This article scripts a genealogy of Indian sociology radically different from its regnant history. Its fundamental thesis is that Indian/Hindu nationalism and knowledge are entwined such that to view them separately is to understand neither. To substantiate this thesis, it focuses on the othering of Islam/Muslims. Far from being accidental, this othering is organised and so ‘naturalised’ in the histories of sociology and majoritarian nationalism––itself reworked from Indology––that it defies the ‘divide’ between traditionalist, Hindu revivalist and ‘communal’, on one hand, and Gandhian, Nehruvian, ‘secular’ and ‘liberal’, on the other. The first section discusses an early global moment when the Empire hired Patrick Geddes to found the first department of sociology in India and who worked for settler Zionism. The second section discusses sociology’s treatment of Islam in the catalogues of silence, erasure and assimilation. Vis-à-vis D. P. Mukherjee’s insistence on sociologist becoming Indian first, the third section compares the nexus between knowledge and Indian nationalism with the one in Germany and the USSR. Invoking Ghalib, who recognised colossal challenges to becoming human first, the article concludes by urging sociologists to become human first and then study nationalism, rather than making the former hostage to the latter to enact dehumanisation. Ultimately, this article demonstrates how the power/knowledge matrix works in sociology.
AhmadI. (2013a). Anthropology of Islam: History, culture, power. Indian Economic and Social History Review, 50(4), 495–509.
2.
AhmadI. (2013b). In defence of ho(s)tel: Islamophobia, domophilia, liberalism. Politics, Religion & Ideology, 14(2), 234–252.
3.
AhmadI. (2014). Kafka in India: Terrorism, media, Muslims. In JeffreyR. & SenR. (Eds), Being Muslims in South Asia (pp. 289–329). Oxford University Press.
4.
AhmadI. (2015). Islamic reform in Asia. In TurnerB. & SaleminkO. (Eds), Routledge handbook of religions in Asia (pp. 144–157). Routledge.
5.
AhmadI. (2017a). Religion as critique: Islamic critical thinking from Mecca to the marketplace. University of North Carolina Press.
6.
AhmadI. (2017b). Injustice and the new world order: An anthropological perspective on ‘terrorism’ in India. Critical Studies on Terrorism, 10(1), 115–137.
7.
AhmadI. (2018, March–April). On the absence of the political in four-field anthropology. Anthropology News. https://doi.org/10.1111/AN.804
8.
AhmadI. (2019). Introduction: Democracy and the algebra of warfare–welfare. In AhmadI. & KanungoP. (Eds), The algebra of warfare–welfare: A long view of India’s 2014 election (pp. 1–54). Oxford University Press.
9.
AhmadI. (2021, November22). Combat-concepts in Indian politics: Understanding democracy as politics of enmity. The Polis Project. https://www.thepolisproject.com/read/combat-concepts-in-indian-politics-understanding-democracy-as-politics-of-enmity/
10.
AhmadI. (2022a). Violence after violence: The politics of narratives over the Delhi pogrom. In HansenT. B. & RoyS. (Eds), Saffron republic: Hindu nationalism and state power in India (pp. 251–274). Cambridge University Press.
11.
AhmadI. (2022b, December6). Destruction of Babri Masjid and phantom of Nehruvian Secularism. Maktoob. https://maktoobmedia.com/opinion/destruction-of-babri-masjid-and-phantom-of-nehruvian-secularism/
12.
AhmadI. (2023). Nationalism and knowledge: Othering and the disciplin(e)ing of anthropology in India. History & Anthropology, 34(5), 904–931. https://doi.org/10.1080/02757206.2023.2237064
13.
AhmadIrfan. 2024. “Drinking Secularism: A Critique of Shahab Ahmed’s What is Islam?”Religion and Society: Advances in Research, 15: 23–46. https://doi.org/10.3167/arrs.2024.150103
14.
AhmadI. (2025). Recognizing Hindu Orientalism. Journal of Political Ideologies, 30(1), 285–305. https://doi.org/10.1080/13569317.2023.2196244
15.
