This study examines the effects of the later stages of comprehensive reorganisation in Scotland. Nationally representative samples show that standards of attainment rose, particularly among females and pupils of lower socioeconomic status (SES). The rise was faster than could be accounted for by the rise in average SES. Inequalities of attainment associated with SES varied between communities but, overall, they declined for both males and females. Female attainment moved ahead of male attainment. Creamed comprehensives did worse than uncreamed ones, but the longer that either creamed or uncreamed schools had been established as comprehensive the higher was their average attainment. Some implications for the reduction and reproduction of inequalities of attainment are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adler, M.E., Petch, A.J. and Tweedie, J.W. 1987. `The origins and impact of the Parents' Charter'. In McCrone, D. (ed.) The Scottish Government Yearbook 1987. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh. Unit for the Study of Government in Scotland.
2.
Aitkin, M.A. and Longford, N.T.1986. `Statistical modelling issues in school effectiveness studies'. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series A149:1-26.
3.
Anderson, R.D. 1983. Education and Opportunity in Victorian Scotland. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
4.
Ball, S.J. 1984. `Introduction: Comprehensives in crisis? In Ball, S.J. (ed.) Comprehensive Schooling:A Reader, Lewes: Falmer.
5.
Benn, C. and Simon, B. 1972. Half Way There. 2nd. edition. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
6.
Brookover, W.B., Schweitzer, J., Schneider, M., Beady, C., Flood, P.K. and Wisenbaker, J.M.1978. `Elementary school climate and school achievement'. American Educational Research Journal15:301-318.
7.
Burnhill, P.M. 1984. `The ragged edge of compulsory schooling'. In Raffe, D. (ed.) Fourteen to Eighteen, Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press.
8.
Burnhill, P.M. and McPherson, A.F. 1984. `Careers and gender: The expectations of able Scottish school leavers in 1971 and 1981'. In Acker, S. (ed.) Is Higher Education Fair to Women?London: Society for Research in Higher Education.
9.
Burnhill, P.M., McPherson, A.F., Raffe, D. and Tomes, N. 1987. `Constructing a public account of an educational system'. In Walford, G. (ed.) Doing Sociology of Education. Lewes: Falmer.
10.
Central Statistical Office (CSO). 1987. Social Trends No. 17 - 1987 Edition. (Edited by T. Griffin and J. Morris). London: HMSO.
11.
Centre For Contemporary Cultural Studies (CCCS). 1981. Unpopular Education. London: Hutchinson.
12.
Centre For Educational Sociology (CES). 1979. `A code of practice for collaborative research'. Collaborative Research Newsletter 6. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh, CES: 84-86.
13.
Cox, C. and Marks, J. 1980. Real Concern. London: Centre for Policy Studies.
14.
Department of Education and Science (DES). 1965. `Organisation of secondary education'. London: HMSO (Circular 10/65).
15.
Glass, C.V., McGaw, B. and Smith, M.L. 1981. Meta-analysis in Social Research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
16.
Goldstein, H.1983. `Measuring changes in educational attainment over time: Problems and possibilities'. Journal of Educational Measurement. 20:269-277.
17.
Goldstein, H.1986. `Multilevel mixed linear model analysis using iterative generalized least squares'. Biometrika73:43-56.
18.
Goldthorpe, J.H. and Hope, K. 1974. The Social Grading of Occupations. London: Oxford University Press.
19.
Government Statistical Service (GSS). 1976. Scottish Educational Statistics 1974. London: HMSO.
20.
Gow, L. and McPherson, A.F. 1980. Tell Them From Me, Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press.
21.
Gray, J.M., McPherson, A.F. and Raffe, D. 1983. Reconstructions of Secondary Education, London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
22.
Halsey, A.H., Heath, A.F. and Ridge, J.M. 1980. Origins and Destinations. Oxford: Clarendon.
23.
Hargreaves, D.H. 1982. The Challenge for the Comprehensive School. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
24.
Harman, H.H. 1976. Modern Factor Analysis, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
25.
Hauser, R.M.1970. `Context and consex: A cautionary tale'. American Journal of Sociology75:645-654.
26.
Heath, A.1987. `Class in the classroom'. New Society. 17 July:13-15.
27.
Highet, J. 1969. A School of One's Choice, London: Blackie.
28.
Hutchison, D. and McPherson, A.F.1976. `Competing inequalities: The sex and social class structure of the first year Scottish university student population'. Sociology10:111-116.
29.
Kendrick, S. 1983. `Social change in Scotland'. In Brown, G. and Cook, R. (eds.) Scotland: The Real Divide. Edinburgh: Mainstream.
30.
Kendrick, S. 1986. `Women's economic activity in post-war Scotland: A comparative account'. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh, Research Centre for the Social Sciences.
31.
Kogan, M. 1983. `The case of education'. In Young, K. (ed.) National Interests and Local Government. London: Heinemann.
32.
McPherson, A.F. 1983. `An angle on the geist: Persistence and change in the Scottish educational tradition'. In Humes, W.M. and Paterson, H.M. (eds.) Scottish Culture and Scottish Education 1800 - 1980. Edinburgh: John Donald.
