International comparisons of engineering graduate numbers are frequently used as indices of industrial development and measures of the responsiveness of the educational system to industrial requirements. Such comparisons make implicit assumptions about quality by assuming that like institutions or like qualifications are being compared. In this paper the concept of `best practice' engineering education is derived from engineering manpower reports of German engineering education in order to address issues of both quantity and quality in comparing engineering education in Britain and Japan. Japan is found to have associated engineering education with relatively more prestigious institutions and to have attracted a higher proportion of more able male pupils to broad based engineering education compared to Britain. Yet there are some interesting differences between the model of `best practice' engineering education based on Germany and Japanese practice, particularly in curricula, which underline the importance of the division of labour between education and employment in the education and training of engineers. Examining the responsiveness of educational systems through propositions derived from a model of `best practice' rather than through simple output statistics underlines the importance of different patterns of institutional development, the role of the state, educational and occupational selection, and status within the curriculum for understanding the variety of contemporary engineering education.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Albu, A. 1980. `British Attitudes to Engineering Education: A Historical Prospective', in Pavitt, K. (ed.) Technical Innovation and British Economic Performance. London: Macmillan.
2.
Amano, I. 1984. `Dai Yon-sho Nihon no Daigaku-Bunnui' (The Classification of Universities in Japan) and `Dai San-sho Nihon ni okel Daigak Hyoka' (Academic Evaluation in Japan), in Keii, T. (ed.) Daigaku Hyoka no Kenkyu (A study of Academic Evaluation). Tokyo: Tokyo University Press.
3.
Arai, K.et al.1978. `Research on the Higher Education of Scientists and Engineers'. Research in Higher Education (Daikagu Ronshu)6.
4.
Armytage, W.H.G. 1955. Civic Universities. London: Ernest Benn.
5.
Armytage, W.H.G. 1965. The Rise of the Technocrats: a Social History. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
6.
Ashby, E. 1958. Technology and the Academics. London: Macmillan.
7.
Beuret, G. and Webb, A. 1983. Goals of Engineering Education: Final Report. Leicester Polytechnic.
8.
Blaug, M.1967. `Approaches to Educational Planning'. Economic Journal: June.
9.
CEPC 1978. Evidence to the Finniston Evidence of Committee of the Engineering Professors' Conference, Westminster; CEPC.
10.
Corfield, Sir Kenneth1984. `Getting the Engineers We Need'. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers vol.198 B, no.4.
11.
Cummings, W.K. 1976. `The Patterns and Prospects for Japanese Higher Education', in Austin, L. (ed.) Japan: The Paradox of Progress. New Haven: Yale University Press.
12.
Dore, R.P. 1973. British Factory - Japanese Factory. London: Allen and Unwin.
13.
Dore, R.P. 1976. The Diploma Disease. London: Allen and Unwin.
14.
Dore, R.P. 1986. `The Quality of Japanese Science and Technology'. London: Technical Change Centre.
15.
Elbaum, B. and Lazonick, W. 1986. The Decline of the British Economy. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
16.
Finniston, Sir Monty 1980. Engineering Our Future: Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Engineering Profession (Sir Monty Finniston: Chairman). London: HMSO.
17.
Gannicot, K.G. and Blaug, M.1969. `Manpower Forecasting Since Robbins: A Science Lobby in Action'. Higher Education Review2:1.
18.
Goldthorpe, J.H. and Hope 1974. The Social Grading of Occupations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
19.
Grayson, L.1984. `Japan's Intellectual Challenge: the System'. Engineering EducationJanuary.
20.
Halsey, A.H.1961. `University Expansion and the College Ideal'. Universities Quarterly16:1.
21.
Hiraoka, L.S.1985. `Japan's Technology Trade'. Technological Forecasting and Social Change28:231-241.
22.
Hutchings, D. 1963. Technology and the Sixth Form Boy. Oxford: Department of Education, Oxford University.
23.
Hutton S. and Lawrence, P.A. 1981. German Engineers: The Anatomy of a Profession. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
24.
IMS 1984. Competence and Competition: Training and Education in the Federal Republic of Germany, the United States and Japan. A report prepared by the Institute of Manpower Studies for the National Economic Development Council and the Manpower Services Commission. London: NEDO/MSC.
25.
Ishikawa, S. 1984. `Japan'. In Hough, J.R. (ed.) Educational Policy: an International Survey. London: Croom Helm.
26.
Kerr, I.H.F.1986. `A study of the First Destinations of Graduates of National Universities in the Tohoku Region of Japan 1980-85'. Higher Education15:305-322.
27.