AhmadI. (2026). Terrorism in question: Decolonizing anthropology and the study of Islam. Berghahn Books.
16.
AhmadI., & van der VeerP. (2022). Muslim bare life in contemporary India. In AhmadI. & KangJ. (Eds), The nation form in the global age: Ethnographic perspectives (pp. 127–152). Palgrave Macmillan.
17.
AhmedI. (Ed.). (1973). Caste and social stratification among Muslims in India. Manohar Publishers.
18.
AhmedI. (Ed.). (1977). Family, kinship and marriage among Muslims in India. Manohar Publishers.
19.
AhmedI. (Ed.). (1981). Modernization and social change among Muslims in India. Manohar Publishers.
20.
AhmedI. (1986). Issues in the study of Muslims in India. In ModiI. (Ed.), Emerging trends in Indian sociology (pp. 206–221). Rawat Publications.
21.
AhmedI. (1972). For a sociology of India. Contributions to Indian Sociology, 6(1), 172–178.
22.
AnsariG. (1960). Muslim caste in Uttar Pradesh: A study of culture contact. Ethnographic and Folk Culture Society.
AsadT. (1986). The idea of an anthropology of Islam. Center for Contemporary Arab Studies, Georgetown University.
25.
AsifM. (2020). The loss of Hindustan, the invention of India. Harvard University Press.
26.
AtalY. (2015). Sociology: Study of the social sphere (2nd ed.). Pearson.
27.
BeteilleA. (2002). Sociology: Essays on approach and method. Oxford University Press.
28.
BharatiA. (1981). Hindu views and ways and Hindu-Muslim interface: An anthropological assessment. Munshiram Publishers.
29.
BoseN. K. (1929/1961). Cultural anthropology. Asia Publishing House.
30.
BoseN. K. (1969). Problems of Indian nationalism. Allied Publishers.
31.
BoyerD., & LomnitzC. (2005). Intellectuals and nationalism: Anthropological engagements. Annual Review of Anthropology, 34(1), 105–120.
32.
BrassP. (2006). Collective violence, human rights, and the politics of curfew. Journal of Human Rights, 5(3), 323–340.
33.
ChandrasekherS. (1976). Foreword. In GuptaG. (Ed.), Contemporary India: Some sociological perspectives (pp. xi–xii). Vikas Publications.
34.
ChopraS., & JhaP. (2014). On their watch: Mass violence and state apathy in India. Three Essays Collective.
35.
DasV. (1984). For a folk-theology and theological anthropology of Islam. Contributions to Indian Sociology, 18(2), 293–300.
36.
DesaiI. P. (1996). Craft of sociology in India: An autobiographical perspective. In SinghiN. (Ed.), Sociology in India: Retrospect and prospect (pp. 167–199). Rawat Publications.
37.
DeshpandeS. (2003). Contemporary India: A sociological view. Viking.
38.
DharP. N. (1987). Bengal renaissance: A study in social contradiction. Social Scientist, 15(1), 26–45.
FoucaultM. (1994). Genealogy and social criticism. In SeidmanS. (Ed.), The postmodern turn: New perspectives on social theory (pp. 139–164). Cambridge University Press.
49.
FoucaultM. (2024). What is critique? And the culture of the self. University of Chicago Press.
50.
GhuryeG. S. (1968). Social tensions in India. Popular Prakashan.
51.
GoodhewD. (2023). George Orwell: Closet Anglican?https://livingchurch.org/covenant/george-orwell-closet-anglican/
52.
HauschildT. (1997). Christian, Jews, and the other in German anthropology. American Anthropologist, 99(4), 746–753.
53.
HirschF. (2005). Empire of nations: Ethnographic knowledge and the making of the Soviet Union. Cornell University Press.
54.
HunterW. W. (1871). The Indian Musalmans: Are they bound in conscience to rebel against the queen?Trubner.
55.
JaffrelotC. (Ed.). (2007). Hindu nationalism: A reader. Princeton University Press.
56.
