Locked in the Home: A Critique of House Arrest as an Alternative to Imprisonment for Women Sentenced for Drug-Related Crimes

Abstract

This article addresses the unintended consequences of using house arrest for female offenders as an alternative to prison for drug-related crimes. We propose that in patriarchal societies, locking women at home could imply moving them to another control device that may be as harmful as prison. Thereby, house arrest creates an unintended effect in which domestication in traditional gender roles ends up being the primary target of female offender punishment.

Keywords

house arrest female imprisonment public policy gender policies prison alternatives

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abadía Cubillos

. (2018). Feminismos y sistema penal. Retos contemporáneos para una legitimación del sistema penal.Bogotá: Uniandes.

Alexander

(2011). The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness. The New Press.

Allspach

(2010). Landscapes of (neo-)liberal control: the transcarceral spaces of federally sentenced women in Canada. Gender Place & Culture, 17(6), 705–723. https://doi.org/10.1080/0966369x.2010.517021

Amador

Amighetti

Bartley-Matthews

Blas

Boiteux

Caicedo

L. P.

Cortés

Chaparro

Cruz

L. F.

Daufemback

Giacomello

Molina

Nougier

Olivera

Pecova

Pieris

N. M.

Pol

Quintanilla

D. . . .

Youngers

(2016). omen, Drug policies, and Incarceration: A Guide for Policy Reform in Latin America and the Caribbean. WOLA-IDPC-DeJusticia-CIM-OEA.

Anderson

T. L.

Kavanaugh

P. R.

(2017). Women’s evolving roles in drug trafficking in the United States: New conceptualizations needed for 21st-century markets. Contemporary Drug Problems, 44(4), 339–355.

Antony

(2000). Las mujeres confinadas: estudio criminológico sobre el rol genérico en la ejecución y la pena en Chile y América Latina. Editorial Jurídica de Chile.

Antony

(2007). Mujeres invisibles: las cárceles femeninas en América Latina. Nueva Sociedad, 208, 73–85.

Aponte Cardona

. (2008). Guerra y derecho penal del enemigo: reflexión crítica sobre el eficientismo penal. Ad-hoc.

Ariza

Iturralde

(2017). Mujer, crimen y castigo penitenciario. Política Criminal, 12(24), 731–753. https://doi.org/10.4067/s0718-33992017000200731

10.

Ariza

L. J.

(2013). The Economic ans Social Rights of Prisoners and Constitucional Court Intervention in the Penitenciary System in Colombia. In Bonilla Maldonado

(Ed.), Constitucionalism of the Global South: The Activist Tribunal of India, south Africa, and Colombia. Cambridge University Press.

11.

Bachman

Kerrison

E. M.

Paternoster

Smith

O’Connell

. (2015). The Complex Relationship Between Motherhood and Desistance. Women & Criminal Justice, 26(3), 212–231. https://doi.org/10.1080/08974454.2015.1113153

12.

Barnes

S. L.

Stringer

E. C.

(2013). Is motherhood important? Imprisoned women’s maternal experiences before and during confinement and their postrelease expectations. Feminist Criminology, 9(1), 3–23. https://doi.org/10.1177/1557085113504450

13.

Berry

Johnson

Severson

Postmus

J. L.

(2018). Wives and mothers at risk: The role of marital and maternal status in criminal activity and incarceration. Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Social Services, 90(3), 293–300. https://doi.org/10.1606/1044-3894.3891

14.

Berry

P. E.

Eigenberg

H. M.

(2008). Role strain and incarcerated mothers. Women & Criminal Justice, 15(1), 101–119. https://doi.org/10.1300/j012v15n01_06

15.

Blackburn

A. G.

Pfeffer

R. D.

Harris

J. A.

(2016). Serious about change: A gendered examination of the impact of offense type on parole success. Women & Criminal Justice, 26(5), 340–353. https://doi.org/10.1080/08974454.2016.1203387

16.

Blanchette

Brown

S. L.

(2006). The assessment and treatment of women offenders. John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

17.

Bloom

McDiarmid

(2000). Gender responsive supervision and programming for women in the community. In Thigpen

(Ed.), National institute of corrections annual issue 2000: Responding to women offenders in the community (pp. 11–18). National Institute of Corrections.

18.

Bogart

J. G.

Stevens

S. J.

Hill

R. J.

Estrada

B. D.

(2005). Criminally involved drug-using mothers: the need for system change. The Prison Journal, 85(1), 65–82. https://doi.org/10.1177/0032885504274291

19.

