, and Schools. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
16.
Citizens' Commission on Civil Rights.1997. Difficult Choices: Do Magnet Schools Serve Children in Need?Washington, DC: Author.
17.
CobbCaseyGlass.Gene1999. “Ethnic Segregation in Arizona Charter Schools.”Educational Policy Analysis7 (1). Available online at http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/Vol7.html
18.
ColemanJames. 1981. “Private Schools, Public Schools, and the Public Interest.”The Public Interest, 64, 19–30.
19.
CooksonPeter. 1994. School Choice: The Struggle for the Soul of American Education. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
20.
CoonsJohn. 1981. “Making Schools Public.” Pp. 91–105 in Private Schools and the Public Good, edited by GaffneyEdwardJr. Notre Dame, IN: Notre Dame University Press.
21.
CoonsJohnSugarmanStephen1977. Education by Choice. Berkeley: University of California Press.
22.
Council of Great City Schools.1996. “Open Enrollment and School Choice Programs in the Great City Schools.”Washington, DC: Author. Available on-line at http://www.cgcs.org/services/fastresp/open.htm
23.
DeeThomas S.Fu.Helen2004. “Do Charter Schools Skim Students or Drain Resources?”Economics of Education Review23:259–71.
24.
EastonDianne. 1994. “A Worm in the Apple: How Vouchers Would Undermine Learning.” Pp. 35–40 in Voices on Choice, edited by BillingsleyK.. San Francisco: Pacific Research Institute for Public Policy.
25.
EverhartRobert, ed. 1982. The Public School Monopoly. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
26.
FairlieRobert W.Resch.Alexandra M.2002. “Is There ‘White Flight’ into Private Schools? Evidence from the National Educational Longitudinal Survey.”Review of Economics and Statistics84:21–33.
27.
FarkasG.1996. Human Capital or Cultural Capital: Ethnicity and Poverty Groups in an Urban School District. New York: Walter de Gruyter.
28.
FarleyReynoldsFrey.William1994. “Changes in the Segregation of Whites from Blacks During the 1980s: Small Steps Toward a More Integrated Society.”American Sociological Review59:23–45.
FullerBruceElmoreRichard eds. 1996. Who Chooses, Who Loses: Culture, Institutions, and the Unequal Effects of School Choice. New York: Teachers College Press.
31.
FullerBruceElmoreRichardOrfield.Gary1996. “Policy-Making in the Dark: Illuminating the School Choice Debate.” Pp. 1–24 in Who Chooses, Who Loses: Culture, Institutions, and the Unequal Effects of School Choice, edited by FullerBruceElmoreRichard. New York: Teachers College Press.
32.
GamoranAdam. 1996. “Student Achievement in Public Magnet, Public Comprehensive, and Private City High Schools.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis18(1):1–18.
33.
GoldhaberDaniel. 1999. “School Choice: An Examination of the Empirical Evidence on Achievement, Parental Decision Making, and Equity.”Educational Researcher9(28):16–26.
34.
GoldringEllenSmrekar.Claire2000. “Magnet Schools and the Pursuit of Racial Balance.”Education and Urban Society33(1):17–35.
35.
GorardStephenFitzJohnTaylor.Chris2001. “School Choice Impacts: What Do We Know?”Educational Researcher30(7):18–23.
36.
GruskyDavid. 1994. Social Stratification: Class, Race, and Gender in Sociological Perspective. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
37.
HasselBruce. 1998. “The Case for Charter Schools.” Pp. 33–51 in Learning from School Choice, edited by PetersonPaulHasselBruce. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
38.
HessFrederickLeal.David2001. “Quality, Race, and the Urban Education Marketplace.”Urban Affairs Review37:249–66.
HoxbyCaroline M.1998. “Analyzing School Choice Reforms Using America's Traditional Forms of School Choice.” Pp. 133–56 in Learning from School Choice, edited by PetersonPaulHasselBruce. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
41.
HussarWilliamSonnenberg.William2000. “Trends in Disparities in School District Level Expenditures Per Pupil” (NCES 2000-020). Washington, DC: National Center For Education Statistics.
