A careful review of Robert Burns's terminal illness, especially as documented in his correspondence, supports the widely held contention that death may have been due to subacute bacterial endocarditis secondary to chronic rheumatic heart disease. However, it is also possible that death may have been caused by brucellosis or some non-infectious process such as malignant lymphoma. There is no evidence that Robert Burns suffered from either chronic alcoholism or venereal disease. The evidence that he may have died a doctor's martyr as a result of treatment with a mercury ointment is critically examined.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CarlyleT. In LockhartJ G. 1904. The Life of Robert BurnsLondon: Huchison and Co1828; 241–290.
2.
HeronR. A Memoir of the Life of the Late Robert Burns 1797. In HechtHans. Robert Burns–The Man and His WorkGlasgow: Wm. Hodge & Co Ltd1950:257–282.
3.
PeterkinA. The Life and Works of Robert Burns, as originally edited by CurrieM.D. JamesEdinburgh: MacReadie, Skelly and Muckersy1815:214–215.
4.
LockhartJG. Life of Robert Burns. Edinburgh1828.
5.
CunninghamA. The Works of Robert Burns, with his Life: 8 Vols. London1834.
6.
BurnsR. Letter to Robert Ainslie, Nov. 1791. No. 482 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ., 1790–1796. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:99–100.
7.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr Samuel Clarke Jr, Dumfries, 1794, No. 631 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ. 1790–1796. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:249–250.
8.
BurnsR. (Letter to Mrs Dunlop, Jan. 2nd. No. 529) in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.1790–1796. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:140–142.
9.
BurnsR. Letter to William Cruikshank, 3rd March 1788. No. 214 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ., 1780–1789. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 1:198.
10.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Agnes McLehose, 6th March 1788. No. 217 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ., 1780–1790. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 1:201.
11.
DeanRamsay. Reminiscences of Scottish Life and Character. London: Cassell and Co Ltd. 1858; 75.
12.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Robert Ridden, 1793. No. 608 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ. 1790–1796. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:226–227.
13.
ChambersR. The Life and Work of Robert Burns. Edinburgh: W. & R. Chambers1851–1852; 4:183.
14.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr Robt. Cleghorn, Saughton Mills, Edinburgh, January 1796. No. 687 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Vol. II. 1790–1796. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press 1931: 2: 315.
15.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop of Dunlop, Dunlop House, Stewarton, January 31st, 1796. No. 688 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Vol. II, 1790–1796. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:315–316.
16.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr James Johnson, Engraver, Music Shop, Lawn Market, Edinburgh, 24th February 1796, No. 690 in The Letters of Robert Burns, 1790–1796. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ., Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:135.
17.
CurrieJ. The Works of Robert Burns with an Account of His Life. London: Cadell and Davies1800; 1:219.
18.
De. L. FergusonJ.The Letters of Robert Burns, Vol. I, 1780–1789, Vol. II, 1790–1796. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931.
19.
GrayJ. In A. Peterkin's The Life and Works of Robert Burns. Originally Edited by CurrieM.D. James, Edinburgh: MacReadie, Skelly and Muchersy1815; Vol. I:IXXXV.
20.
FindtaterA. In A. Peterlin's The Life and Works of Robert Burns. Originally Edited by CurrieM.D. James, Edinburgh: MacReadie, Skelly and Muckersy1815; Vol. I:XCii–XCV.
21.
BurnsG. In A. Peterkin's The Life and Works of Robert Burns. Originally Edited by CurrieM.D. James, Edinburgh; MacReadie, Skelly and Muckersy1815; Vol. I:IXXV–IXXXii.
22.
Riddell Maria as ‘Candidior’, character sketch in Dumfries Journal, August 1796. In James Currie's The Works of Robert Burns, with an Account of His Life, 2nd Edition 1801; 1: 247–259.
23.
HechtH. Robert Burns, The Man and His Work. London: William Hodge & Co Ltd1950.
24.
LindsayM. Robert Burns The Man, His Work, The Legend, London: MacGibbon and Kee1954.
25.
SnyderFB. The Life of Robert Burns, New York:Archon Books, 1968.
26.
BarkeJ. The Wonder of All The Gay World. Glasgow: Collins1949.
27.
DentA. Burns in His Time. London: Thomas Nelson & Sons Ltd. 1966; 156.
28.
CurrieJ. The Works of Robert Burns, with an Account of His Life. London: Cadell and Davies1800; 1:219.
29.
BurnsG. Narrative of his Brother's life (originally written as a letter to Mrs Dunlop). In LindsayM. The Burns Encyclopaedia, Hutchison of London1970;387–394.
