There is little question that organized religion as embodied in the Christian churches has not fared well in recent decades. Yet, precisely the period when the decline of organized religion hit its stride – the 1960s and 1970s – also witnessed the rise of what Ernst Troeltsch referred to as ‘mystic religion’, only now it goes by ‘spirituality’. Indeed, recent empirical studies suggest that, in addition to secularization, we are also witnessing a veritable spiritual turn. How do we explain this? We pursue this puzzle in a somewhat peculiar fashion: by turning the sociological gaze toward the lives and oeuvres of the two sociologists who have arguably played the largest roles in the development of classical secularization theory: Max Weber and Peter Berger. Addressing their theoretical contributions in tandem with their personal stances vis-à-vis religion, we argue that the standard account of secularization rests on an extremely one-sided interpretation of their legacy: it leaves out their steadfast romanticism, their deep commitments to the value of individual freedom, and, most importantly, the particular religious paths they charted. Furthermore, we contend that each of them exemplifies a way of reconciling a rationalist commitment to disenchanting science with a romantic longing for ultimate meaning, which sheds significant light on why mystical religion (or ‘spirituality’) has come to flourish in late modernity.
AspremE. (2014). The problem of disenchantment: Scientific naturalism and esoteric discourse, 1903–1939. State University of New York Press.
2.
AupersS.HoutmanD. (2006). Beyond the spiritual supermarket: The social and public significance of New Age spirituality. Journal of Contemporary Religion, 21(2), 201–222.
3.
BaehrP. (2001). The ‘iron cage’ and the ‘shell as hard as steel’: Parsons, Weber, and the stahlhartes Gehäuse metaphor in The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. History and Theory, 40(2), 153–169.
4.
BeethamD. (1994). Max Weber and the liberal political tradition. In HorowitzA.MaleyT. (Eds.), The barbarism of reason: Max Weber and the twilight of enlightenment (pp. 99–112). University of Toronto Press.
5.
BellahR. (1970). Beyond belief: Essays on religion in a post-traditionalist world. University of California Press.
6.
BenderC. (2010). The new metaphysicals: Spirituality and the American religious imagination. University of Chicago Press.
7.
BergerP. L. (1963). Invitation to sociology: A humanistic perspective. Doubleday & Company, Inc.
8.
BergerP. L. (1967). The sacred canopy: Elements of a sociological theory of religion. Anchor Books.
9.
BergerP. L. (1969). A rumor of angels: Modern society and the rediscovery of the supernatural. Doubleday & Company, Inc.
BergerP. L. (1979). The heretical imperative: Contemporary possibilities of religious affirmation. Anchor Press/Doubleday.
12.
BergerP. L. (1998). The culture of liberty: An agenda. Society, 35(2), 407–415.
13.
BergerP. L. (1999). The desecularization of the world: Resurgent religion and world politics. Ethics and Public Policy Center.
14.
BergerP. L. (2012a). A friendly dissent from Pentecostalism. First Things, 227, 45–50.
15.
BergerP. L. (2012b). Further thoughts on religion and modernity. Society, 49, 313–316.
16.
BergerP. L. (2014). The many altars of modernity: Toward a paradigm for religion in a pluralist age. De Gruyter.
17.
BergerP. L.KellnerH. (1981). Sociology reinterpreted: An essay on method and vocation. Anchor Press/Doubleday.
18.
BergerP. L.LuckmannT. (1995). Modernity, pluralism and the crisis of meaning: The orientation of modern man. Bertelsmann Foundation.
19.
BruceS. (2011). Secularization: In defence of an unfashionable theory. Oxford University Press.
20.
BruceS. (2017). Secular beats spiritual: The westernization of the easternization of the west. Oxford University Press.
21.
CampbellC. (1978). The secret religion of the educated classes. Sociological Analysis, 39(2), 146–156.
22.
CampbellC. (2002). The cult, the cultic milieu and secularization. In KaplanJ.LööwH. (Eds.), The cultic milieu: Oppositional subcultures in an age of globalization (pp. 12–25). Altamira Press (Original work published 1972).
23.
CampbellC. (2007). The easternization of the west: A thematic account of cultural change in the modern era. Paradigm Publishers.
24.
ClarkeB.MacdonaldS. (2017). Leaving Christianity: Changing allegiances in Canada since 1945. McGill-Queen’s University Press.
25.
CollinsR. (2007). The classical tradition in sociology of religion. In BeckfordJ. A.Demerath IIIN. J. (Eds.), The SAGE handbook of the sociology of religion (pp. 19–38). Sage.
26.
DaiberK. (2002). Mysticism: Troeltsch’s third type of religious collectivities. Social Compass, 49(3), 329–341.
27.
DobbelaereK. (2011). The meaning and scope of secularization. In ClarkeP. (Ed.), The Oxford handbook of the sociology of religion (pp. 559–613). Oxford University Press.
28.
DorrienG. (2001). Berger: Theology and sociology. In WoodheadL.HeelasP.MartinD. (Eds.), Peter Berger and the study of religion (pp. 26–40). Routledge.
29.
FullerR. C. (2001). Spiritual but not religious: Understanding unchurched America. Oxford University Press.
30.
GarrettW. R. (1975). Maligned mysticism: The maledicted career of Troeltsch’s third type. Sociological Analysis, 36(3), 205–223.
31.
GouldnerA. W. (1962). Anti-minotaur: The myth of a value-free sociology. Social Problems, 9(3), 199–213.
32.
HanegraaffW. J. (1996). New Age religion and western culture: Esotericism in the mirror of secular thought. Brill.
33.