JoshiP. C. (1986). Founders of the Lucknow school and their legacy: Radhakamal Mukerjee and D. P. Mukerji. Economic & Political Weekly, 21(33), 1455–1469.
57.
KantI. (1784/2007). What is aufklärung? In LotringerS. (Ed.), Michel Foucault: The politics of truth (pp. 29–37). Semiotext(e).
58.
KarveI. (1947). Racial conflict. In MajumdarD. N. & KarveI. (Eds), Racial problems in India (pp. 27–54). Indian Council of World Affairs.
59.
MajumdarD. N., & MadanT. N. (1999). An introduction to social anthropology. Mayoor.
60.
MadanT. N. (Ed.). (1991). Introduction. InReligion in India (pp. 1–22). Oxford University Press.
61.
MadanT. N. (1996). Dialectic of tradition and modernity in the sociology of DP Mukherjee. In SinghiN. (Ed.), Sociology in India: Retrospect and prospect (pp. 382–404). Rawat Publications.
62.
MadanT. N. (2003). Religion. In DasV. (Ed.), The Oxford India companion to sociology and social anthropology (Vol. 2, pp. 1001)–1036). Oxford University Press.
63.
MadanT. N. (2007). One from many: Explorations in the anthropology of Islam. The Eastern Anthropologist, 60(1), 1–25.
64.
MadanT. N. (2011). Sociological traditions: Methods and perspectives in the sociology of India. Sage Publications.
65.
MaksudyanN. (2023). Racial anthropology in Turkey and transnational entanglements in the making of scientific knowledge. History of the Human Sciences, 36(2), 154–177.
66.
MantoS. H. (1954). Ūpar, nīchē avr darmeyāñ. Gosha-e-adab.
67.
MeyersJ. (2000). Orwell: Wintry conscience of a generation. W.W. Norton.
68.
MukerjeeR. (1958). A history of Indian civilization (Vol. 1). Hind Kitab.
69.
MukherjeeR. (1976). Indian sociology: Historical development and present problem. InSocial sciences and social realities (pp. 84–102). Indian Institute of Advanced Study.
70.
MunshiI. (2007). Patrick Geddes: Sociologist, environmentalist and town Planner. In UberoiP., SundarN. & DeshpandeS. (Eds), Anthropology in the East: Founders of Indian sociology and anthropology (pp. 172–193). Permanent Black.
71.
NadviA. A. (1992). Hindustānī musalmān. Majlis-e-taḥqīqāt.
72.
NandyA. (1988). The politics of secularism and the recovery of religious tolerance. Alternatives, 23(2), 177–194.
73.
NasrV. R. (1999). European colonialism and the emergence of modern Muslim states. In EspositoJ. (Ed.), The Oxford history of Islam (pp. 549–600). Oxford University Press.
74.
NCERT. (1982). Understanding society: Sociology, the discipline and its significance.
75.
NCERT. (1990). Sociology: An introduction, textbook for class XI.
76.
NCERT. (2006). Understanding society, textbook for class XI.
77.
NietzscheF. (2003). The genealogy of morals. Dover.
78.
OrwellG. (1972). The freedom of the press. https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwell/essays-and-other-works/the-freedom-of-the-press/
79.
OrwellG. (1946/2002). Why I write? In Orwell: Essays (selected and introduced by John Carey) (pp. 1079–1085). Everyman’s Library.
80.
OzdalgaE. (2006). The hidden Arab: A critical reading of the notion of ‘Turkish Islam’. Middle East Studies, 42(4), 551–570.
81.
PatelS. (2002). The profession and its association: Five decades of Indian Sociological Society. International Sociology, 17(2), 269–284.
82.
PatelS. (2010). At crossroads: Sociology in India. In PatelS. (Ed.), The ISA handbook of diverse sociological traditions (pp. 280–291). Sage Publications.
83.
PatelS. (2011). Sociology in India: Trajectories and challenges. Contributions to Indian Sociology, 45(3), 427–435.
84.
PaytonN. (1995). The machine in the garden city: Patrick Geddes’ plan for Tel Aviv. Planning Perspectives, 10(4), 359–381.
