In 2009, two Idaho prisoners with gender identity disorders (GIDs) settled lawsuits against the Department of Corrections for failing to treat properly their conditions. Prisoners in other states have also sued prison officials for failing to treat their GIDs. Initially, the courts held that prisoners with GIDs did not have a serious mental disorder and thus were not entitled to treatment. However, later courts have held that a GID is a serious medical problem, which implicates the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution that requires treatment for prisoners’ serious medical problems. No court, however, has ordered sex-reassignment surgery for any transsexual prisoner, despite holding that GID is a serious medical problem. This issue presents an interesting dilemma for the law and has implications for prison mental health professionals and prison administrators. The authors elaborate on these issues and discuss policy implications.
Alexander, R., Jr. ( 2001). To ascend into the shining world again. Westerville, OH: Theroe Enterprises.
2.
Allen, H.E., & Simonsen, C.E. (1998). Corrections in America: An introduction. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
3.
American Psychiatric Association. (1980). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (3rd ed.). Washington, DC: Author .
4.
American Psychiatric Association. (2000). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed., Text revision). Washington, DC: Author.
5.
Augustus Joseph Isaak, a.k.a Josephine Von Issak v. Idaho Department of Correction, 2007 U. S. Dist. LEXIS70298.
6.
Ault, A., & Brzuzy, S. ( 2009). Removing gender identity disorder from the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: A call for action. Social Work, 54, 187-189.
7.
Barker, H., & Wylie, K. ( 2008). Are the criteria for the ‘real-life experience’ (RLE) stage of assessment for GID useful to patients and clinicians? International Journal of Transgenderism, 10(3/4), 121-131
8.
Barnes, A.C. ( 1998). The sexual continuum: Transsexual prisoners. New England Journal on Criminal and Civil Confinement, 24, 599-646.
9.
Bockting, W.O., & Cesaretti, C. ( 2001). Spirituality, transgender identity, and coming out. Journal of Sex Education & Therapy, 26, 291-300.
10.
Boone, R. ( 2009, August 7). Idaho settles transgender suit: Two inmates castrated selves after being denied therapy. The Spokesman-Review . Retrieved from http://www.spokesman.com/stories/2009/aug/07/idaho-settles-transgender-suit/?print-friendly
11.
Bowring v. Godwin, 551 F.2d 44 (4th Cir. 1977).
12.
Brooks v. Berg, 2003 U. S. Dist. LEXIS 11911.
13.
Bullough, V.L. ( 1999). Medicine and gender dysphoria: A brief overview . Journal of Sex Education & Therapy, 24, 110-116.
14.
Carbonell, J.L., & Perkins, R. ( 1997). Diagnosis and assessment of criminal offenders . In P. Van Voorhis, M. Braswell, & D. Lester (Eds.), Correctional counseling and rehabilitation (pp. 63-80). Cincinnati, OH : Anderson.
15.
Carroll, R.A. ( 1999). Outcomes of treatment for gender dysphoria. Journal of Sex Education & Therapy, 24, 128-136.
16.
Champion, D.J. ( 1998). Corrections in the United States (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
17.
Chang, A. ( 2009). Unusual perks: Goldman Sachs covers sex changes . Retrieved from http://money.cnn.com/2008/02/08/news/companies/gender.fortune/index.htm
18.
Chin, L. ( 2004). A prisoner’s right to transsexual therapies: A look at Brooks v. Berg. Cardozo Women’s Law Journal , 11, 151-176.
19.
Cloud, J. ( 1998, July 20). Trans across America. Time, pp. 48-49.
20.
Cohen-Kettenis, P.T., & Pfafflin, F. ( 2009). The DSM diagnostic criteria for gender identity disorder in adolescents and adults. Archives of Sex Behavior (Online) , 1-15.
21.
Colapinto, J. ( 2000). As nature made him: The boy was raised as a girl . New York, NY: HarperCollins .
De’Lonta v. Angelone et al. 330 F.3d 630 (4th Cir. 2003).
24.
Denny, D. ( 1999, October/November). Transgender in the United States: A brief discussion. SEICUS Report, 8-13.
25.
Deogracias, J.J., Johnson, L.L., Meyer-Bahlburg, H.F.L., Kessler, S.J., Schober, J.M., & Zucker, K.J. ( 2007). The gender identity/gender dysphoria questionnaire for adolescents and adults. Journal of Sex Research, 44, 370-379.
26.
Drescher, J. ( 1998). I’m your handyman: A history of reparative therapies . Journal of Homosexuality, 36, 19-42.
27.
Duisin, D., Nikolic-Balkoski, G., & Batinic, B. ( 2009). Sociodemographic profile of transsexual patients . Pyschiatria Danubina, 21, 220-223.
28.
Eliason, M.J. ( 1996). Institutional barriers to health care for lesbian, gay and bisexual persons. Who cares?New York, NY: NLN Press.
29.
Estate of Miki Ann Dimarco v. Wyoming Department of Corrections, 473 F.3d 1334 (9th Cir. 2007).
30.
Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U. S. 825 (1994 ).
31.
Farmer v. Hawk-Sawyer, 69 F.Supp. 2d120 (USDC, DC Cir.1999).
32.
Farmer v. Moritsugu, 163 F.3d 610 (Ct App., DC Cir., 1998).
33.
Finney v. Arkansas Bd of Correction, 505 F. 2d 194 (8th Cir.1991).
34.
Gamble v. Estelle, 429 U. S. 97 (1976).
35.
Gammett a/k/a Jenniffer Ann Spencer v. Idaho State Board of Corrections2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 55564 , (2007).
36.
Gordon, E.B. ( 1991). Transsexual healing: Medicaid funding of sex reassignment surgery. Archives of Sexual Behavior, 20, 61-99.
