Sudden Unexpected Infant Deaths in Dundee,1882

Abstract

Using a cohort study of all deaths in infants under 12 months in Dundee bom between 1882–91 we set out to compare the aetiology of sudden unexpected infant deaths in Dundee at the end of the 19th Century with the aetiology of present day Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). During. 1882–1891, 361 infants died suddenly and unexpectedly and without obvious cause while in bed with their parents. The sex ratio of deaths was even (0.51 male) whereas the typical male fraction of SIDS today is 0.61. The mean age at death was almost two and one-half weeks younger in the Dundee cohort than for SIDS in modern Scotland. The infants in the Dundee cohort were discovered more frequently early in the morning than is typical. Their social class distribution was different in that no overlying cases were found in the higher classes whereas SIDS affects all classes. The overlying rate for illegitimate infants was lower than that reported for SIDS today. The epidemiological characteristics of the Dundee cohort and of those dying from present day SIDS differ considerably. The Dundee cohort apparently died from overlying rather than from SIDS as it is classified today. Present day advice that co-sleeping is safe should be given more cautiously until the safety of co-sleeping is resolved. It might be prudent to inform parents that co-sleeping is a risk factor for SIDS and that it should therefore be avoided.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Gibson

AAM

. Current epidemiology of SIDs. Journal of Clinical Pathology. 1992; 45 Suppl: 7–10.

Fleming

, Gilbert

, Azaz

, Berry

, Rudd

, Stewart

Interaction between bedding and sleeping position in the sudden infant death syndrome: population based control study. Br Med J 1990; 301: 85–9.

Taylor

, Krieger

, Reay

, Davis

, Haruff

, Cheney

. Prone sleep position and the sudden infant death syndrome in King County, Washington: a case control study. Journal of Pediatrics. 1996; 128: 626–30.

Warden

First rise in cot deaths for five years. Br Med J 1997; 3 15: 564.

Dwyer

, Ponsonby A-L. Sudden infant death syndrome-insights from epidemiological research. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health. 1992; 46: 98–102.

Mage

, Donner

A genetic basis for the sudden infant death syndrome sex ratio. Medical hypotheses 1997; 48: 137–142.

Mage

. A probability model for the age distribution of sudden infant death syndrome. Journal of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome and Infant Mortality. 1996; 1: 13–3 0.

Arrundale

Numbers of infant deaths in Scotland, with special reference to sudden infant death syndrome. Health Bulletin (Edinburgh) 1993; 51 (2): 106–117.

Fredrick

Sudden unexpected death in infants in the Oxford linkage area: the mother. British Journal of Preventive and Social Medicine. 1974; 28: 93–97.

10.

Golding

, Limerick

, Macfarlane

Sudden infant death: patterns, puzzles and problems. Somerset, England.: Open Books Publishing., 1985.

11.

Brooke

, Gibson

, Tappin

, Brown

Case-control study of sudden infant death syndrome in Scotland, 1992–5. Br Med J 1997; 314: 1516–20.

12.

Schauld

, Kleeman

, Poets

, Sens

Smoking during pregnancy and poor antenatal care: two major preventable factors for sudden infant death syndrome. International Journal of Epidemiology 1996; 25: 959–965.

13.

McKenna

, Mosko

Evolution and infant sleep: an experimental study of infant-parent co-sleeping and its implications for SIDs. Acta Paediatrica; Suppl 389 1993: 31–36.

14.

Davies

Cot death in Hong Kong: a rare problem. The Lancet 1985; 298: 1346–1348.

15.

Scragg

, Mitchell

, Taylor

, Stewart

, Ford

RPK

, Thompson

JMD

Bed sharing, smoking, and alcohol in the sudden infant death syndrome. Br Med J 1993; 307: 312–318.

16.

Gilbert

, Wigfield

, Fleming

, Rudd

. Bottle feeding and the sudden infant death syndrome. Br Med J 1995; 310: 88–90.

17.

Templeman

Two hundred and fifty-eight cases of suffocation of infants. Edinburgh Medical Journal 1892(October): 322–329.

18.

Guntheroth

. Crib death. The sudden infant death syndrome. New York: Futura Publishing Co. Inc., 1995.

19.

Limerick

Sudden infant death in historical perspective. Journal of Clinical Pathology 1992; 45 Suppl: 31–6.

20.

Walker

. Infant suffocation-historical myth. Scottish Economic and Social History. 1988; 8: 57–72.

21.

Wakley

Inquests and medical trials. Infants found dead in bed. Lancet 1855; 1: 103).

22.

Lennox

Working class life in Dundee for 25 years 1878–1903. Dundee: University of Dundee Archives.

23.

Beckwith

. Discussion of the terminology and definition of sudden infant death syndrome. Beck-with

, Ray

, editors. Proceedings of the second international conference on the causes of suddeninfant death syndrome. Seattle: University of Washington, 1970: 14–22.

24.

Cameron

, Asher

Cot deaths in Birmingham. Medicine, Science and the Law 1965; 5: 187–199.

25.

Cooke

, Welch

. A study in cot death. Br Med J 1964; 2: 1549–1554.

26.

Osmond

, Murphy

Seasonality in the sudden infant death syndrome. Paediatric and perinatal epidemiology 1988; 2: 337–345.

27.

Kane

. Signifiance of autopsies in premature infants. Journal of the American Medical Association 1964; 1: 187–865.

28.

Waldron

Sex differences in infant and early childhood mortality: Major causes of death and possible biological causes. In: Too young to die: Genes or Gender? In Waldron , Edit. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division, United Nations STIESA/SER.A/1 55, New York, 1998, pp 64–83.

29.

Kraus

, Greenland

, Bulterys

Risk factors for sudden infant death syndrome in the US collaborative perinatal project, International Journal of Epidemiology 1989; 18: 113–120.

30.

D-K

. Maternal prior pregnancy loss and the sex ratio among infants with sudden infant death syndrome. Epidemiology 1993; 4: 549–554.

31.

Frean

Babies are ‘safer’ sleeping in the marital bed. The Times 1998 1st April 1998; 1

32.

Douglas

, Alexander

, Allan

, Helms

. Seasonality of birth in sudden infant death syndrome. Scot Med J 1996; 42: 39–43.

Sudden Unexpected Infant Deaths in Dundee,1882–1891: Overlying or Sids?

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References