33.
McPherson, A.F. and Raab, C.D. in press. Governing Education. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
34.
McPherson, A.F. and Willms, J.D. 1986. `Certification, class conflict, religion and community: A socio-historical explanation of the effectiveness of contemporary schools'. In Kerckhoff, A.C. (ed.) Research in Sociology of Education and Sociolization Volume 6, Greenwich, Conn: JAI Press.
35.
Marks, J., Cox, C. and Pomian-Srzednicki, M. 1983. Standards in English Schools. London: National Council for Educational Standards.
36.
Marks, J. and Pomian-Srzednicki, M. 1985. Standards in English Schools:Second Report. London: Sherwood Press.
37.
Mason, W.M., Wong, G.Y. and Entwisle, B. 1984. `Contextual analysis through the multilevel linear model'. In Leinhardt, S. (ed.) Sociological Methodology 1983 - 1984. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
38.
Nuttall, D. 1986. `Problems in the measurement of change'. In Nuttall, D. (ed.) Assessing Educational Achievement. Lewes: Falmer.
39.
Office of Population Censuses and Surveys (OPCS). 1970. Classification of Occupations 1970. London: HMSO.
40.
OPCS 1980. Classification of Occupations 1980. London: HMSO.
41.
Oxford Review of Education. 1984, 10.
42.
Raffe, D.1984. `The transition from school to work and the recession: Evidence from the Scottish School Leavers Surveys 1977 - 1983'. British Journal of Sociology of Education5:247-265.
43.
Raffe, D.1986. `Unemployment and school motivation: The case of truancy'. Educational Review38:11-19.
44.
Raffe, D. 1987. `Youth unemployment in the UK 1979 - 1984'. Paper prepared for the International Youth Labour Office, Geneva, forthcoming in Brown, P. and Ashton, D. (eds.) Education and Economic Life. Lewes: Falmer.
45.
Raudenbush, S.W. and Bryk, A.S.1986. `A hierarchical model for studying school effects'. Sociology of Education59(1):1-7.
46.
Resistrar General, Scotland (RGS). 1967. Annual Estimates of the Population of Scotland. Edinburgh: HMSO.
47.
Reynolds, D., Sullivan, M. and Murgatroyd, S. 1987. The Comprehensive Experiment. Lewes: Falmer.
48.
Scottish Education Department (SED). 1962. `List of presenting centres for the Scottish Leaving Certificate examination'. Edinburgh: SED, unpublished mimeograph.
49.
SED 1965a. `Reorganisation of secondary education on comprehensive lines'. Edinburgh: HMSO (Circular 600).
50.
SED 1965b. Education in Scotland in 1964. Edinburgh: HMSO, Cmnd 2600.
51.
SED 1966a. Education in Scotland in 1965. Edinburgh: HMSO, Cmnd 2914.
52.
SED 1966b. Raising the School Leaving Age:Suggestions for Courses. Edinburgh: HMSO.
53.
SED 1966c. `Transfer of pupils from primary to secondary education'. Edinburgh: HMSO (Circular 614).
54.
SED 1967. Scottish Educational Statistics 1966. Edinburgh: HMSO.
55.
SED 1971a. `Raising the school leaving age'. Edinburgh: SED (Circular 813).
56.
SED 1971b. Scottish Educational Statistics 1970. Edinburgh: HMSO.
57.
SED 1982. Statistical Bulletin 3/A3/1982, Edinburgh: SED.
58.
SED 1986. Statistical Bulletin 10/E2/1986. Edinburgh: SED.
59.
Shavit, Y. and Williams, R.A.1985. `Ability grouping and contextual determinants of educational expectations in Israel'. American Sociological Review50:62-73.
60.
Steedman, J. 1980. Progress in Secondary Schools, London: National Children's Bureau.
61.
Steedman, J. 1983. Examination Results in Selective and Non-selective Schools. London: National Children's Bureau.
62.
Steedman, J., Fogelman, K. and Hutchison, D. 1980. Real Research. London: National Children's Bureau.
63.
Stevens, A. 1980. Clever Children in Comprehensive Schools. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
64.
Tibbenham, A., Essen, J. and Fogelman, K.1978. `Ability grouping and school characteristics'. British Journal of Educational StudiesXXVI:8-23.
65.
Universities of Scotland Organisation and Methods Unit (USOMU). 1970 and annually. List of Presenting Centres for the Scottish Certificate of Education Examinations. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh, USOMU.
66.
Willms, J.D.1985. `The balance thesis: Contextual effects of ability on pupils' O-grade examination results'. Oxford Review of Education11:33-41.
67.
Willms, J.D.1986. `Social class segregation and its relationship to pupils' examination results in Scotland'. American Sociological Review51:224-241.
68.
(published in Journal of Early Adolescence. June1987, with an authors' correction in a subsequent issue).
69.
Wright, N. 1977. Progress in Education. London: Croom Helm.
