The Impact of the Economic and Political System on Social Stratification and Social Mobility: Soviet Lower White-Collar Workers in Comparative Perspective
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online May, 1987
The Impact of the Economic and Political System on Social Stratification and Social Mobility: Soviet Lower White-Collar Workers in Comparative Perspective
This paper provides the first detailed study of lower white-collar workers in Soviet society. It traces the historical development of this social category during the Soviet period, gives a general social profile of the stratum now and locates it in the Soviet system of social stratification. Comparisons are made with equivalent strata in Western society, and both divergences and commonalities are identified. The former are explained by reference to the different economic, political/ideological and cultural factors which have shaped the system of social stratification and movement within it. Similarities are seen to be a consequence of the fact that the same division of labour characterises both types of society.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Aimre, I.A. 1976. Rol' Semi v Ismenenii Sotsial'noi Struktury Obshchestva v Usloviyakh Razvitogo Sotsialisma (na materialakh ESSR). Avtoreferat. Moscow.
2.
Aitov, N.A. 1974. `Sotsial'nye Peremeshcheniya v SSSR'. Problemy Razvitiya Sotsial'noi Struktury Obshchestva v Sovetskom Soyuze i Pol'she. Moscow - Warsaw.
3.
Antoschkin, A. 1923. Die Lage der Angestellten in Sowjetrussland. Berlin.
4.
Arutyunyan, Yu., Drobyzheva, L.M. and Shkaratan, O.I. 1973. Sotsial'noe i Natsional'noe. Moscow.
5.
Baethge, M. and Oberbeck, H. 1984. Zukunft der Angestellten. Kölln: Campus Verlag.
6.
Blyakhman, L.S. & Shkaratan, O.I. 1973. Man at Work. Moscow: Progress.
Chernovolenko, V.F., Paniotto, V.I., Tarasenko, V.I., Vishnyak, A.I. 1984. Semya i Vozproizvodstvo Struktury Trudovoi Zanyatosti. Kiev.
9.
Crompton, R. and Jones, G. 1984. White-Collar Proletariat. London: Macmillan Press.
10.
Eshmambetov, N.A. 1978. Zarabotnaya Plata Sluzhashchikh i Puti ee Sovershenstvovaniya. Avtoreferat. Leningrad.
11.
Faizullin, F. 1981. `Sotsial'naya Struktura goroda v razvitom sotsialisticheskom obshchestve'. O Formirovanii Sotsial'noi Odnorodnosti. Talllin.
12.
Freitag, J. and Lötsch, M. 1982. `Manual and Mental Work as Factors of Social Equality and Inequality. Some Results of Factor Analysis'. Paper presented at the 19th World Congress of Sociology in Mexico City. August 1982.
13.
Garnsey, E.1975. `Occupational Structure in Industrialized Societies:Some Notes on the Convergence Thesis in the Light of Soviet Experience'. Sociology3:437-458.
14.
Giddens, A. 1973. The Class Structure of the Advanced Societies. London:Hutchinson.
15.
Gogolyukhin, S.P. 1970. `Sootnoshenie Sotsial'no-klassovykh i Professional'no kvalifikatsionnykh Razlichii v Sovetskom Obshchestve'. Problemy Razvitiya Sotsialisticheskikh Obshchestvennykh Otnoshenii. Sverdlovsk.
16.
Goldthorpe, J.H. 1967. `Social Stratification in Industrial Society'. Bendix, R. and Lipset, S. (eds.) Class, Status and Power. London:Routledge and Kegan Paul.
17.
Gordon, L.A. and Nazimova, A.K.1983. `Sotsial'no-Professional'naya Struktura Sovremennogo Sovetskogo Obshchestva:tipologiya i statistika'. Rabochii Klass i Sovremennyi Mir2:61-73.
1977. Klassifikationnyi Spravochnik Dolzhnostei Sluzhashchikh (edited by the State Committee of the Council of Ministers of the USSR for Labour and Social Questions). 2nd ed.Moscow.
20.
Ksenofontava, V.V. 1970. `Rol' Sotsial'noi Prinadlezhnosti v Zhiznennykh Planakh Vypusnikov Shkol'. Problemy Razvitiya Sotsialisticheskikh Obschchestvennykh Otnoshenii. Sverdlovsk.
21.
Lane, C.1985. `White-Collar Workers in the Labour Process:The Case of the Federal Republic of Germany'. Sociological Review. 2:198-326.
22.
Lane, D.S. 1985. Soviet Economy and Society. Oxford:Blackwell.
23.
Lapidus, G.W. 1978. Women in Soviet Society. (Equality, Development and Social Change). University of California Press.
24.
Levitan, V.M. 1973. Normirovanie truda Sluzhashchikh v Uchrezhdeniyakh (na primere uchrezhdenii Gosbanka). Avtoreferat. Moscow.
25.
Lockwood, D. 1958. The Blackcoated Worker. London:Allen & Unwin.
26.
Makeev, G. and Gusinskii, N. 1972. Profsoyuz Sovetskikh Gosudarstvennykh sluzhashchikh. Moscow.
27.
McAuley, A. 1981. Women's Work and Wages in the Soviet Union. London:Allen and Unwin.
28.
Mokliyak, N.N. 1977. Sotsial'no-professional'nye Peremeshcheniya na Sotsialisticheskom Predpriyatii. Kiev.
29.
1984. Narodnoe Khozyaistvo v SSSR 1983g. Moscow.
30.
Ofer, G. 1973. The Service Sector in Soviet Economic Growth. Cambridge, Mass.
31.
Parkin, F. 1971. Class Inequality and Political Order. London:MacGibbon and Kee.
