When the 1918 influenza epidemic began, African American communities were already beset by many public health, medical, and social problems, including racist theories of black biological inferiority, racial barriers in medicine and public health, and poor health status. To address these problems, African Americans mounted efforts such as establishing separate hospitals and professional organizations and repudiating racist scientific theories. Contradicting prevailing theories about African Americans' increased susceptibility to disease, it appears that during the 1918 epidemic the incidence of influenza was lower in African Americans. Although the epidemic had a less devastating impact on African American communities, it still overwhelmed their medical and public health resources. Observations about the lower rates of influenza in African Americans did not derail racist theories about the biological inferiority of black people or overturn conceptualizations of black people as disease threats to white people. When the epidemic ended, the major problems that African Americans faced still remained.
References
1.
A prose poem on the epidemic. Am J Nurs1919;19:718.
2.
GalishoffS. Germs know no color line: Black health and public policy in Atlanta, 1900–1918. J Hist Med Allied Sci1985;40:23.
3.
Du BoisWEB. The health and physique of the Negro American. Atlanta: Atlanta University Press; 1906. p. 76, 89–90.
4.
LoganRW. The Negro in American life and thought: The Negro, 1877–1901. New York: Dial Press; 1954.
5.
HoffmanFL. Race traits and tendencies of the American Negro. New York: American Economic Association; 1896. p. 5, 311–2.
6.
WolffMJ. The myth of the actuary: Life insurance and Frederick L. Hoffman's Race traits and tendencies of the American Negro. Public Health Rep2006;121:84–91.
7.
RomanCV. Fifty years' progress of the American Negro in health and sanitation. J Natl Med Assoc1917;9:64–5.
8.
TaylorJM. Remarks on the health of colored people. J Natl Med Assoc1915;7:160–3.
9.
RobertsSKJr. Infectious fear: Politics, disease, and the health effects of segregation. Chapel Hill (SC): University of North Carolina Press; 2009. p. 41–66, 170–4.
10.
GrossmanJR. Land of hope: Chicago, black southerners, and the Great Migration. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1989. p. 3, 48, 79.
11.
GambleVN. Making a place for ourselves: The Black hospital movement, 1920–1945. New York: Oxford University Press; 1995.
12.
BakerRBWashingtonHAOlakanmiOSavittTLJacobsEAHooverE. African American physicians and organized medicine, 1846–1968: Origins of a racial divide. JAMA2008;300:306–13.
13.
Better health for Negroes in Virginia. J Natl Med Assoc1915;15:52–4.
14.
SmithSL. Sick and tired of being sick and tired: Black women's health activism in America, 1890–1950. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 1995. p. 39.
15.
BousfieldMO. Reaching the Negro community. Am J Public Health1934;24:123.
16.
RouseJA. Lugenia burns hope: Black southern reformer. Athens (GA): University of Georgia Press; 1989. p. 57–90.
17.
FergusonER. The Woman's Improvement Club of Indianapolis: Black women pioneers in tuberculosis work, 1903–1938. Indiana Mag Hist1988;89:237–61.
18.
AllenLC. The Negro health problem. Am J Public Health1915;5:194.
19.
JonesEH. Tuberculosis in the Negro. Tr Tn State Med Assoc1907;175.
20.
HunterTW. To 'joy my freedom: Southern black women's lives and labors after the Civil War. Cambridge (MA): Harvard University Press; 1997. p. 187–218.
21.
IPS#17 Student letters to Irven Armstrong, 7 November 1918. Box 1, Irven Armstrong Collection, Manuscript and Visual Collections Department, William Henry Smith Memorial Library, Indiana Historical Society, Indianapolis, IN. p.ix.
22.
PageC. Foreword. In: WashburnPS. The African American newspaper: Voice of freedom. Evanston (IL): Northwestern University Press; 2006. p. ix.
23.
JordanWG. Black newspapers and America's war for democracy, 1914–1920. Chapel Hill (SC): University of North Carolina; 2001.
24.
FranklinVP. “Voice of the black community”: The Philadelphia Tribune, 1912–41. Pa Hist1984;4:264–5.
25.
City in grip “flu” 36 reported dead in 2 days. Baltimore Afro-American1918 Oct 11:1.
26.
Counsellor Taylor victim of “flu.”Chicago Defender1918 Oct 12:10.
27.
Society. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 12:6.
28.
Mrs. Monroe Trotter interred in Boston. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:12.
29.
Jamaica gleanings. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:4.
30.
The blue grass state. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:8.
31.
Defender writer resumes duties. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:10.
32.
Elwood Turnbo passes away. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:12.
