Improvement of the Damaged Thermowell of the Monju Fast-Breeder Reactor Based on Vibration Analysis

Abstract

In December 1995, the thermowell in the secondary cooling system of the Japanese fast-breeder reactor Monju was damaged, resulting in a sodium leak. Sodium flow was thought to have produced a vibration in the thermowell that then caused high-cycle fatigue that eventually destroyed the thermowell. Using the finite element method, the natural frequency of the thermowell was found to be approximately 230 Hz, which is in the region of resonance of the fluid vibration. Next, in a theoretical study, the authors altered the position at which the diameter of the thermowell changes and examined the resulting natural frequencies. They also studied the effects of thickness and diameter on the natural frequency of the thermowell and examined the case for a truncated conical thermowell. The results indicate that production of a thermowell that is not affected by vibration due to resonance is possible. This paper recommends improved shapes for the thermowell.

Keywords

Natural frequency thermowell thermometer flow-induced vibration FEM sodium leak FBR

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

[1] Aoi, H. , T. Shimooke , and Y. Zhao . 1998. Vibration analysis of the damaged thermometer at the Monju fast breeder reactor. In Fourth World Congress on Computational Mechanics, Buenos Aires, I-115.

[2] Aoi, H. , T. Shimooke , and Y. Zhao . 1998. Vibration analysis of Monju thermometer. The Japan Society for Computational Engineering and Science 3:699-702 (in Japanese).

[3] Shimooke, T. , and H. Aoi . 1998. A conservative evaluation equation for normal-mode frequency of the sharp diameter-change type thermowell. Memoirs of the Hiroshima-Denki Institute of Technology and the Hiroshima Junior College of Automotive Engineering 31:45-51 (in Japanese).

[4] Anoda, Y. , et al. 1996. Water flow simulation of the flow-induced vibration phenomenon of the thermowell in the prototype-FBR “Monju.” JAERI-Tech, 96-028 (in Japanese).

[5] Itoh, K. , et al. 1997. Technical report on Monju's sodium leak incident. Journal of the Atomic Energy Society of Japan 39 (9): 2-30 (in Japanese).

[6] ASME . 1995. ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, Division 1, Appendix N-1300. ASME.

[7] Kobori, Y. 1981. Practical method of vibration calculation. Kogaku-Tosho (in Japanese).

[8] Kunieda, M. 1995. Mechanical vibration. Rikougaku-sha (in Japanese).

[9] Fenner, R. 1996. Finite element method for engineering. London: Imperial College Press.

10.

[10] Hitachi, Ltd. 1992. HITAC APP, CNDYN program, APP-A-901-20. Kanagawa-ken, Japan: Hitachi, Ltd.

11.

[11] Hitachi, Ltd. 1999. HITACHI APP, HICAD/CADAS, APP-B-380-A0. Version 02-05. Kanagawa-ken, Japan: Hitachi, Ltd.