The factors determining the use of Section 31 admissions and reclassifications at a district psychiatric hospital were investigated prospectively over an eight month period. Thirty-six per cent of patients failed to meet the criteria laid down for full detention and, particularly with reclassification. Section 31 was invoked to secure treatment. While the Emergency Recommendation is not used as the legislators intended, a seven day detention order appears more relevant to modern psychiatric practice than the full detention procedure.
ChiswickD. Operating the Mental Health Acts. Br J Hosp Med1979;; 21:167–175.
2.
ElliotWATimburyGCWalkerMW. Compulsory admission to hospital: An operational review of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act, 1960. Br J Psychiat1979; 135:104–114.
3.
ChiswickD. Section 31 of the Mental Health (Scotland) Act 1960. Compulsory crisis intervention? Int J Law Psychiat1980; 3:435–441.
4.
McPhailNI. Behavioural disturbances in a general hospital psychiatric unit. Health Bull1978; 36:79–88.
5.
BeanP. Compulsory Admissions to Mental Hospitals. Chichester: John Wiley and Sons, 1980.
6.
MastertonGNewlandsCATimburyGC. The validity of emergency recommendations for compulsory psychiatric care. Scott Med J1980; 25:299–301.
7.
EnochMDBarkerJC. Misuse of Section 29: Fact or fiction?Lancet1965; 1:760.
8.
BartonRHaiderI. Unnecessary compulsory admission to a psychiatric hospital. Med Sci Law1966; 6: 147–150. Scott Med J 1979; 24:108–110.
9.
ElliotWA. Modern Mental Health Acts. Scott Med J1979; 24:108–110.
10.
The Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland. Does the patient come first?Edinburgh: HM Stationery Office, 1981.
11.
GunnJ. Reform of mental health legislation. Br Med J1981; 283:1487–1488.