33.
JohnsonJoe. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:7.
34.
J Johnson dies of Spanish influenza. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 9:1.
35.
CrosbyAW. America's forgotten pandemic: The influenza of 1918. 2nd ed.Cambridge (MA): Cambridge University Press; 2003. p. 74, 229.
36.
Northwestern breezes. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 12:3.
37.
Chester Letter. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 12:7.
38.
WilliamH. Jackson. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 19:1.
39.
Prominent fraternal and churchman victim of the “flu.”Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 19:1.
40.
JohnT. Gibson, one of our most successful theatrical managers. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 19:1.
41.
All churches were tightly closed on last Sunday. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 19:1.
42.
Influenza epidemic closes baseball season for American Giants. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 2:9.
43.
Hampton anniversary postponed because of “flu” epidemic. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 2:13.
44.
Among the churches. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 12:2.
45.
Spanish plague raging in Chicago. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 19:1.
46.
M.K.B. Experiences during the epidemic: A two week's assignment. Am J Nurs1919;19:607–8 [cited 2009 Mar 12]. Available from: URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3405398
Influenza workers doing good. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 9:5.
51.
Open clinic at Urban League. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 23:5.
52.
StricklandAE. History of the Chicago Urban League. Columbia (MO): University of Missouri Press; 2001. p. 45.
53.
Douglass hospital opens emergency annex. Philadelphia Tribune1918 Oct 19:5.
54.
Pennsylvania. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 2:9.
55.
What the health department has done to curb the epidemic of influenza. The Monthly Bulletin of the Department of Public Health and Charities of the City of Philadelphia1918;3:10–3.
56.
All helping sufferers in emergency hospital. Richmond Times Dispatch1918 Oct 13:1.
57.
Total of 1,000 patients expected at hospital. Richmond Times Dispatch1918 Oct 25:4.
58.
Virginia executive visits hospital. Baltimore Afro-American1918 Nov 1:1.
59.
Influenza and pneumonia claims many victims. Baltimore Afro-American1918 Oct 18:1.
60.
Young Women's Christian Association. Chicago Defender. 1918 Oct 26:12.
61.
HineDC. The call that never came: Black women nurses and World War I—an historical note. Mil Hist J1983;8:23–7.
62.
StewartAC. Ready to serve. Am J Nurs1963;63:85–7.
63.
ByerlyCR. Fever of war: The influenza epidemic in the U.S. Army during World War I. New York: New York University Press; 2005.
64.
College dean rejects nurse. Chicago Defender1918 Nov 2:16.
65.
DukesTSr. Oral history conducted by Pyle RW, 1980 Aug 20. Center for Oral History and Cultural Heritage, The University of Southern Mississippi [cited 2009 Mar 10]. Available from: URL: http://www.lib.usm.edu/∼spcol/coh/cohdukest.html
66.
New Jersey. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 12:7.
67.
West Philadelphia. Philadelphia Tribune. 1918 Oct 12:4.
68.
Lone Star State. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 26:13.
69.
Influenza spares race. Chicago Defender1918 Oct 26;1.
70.
JohnsonJF. The forum. Baltimore Afro-American1918 Nov 1;4.
Chicago Department of Health. Report and handbook of the Department of Health of the City of Chicago. Chicago: City of Chicago; 1917–1918. p. 135.
73.
FrostWH. Statistics of influenza mortality. Public Health Rep1920;35:591–2.
74.
DublinLILotkaAJ. Twenty-five years of health progress. New York: Metropolitan Life Insurance Company; 1937. p. 129–31
75.
HolmesSJ. Differential mortality in the American Negro. Hum Biol1931;3:212.
76.
HowardDCLoveAG. Influenza—U.S.Army Mil Surg1920;46: 545.
77.
Influenza and racial susceptibility. J Natl Med Assoc1919;11:74.
78.
Influenza and pneumonia in Philadelphia during the recent epidemic. J Natl Med Assoc1919;11:20.
79.
LoveAGDavenportCB. A comparison of white and colored troops in respect to incidence of disease. Proc Natl Acad Sci1919;5:60.
80.
VaughanWT. Influenza, an epidemiologic study. Am J Hyg1921;1:155–6.
81.
TurnerJP. Epidemic influenza and the Negro physician. J Natl Med Assoc1918;10:184.
82.
‘Please, let me put him in a macaroni box,’ the Spanish influenza epidemic in Philadelphia in 1918 [interview by Hardy C, for WHYY-FM radio] [cited 2009 Apr 3]. Available from: URL: http://historymatters.gmu.edu/d/13
