How do economic crises harm political trust? And can their impact be mitigated? Using data from Eurofound’s Living, working, and COVID-19 survey conducted across the EU during the COVID-19 pandemic, I find that economic performance and social protection are strongly correlated with political trust in such contexts, however independently from each other. While deteriorating economic conditions severely harm trust, social protection can subsequently temper this negative impact. More specifically, in the case of the COVID-19 crisis, the deferral of debt and taxes, followed by support from public services and wage support mitigated the most the negative impact of the crisis on political trust. However, I find this mitigating effect to be only moderate as trust attitudes are likely to be affected by a negativity bias. In other words, the positive effect of receiving state support on political trust is systematically inferior to the negative effect of the crisis. Because of this bias, governments are more likely to be punished by citizens for what the crisis has done to them than to be rewarded for what they have done for them.
BavelJJVBaickerKBoggioPS, et al. (2020) Using Social and Behavioural Science to Support COVID-19 Pandemic Response. Nature Human Behaviour4 (5): 460–471.
2.
BenoîtCHayC (2022) The Antinomies of Sovereigntism, Statism and Liberalism in European Democratic Responses to the COVID-19 Crisis: A Comparison of Britain and France. Comparative European Politics20 (3): 390–410.
3.
BitenMKuhnTVan Der BrugW (2023) How Does Fiscal Austerity Affect Trust in the European Union? Analyzing the Role of Responsibility Attribution. Journal of European Public Policy30 (6): 1033–1050.
4.
BolDGianiMBlaisA, et al. (2021) The Effect of COVID-19 Lockdowns on Political Support: Some Good News for Democracy?European Journal of Political Research60 (2): 497–505.
5.
BollykyTJHullandENBarberRM, et al. (2022) Pandemic Preparedness and COVID-19: An Exploratory Analysis of Infection and Fatality Rates, and Contextual Factors Associated with Preparedness in 177 Countries, from Jan 1, 2020, to Sept 30, 2021. The Lancet399 (10334): 1489–1512.
6.
BrehmJRahnW (1997) Individual-Level Evidence for the Causes and Consequences of Social Capital. American Journal of Political Science41 (3): 999.
7.
CarstensJ (2023) Unpacking Political Trust: A Review of Conceptualisations, Determinants, and Consequences. French Politics21 (3): 295–314.
8.
CitrinJGreenDP (1986) Presidential Leadership and the Resurgence of Trust in Government. British Journal of Political Science16 (4): 431–453.
9.
CitrinJStokerL (2018) Political Trust in a Cynical Age. Annual Review of Political Science21 (1): 49–70.
10.
ClarkeHDDuttNKornbergA (1993) The Political Economy of Attitudes toward Polity and Society in Western European Democracies. The Journal of Politics55 (4): 998–1021.
11.
DaltonRJ (2004) Democratic Challenges, Democratic Choices. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
DassonnevilleRLewis-BeckMS (2014) Macroeconomics, Economic Crisis and Electoral Outcomes: A National European Pool. Acta Politica49 (4): 372–394.
13.
de BlokLHaugsgjerdAKumlinS (2020) Increasingly Connected? Political Distrust and Dissatisfaction with Public Services in Europe, 2008–2016. In: LaenenTMeulemanBvan OorschotW (eds) Welfare State Legitimacy in Times of Crisis and Austerity. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.201–221.
14.
DevineD (2024) Does Political Trust Matter? A Meta-Analysis on the Consequences of Trust. Political Behavior46 (4): 2241–2262.
15.
DevineDValgarðssonVSmithJ, et al. (2023) Political Trust in the First Year of the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Meta-Analysis of 67 Studies. Journal of European Public Policy. Epub ahead of print 30 January. DOI: 10.1080/13501763.2023.2169741.
EastonD (1975) A Re-Assessment of the Concept of Political Support. British Journal of Political Science5 (4): 435–457.
18.
EllinasAALamprianouI (2014) Political Trust in Extremis. Comparative Politics46 (2): 231–250.
19.
ErbringLGoldenbergENMillerAH (1980) Front-Page News and Real-World Cues: A New Look at Agenda-Setting by the Media. American Journal of Political Science24 (1): 16.
20.
Eurofound (2020a) COVID-19: Policy Responses across Europe. Luxembourg: Publications Office.
21.
Eurofound (éd.) (2020b) Living, Working and COVID-19 Dataset. Available at: https://www.eurofound.europa.eu/en/surveys-and-data/surveys/living-and-working-in-the-eu-e-survey
22.
Eurostat (n.d.) Unemployment by Sex and Age—Monthly Data (Jeu de données). Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/view/une_rt_m/default/table?lang=en
23.
GamsonWA (1968) Power and Discontent. Homewood, IL: Dorsey Press.
24.