32.
Pauts, I.Kh. 1981. `Sotsial'naya Prinadlezhnost' Kak Faktor Opredelyayushchii Otnoshenie Rabochego Molodezhi k Professional'nomu Samosovershenstvovaniyu'. O Formirovanii Sotsial'noi Odnorodnosti. Tallin.
33.
Pravda, A.1982. `Is there a Soviet Working Class?'. Problems of CommunismNov-Dec. Vol.XXXI:1-24.
34.
Rashin, A.G. 1929. Fabrichno-Zavodskie Sluzhashchie v SSSR. Moscow.
35.
Russkikh, B.G. 1969. Problemy Razvitiya Sotsial'nykh Prosloek v Period Stroitel'stva Kommunizma (na primere sluzhashchikh). Moscow.
36.
Russkikh, B.G. 1970. Razvitie Sotsial'noi Gruppy Sluzhashchikh-Nespetsialistov v Period Perekhoda ot Sotsializma k Kommunizmu. Avtoreferat. Ural'nyi Gosudarstvennyi Universitet A.M. Go”rkogo. Sverdlovsk.
37.
Russkikh, B.G.1976. `K Voprosy ob Izmeneniyakh v Sotsial'noi Strukture Sluzhashchikh-Nespetsialistov v Usloviyakh NTR'. Nauchno-Tekhnicheskii proges i ego Sosial'nye Posledstviya:27-30. Ufa.
38.
Russkikh, B.G.1983. `Prestizh Professii Sluzhashchikh-Nespetsialistov Kak Odin Iz Faktorov Upravleniya Razvitiem Sotsial'noi Struktury Obshchestva Razvitogo Sotsializma'. Upravlenie Sotsial'nymi Protsessami. Ufa.
39.
Rutkevich, M.N. 1975. Tendentsii Razvitiya Sotsial'noi Struktury Sovetskogo Obshchestva. Moscow.
40.
Rutkevich, M.N. and Filippov, F.P. (eds) 1976. Sotsial'naya Struktura Razvitogo Sotsialisticheskogo Obshchestva v SSSR. Moscow.
41.
Rutkevich, M.N. and Filippov, F.P. 1978. Vysshaya Shkola Kak Faktor Izmeneniya Sotsial'noi Struktury Razvitogo Sotsialisticheskogo Obshchestva. Moscow.
42.
Saar, E. and Titma, M. 1984. `Sotsial'nye Peremeshcheniya Molodezhi so Srednem Obrazovaniem'. Sotsial'no-Ekonomicheskie Problemy Podgotovki Kadrov ESSR. Tallin.
43.
Saar, E. and Titma, M. 1984. Modelirovanie Formirovaniya Popolneniya Osnovnykh Sotsial'nykh Sloev. Tallin.
44.
Scharff, R.1979. `Angestellte “Nicht-Spezialisten” und “unteres Dienstleistungspersonal” in der sowjetischen Gesellschaft'. Osteuropa29:731-743.
45.
Scharff, R. 1980. Angestellte im Sozialismus. Unpublished manuscript.
46.
Senyavskii, S.L. and Tel'pukhovskii, V.B. 1971. Rabochii Klass SSSR. 1938-65. Moscow.
47.
Senyavskii, S.L. 1982. Sotsial'naya Struktura Sovetskogo Obshchestva v Usloviyakh Razvitogo Sotsializma (1961-80). Moscow.
48.
Shkaratan, O.I. 1970. Problemy Sotsial'noy Struktury Rabochego Klassa SSSR. Moscow.
Solov'ev, R.N. 1975. `Nekotorye Problemy Vosproizvodstva Spetsialistov Bukhgal'terskogo Ucheta i ikh Ispolzovanie'. Trudovye Resursy i ikh Ispol'zovanie v Narodnom Khozyaistve SSSR. Moscow.
53.
1984. The USSR in Figures for 1983. Finansy i Statistika Publishers. Moscow.
54.
Titma, M.Kh. and Tal'yunaite, M.I. 1984. Prestizh Professii. Vilnyus.
55.
Titma, M.Kh.et al. (eds.) 1982. Sotsial'nye peremeshcheniya v Studenchestvo. Vil'nyus.
56.
Titma, M.Kh. 1981. `Sotsial'nye Peremeshcheniya Kak Faktor Razvitiya Sotsial'noi Struktury Obshchestva'. O Formirovanii Sotsial'noi Odnorodnosti. Tallin.
57.
Tsitse, A. 1983. Sblizhenie Sotsial'nykh Kharakterstik i Uslovii Zhizni Rabotnikov Fizicheskogo i Umstvennogo Truda v Latviiskoi SSR. Riga.
58.
Vasil'eva, E.K. 1978. Sotsial'no-ekonomicheskaya Struktura Naseleniya SSSR. Moscow.
59.
1983. Vestnik Statistiki, 12. Moscow.
60.
Vinokur, A. and Ofer, G. 1979. `Family Income Levels for Soviet Industrial Workers. 1965-75'. Kahan, A. and Ruble, B.A. (eds.) Industrial Labour in the USSR. New York:Pergamon Press.
61.
Vovsi, M. 1926. Trud sluzhashchikh v SSSR (Statistiko-ekonomicheskii Obzor). Moscow.
62.
Yarve, M.K. 1981. `Izmeneniya v Strukture Kul'turnoi Deyatel'nosti Predstavitelei Razlichnykh Sotsial'nykh Grupp v Usloviyakh Razvitogo Sotsializma'. O Formirovanii Sotsial'noi Odnorodnosti. Tallin.
