Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2023-10
Neighbourliness and Situational Factors: Explaining Neighbour Behaviour in Attacks and Rescues of Sikhs in Delhi in 1984 and Muslims in Ahmedabad in 2002
Studies find a direct association of collective violence with relational distance: lower the relational distance, lower the violence. Where people live as neighbours, spatial proximity provides more opportunity for contact. However, perpetrators of mass violence are often neighbours who had previously coexisted with their victims in apparent harmony. Neighbour-on-neighbour violence is a social violation: it shakes our confidence in the collective values of ‘neighbourliness’ and the strength of prior relations. In two state-orchestrated pogroms in India – against Sikhs in 1984 and Muslims in 2002 – the nature of prior neighbour relationships is delineated to identify why some neighbours participated in attacks, others in rescues. A qualitative analysis of 50 survivor affidavits and 41 in-depth interviews enabled reconstructing the texture of these relationships. Neighbourliness and situational factors (timing of attacks; built environment) provided a more nuanced understanding of behaviour. For democratic polities that authorise pogroms, findings challenge existing knowledge on contact and violence.
AllportG (1954/1979) The Nature of Prejudice. 25th Anniversary Issue. Cambridge: Perseus Books.
2.
BaberZ (2004) ‘Race’, religion and riots: The ‘racialization’ of communal identity and conflict in India. Sociology38(4): 701–718.
3.
BerenschotW (2012) Riot Politics: Hindu Muslim Violence and the Indian State. London: C. Hurst and Co. Publishers.
4.
BiggsMKnaussS (2012) Explaining membership in the British national party: A multilevel analysis of contact and threat. European Sociological Review28(5): 633–646.
5.
BlackD (1976) The Behavior of Law. New York, NY: Academic Press.
BlumerH (1955) Race prejudice as a sense of group position. Pacific Sociological Review1(1): 3–7.
8.
BrowningC (1992) Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland. New York, NY: Harper Collins.
9.
BulmerM (1986) Neighbours: The Work of Philip Adams. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.
Census of India (1981) Village and Townwise Primary Census Abstract, Series 28, Delhi. New Delhi, India: Director of Census Operations.
11.
Census of India (2004 [2001]) Slum Population. Gujarat: District Census Handbook, Series 25, Part XII A and B: Ahmadabad District, Village and Town Directory. New Delhi: Controller of Publications.
12.
ChakravartiU (1994) Victims, ‘neighbours’, and ‘watan’: Survivors of anti-Sikh carnage of 1984. Economic & Political Weekly29(42): 2722–2726.
13.
ChandraK (2006) The production of Hindu-Muslim violence in contemporary India by Paul R. Brass. The Journal of Asian Studies65(1): 207–209.
14.
CheshireL (2015) ‘Know your neighbours’: Disaster resilience and the normative practices of neighbouring in an urban context. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space47: 1081–1099.
15.
CollinsR (2008) Violence: A Micro-Sociological Theory. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
16.
CollinsR (2022) Explosive Conflict: Time-Dynamics of Violence. New York: Routledge.
17.
Common Judgment (Special Court) (2012) The State of Gujarat versus Naresh Agarsinh Chhara (and others), Exhibit 2671, 31 August. Available at: https://cjp.org.in/naroda-patiya-common-judgment/ (accessed 21 April 2021).
18.
CrowGPGrahamAASummersM (2002) Neither busybodies nor nobodies: Managing proximity and distance in neighbourly relations. Sociology36: 127–145.
19.
DasV (2006) Life and Words: Violence and the Descent into the Ordinary. Berkeley, CA/Los Angeles, CA/London: University of California Press.
20.
DhattiwalaR (2016) The ecology of ethnic violence: Attacks on Muslims in Ahmedabad in 2002. Qualitative Sociology39(1): 71–95.
21.
DhattiwalaR (2017) Mapping the self: Challenges of insider research in a riot-affected city and strategies to improve data quality. Contemporary South Asia25(1): 7–22.
22.
DhattiwalaR (2019) Keeping the Peace: Spatial Differences in Hindu-Muslim Violence in Gujarat in 2002. Cambridge/New Delhi, India: Cambridge University Press.
23.
DhattiwalaRBiggsM (2012) The political logic of ethnic violence: The anti-Muslim pogrom in Gujarat, 2002. Politics & Society40(4): 483–516.
24.
DrakulicS (2004) They Would Never Hurt a Fly: War Criminals on Trial in the Hague. London: Hachette Digital.
25.
DrumblMA (2000) Punishment, postgenocide: From guilt to shame to civis in Rwanda. New York University Law Review75(5): 1221–1326.