30.
SnyderFB. The Life of Robert Burns, New York:Archon Books1968:447.
31.
Chrichton-BrowneJ. Burns from a New Point Of View. London: Hodder and Stoughton1926; 62.
32.
AndersonHB. Robert Burns, his medical friends, attendants, and biographers. Ann Med Hist1928; 10:47.
33.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop, 25th June 1794. No 628 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:246.
34.
BurnsR. Letter to William Creech, May 1795 No. 671 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:302.
35.
DouglasWS. The Complete Poetical Works of Robert Burns, London: Swan Sonnenschein & Co. 1890; 2:145.
36.
HenleyWEHendersonTF. The Poetry of Robert Burns. London: Caxton Publishing Co.1896; 2:342.
37.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr Robt. Cleghorn, Saughton Mills, Edinburgh, per favor of Mr Mundell, Surgeon. January 1796. No. 687 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:315.
38.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop of Dunlop, Dunlop-House, Stewarton, 31st January 1796. No. 688 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:315–316.
39.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr George Thomson, Trustees Officer, Edinburgh, per favor of Mrs Hyslop, April 1796. No. 693 in The Letters of Robert Burns. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:319–320.
40.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr George Thomson, Trustees Officer, Edinburgh, May 1796. No 694 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:320–321.
41.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr James Johnson, Engraver, Lawn Market, Edinburgh, per favor of Mr Levars (deleted) about 1st June 1796. No 696 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:322–323.
42.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Riddell, Halleaths, 1st June 1796. No 697 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:323.
43.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr James Clarke, Schoolmaster, Forfar, June 26th 1796. No. 698 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:323–324.
44.
BurnsR. Letter to George Thomson, 4th July 1796. No. 699 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:324.
45.
BurnsR. Letter to Alexr Cunningham, Esq. No 37 Geo Street, Edinr, July 7th 1796. In The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ., Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:325.
46.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr Jas Armour, Mason, Mauchline, July 10th 1796. No 701 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:326.
47.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop of Dunlop, Dunlop-House, Stewarton, July 10th 1796 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:326.
48.
BurnsR. Letter to Gilbert Burns, July 10th 1796. No. 703 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:326–327.
49.
BurnsR. Letter to James Burness, Writer, Montrose, July 12th 1796. No. 705 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:327–328.
50.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr George Thomson, Trustees’ Office, Edinr, July 12th 1796. No. 706 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:328.
51.
SnyderFB. The Life of Robert Burns. New York: Archon Books1968;427–428.
52.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr Jas Gracie, Dumfries, 13th July 1796. No. 707 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford:Clarendon Press1931; 2:329.
53.
BurnsR. Letter to Jean Armour Burns, 14th July 1796. No 708 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford:Clarendon Press1931; 1:329.
54.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr James Armour, Mauchline, 18th July 1796. No. 710 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford:Clarendon Press1931; 2:330.
55.
CunninghamA. Robert Burns and Lord Byron, London Magazine 1st Series1824; 10:117–122.
56.
CurrieJ. Life of Robert Burns. Edinburgh: 1828; 218.
57.
LowDA. Critical Essays on Robert Burns, Edited by LowD. A., London: Routledge and Kegan Paul1975:1.
58.
BurnsG. Letter to Mrs Dunlop In The Burns Encyclopaedia by Maurice Lindsay Hutchison of London 1970; 387–394.
59.
BarnesPFitzgeraldGBrownMDolleryC. Nocturnal asthma and changes in circulating epinephrine, histamine, and Cortisol. N Engl J Med1980; 303:263–267.
60.
BurnsR. Robert Burns's Commonplace Book, 1783–1785, Edited by EwingJ Cameron, D Cook, Glasgow1938; 18.
61.
SnyderFB. The Life of Robert BurnsNew York: Archon Books1968; 343.
62.
HechtH. Robert Burns, The Man and His Work. Glasgow: William Hodge and Co Ltd1950227.
63.
SnyderFB. The Life of Robert Burns. London: Archon Books1968; 343.
64.
BurnsR. Letter to Mr William Burns, 10th Nov. 1789 In The Letters of Robert Burns, 1780–1789, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 1:368–369.
65.
BurnsR. Letter to Gilbert Burns, 11th Jan 1790. No. 381 in The Letters of Robert Burns, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ., 1790–1796. Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:1.
66.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop, Stewarton 13th Dec 1789. No. 374 in The Letters of Robert Burns 1780–1789, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 1:372–374.