HanegraaffW. J. (2002). New Age religion. In WoodheadL.FletcherP.KawanamiK.SmithD. (Eds.), Religion in the modern world (pp. 249–263). Routledge.
34.
HeelasP.WoodheadL. (2005). The spiritual revolution: Why religion is giving way to spirituality. Blackwell.
35.
HennisW. (1998). The spiritualist foundation of Max Weber’s ‘interpretative sociology’: Ernst Troeltsch, Max Weber and William James’Varieties of Religious Experience. History of the Human Sciences, 11(2), 83–106.
36.
HöllingerF.SmithT. B. (2002). Religion and esotericism among students: A cross-cultural comparative study. Journal of Contemporary Religion, 17(2), 229–249.
37.
HonigsheimP. (2000). The unknown Max Weber. Transaction Publishers.
38.
HoutmanD. (2021). The disenchantment of the world and the authority of sociology: How the queen of the sciences lost her throne. In HoutmanD.AupersS.LaermansR. (Eds.), Science under siege: Contesting the secular religion of scientism (pp. 37–63). Palgrave Macmillan.
39.
HoutmanD.AupersS. (2007). The spiritual turn and the decline of tradition: The spread of post-Christian spirituality in 14 western countries, 1981–2000. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 46(3), 305–320.
40.
HoutmanD.AupersS. (2010). Religions of modernity: Relocating the sacred to the self and the digital. In AupersS.HoutmanD. (Eds.), Religions of modernity: Relocating the sacred to the self and the digital (pp. 1–30). Brill.
41.
HoutmanD.MasciniP. (2002). Why do churches become empty, while New Age grows? Secularization and religious change in the Netherlands. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 41(3), 455–473.
42.
JamesW. (1990). The varieties of religious experience. Vintage Books (Original work published 1902).
43.
Josephson-StormJ. Ã. (2017). The myth of disenchantment: Magic, modernity, and the birth of the human sciences. University of Chicago Press.
44.
KontosA. (1994). The world disenchanted, and the return of gods and demons. In HorowitzA.MaleyT. (Eds.), The barbarism of reason: Max Weber and the twilight of Enlightenment (pp. 223–247). University of Toronto Press.
45.
LewisJ. R.CurrieS. E.Oman-ReaganM. P. (2016). The religion of the educated classes revisited: New religions, the nonreligious, and educational levels. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 55(1), 91–104.
46.
MartinB. (2001). Berger’s anthropological theology. In WoodheadL.HeelasP.MartinD. (Eds.), Peter Berger and the study of religion (pp. 154–188). Routledge.
47.
PalonenK. (1999). Max Weber’s reconceptualization of freedom. Political Theory, 27(4), 523–544.
48.
PorterfieldA. (2001). The transformation of American religion: The story of a late-twentieth-century awakening. Oxford University Press.
49.
RadkauJ. (2009). Max Weber: A biography. Polity Press (Original work published in German 2005).
50.
RobertsonR. (1975). On the analysis of mysticism: Pre-Weberian, Weberian and post-Weberian perspectives. Sociological Analysis, 36(3), 241–266.
51.
RoofW. C. (1999). Spiritual marketplace: Baby boomers and the remaking of American religion. Princeton University Press.
52.
SchmidtL. E. (2012). Restless souls: The making of American spirituality. University of California Press.
53.
SeidmanS. (1983). Modernity, meaning, and cultural pessimism in Max Weber. Sociological Analysis, 44(4), 267–278.
54.
SeidmanS.GruberM. (1977). Capitalism and individuation in the sociology of Max Weber. British Journal of Sociology, 28(4), 498–508.
55.
TaylorC. (2002). Varieties of religion today: William James revisited. Harvard University Press.
56.
TaylorC. (2007). A secular age. The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
57.
TroeltschE. (1992). The social teachings of the Christian churches: Volume II (WyonO., Trans.). Westminster/John Knox Press (Original work published in German 1912).
58.
TrompP.PlessA.HoutmanD. (2020). ‘Believing without belonging’ in twenty European countries (1981–2008): De-institutionalization of Christianity or spiritualization of religion?Review of Religious Research, 62(4), 509–531.
59.
VoasD.CrockettA. (2005). Religion in Britain: Neither believing nor belonging. Sociology, 39(1), 11–28.
60.
WattsG. (2018a). On the politics of self-spirituality: A Canadian case study. Studies in Religion, 47(3), 345–372.
61.
WattsG. (2018b). Missing the forest for the trees: ‘Spiritual’ religion in a secular age. Toronto Journal of Theology, 34(2), 243–256.
62.
WattsG. (2022). The religion of the heart: ‘Spirituality’ in late modernity. American Journal of Cultural Sociology, 10, 1–33.
63.
WeberM. (1946). From Max Weber: Essays in sociology (GerthH. H.MillsC. W.Trans.). Oxford University Press.
64.
WeberM. (1949). ‘Objectivity’ in social science and social policy. In The methodology of the social sciences (pp. 49–112) (ShilsE. A.FinchH. A. Trans.). The Free Press.
65.
WeberM. (1991). The sociology of religion. Beacon Press (Original work published in German 1922).
66.
WeberM. (2003). The Protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism (ParsonsT. Trans.). Dover (Original work published in German 1904/1905).
67.
Wilkins-LaflammeS. (2021). A tale of decline or change? Working toward a complementary understanding of secular transition and individual spiritualization theories. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 60(3), 516–539.
68.
WuthnowR. (1976). The consciousness reformation. University of California Press.
69.
Zarrabi-ZadehS. (2020). The ‘mystical’ and the ‘modern’: Mutual entanglements and multiple interactions. Studies in Religion, 49(4), 525–545.