Boutron

Constant

(2013). Gendering transnational criminality: The case of women’s imprisonment in Peru. Woman, Gender and Prison: National and Global Perspectives, 39(1), 177–195. https://doi.org/10.1086/670827

20.

Brennan

P. K.

(2008). An intermediate sanction that fosters the mother-child bond. A process evaluation of summit house. Woman & Criminal Justice, 18(3), 47–80.

21.

Bronson

Carson

(2019). Prisoners in 2017. U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.

22.

Buchanan

(2006). Women offenders: Identifying and addressing barriers to employment, training and education. Probation Journal, 53(3), 279–280. https://doi.org/10.1177/026455050605300307

23.

Campbell

(2008). Female Drug Smugglers on the U-S.-Mexico Border: Gender, Crime, and Empowerment. Anthropological Quarterly, 81(1), 233–267. https://doi.org/10.1353/anq.2008.0004

24.

Capriolo

Jaitman

Mello

(2017). Los costos del crimen sobre el bienestar en Brasil: un país de contrastes. In Jaitman

(Ed.), Los costos del crimen y de la violencia: nueva evidencia y hallazgos en América Latina y el Caribe (pp. 55–70). BID.

25.

Carlen

(2002). Carceral clawback. The case of women’s imprisonment in Canada. Punishment & Society, 4(1), 115–121.

26.

Carlen

(2006). Reconfigurations of penality. The ongoing case of the women’s imprisonment and reintegration industries. Theoretical Criminology, 10(3), 337–360.

27.

Carlen

Worrall

(2004). Analyzing Women’s Imprisonment. Willan Publishing.

28.

Carmichael

Gover

A. R.

Koons-Witt

Inabnit

(2007). The successful completion of probation and parole among female offenders. Women & Criminal Justice, 17(1), 75–97. https://doi.org/10.1300/j012v17n01_04

29.

Chesney-Lind

(1991). Patriarchy, prisons, and jails: A critical look at trends in Women’s Incarceration. The Prison Journal, 71(1), 51–67. https://doi.org/10.1177/003288559107100106

30.

Corda

R. A.

(2009). Encarcelamiento por delitos relacionados con estupefacientes en Argentina. In Metaal

Coletta

(Eds.), Sistemas sobrecargados: leyes de drogas y cárceles en América Latina (pp. 11–20). Transitional Institute-Washington Office on Latin America.

31.

DANE. (2017). Encuesta Nacional del Uso del Tiempo (ENUT) 2016-2017. DANE.

32.

DANE. (2018). Mercado laboral por sexo, trimestre móvil diciembre 2017-febrero 2018. DANE.

33.

Drug Policy Alliance. (2016). The drug war, mass incarceration and race. UNODC.

34.

Facio

Fries

(2005). Feminismo, género y patriarcado. Academia. Revista Sobre Enseñanza del Derecho de Buenos Aires, 3(6), 259–294.

35.

Figuereido Rodrígues

L. B. de

. (2009). Drogas y prisión: represión contra las drogas y el aumento de la población penitenciaria en Brasil. In Metaal

Coletta

(Eds.), Sistemas sobrecargados: leyes de drogas y cárceles en América Latina (pp. 30–39). Transitional Institute-Washington Office on Latin America.

36.

Flacks

(2018). Dangerous drugs, dangerous mothers: Gender, responsibility and the problematisation of parental substance use. Critical Social Policy. https://doi.org/10.1177/0261018318795573

37.

García Castro

. (2019). Pretrial Detention in Latin America: The Disproportionate Impact on Women Deprived of Liberty for Drug Offenses. WOLA-IDPC-DeJusticia-CIM-OEA.

38.

Gelsthorpe

Morris

(2002). Women’s imprisonment in England and Wales: A penal paradox. Criminology and Criminal Justice, 2(3), 277–301.

39.

Giacomello

(2017). Women and Drug Policies in Latin America: A Critical Review of the United Nations Resolution ‘Mainstreaming a Gender Perspective in Drug-Related Policies and Programmes’. The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice, 56(3), 288–308. https://doi.org/10.1111/hojo.12216

40.

Gilfus

M. E.

(1993). From victims to survivors to offenders: Women’s routes of entry and immersion into street crime. Women & Criminal Justice, 4(1), 63–89.

41.

González Ramírez

J. D.

González Rojas

Moscoso Rojas

. (2012). Documentos de CERAC (Centro de Recursos Para el Análisis de Conflictos). CERAC.

42.

Harper

Stockdale

(2010). The role and sentencing of women in drug trafficking crime. Legal and Criminological Psychology, 7(1), 101–114.

