Institutional Racism and Pregnancy Health: Using Home Mortgage Disclosure Act Data to Develop an Index for Mortgage Discrimination at the Community Level
Free accessResearch articleFirst published online September, 2011
Institutional Racism and Pregnancy Health: Using Home Mortgage Disclosure Act Data to Develop an Index for Mortgage Discrimination at the Community Level
We used Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) data to demonstrate a method for constructing a residential redlining index to measure institutional racism at the community level. We examined the application of the index to understand the social context of health inequities by applying the residential redlining index among a cohort of pregnant women in Philadelphia.
Methods.
We used HMDA data from 1999–2004 to create residential redlining indices for each census tract in Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania. We linked the redlining indices to data from a pregnancy cohort study and the 2000 Census. We spatially mapped the levels of redlining for each census tract for this pregnancy cohort and tested the association between residential redlining and other community-level measures of segregation and individual health.
Results.
From 1999–2004, loan applicants in Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania, of black race/ethnicity were almost two times as likely to be denied a mortgage loan compared with applicants who were white (e.g., 1999 odds ratio [OR] = 2.00, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.63, 2.28; and 2004 OR=2.26, 95% CI 1.98, 2.58). The majority (77.5%) of the pregnancy cohort resided in redlined neighborhoods, and there were significant differences in residence in redlined areas by race/ethnicity (p<0.001). Among the pregnancy cohort, redlining was associated with residential segregation as measured by the percentage of black population (r=0.155), dissimilarity (r=0.250), exposure (r=–0.115), and isolation (r=0.174) indices.
Conclusions.
The evidence of institutional racism may contribute to our understanding of health disparities. Residential redlining and mortgage discrimination against communities may be a major factor influencing neighborhood structure, composition, development, and wealth attainment. This residential redlining index as a measure for institutional racism can be applied in health research to understand the unique social and neighborhood contexts that contribute to health inequities.
References
1.
LinkBGPhelanJ.Social conditions as fundamental causes of disease. J Health Soc Behav1995;Spec No:80–94.
2.
LinkBGPhelanJC, McKeown and the idea that social conditions are fundamental causes of disease. Am J Public Health2002;92:730–2.
3.
HoganVKNjorogeTDurantTMFerreCD, Eliminating disparities in perinatal outcomes—lessons learned. Matern Child Health J2001;5:135–40.
4.
BlankRM, An overview of trends in social and economic well-being, by race. In: SmelserNJWilsonWJMitchellF, editors. America becoming: Racial trends and their consequences. Washington: National Academy Press; 2001. p. 21–39.
5.
JargowskyPA, Poverty and place: Ghettos, barrios and the American city. New York: Russell Sage Foundation; 1997.
6.
MasseyDDentonNA, American apartheid: Segregation and the making of the underclass. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press; 1993.
7.
CulhaneJFEloIT, Neighborhood context and reproductive health. Am J Obstet Gynecol2005;192(5 Suppl):S22–9.
8.
BellJFZimmermanFJAlmgrenGRMayerJDHuebnerCE, Birth outcomes among urban African-American women: A multilevel analysis of the role of racial residential segregation. Soc Sci Med2006;63:3030–45.
9.
BellJFZimmermanFJMayerJDAlmgrenGRHuebnerCE, Associations between residential segregation and smoking during pregnancy among urban African-American women. J Urban Health2007;84:372–88.
10.
RouxAV. DiezInvestigating neighborhood and area effects on health. Am J Public Health2001;91:1783–9.
11.
EloITMykytaLMargolisRCulhaneJF, Perceptions of neighborhood disorder: The role of individual and neighborhood characteristics. Soc Sci Q2009;90:1298–320.
12.
FangJMadhavanSAldermanMH, Low birth weight: Race and maternal nativity—impact of community income. Pediatrics1999;103:E5.
13.