Kinmonth, E.H.1986. `Engineering Education and its Rewards'. Comparative Education Review30:3.
28.
Lawrence, P. and Lee, R. 1984. Insight into Management. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
29.
Layard, R. and Saigal, J.C.1966. `Educational and Occupational Characteristics of Manpower: an International Comparison'. British Journal of Industrial RelationsIV: June.
30.
Levine, S.B. and Kawada, H. 1980. Human Resources in Japanese Industrial Development. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
31.
Lynn, R.1977. `The Intelligence of the Japanese'. Bulletin of the British Psychological Society. 30:69-72.
32.
McCormick, K. 1972. `Models and Assumptions in Manpower Planning in Science and Technology', in Halmos, P. (ed.) The Sociological Review Monograph No. 18: The Sociology of Science, September.
33.
McCormick, K.1986. `The Search for Corporatist Structures in British Higher Technological Education: the creation of the National Advisory Council on Education in Industry and Commerce (NACEIC) in 1948'. British Journal of Sociology of Education7:293-317.
34.
Mace, J. and Taylor, S.1975. `The Demand for Engineers in British Industry: some implications for manpower forecasting'. British Journal of Industrial Relations15:175-193.
35.
Mace, J. and Wilkinson, G.C.G.1977. `Are Labour Markets Competitive? A Case Study of Engineers'. British Journal of Industrial Relations15:1-17.
36.
Marshall, F.G. 1981. Japan, Prosperity from Technology. London: Overseas Technical Information Unit, Department of Industry.
37.
Nakoaoka, T.1981. `Production Management in Japan Before the Period of Economic Growth'. Osaka City University Economic Review17.
38.
Nier 1983. Basic Facts and Figures about the Educational System in Japan. March.
39.
OECD 1967. Reviews of National Science Policy: United Kingdom and Germany. Paris: OECD.
40.
Okuda, K.1983. `The Role of Engineers in Japanese Industry and Education'. Journal of Japanese Trade and IndustrySeptember/October23-26.
41.
Oshima, K.1983. `Science and Technology in Japan - Prospects and Future Tasks'. Journal of Japanese Trade and IndustrySept/October18-22.
42.
Pavitt, K. (ed.) 1980. Technical Innovation and British Economic Performance. London: Macmillan.
43.
Pickman, S.P. 1984. The Output of UK Universities by Institution and Discipline. Manchester: Central Statistical Unit for University and Polytechnic Careers Service.
44.
Playfair 1885. `Science and Technology as Sources of National Power'. Aberdeen: British Association for the Advancement of Science.
45.
Prais, S.1981. `Vocational Qualifications of the Labour Force in Britain and Germany'. National Institute Economic Review, August.
46.
Rawle, P.R. 1983. The Education and Training of Engineers in Japan. London: General Electric Company plc.
47.
Rohlen, T.P.1977. `Is Japanese Education Becoming Less Egalitarian? Notes on High School Stratification and Reform'. Journal of Japanese Studies3:37-70.
48.
Rohlen, T.P. 1983. Japan's High Schools. Berkeley: University of California Press.
49.
Sanderson, M. 1972. The Universities and British Industry. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
50.
Searle, G.R. 1971. The Quest for National Efficiency: a Study in British Politics and Political Thought (1899-1914). Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
51.
Sumiya, M. and Taira, K. 1979. An Outline of Japanese Economic History 1603 - 1940: Major Works and Research Findings. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press.
52.
Swords-Isherwood, N. 1980. `British Management Compared', in Pavitt, K. (ed.) Technical Innovation and British Economic Performance. London: Macmillan.
53.
Tskukahara, S. and Muta, H. 1986. Development of Scientific and Technical Manpower. Tokyo: National Institute for Educational Research of Japan.
54.
Tsru, S. 1983. `Economic Development and Human Resources: Japan's Experiences, in Tsru, S. (ed.) Human Resources, Employment and Development 1: The Issues. London: Macmillan.
55.
TUC 1985. The Future Business: Britain's Research and Development Crisis. Trade Union Congress Publications.
56.
Watson, H. 1976. `Organisational Bases of Professional Status: a Comparative Study of the Engineering Profession'. Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of London.
57.
Welbourn, D.B.1972. `Britain's Industrial Expansion: A Note on Engineering'. Lloyds Bank Review, 106: October.
58.
Westney, E. and Sakakibara, R. 1985. Comparative Study of the Training, Careers and Organisation of Engineers in the Computer Industry in Japan and the United States. MIT-Japan Science and Technology Program.
59.
Whalley, P. 1986. The Social Production of Technical Work. Basingstoke: Macmillan.