43.

Hart

E. L.

(2016). Women Prisoners and the Drive for Desistance: Capital and Responsibilization as a Barrier to Change. Women & Criminal Justice, 27(3), 151–169. https://doi.org/10.1080/08974454.2016.1217814

44.

Holtfreter

Morash

(2003). The needs of women offenders. Women & Criminal Justice, 14(2-3), 137–160. https://doi.org/10.1300/j012v14n02_07

45.

Inpec. (2017). Series estadísticas diciembre 2017. INPEC.

46.

Inpec. (2018). Informe estadístico diciembre 2018. INPEC.

47.

Iturralde

(2010). Castigo, liberalismo autoritario y justicia penal de excepción. Siglo del Hombre-Universidad de los Andes.

48.

Iturralde

(2016). Colombian prisons as a core institution of authoritarian liberalism. Crime Law and Social Change, 65(3), 137–162. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10611-015-9581-7

49.

Jacomé

A. I.

(2017). Subsistencia tóxica: mujeres que viven del microtráfico en el Ecuador. FES y Parametría.

50.

Jaitman

Torre

(2017). Los costos directos de los homicidios. In Jaitman

(Ed.), Los costos del crimen y de la violencia: nueva evidencia y hallazgos en América Latina y el Caribe (pp. 33–52). BID.

51.

Jaramillo Sierra

I. C

. (2013). Derecho y familia en Colombia: historias de raza, género y propiedad (1540-1980). Universidad de los Andes.

52.

Jaramillo Sierra

I. C.

Alfonso Sierra

. (2008). Mujeres, cortes y medios: la reforma judicial del aborto. Uniandes-Siglo del Hombre.

53.

Kajstura

(2017). Women’s Mass Incarceration: The Whole Pie 2017. https://www.prisonpolicy.org/reports/pie2017women.html

54.

King

Gibbs

(2003). Is home detention in New Zealand disadvantaging women and children? Probation Journal, 50(2), 115–126. https://doi.org/10.1177/0264550503502003

55.

Lavrin

(1987). Women, the family, and social change in Latin America. WorldAffairs, 150(2), 109–128.

56.

Lemaitre Ripoll

. (2009). El derecho como conjuro: fetichismo legal, violencia y movimientos sociales. Uniandes-Siglo del Hombre.

57.

Lerner

(1986). The creation of patriarchy. Oxford University Press.

58.

Matthews

(2011). Una propuesta realista de reforma para las prisiones en Latinoamérica. Política Criminal, 6(12), 296–338. https://doi.org/10.4067/s0718-33992011000200003

59.

McIvor

Trotter

Sheehan

(2009). Women, resettlement and desistance. Probation Journal, 56(4), 347–361. https://doi.org/10.1177/0264550509346515

60.

Metaal

Youngers

(2009). Sistemas sobrecargados: leyes de drogas y cárceles en América Latina. Transitional Institute-Washington Office on Latin America.

61.

Michalsen

(2014). Not All Women Are Mothers. Addressing the Invisibility of Women Under the Control of the Criminal Justice System Who Do Not Have Children. The Prison Journal, 94(3), 328–346.

62.

Morash

(2010). Women on Probation and. A Feminist Critique of Community Programs and Services. Northeastern University Press.

63.

Moura

M. V.

(2019). Levantamento nacional de informações penitenciárias, atualização, junho de 2017. Ministério da Justiça e Segurança Pública: Departamento Penitenciário Nacional.

64.

Norza-Céspedes

González-Rojas

Moscoso-Rojas

González-Ramírez

J. D.

(2012). Descripción de la criminalidad femenina en Colombia: factores de riesgo y motivación criminal. Revista Criminalidad, 54(1), 339–357.

65.

Opsal

(2014). “It’s Their World, so You’ve Just Got to Get Through”: Women’s Experiences of Parole Governance. Feminist Criminology, 10(2), 188–207.

66.

Paladines

(2017). Cárcel y drogas en Ecuador: el castigo de los más débiles. CEED.

67.

Parsons

Wei

Henrichson

Drucker

Trone

(2015). End of an era? The impact of drug law reform in New York. VERA Institute of Justice.

68.

Parsons

M. L.

Warner-Robbins

(2002). Factors that support women’s successful transition to the community following jail/prison. Health Care for Women International, 23(1), 6–18. https://doi.org/10.1080/073993302753428393

69.

Pearl

N. R.

(2008). Use of community based social services to reduce recividism in female parolees. Women & Criminal Justice, 10(1), 27–52.

