On September 11, 2001 (9/11), attacks on the World Trade Center (WTC) killed 341 Fire Department of the City of New York (FDNY) firefighters and injured hundreds more. Previous WTC-related studies reported high rates of comorbid depression and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), identifying disability retirement, alcohol use, and early arrival at the WTC site as correlates. However, those studies did not evaluate risk factors that could have mediated the observed comorbidity. We identified unique risk factors for each condition in an effort to better understand comorbidity.
Methods.
We screened retired WTC-exposed firefighters using self-administered questionnaires including the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale, the Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Checklist, and the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test. We performed regression analyses to compare independent predictors of elevated depression and PTSD risk, and also tested a mediation hypothesis.
Results.
From December 2005 to July 2007, 23% and 22% of 1,915 retirees screened positive for elevated depression and PTSD risk, respectively, with comorbidity >70%. Controlling for comorbidity, we identified unique risk factors for (7) depression: problem alcohol use and (2) PTSD: early arrival at the WTC site.
Conclusions.
Our data support the premise that PTSD and depression are different responses to trauma with unique risk factors. The data also suggest a hypothesis that PTSD mediates the relationship between early WTC arrival and depression, while depression mediates the relationship between alcohol use and PTSD, a more complex relationship than shown in previous studies. Clinicians should consider these factors when evaluating patients for depression and PTSD.
References
1.
NorthCSNixonSJShariatSMalloneeSMcMillenJCSpitznagelELPsychiatric disorders among survivors of the Oklahoma City bombing. JAMA1999;282:755–62.
2.
GaleaSAhernJResnickHKillpatrickDBucuvalasMGoldJPsychological sequelae of the September 11 terrorist attacks in New York City. N Engl J Med2002;346:982–7.
3.
CampbellDGFelkerBLLiuCFYaneoEMKirchnerJEChanDPrevalence of depression-PTSD comorbidity: implications for clinical practice guidelines and primary care-based interventions. J Gen Intern Med2007;22:711–8.
4.
GerrityMSCorsonKDobschaSK. Screening for posttraumatic stress disorder in VA primary care patients with depression symptoms. J Gen Intern Med2007;22:1321–4.
5.
GillJMPageGGSharpsPCampbellJC. Experiences of traumatic events and associations with PTSD and depression development in urban health care-seeking women. J Urban Health2008;85: 693–706.
6.
SalciogluEBasogluMLivanouM. Post-traumatic stress disorder and comorbid depression among survivors of the 1999 earthquake in Turkey. Disasters2007;31:115–29.
7.
FullertonCSUrsanoRJWangL. Acute stress disorder, posttraumatic stress disorder, and depression in disaster or rescue workers. Am J Psychiatry2004;161:1370–6.
8.
GinzburgKEin-DorTSolomonZ. Comorbidity of posttraumatic stress disorder, anxiety and depression: a 20-year longitudinal study of war veterans. J Affect Disord2010;123:249–57.
9.
FranklinCLZimmermanM. Posttraumatic stress disorder and major depressive disorder: investigating the role of overlapping symptoms in diagnostic comorbidity. J Nerv Ment Dis2001;189: 548–51.
10.
BlanchardEBBuckleyTCHicklingEJTaylorAE. Posttraumatic stress disorder and comorbid major depression: is the correlation an illusion?J Anxiety Disord1998;12:21–37.
11.
O'DonnellMLCreamerMPattisonP. Posttraumatic stress disorder and depression following trauma: understanding comorbidity. Am J Psychiatry2004;161:1390–6.
12.
ChiuSWebberMPZeig-OwensRGustaveJLeeRKellyRJValidation of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale in screening for major depressive disorder among retired firefighters exposed to the World Trade Center disaster. J Affect Disord2010;121:212–9.
13.
ChiuSWebberMPZeig-OwensRNilesJGustaveJLeeRPerformance characteristics of the Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist in retired firefighters exposed to the World Trade Center disaster. Ann Clin Psychiatry. In press2011.
14.
PrezantDJWeidenMBanauchGIMcGuinnessGRomWNAldrichTKCough and bronchial responsiveness in firefighters at the World Trade Center site. N Engl J Med2002;347:806–15.
15.
RadloffLS. The CES-D Scale: a self-report depression scale for research in the general population. Appl Psych Meas1977; 1:385–401.
16.
WeathersFWLitzBTHermanDSHuskaJAKeaneTM. The PTSD Checklist (PCL): reliability, validity, and diagnostic utility. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the International Society for Traumatic Stress Studies; 1993 Oct 24–27; San Antonio, Texas.
17.
SaundersJBAaslandOGBaborTFde la FuenteJRGrantM. Development of the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT): WHO collaborative project on early detection of persons with harmful alcohol consumption—II. Addiction1993;88: 791–804.
18.
SaundersJBAaslandOGAmundsenAGrantM. Alcohol consumption and related problems among primary health care patients: WHO collaborative project on early detection of persons with harmful alcohol consumption—I. Addiction1993;88:349–62.
19.
BaborTFHiggins-BiddleJCSaundersJBMonteiroMG. AUDIT—the Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test: guidelines for use in primary health care. 2nd ed.Geneva: Department of Mental Health and Substance Dependence, World Health Organization; 2001.
20.
SAS Institute, Inc.SAS®: Version 9.1.3 for Windows. Cary (NC): SAS Institute, Inc.; 2009.
21.