67.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop, 8th Nov 1789. No. 371 in the Letters of Robert Burns 1780–1789, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 1:367–368.
68.
BurnsR. Letter to William Cruickshank, December 1788. No. 292 in The Letters of Robert Burns 1780–1789. Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarenden Press1931; 1:281–282.
69.
BurnsR. Letter to Alexander Fraser Tytler, April 1791. No. 445 in The Letters of Robert Burns 1790–1796, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:69–70.
70.
BurnsR. Letter to Patrick Heron, March 1795. No. 660 in The Letters of Robert Burns 1790–1796, Edited by De Lancey FergusonJ.Oxford: Claredon Press1931; 2:291–293.
71.
BurnsR. Letter to Mrs Dunlop, 14th Jan 1792. No. 491 in The Letters of Robert Burns, 1790–1796, Edited by de Lancey FergusonJ., Oxford: Clarendon Press1931; 2:105–106.
72.
ChreightonC. Scarlatina and diphtheria. Chapter VII in A History of Epidemics in Britain, Vol. 2, Second Edition 1965. London: Frank Cass & Co Ltd1965; 2:678–746.
73.
GoodallAL. Robert Burns and the Medical Profession. Scott Med J1959; 4:133–140.
74.
MarstonJA. Report on Fever (Malta). Army Medical Report1861; 3:486–521.
75.
HardyAV. Arthritis in brucella melitensis infections. Med Clin N Am1937;21: No. 6, 1747–1749.
76.
HuddlesonIF. Brucellosis in Man and Animals. New York: The Commonwealth Fund1939;75–125.
77.
KellyPJMartinWJSchirgerAWeedLA. Brucellosis of the bones and joints. JAMA, 1960; 174:347–353.
78.
HerrellWEBarberTS. Treatment of Brucellosis with aureomycin or terramycin combined with dihydrostreptomycin. Postgrad Med1952; 11:476–486.
79.
OslerW. The Principles and Practice of Medicine. New York: D Appleton and Co. 1892; 266–268.
80.
MakinMAlkalajIRosanskyR. Mono-articular brucellar arthritis. J Bone Jt Surg1957;39A:1183–1186.
81.
DavisBDDulbeccoREisenHNGinsbergHSWoodBJMcCartyM. The brucellae in Microbiology, 2nd Edition, Hagerstown, Maryland, USA: Harper & Row, Publishers, Inc.1973;812–817.
82.
BalintGP. Rheumatic Disease Diagnosis by Punch-card (personal communication, Department of Rheumatology, Budapest, Hungary).
83.
PickeringG. Creative Malady. London: George Allen and Unwin Ltd1974.
84.
LockhartJG. The Life of Robert Burns, London: Huchison & Co (first published 1828), 1904; 200.
85.
SnyderFB. The Life of Robert Burns, New York:Archon Books1968; 327.
86.
FindlayW. Robert Burns and the Medical Profession. Paisley: Alexander Gardner1898.
87.
PitcairnDWellsWC. On rheumatism of the heart. Transactions of the Society for Improvement of medico-chirurgical knowledge1812; 3:373–424.
88.
JennerE, cited in A Medical Bibliography (Garrison and Morton). Edited by MortonL T, Third Edition. London: Andre Deutsch Ltd., Abstract 2740; 327.
89.
WellsWC. On rheumatism of the heart. Transactions of the Society for Improvement of Medico-chirurgical knowledge1812; 3:373–424.
90.
BouillaudJB. Traité cliniques des maladies du coer, 2 vols. Paris: J B Bailliere1835; 2:238.
91.
DavidBruceSir. Note on the discovery of a microorganism in Malta fever. Practitioner1887; 39:161–170.
92.
LaennecRTH. De Pauscultation mèdiate, 2 Vols. Paris: J A Brosson & J S Chaudé1819.
93.
AllbuttTCSir. Medical thermometry. Brit Forensic Medico Chirurgical Review1870; 45:429–441.
94.
GelfandM. Livingstone The Doctor, His Life and Travels. A Study in Medical History. Oxford: Basil Blackwell1957; 9.
95.
ThomsonJ. Education: Man's Salvation from Crime, Disease and Starvation; with Appendix vindicating Robert Burns, Edinburgh1844; quoted in ref. 86:63.
96.
LenihamJMALeslieACDSmithH. Mercury in the hair of Robert Burns. Letter to the Editor, Lancet1971; 2:1030.
97.
LenihanJMA. (personal communication. Department of Clinical Physics and Bio-Engineering, 11 West Graham Street, Glasgow, Scotland).