70.

Penal Reform International. (2012). Ten-Point Plan to Reduce Prison Overcrowding. Penal Reform International.

71.

Penglase

(2010). The owner of the hill: Masculinity and drug-trafficking in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. The Journal of Latin American and Caribbean Anthropology, 15(2), 317–337. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1935-4940.2010.01088.x

72.

Pfaff

(2017). Locked in: The true causes of mass incarceration and how to achieve real reform. Basic Books.

73.

Pontón

(2006). Mujeres que cruzaron la línea: Vida cotidiana en el encierro. FLACSO.

74.

Ramírez

Tribín

A. M.

Vargas

C. O.

(2016). Maternidad y mercado laboral: el impacto de la legislación. In Arango

L. E.

Castellani

Lora

(Eds.), Desempleo femenino en Colombia. Banco de la República.

75.

Rastogi

Johnson

T. D.

Hoeffel

Drewery

M. P.

(2011). The Black population: 2010, U.S. census bureau, 2010. United States Deartment of commerce, Economics and Statics Administration.

76.

Robison

K. J.

Hughes Miller

(2016). Decentering motherhood: Reentry strategies for women on parole and probation. Women & Criminal Justice, 26(5), 319–339. https://doi.org/10.1080/08974454.2016.1145617

77.

Rodríguez

M. N.

(2009). Mujeres en prisión. Un abordaje desde la perspectiva de género. In Carranza

(Ed.), Cárcel y Justicia Penal en América Latina y el Caribe. Cómo implementar el modelo de derechos y obligaciones de las Naciones Unidas (pp. 199–227). ILANUD-Sigloveintiunoeditores.

78.

Sánchez-Mejía

A. L.

Rodríguez Cely

Fondevila

Morad

A. J

., (2018). Mujeres y prisión en Colombia: desafíos para la política criminal desde un enfoque de género. CIDE-Universidad Javeriana-CICR.

79.

Schmitt

Warner

Gupta

(2010). The high budgetary cost of incarceration. CEPR.

80.

Sestokas

Oliveira

(2018). Drug policy is a women’s issue: Drug policy, criminal justice, and gender in Brazil. Revista Internacional de Direitos Humanos, 15(27), 147–160.

81.

Simon

(2011). Gobernar a través del delito (trad. Victoria de los Ángeles Boschiroli). Gedisa.

82.

SISBEN. (2018). Base certificada Nacional-Corte octubre 2018. DNP.

83.

Tonry

(2011). Punishing race: a continuing American dilemma. Oxford University Press.

84.

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2013). Handbook on strategies to reduce overcrowding in prisons. United Nations.

85.

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2018). World drug report, 2018. United Nations Publication.

86.

Uprimny

Chaparro

Cruz

(2017). Delitos de drogas y sobredosis carcelaria en Colombia. DeJusticia.

87.

Uprimny

Martínez

Cruz

L. F.

Chaparro

(2016). Women, drug policies and incarceration. A guide for Policy Reform in Colombia. DeJusticia.

88.

Wacquant

(2009). Punishing the poor. The neoliberal government of social insecurity. Duke University Press.

89.

Wamsley

(2015). World female imprisonment list. Institute for General Policy Research.

90.

Wamsley

(2018). World female imprisonment list (4th ed.). Institute for General Policy Research.

91.

Whaley

R. B.

Moe

A. M.

Eddy

J. M.

Daugherty

(2007). The domestic violence experiences of women in community corrections. Women & Criminal Justice, 18(3), 25–45. https://doi.org/10.1300/j012v18n03_02

92.

Willging

C. E.

Nicdao

E. G.

Trott

E. M.

Kellett

N. C.

(2015). Structural inequality and social support for women prisoners released to rural communities. Women & Criminal Justice, 26(2), 145–164. https://doi.org/10.1080/08974454.2015.1067174

93.

Worrall

Gelsthorpe

(2009). ‘What works’ with women offenders: The past 30 years. Probation Journal, 56(4), 329–345. https://doi.org/10.1177/0264550509346538

94.

Zaluar

(2010). Youth, drug traffic and hyper-masculinity in Rio de Janeiro. Vibrant, 7(2), 7–27.

95.

Zaluar

(2012). Turf- war in Rio the Janeiro: youth, drug traffic, guns and hyper-masculinity. In Ceccato

(Ed.), The urban fabric of crime and fear (pp. 217–237). Springer.

96.

Zeng

(2019). Jail Inmates in 2017 (p. 2019). Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Statistics.