Acevedo-GarciaDLochnerKA, Residential segregation and health. In: KawachiIBerkmanLF, editors. Neighborhoods and health. New York: Oxford University Press; 2003. p. 265–87.
14.
GeeGC, A multilevel analysis of the relationship between institutional and individual racial discrimination and health status. Am J Public Health2002;92:615–23.
15.
GradySC, Racial disparities in low birthweight and the contribution of residential segregation: A multilevel analysis. Soc Sci Med2006;63:3013–29.
16.
InagamiSBorrellLNWongMDFangJShapiroMFAschSM, Residential segregation and Latino, black and white mortality in New York City. J Urban Health2006;83:406–20.
17.
LaraiaBMesserLEvensonKKaufmanJS, Neighborhood factors associated with physical activity and adequacy of weight gain during pregnancy. J Urban Health2007;84:793–806.
18.
MasonSMMesserLCLaraiaBAMendolaP.Segregation and preterm birth: The effects of neighborhood racial composition in North Carolina. Health Place2009;15:1–9.
19.
MesserLCBuescherPALaraiaBAKaufmanJS, Neighborhood-level characteristics as predictors of preterm birth: Examples from Wake County, North Carolina. North Carolina State Center for Health Statistics Studies November2005;(148):1–9. Also available from: URL: http://www.epi.state.nc.us/SCHS/pdf/SCHS148.pdf [cited 2011 Apr 14].
20.
MesserLCKaufmanJSDoleNSavitzDALaraiaBA, Neighborhood crime, deprivation, and preterm birth. Ann Epidemiol2006;16:455–62.
21.
O'CampoPBurkeJGCulhaneJEloITEysterJHolzmanC, Neighborhood deprivation and preterm birth among non-Hispanic black and white women in eight geographic areas in the United States. Am J Epidemiol2008;167:155–63.
22.
PearlMBravemanPAbramsB.The relationship of neighborhood socioeconomic characteristics to birthweight among 5 ethnic groups in California. Am J Public Health2001;91:1808–14.
23.
PickettKECollinsJWJrMasiCMWilkinsonRG, The effects of racial density and income incongruity on pregnancy outcomes. Soc Sci Med2005;60:2229–38.
24.
PickettKEPearlM.Multilevel analyses of neighbourhood socioeconomic context and health outcomes: A critical review. J Epidemiol Community Health2001;55:111–22.
25.
WilliamsDRCollinsC.Racial residential segregation: A fundamental cause of racial disparities in health. Public Health Rep2001;116:404–16.
26.
MasseyDS, Residential segregation and neighborhood conditions in U.S. metropolitan areas. In: SmelserNJWilsonWJMitchellF, editors. America becoming: Racial trends and their consequences. Washington: National Academy Press; 2000. p. 391–434.
27.
JonesCP, Levels of racism: A theoretic framework and a gardener's tale. Am J Public Health2000;90:1212–5.
28.
McKenzieKBhuiK.Institutional racism in mental health care. BMJ2007;334:649–50.
29.
GothamKF, Racialization and the state: The Housing Act of 1934 and the creation of the Federal Housing Administration. Soc Perspect2000;43:291–317.
30.
SemmesCE, Racism, health, and post-industrialism: A theory of African-American health. Westport (CT): Praeger Publishers; 1996.
31.
SatterB.Family properties: Race, real estate, and the exploitation of black urban America. New York: Henry Holt and Company; 2009.
32.
CharlesCZ, The dynamics of racial residential segregation. Annu Rev Sociol2003;29:167–207.
33.
CourchaneMJZornPM, Dawning of a new age: Examinination for discrimination in lending. Banking and Financial Services Policy Rep2008;27:1–9.
34.
HillierAE, Redlining and the home owners' loan corporation. J Urban History2003;29:394–420.
35.
Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council. Home Mortgage Disclosure Act [cited 2011 Apr 14]. Available from: URL: http://www.ffiec.gov/hmda.
36.