42.
JargowskyPaul. 1996. Poverty and Place: Ghettos, Barrios, and the American City. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
43.
JimersonLorna. 1998, April. “The Students Left Behind: School Choice and Social Stratification in Nonurban Districts.”Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Diego.
44.
KahlenbergRichard D.2001. All Together Now: Creating Middle-Class Schools Through Public School Choice. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press.
45.
KottkampRobertNault.Richard1982. “Salient Considerations in Program Choice.” Pp. 99–118 In Family Choice in Schooling, edited by Manley-CasimirMichael. E.. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
46.
KozolJonathon. 1991. Savage Inequalities: Children in America's Schools. New York: Crown.
47.
LankfordHamiltonWycoff.James2000. “The Effect of School Choice and Residential Location on the Racial Segregation of Students.” Unpublished manuscript, Department of Economics, State University of New York at Albany.
48.
LarsonJohnKirshstein.Rita1986. A Microscope on Magnet Schools, 1983 to 1985: Implementation and Racial Balance. Rockville, MD: Montgomery County Public Schools.
49.
LauderHughHughesDavidWatsonSueWaslanderSietskeThruppMartinStrathdeeRobSimiyuIbrahimDupuisAnnMcGlinnJimHamlin.Jennie1999. Trading in Futures: Why Markets in Education Don't Work. Philadelphia: Open University Press.
50.
LeeValerieCroningerRobertSmith.Julia1996. “Equity and Choice in Detroit.” Pp. 70–91 in Who Chooses, Who Loses: Culture, Institutions, and the Unequal Effects of School Choice, edited by FullerBruceElmoreRichard. New York: Teachers College Press.
51.
LevineDanielHavighurst.Robert1977. The Future of Big City Schools: Desegregation Policies and Magnet Alternatives. Berkeley: McCutchan.
52.
LevineRoger. 1996, April. “Research on Magnet Schools and the Context of School Choice.”Paper presented at the Citizens' Commission on Civil Rights Issues Forum: Magnet Schools and the Context of School Choice: Implications for Public Policy, Washington, DC.
53.
MartinezValerieGodwinKennethKemerer.Frank1996. “Public School Choice in San Antonio: Who Chooses and with What Affects?” Pp. 50–69 in Who Chooses, Who Loses: Culture, Institutions, and the Unequal Effects of School Choice, edited by FullerBruceElmoreRichard. New York: Teachers College Press.
54.
MartinezValerieThomasKayKemerer.Frank1994. “Who Chooses and Why: A Look at Five School Choice Plans.”Phi Delta Kappan75:678–81.
55.
MetzMary. 1986. Different by Design. New York: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
56.
MoeTerry. 2000. “The Structure of School Choice.” Pp. 179–212 in Choice with Equity, edited by HillPaul. Stanford, CA: Hoover Institution Press, Stanford University.
57.
MooreDonaldDavenportS.1989. “School Choice: The New Improved Sorting Machine.”Paper presented at the National Invitational Conference on Public-School Choice, sponsored by the Educational Commission of the States, Minneapolis, MN.
58.
NathanJoe, ed.1989. Public Schools by Choice: Expanding Opportunities for Parents, Students, and Teachers. Bloomington, IN: Meyer-Stone.
59.
NelsonBerylBermanPaulEricsonJohnKamprathNancyPerryRebeccaSilvermanDebiSolomon.Debra2000. The State of Charter Schools 2000: Fourth-Year Report. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
60.
OrfieldGary. 1992. The Closing Door: Conservative Policy and Black Opportunity. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
61.
OrfieldGaryBachmeierMarkJamesDavidEitle.Tamela1997. Deepening Segregation in American Schools. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Project on School Desegregation.
62.
OrfieldGaryEaton.Susan1996. Dismantling Desegregation: The Quiet Reversal of Brown v. Board of Education. New York: New York Press.
63.
PearsonJudith. 1993. Myths of Educational Choice. Westport, CT: Praeger.
64.