GerringJ (2009) Case Selection for Case-Study Analysis: Qualitative and Quantitative Techniques. In: Box-SteffensmeierJMBradyHECollierD (éds) The Oxford Handbook of Political Methodology, 1st édn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.645–684.
HaugsgjerdA (2018) Political Distrust Amidst The Great Recession: The Mitigating Effect of Welfare State Effort. Comparative European Politics16 (4): 620–648.
27.
HetheringtonMJ (1998) The Political Relevance of Political Trust. American Political Science Review92 (4): 791–808.
28.
HetheringtonMJRudolphTJ (2008) Priming, Performance, and the Dynamics of Political Trust. The Journal of Politics70 (2): 498–512.
29.
HibbingJRPattersonSC (1994) Public Trust in the New Parliaments of Central and Eastern Europe. Political Studies42 (4): 570–592.
30.
HoogheMOkolikjM (2020) The Long-Term Effects of the Economic Crisis on Political Trust in Europe: Is There a Negativity Bias in the Relation between Economic Performance and Political Support?Comparative European Politics18 (6): 879–898.
31.
IyengarSKinderDR (2010) News That Matters : Television and American Opinion (Updated edn). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
32.
KahnemanDTverskyA (1984) Choices, Values, and Frames. American Psychologist39 (4): 341–350.
33.
KeeleL (2007) Social Capital and the Dynamics of Trust in Government. American Journal of Political Science51 (2): 241–254.
34.
KroknesVFJakobsenTGGrønningL-M (2015) Economic Performance and Political Trust: The Impact of the Financial Crisis on European Citizens. European Societies17 (5): 700–723.
35.
KumlinSHaugsgjerdA (2017) The Welfare State and Political Trust: Bringing Performance Back in. In: ZmerliSvan Der MeerTWG (eds) Handbook on Political Trust. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.285–301.
36.
LauRR (1985) Two Explanations for Negativity Effects in Political Behavior. American Journal of Political Science29 (1): 119.
37.
LawrenceMHomer-DixonTJanzwoodS, et al. (2024) Global Polycrisis: The Causal Mechanisms of Crisis Entanglement. Global Sustainability7: e6.
38.
ListhaugOWibergM (1998) Confidence in Political and Private Institutions. In: KlingemannH-DFuchsD (éds) Citizens and the State, 1st édn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.298–322.
39.
MayneQHahkverdianA (2017) Education, Socialization, and Political Trust. In: ZmerliSvan Der MeerT (eds) Handbook on Political Trust. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, pp.176–197.
40.
MazowerM (1999) Dark Continent: Europe’s Twentieth Century, 1st American edn. New York: A.A. Knopf ; Distributed by Random House.
41.
MillerAListhaugO (1999) Political Performance and Institutional Trust. In: NorrisP (éd.) Critical Citizens, 1st édn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.204–216.
42.
MillerAHBorrelliSA (1991) Confidence in Government During the 1980s. American Politics Quarterly19 (2): 147–173.
43.
NewtonK (2006) Political Support: Social Capital, Civil Society and Political and Economic Performance. Political Studies54 (4): 846–864.
44.
OECD (2023) Social Spending (Jeu de données). Paris: OECD.
45.
RichardsonLHoustonDHadjiharalambousC (2001) Public Confdence in the Leaders of American Governmental Institutions. In: HibbingJRTheiss-MorseE (éds) What Is It about Government That Americans Dislike?Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp.83–97.
SchraffD (2021) Political Trust during the Covid-19 Pandemic: Rally around the Flag or Lockdown Effects?European Journal of Political Research60 (4): 1007–1017.
48.
t’HartP (1994) Groupthink in Government: A Study of Small Groups and Policy Failure, Johns Hopkins Paperbacks edn. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
49.
Van Der MeerTWG (2017) Democratic Input, Macroeconomic Output and Political Trust. In: ZmerliSVan Der MeerTW (eds) Handbook on Political Trust. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing. pp.270–285.
50.
Van ErkelPFAVan Der MeerTWG (2016) Macroeconomic Performance, Political Trust and the Great Recession: A Multilevel Analysis of the Effects of Within-Country Fluctuations in Macroeconomic Performance on Political Trust in 15 EU Countries, 1999-2011: Macroeconomic Performance, Political Trust and the Great Recession. European Journal of Political Research55 (1): 177–197.
51.
WeatherfordMS (1987) How Does Government Performance Influence Political Support?Political Behavior9 (1): 5–28.
52.
WeaverRK (1988) Automatic Government: The Politics of Indexation. Washington, DC: Brookings Institution.
53.
WilliamsNSSnipesASinghSP (2021) Gender Differences in the Impact of Electoral Victory on Satisfaction with Democracy. Electoral Studies69: 102–205.
54.
ZmerliSNewtonK (2008) Social Trust and Attitudes toward Democracy. Public Opinion Quarterly72 (4): 706–724.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