CulhaneJFRauhVMcCollumKFEloITHoganV.Exposure to chronic stress and ethnic differences in rates of bacterial vaginosis among pregnant women. Am J Obstet Gynecol2002;187:1272–6.
37.
CulhaneJFRauhVMcCollumKFHoganVKAgnewKWadhwaPD, Maternal stress is associated with bacterial vaginosis in human pregnancy. Matern Child Health J2001;5:127–34.
38.
HutchinsonPMOstasJRReedJD, A survey and comparison of redlining influences in urban mortgage lending markets. Real Estate Economics: J Am Real Estate Urban Economics Assoc1977;5:463–72.
39.
AhlbrandtRS, Exploratory research on the redlining phenomenon. Real Estate Economics: J Am Real Estate Urban Economics Assoc1977;5:473–81.
40.
SiefertKBowmanPJHeflinCMDanzigerSWilliamsDR, Social and environmental predictors of maternal depression in current and recent welfare recipients. Am J Orthopsychiatry2000;70:510–22.
41.
SAS Institute, Inc.SAS®: Version 9.2 for Windows. Cary (NC): SAS Institute, Inc.; 2008.
42.
MasseyDSDentonNA, The dimensions of residential segregation. Social Forces1988;67:281–315.
43.
CohenSKamarckTMermelsteinR.A global measure of perceived stress. J Health Soc Behav1983;24:385–96.
44.
CohenSDoyleWJBaumA.Socioeconomic status is associated with stress hormones. Psychosom Med2006;68:414–20.
45.
ESRI. ArcGIS®: Version 9.3. Redlands (CA): ESRI; 2008.
KaufmanJSDoleNSavitzDAHerringAH, Modeling community-level effects on preterm birth. Ann Epidemiol2003;13:377–84.
48.
MesserLCLaraiaBAKaufmanJSEysterJHolzmanCCulhaneJ, The development of a standardized neighborhood deprivation index. J Urban Health2006;83:1041–62.
49.
MesserLCKaufmanJS, Using Census data to approximate neighborhood effects. In: OakesJMKaufmanJS, editors. Methods in social epidemiology. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 2006. p. 209–36.
50.
ZierlerSKriegerNTangYCoadyWSiegfriedEDeMariaA, Economic deprivation and AIDS incidence in Massachusetts. Am J Public Health2000;90:1064–73.
51.
FernandezM.Study finds disparities in mortgages by race. The New York Times2007 Oct 15.
52.
TurnerMASkidmoreF, editors. Mortgage lending discrimination: A review of existing evidence. Washington: The Urban Institute; 1999.
53.
OsypukTLAcevedo-GarciaD.Are racial disparities in preterm birth larger in hypersegregated areas?Am J Epidemiol2008;167:1295–304.
54.
GlaeserELVigdorJL, Racial segregation in the 2000 Census: Promising news. Washington: The Brookings Institution Survey Series, Center on Urban and Metropolitan Policy; April 2001.
55.
CulhaneJFEloIT, Neighborhood context and reproductive health. Am J Obstet Gynecol2005;192(5 Suppl):S22–9.
56.
KriegerNChenJTWatermanPDSoobaderMJSubramanianSVCarsonR.Geocoding and monitoring of US socioeconomic inequalities in mortality and cancer incidence: Does the choice of area-based measure and geographic level matter? The Public Health Disparities Geocoding Project. Am J Epidemiol2002;156:471–82.
57.
Dietrich J; Department of the Treasury, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (US). Missing race data in the HMDA and the implications for the monitoring of fair lending compliance. Economic and Policy Analysis Working Paper 2001–1. Washington: Department of the Treasury, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency; March 2001.
58.
MunnellAHBrowneLEMcEneaneyJTootellGMB, Mortgage lending in Boston: Interpreting HDMA data. Working Paper 92–7. Boston: Federal Reserve Bank of Boston; 1992.