85.
PremchandM. (n.d.). Maiñ afsāna keyoñ likẖta huñ. In YusufH. M. (Ed.), Maiñ afsāna keyoñ kar likhta huñ (pp. 11–15). Darul Adab Punjab.
86.
RobinsonF. (1983). Islam and Muslim society in South Asia. Contributions to Indian Sociology, 17(2), 185–203.
87.
RubinH. (2011). Geography, colonialism and the town planning: Patrick Geddes’ plan for Mandatory Jerusalem. Cultural Geographies, 18(2), 231–248.
88.
SaraswatiB. (2002). Prof. Nirmal Bose. In BhattacharyaR. & SarkarJ. (Eds), Passage through Indian civilization (pp. 10–39). Anthropological Survey of India.
89.
ScottJ., & BromleyR. (2013). Envisioning sociology: Victor Branford, Patrick Geddes and the quest for social reconstruction. State University of New York.
90.
SharmaM. (2023). Hindu nationalism and right-wing ecology. Studies in Indian Politics, 11(1), 102–117.
91.
ShoreC., & WrightS. (1999). Audit culture and anthropology. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 5(4), 557–575.
92.
SingerM. (1955). The cultural pattern of Indian civilization. Far Eastern Quarterly, 15(1), 23–36.
93.
SinghY. (1986a). Indian sociology: Social conditioning and emerging concerns. Vistaar.
94.
SinghY. (1972/1986b). Modernization of Indian tradition. Rawat Publications.
95.
SinghiN. (Ed.). (1996). Theory and ideology in Indian sociology: Essays in honour of Professor Yogendra Singh. Rawat Publications.
96.
SpencerJ. (2007). Anthropology, politics and the state. Cambridge University Press
97.
SpillerL. (2003). George Orwell’s anti-Catholicism. Logos, 6(4), 150–163.
98.
SrinivasM. N. (1991). India: Social structure. Hindustan.
99.
SrinivasM. N. (1987). Development of sociology in India: An overview. Economic & Political Weekly, 22(4), 135–138.
100.
SrinivasM. N. (2002). Collected Essays. Oxford University Press.
101.
SunderN. (2007). In the cause of anthropology: The life and work of Iravati Karve. In UberoiP., SundarN. & DeshpandeS. (Eds), Anthropology in the East: Founders of Indian sociology and anthropology (pp. 360–416). Permanent Black.
102.
ThakurM. (2012). Radhakamal Mukerjee and the quest for an Indian sociology. Sociological Bulletin, 61(1), 89–108.
103.
ThakurM. (2014). Sociological traditions: Contexts, claims and practices. Contributions to Indian Sociology, 48(3), 419–428.
104.
ThakurM. (2018). The quest for indigenous theory: Then and now. In ChaudhuriM. & ThakurM. (Eds), Doing theory: Locations, hierarchies & disjunctions (pp. 39–58). Orient BlackSwan.
105.
The Quint. (2019, August29). 50% of cops feel Muslims are more prone to criminality: CSDS study.
106.
TRT World. (2022). How did the Baburids rule India. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qm8WVnOLyZ4
107.
UberoiP. (2000). Déjà vu. Seminar, 495, 14–19.
108.
UberoiP., SundarN., & DeshpandeS. (Eds). (2007). Anthropology in the east: Founders of Indian sociology and anthropology. Seagull.
109.
UpadhyaC. (2007). The idea of Indian society: GS Ghurye and the making of Indian sociology. In UberoiUberoi P., SundarN. & DeshpandeS. (Eds), Anthropology in the East: Founders of Indian sociology and anthropology (pp. 195–225). Permanent Black.
110.
VHP, Australia. (2021). Submission to the Queensland government. https://documents.parliament.qld.gov.au/com/LASC-C96E/I-20CA/submissions/00000051.pdf
111.
ViswanathanG. (1995). Beyond orientalism: Syncretism and the politics of knowledge. Stanford Humanities Review, 5(1), 19–32.
112.
WittgensteinL. (1980). Culture and value. University of Chicago Press.