BaronRMKennyDA. The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. J Pers Soc Psychol1986;51:1173–82.
22.
StellmanJMSmithRPKatzCLSharmaVCharneyDSHerbertREnduring mental health morbidity and social function impairment in World Trade Center rescue, recovery, and cleanup workers: the psychological dimension of an environmental health disaster. Environ Health Perspect2008;116:1248–53.
23.
TappLCBaronSBernardBDriscollRMuellerCWallingfordK. Physical and mental health symptoms among NYC transit workers seven and one-half months after the WTC attacks. Am J Ind Med2005;47:475–83.
24.
AgronickGStueveAVargoSO'DonnellL. New York City young adults' psychological reactions to 9/11: findings from the Reach for Health longitudinal study. Am J Community Psychol2007;39: 79–90.
25.
ChemtobCMNomuraYAbramovitzRA. Impact of conjoined exposure to the World Trade Center attacks and to other traumatic events on the behavioral problems of preschool children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med2008;162:126–33.
26.
PerrinMADiGrandeLWheelerKThorpeLFarfelMBrackbillR. Differences in PTSD prevalence and associated risk factors among World Trade Center disaster rescue and recovery workers. Am J Psychiatry2007;164:1385–94.
27.
BeckhamJCMooreSDFeldmanMEHertzbergMAKirbyACFairbankJA. Health status, somatization, and severity of posttraumatic stress disorder in Vietnam combat veterans with posttraumatic stress disorder. Am J Psychiatry1998;155:1565–9.
28.
ChenYSChenMCChouFHSunFCChenPCTsaiKYThe relationship between quality of life and posttraumatic stress disorder or major depression for firefighters in Kaohsiung, Taiwan. Qual Life Res2007;16:1289–97.
29.
GrossRNeriaYTaoXGMassaJAshwellLDavisKPost-traumatic stress disorder and other psychological sequelae among World Trade Center clean up and recovery workers. Ann N Y Acad Sci2006;1071:495–9.
30.
CohenCIGohKHYaffeeRA. Depression outcome among a biracial sample of depressed urban elders. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry2009;17:943–52.
31.
KesslerRCAkiskalHSAmesMBirnbaumHGreenbergPHirschfeldRMPrevalence and effects of mood disorders on work performance in a nationally representative sample of U.S. workers. Am J Psychiatry2006;163:1561–8.
32.
AbrahamHDFavaM. Order of onset of substance abuse and depression in a sample of depressed outpatients. Compr Psychiatry1999;40:44–50.
33.
ShipherdJCStaffordJTannerLR. Predicting alcohol and drug abuse in Persian Gulf War veterans: what role do PTSD symptoms play?Addict Behav2005;30:595–9.
34.
HienDAJiangHCampbellANHuMCMieleGMCohenLRDo treatment improvements in PTSD severity affect substance use outcomes? A secondary analysis from a randomized clinical trial in NIDA/s Clinical Trials Network. Am J Psychiatry2010; 167:95–101.
35.
O'TooleBICattsSV. Trauma, PTSD, and physical health: an epidemiological study of Australian Vietnam veterans. J Psychosom Res2008;64:33–40.
36.
GinzburgKEin-DorTSolomonZ. Comorbidity of posttraumatic stress disorder, anxiety and depression: a 20-year longitudinal study of war veterans. J Affect Disord2010;123:249–57.
37.
CookJMElhaiJDAreanPA. Psychometric properties of the PTSD Checklist with older primary care patients. J Trauma Stress2005;18:371–6.
38.
CuijpersPBoluijtPvan StratenA. Screening of depression in adolescents through the Internet: sensitivity and specificity of two screening questionnaires. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry2008; 17:32–8.
39.
ForbesDCreamerMBiddleD. The validity of the PTSD checklist as a measure of symptomatic change in combat-related PTSD. Behav Res Ther2001;39:977–86.
40.
HaringsmaREngelsGIBeekmanATSpinhovenP. The criterion validity of the Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) in a sample of self-referred elders with depressive symptomatology. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2004;19:558–63.
41.
WadaKTanakaKTheriaultGSatohTMimuraMMiyaokaHValidity of the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale as a screening instrument of major depressive disorder among Japanese workers. Am J Ind Med2007;50:8–12.
42.
WatsonLCLewisCLKistlerCEAmickHRBoustaniM. Can we trust depression screening instruments in healthy ‘old-old’ adults?Int J Geriatr Psychiatry2004;19:278–85.
43.
YeagerDEMagruderKMKnappRGNicholasJSFruehBC. Performance characteristics of the posttraumatic stress disorder checklist and SPAN in Veterans Affairs primary care settings. Gen Hosp Psychiatry2007;29:294–301.
44.
HoltzheimerPEIIIRussoJZatzickDBundyCRoy-ByrnePP. The impact of comorbid posttraumatic stress disorder on short-term clinical outcome in hospitalized patients with depression. Am J Psychiatry2005;162:970–6.
45.
RauchSAFavoriteTGiardinoNPorcariCDefeverELiberzonI. Relationship between anxiety, depression, and health satisfaction among veterans with PTSD. J Affect Disord2010;121:165–8.
46.
AndreskiPChilcoatHBreslauN. Post-traumatic stress disorder and somatization symptoms: a prospective study. Psychiatry Res1998;79:131–8.
47.
Institute of Medicine. Treatment of PTSD: an assessment of the evidence. Washington: National Academies Press; 2007.