26.
DunnSNolan-HaleyJ (1998) Conflict in Northern Ireland after the Good Friday Agreement. Fordham International Law Journal22(4): 1372–1388.
27.
FoxNNyseth BrehmH (2018) ‘I decided to save them’: Factors that shaped participation in rescue efforts during genocide in Rwanda. Social Forces94(4): 1625–1648.
28.
FujiiLA (2009) Killing Neighbours: Webs of Violence in Rwanda. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
29.
GolwalkarMS (1939) We or Our Nationhood Defined. Nagpur, India: Bharat Publications.
30.
GrannisR (2009) From the Ground Up: Translating Geography into Community through Neighbor Networks. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
31.
GranovetterM (1985) Economic action and social structure: The problem of embeddedness. American Journal of Sociology91(3): 481–510.
32.
GrossJT (2001) Neighbours: The Destruction of the Jewish Community in Jedwabne, Poland. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
33.
HaydenRM (2000). Rape and rape avoidance in ethno-national conflicts: Sexual violence in liminalized states. American Anthropologist102(1): 27–41.
34.
Human Rights Watch (2002) ‘We Have No Orders to Save You’: State Participation and Complicity in Communal Violence in Gujarat, 14 (3C). Available at: https://www.hrw.org/reports/2002/india/ (accessed 10 December 2021).
35.
JaffrelotC (1993) Hindu nationalism: Strategic syncretism in ideology building. Economic and Political Weekly28(12/13): 517–524.
36.
Justice Nanavati Commission of Inquiry (2005) Anti-Sikh Riots, Vol. 1. New Delhi, India: Justice Nanavati Commission of Inquiry.
37.
KaurJ (2006) Twenty Years of Impunity: The November 1984 Pogroms of Sikhs in India. New Delhi, India: Ensaaf.
MannPH (1954) The concept of neighborliness. American Journal of Sociology60(2): 163–168.
40.
McLarenLM (2003) Anti-immigrant prejudice in Europe: Contact, threat perception, and preferences for the exclusion of migrants. Social Forces81(3): 909–936.
41.
MittaMPhoolkaHS (2007) When a Tree Shook Delhi. New Delhi, India: Roli Books.
42.
PaluckELGreenSAGreenDP (2019) The contact hypothesis re-evaluated. Behavioral Public Policy3(2): 129–158.
43.
People’s Union for Democratic Rights (PUDR) (1984) Who are the Guilty? Report of a Joint Inquiry Into the Causes and Impact of the Riots in Delhi From 31 October to 10 November, 1984. New Delhi, India: People’s Union for Democratic Rights, People's Union for Civil Liberties.
44.
PetersenR (2002) Understanding Ethnic Violence: Fear, Hatred and Resentment in Twentieth-Century Eastern Europe. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
45.
SampsonRJ (2012) Great American City: Chicago and the Enduring Neighborhood Effect. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
46.
SampsonRJRaudenbushSWEarlsF (1997) Neighborhoods and violent crime: A multilevel study of collective efficacy. Science277(5328): 918–924.
47.
Senechal de la RocheR (1996) Collective violence as social control. Sociological Forum11(1): 97–128.
State vs. Naresh Sehrawat and Anr. (2018) In the Court of Shri Ajay Pandey, Additional Sessions Judge 04. Delhi, India: Patiala House Courts.
50.
State vs. Shyam Vir & Others (1996) In the Court of Shri S.N. Dhingra, Session Case No. 34/95. Delhi, India: Karkardooma Courts.
51.
TambiahS (1997) Friends, neighbours, enemies, strangers: Aggressor and victim in civilian ethnic riots. Social Science & Medicine45(8): 1177–1188.
52.
Van EijkG (2011) ‘They eat potatoes, I eat rice’: Symbolic boundary making and space in neighbour relations. Sociological Research Online16(4): 22–23.
53.
VareseFYaishM (2000) The importance of being asked: The rescue of Jews in Nazi Europe. Rationality and Society12(3): 307–334.
54.
VarshneyA (2002) Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life: Hindus and Muslims in India. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
55.
WoodEJ (2006) The ethical challenges of field research in conflict zones. Qualitative Sociology29: 373–386.
56.
YablonYB (2012) Are we preaching to the converted? The role of motivation in understanding the contribution of intergroup encounters. Journal of Peace Education9(3): 249–263.
57.
YoungMWillmottP (1957/1986) Family and Kinship in East London. London/Boston, MA/Henley, TX: Routledge and Kegan Paul.
