Education or indoctrination? An exploration of the resistance towards making policing a degree-level profession

Abstract

Following a governmental U-turn on the requirement for new police officers to have degrees, this article examines what happened within just 7 years to cause this; specifically from the perspective of chief constables. This is contextualised through social learning and followership, and examining best practice in police leadership. It concludes that with unambiguous buy-in of ideas - such as the requirement for professionalisation through education - officers accept them; but that in this example that was not the case. It demonstrates that where chief constables supported the entry routes, satisfaction rates were higher; but chiefs who obstructed their delivery ensured its failure.

Keywords

police education chief constables police culture police constable entry routes;police training

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam

Galinsky

(2012) Enclothed cognition. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 48: 918–925.

Adderley

Vincent

(2021) Graduate police recruits are ‘taken aback’ by violence’, ‘sadly lacking’ in life experience and aren’t prepared to work nights and weekends, chief constable Nick Adderley says. Daily Mail, 19th May.

Adlam

(2002) Governmental rationalities in police leadership: an essay exploring some of the ‘deep structure’ in police leadership praxis. Policing and Society 12(1): 15–36.

Alderson

Stead

(1973) The Police We Deserve. London: Wolf.

Andrews

(2023a) Perceptions of student police officers on the police constable degree apprenticeship. The Police Journal: Theory, Practice and Principles, online first.

Andrews

(2023b) The superhero effect: how enclothed cognition can impact on the perceptions and actions of serving UK police officers. The Police Journal: Theory, Practice and Principles, online first.

Astley

(2019) Power relationships within the UK police service: towards enhanced female career progression. International Journal of Human Resources Development and Management 4(1): 59–70.

Bandura

(1977) Social Learning Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Barton

(2011) Challenges, issues and change: what’s the future for UK policing in the twenty‐first century? International Journal of Public Sector Management 24(2): 146156.

10.

Bass

(1985) Leadership and Performance beyond Expectations. New York: Free Press.

11.

Bratton

Knobler

(1998) Turnaround: How America’s Top Cop Reversed the Crime Epidemic. New York: Random House.

12.

Braverman

(2022) Gov.uk. [Online]. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/suella-braverman-at-the-apcc-and-npcc-partnership-summit (Accessed 28th July 2023).

13.

Byrne

(2023) The Fourth Entry Route: Where We Are and where We're Headed. Liverpool: Liverpool John Moores University.

14.

Campbell

Colover

(2020) Direct Entry Superintendent Programme: Five-Year Evaluation Report 2014 – 2019. Ryton-On-Dunsmore: College of Policing.

15.

Campbell

Kodz

(2011) What Makes Great Police Leadership? Ryton-On-Dunsmore, UK: NPIA.

16.

Canter

(2004) A tale of two cultures: a comparison of the cultures of the police and academia. In: Villiers

Adlam

(eds) Policing a Safe, Just and Tolerant Socitey: An International Model. Winchester, UK: Waterside Press, 109–121.

17.

Casey

(2023) Final Report: An Independent Review into the Standards of Behaviour and Internal Culture of the Metropolitan Police Service. London: s.n.

18.

Casey

Mitchell

(2007) Requirements of police managers from sergeant to commissioner. In: Mitchell

Casey

(eds) Police Leadership & Management. Sydney: Federation Press, 4–20.

19.

Chan

Doran

(2009) Staying in the Job: job satisfaction among mid-career police officers. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 3(1): 66–77.

20.

Charman

(2024) The Development & Impact of Cultures and Identities in Policing and the Lessons for Leadership. Stoke-On-Trent: Staffordshire University.

21.

Charman

Bennett

(2022) Voluntary resignations from the police service: the impact of organisational and occupational stressors on organisational commitment. Policing and Society 32(2): 159–178.

22.

Clinton

(2022) Police: 1,800 officers recruited under Boris Johnson scheme ‘have resigned’. The Guardian, 30th December.

23.

Cockroft

(2013) Police Culture: Themes and Concepts. London: Routledge.

24.

Cohen

McCormick

Rich

(2019) Creating a culture of police officer wellness. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 13(2): 213–229.

25.

College of Policing (n.d.) Bursary scheme. [Online]. Available at: https://www.college.police.uk/research/support-research/college-bursary (Accessed 2nd December 2023).

26.

College of Policing (2015) Leadership Review. Ryton-On-Dunsmore: College of Policing.

27.

College of Policing (2016) Developing and Delivering an Education Qualification Framework for Policing: The College of Policing Response to the Consultation. Ryton-On-Dunsmore: College of Policing.

28.

Cooper

(2021) Police and crime commissioners: a dislocated expectation? Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 15(3): 1916–1932.

29.

Cordner

(2017) Police culture: individual and organizational differences in police officer perspectives. Policing: International Journal 40(1): 11–25.

30.

Cox

Kirby

(2018) Can higher education reduce the negative consequences of police occupational culture amongst new recruits? Policing: International Journal 41(5): 550–562.

31.

Creaghan

(2019) Lincolnshire Police bosses launch legal challenge against degree training. The Lincolnite, 11th July.

32.

Dobby

Anscombe

Tuffin

(2004) Police Leadership: Expectations and Impact. London: The Home Office.

33.

Durkheim

(1893) The Division of Labour in Society. Glencoe, IL: The Free Press.

34.

Fielding

(1988) Joining Forces: Police Training, Socialization and Occupational Competence. London: Routledge.

35.

Flannagan

(2008) The Review of Policing. London: UK Government.

36.

Francis

(2023) Rishi sunak sacks Suella Braverman as home secretary. [Online]. Available at https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-67401753 (Accessed 26th March 2024).

37.

Gibbons

(2023) Hampshire police officers are reaching ‘breaking point’. The Basingstoke Gazette, 24th January.

38.

Goode

Lumsden

(2018) The McDonaldisation of police–academic partnerships: organisational and cultural barriers encountered in moving from research on police to research with police. Policing and Society 28(1): 75–89.

39.

Gov.uk (2022) Police workforce statistics England and wales year ending 31 March 2022. [Online]. