Why, and to what extent, must taxpayers share the costs of raising children with parents? The most influential argument over this question has been the public goods argument: Taxpayers must share costs with parents because and to the extent that child-rearing contributes toward public goods by helping to develop valuable human capital. However, political theorists have not examined the public goods argument in a context in which replacement migration is available: If replacement migration can provide valuable human capital more efficiently than child-rearing, can the public goods argument still justify a taxpayer obligation to share the costs of child-rearing? This article argues that there are importantly different versions of the public goods argument, and that on a plausible version of that argument, it can withstand the replacement migration challenge under most circumstances.
AlstottA (2005) No Exit: What Parents Owe Their Children and What Society Owes Parents. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
2.
AndersonE (1999) What’s the Point of Equality?Ethics109: 287–337.
3.
ArchardD (2010) The Obligations of Parenthood. In: ArchardDBenatarD (eds) Procreation and Parenthood: The Ethics of Bearing and Rearing Children. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.103–127.
4.
ArnesonR (1982) The Principle of Fairness and Free-Rider ProblemsEthics4: 616–633.
5.
Australia Bureau of Statistics (ABS) (1996) Births: Australia (Catalogue no. 3301.0). Canberra, ACT, Australia: ABS.
6.
Bou-HabibP (2019) The Case for Replacement Migration. Journal of Political Philosophy27: 67–87.
7.
BradleyB (2012) Doing Away with Harm. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research85: 390–412.
8.
BrakeE (2010) Willing Parents: A Voluntarist Account of Parental Role Obligations. In: ArchardDBenatarD (eds) Procreation and Parenthood: The Ethics of Bearing and Rearing Children. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.151–177.
9.
BrazerH (1977) Comments. In: PechmanJ (ed.) Comprehensive Income Taxation. Washington, DC: Brookings Institute.
10.
BrockGBlakeM (2015) Debating Brain Drain. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
11.
BurkettE (2000) The Baby Boon. New York: The Free Press.
12.
CafaroP (2009) The Environmental Argument for Reducing Immigration into the United StatesEnvironmental Ethics31: 5–30.
13.
CaneyS (2020): Human Rights, Population and Climate Change. In: AkandeDRoserSMcDermottH, et al. (eds) Human Rights and 21st Century Challenges. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.348–370.
14.
CasalP (1999) Environmentalism, Procreation, and the Principe of Fairness. Public Affairs Quarterly13: 363–376.
15.
CasalPWilliamsA (1995) Rights, Equality and Procreation. Analyse & Kritik17: 93–116.
16.
ClaytonM (2006) Justice and Legitimacy in Upbringing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
17.
ConlyS (2016) One Child: Do We Have a Right to More?Oxford: Oxford University Press.
18.
CrippsE (2017) Do Parents Have a Special Duty to Mitigate Climate Change?Politics, Philosophy & Economics16: 308–325.
19.
CullityG (1995) Moral Free Riding. Philosophy and Public Affairs24: 3–34.
20.
De la CroixDDoepkeM (2003) Inequality and Growth: Why Differential Fertility Matters. American Economic Review93: 1091–1113.
21.
De WispelaereJWeinstockD (2012) Licensing Parents to Protect Our Children?Ethics and Social Welfare6: 195–205.
DocquierFMarchioriL (2012) The Impact of MENA-to-EU Migration in the Context of Demographic Change. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance11: 243–284.
24.
EngsterD (2007) The Heart of Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
25.
Esping-AndersenG (2009) The Incomplete Revolution. Cambridge: Polity Press.
26.
FinemanM. (2004). The Autonomy Myth. The New Press.
27.
FleurbaeyM (1995) Equal Opportunity or Equal Social Outcome. Economics and Philosophy11: 25–55.
28.
FolbreN (1994a) Children as Public Goods. American Economic Review84: 86–90.
29.
FolbreN (1994b) Who Pays for the Kids?London: Routledge.
30.
FolbreN (2001) The Invisible Heart. Economics and Family Values. New York: The New Press.
31.
FolbreN (2008) Valuing Children: Rethinking the Economics of the Family. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
32.
FolbreNBittmanM (eds) (2004) Family Time: The Social Organization of Care. London: Routledge.
33.
GálRVanhuyssePVarghaL (2018) Pro-Elderly Welfare States within Child-Oriented Societies. Journal of European Public Policy25: 944–958.
34.
GeorgeR (1987) Who Should Bear the Costs of Children?Public Affairs Quarterly1: 1–42.
35.
GeorgeR (1993) On the External Benefits of Children. In: MeyersDKipnisKMurphyC (eds) Kindred Matters. Rethinking the Philosophy of the Family. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, pp.209–217.
36.
GornickJMeyersMRossK (1999) Public Childcare, Parental Leave, and Employment. In: SainsburyD (ed.) Gender and Welfare State Regimes. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp.117–146.
37.
GosseriesAZwarthoedD (2017) Generations and Global Justice. In: HeldDMaffetoneP (eds) Global Political Theory. Cambridge: Polity Press, pp.281–304.
38.
HartHLA (1955) Are There Any Natural Rights?The Philosophical Review64: 175–191.
39.
HaslangerS (2009) Family, Ancestry and Self: What Is the Moral Significance of Biological Ties?Adoption and Culture2: 91–122.
40.
HeckmanJ (2013) Giving Kids a Fair Chance. Boston, MA: MIT Press.
41.
HeckmanJMasterovD (2007) The Productivity Argument for Investing in Young Children. Review of Agricultural Economics29: 446–493.
42.
HeywardC (2012) A Growing Problem? Dealing with Population Increases in Climate Justice. Ethical Perspectives19: 703–732.
43.
HickeyCRiederTEarlJ (2016) Population Engineering and the Fight Against Climate Change. Social Theory and Practice42: 845–870.
44.
KloskoG (1987) Presumptive Benefit, Fairness and Political Obligation. Philosophy and Public Affairs16: 241–259.
45.
LaFolletteH (2010) Licensing Parents Revisited. Journal of Applied Philosophy27: 327–343.
46.
LewisJ (2003) Should We Worry about Family Change?Toronto, ON, Canada: University of Toronto Press.
47.
LiaoSM (2015) The Right to Be Loved. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
48.
McKibbenB (1998) Maybe One. New York: Simon & Schuster.
49.
MacleodC (2002) Liberal Equality and the Affective Family. In: ArchardDMacleodC (eds) The Moral and Political Status of Children. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.212–230.
50.
MeijersT (2016) Climate Change and the Right to One Child. In: BosGDüwellM (eds) Human Rights and Sustainability. London: Routledge, pp.181–194.
51.
MillerDTaylorI (2018) Public Goods. In: OlsarettiS (ed.) The Oxford Handbook of Distributive Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.556–575.
52.
NagelTMurphyL (2004) The Myth of Ownership: Taxes and Justice. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
53.
NozickR (1969) Coercion. In: MorgenbesserSSuppesPWhiteM (eds) Philosophy, Science, and Method: Essays in Honor of Ernest Nagel. New York: St. Martin’s Press, pp.440–472.
54.
NozickR (1974) Anarchy State, and Utopia. New York: Basic Books.
55.
OECD (2019) Fiscal Challenges and Inclusive Growth in Ageing Societies. Paris: OECD Economic Policy Papers.
56.
OlsarettiS (2013) Children as Public Goods?Philosophy and Public Affairs41: 226–258.
57.
OlsarettiS (2018) The Costs of Children. In: GheausACalderGDe WispelaereD (eds) The Routledge Handbook of the Philosophy of Childhood and Children. Abingdon: Routledge, pp.339–350.
58.
OverallC (2012) Why Have Children? The Ethical Debate. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
59.
ParfitD (1987) Reasons and Persons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
60.
PasternakA (2017) Fair Play and Wrongful Benefits. Journal of Moral Philosophy14: 515–534.
61.
PinkertFStickerM (2020) Procreation, Footprint and Responsibility for Climate Change. The Journal of Ethics25: 293–321.
62.
PutnamR (2015) Our Kids: The American Dream in Crisis. New York: Simon & Schuster.
RawlsJ (1996) Political Liberalism. New York: Columbia University Press.
65.
RawlsJ (1999) A Theory of Justice (Revised Edition). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
66.
RawlsJ (2001) Justice as Fairness: A Restatement. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
67.
RoseJ (2016) Free Time. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
68.
RulliT (2014) The Unique Value of Adoption. In: BaylisFMcLeodC (eds) Family-Making: Contemporary Ethical Challenges. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp.109–130.
69.
SaracenoC (2010) Can We Identify Intergenerational Policy Regimes in Europe?European Societies12: 675–696.
70.
ShelbyT (2016) Dark Ghettoes: Injustice, Desert and Reform. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