PetersonPaul. 1990. “Monopoly and Competition in American Education.” Pp 47–79 in Choice and Control in American Education, edited by CluneW.WitteJ.. New York: Falmer Press.
RossKaren E.2003. “Competition versus Equity: The Impact of Charter Schools on Segregation in Michigan Public Schools.”Ann Arbor: University of Michigan and Santa Monica, CA: RAND.
67.
RossellChristine. 1988. “How Effective Are Voluntary Plans with Magnet Schools?”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis10:325–42.
68.
RossellChristine. 1990. The Carrot or the Stick for School Desegregation Policy?Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
69.
SaporitoSalvatore. 2003. “Private Choices, Public Consequences: Magnet School Choice and Segregation by Race and Poverty.”Social Problems50:181–203.
70.
SchneiderMarkTeskePaulMarschall.Melissa2000. Choosing Schools: Consumer Choice and the Quality of American Schools. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.
71.
SchneiderMarkTeskePaulMarschallMelissaRoch.Christine1998. “Shopping for Schools: In the Land of the Blind, the One-Eyed Parent May Be Enough.”American Journal of Political Science42:769–93.
72.
SmithAngela. 1995. “Public School Choice and Open Enrollment: Implications for Education, Desegregation, and Equity.”Nebraska Law Review72:256–303.
73.
SmithKevinMeier.Kenneth1995a. The Case Against School Choice: Politics, Markets, and Fools. Armonk, NY: M. E. Sharpe.
74.
SmithKevinMeier.Kenneth. 1995b. “Public Choice in Education: Markets and the Demand for Quality Education.”Political Research Quarterly48:461–78.
75.
SmrekarClareGoldring.Eleanor1999. School Choice in Urban America: Magnet Schools and the Pursuit of Equity. New York: Teachers College Press.
76.
SteelLaurieLevine.Roger1994. Educational Innovation in Multiracial Contexts. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education.
77.
TochThomas. 1991, May 27. “Making Kids Smarter: How Magnet Education Is Giving Children the Edge They Need.”US News & World Report:58–66.
78.
UchitelleSusanNault.Richard1997, April 4-8. “The School Choice Behavior of Parents Afforded Public School Options: A Case Study of Parental Decision Making in One Suburban Community.”Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, New York.
79.
WaldripDonaldMarksWilliamEstes.Nolan1993. Magnet School Policy Studies and Evaluations. Houston, TX: International Research Institute on Educational Choice, University of Houston.
80.
WellsAmyHolmeJenniferLopezAlejandraCooper.Camille2000. “Charter Schools and Racial and Social Class Segregation: Yet Another Sorting Machine?” Pp. 169–221 in A Nation at Risk: Preserving Public Education as an Engine for Social Mobility, edited by KahlenbergRichard D.. NewYork: Century Foundation Press.
81.
WellsAmy StuartLopezAlejandraScottJanelleJellison Holme.Jennifer1999. “Charter Schools as Postmodern Paradox: Rethinking Social Stratification in an Age of Deregulated School Choice.”Harvard Education Review69:172–204.
82.
WillieCharlesAlves.Michael1996. Controlled Choice: A New Approach to Desegregated Education and School Improvement. Providence, RI: Education Alliance Press and the New England Desegregation Assistance Center of Brown University.
83.
WillmsDougEchols.Frank1993. “The Scottish Experience of Parental School Choice.” Pp. 49–68 in School Choice: Examining the Evidence, edited by RassellEdithRothsteinRobert. Washington, DC: Economic Policy Institute.
84.
WilsonWilliam Julius. 1997. When Work Disappears: The World of the New Urban Poor. New York: Vintage Books.
85.
WitteJohnWalsh.Daniel1990. “A Systematic Test of the Effective Schools Model.”Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis12:188–212.
86.
WrinkleRobert D.StewartJosephJr.PolinardJ. L.1999. “Public School Quality, Private Schools, and Race.”American Journal of Political Science43:1248–53.
87.
YoungThomasClinchy.Evans1992. Choice in Public Education. New York: Teachers' College Press.