37.
Hoptowit v. Ray, 682 F.2d 1237 (9th Cir.1982).
38.
Idaho Department of Corrections. (2009). Gender identity disorder: Healthcare for offenders. Boise, ID: Author.
39.
Inmates of Allegheny County Jail v. Pierce, 612 F.2d 754 (3rd Cir.1979).
40.
Jones v. Diamond, 636 F.2d 1378 (5th Cir.1981).
41.
Juran, S. ( 1999). Case report: Crossing boundaries in the treatment of a female-to-male transsexual. Journal of Sex Education & Therapy, 24, 147-154.
42.
Keys, D.P. ( 2002). Instrumental sexual scripting: An examination of gender-role fluidity in the correctional institutional. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 18, 258-278.
43.
Kosilek v. Maloney, 221 F. Supp. 2d 156 (US Dist MA,2002).
44.
Kunselman, J., Tewksbury, R., Dumond, R.W., & Dumond, D.A. ( 2002). Nonconsensual sexual behavior. In C. Hensley (Ed.), Prison sex: Practice and policy (pp. 27-47). Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
45.
Lee, A. ( 2008). Trans models in prison: The medicalization of gender identity and the Eighth Amendment right to sex reassignment therapy . Harvard Journal of Law & Gender, 31, 447-471.
46.
Levine, S.B. ( 1999). The newly revised standards of care for gender identity disorders. Journal of Sex Education & Therapy , 24, 117-127.
47.
Long v. Nix et al, 86 F. 3d 761 (8th Cir.1996).
48.
Mason, M. ( 2009). Bangkok big for gender reassignment surgery. Pride Source. Retrieved from http://www.pridesource.com/article.html?article=19951
49.
McCloskey, D.N. ( 1999). From Donald to Deirdre: How a man became a woman- and what it says about identity. REASON, December, 42-49.
50.
McNamara, M. ( 2001, February 27). Era of the gender crossover. Los Angeles Times, p. A1.
Michigan Department of Corrections. (1993). Policy directive: Gender identity disorders in prisoners. Detroit, MI: Author.
53.
National Center for Lesbian Rights. (2006). Rights of transgender prisoners. Retrieved from http://www.nclrights.org/site/DocServer/RightsofTransgenderPrisoners.pdf?doc
54.
Phillips v. Michigan Department of Corrections et al, 731 F. Supp. 792 (WD Mich, 1990).
55.
Ramos v. Lamm, 639 F.2d 559 (10th Cir.1980 ).
56.
Reed, H.M. ( 2003). Sexual reassignment surgery (SRS): Sex change operation in Greater Miami. Miami, FL: The Reed Center for Genital Surgery.
57.
Robbins, I.P. ( 1999). Managed health care in prisons as cruel and unusual punishment . Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 90, 195-238.
58.
Schroder, M., & Carroll, R.A. ( 1999). New women: Sexological outcomes of male-to-female gender reassignment surgery. Journal of Sex Education & Therapy , 24, 137-146.
59.
Seil, D. ( 1996). Transsexuals: The boundaries of sexual identity and gender . In R. P. Cabaj & T. S. Stein (Eds.), Textbook of homosexuality and mental health (pp. 743-762). Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
60.
Singh, D., Deogracias, J.J., Johnson, L.L., Bradley, S.J., Kibblewhite, S.J., Owen-Anderson, A., . . . Zucker, K. J. ( 2009). The gender identity/gender dysphoria questionnaire for adolescents and adults: Further validity evidence. Journal of Sex Research, 46(2/3), 1-10.
61.
Stinchcomb, J.B., & Fox, V. ( 1999). Introduction to corrections (5th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
62.
Sultan, B.A. ( 2003). Transsexual prisoners: How much treatment is enough . New England Law Review, 37, 1195-1230.
63.
Sundstrom et al. v. Frank et al, 2007 U.S. Dist. LEXIS (2007).
64.
Tarzwell, S. ( 2006). The gender lines are marked with razor wire: Addressing state prison policies and practices for the management of transgender prisoners . Columbia Human Rights Law Review, 38, 167-202.
65.
Tedeschi, D.S. ( 1995). The predicament of the transsexual prisoner. Temple Policy & Civil Rights Law Review, 5, 27-47.
66.
Torraco v. Maloney et al, 923 F.2d 231 (1st Cir.1991).
67.
Tsist Sistas Vo OME Voto Reverse v. Yordy et al., 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 84219 (2009).
68.
Waldrop v. Evans, 871 F.2d 1030 (11th Cir.1989).
69.
Walling, D.P., Goodwin, J.M., & Cole, C.M. ( 1998). Dissociation in a transsexual population. Journal of Sex Education & Therapy, 23, 121-123.
70.
Wellman v. Faulkner, 715 F.2d 269 (7th Cir.1983).
71.
World Professional Association for Transgender Health. ( 2008). WPATH clarification on medical necessity of treatment, sex reassignment, and insurance coverage in the U.S.AAmerican Academy of Pediatrics, 17, 1-4.
72.
World Professional Association for Transgender Health’s Standards of Care for Gender Identity Disorders. (2009). WPATH standards of care. Retrieved from http://www.wpath.org/publications_standards.cfm
73.
Zucker, K.J. ( 2008). Reflections on the relation between sex-typed behavior in childhood and sexual orientation in adulthood. Journal of Gay & Lesbian Mental Health, 12, 29-59.
74.
Zucker, K.J., & Bradley, S.J. ( 1999). Gender identity disorder and transvestic fetishism . In S. Netherton, D. Holmes, & C. E. Walker (Eds.), Child and adolescent psychological disorders: A comprehensive textbook (pp. 367-396). New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
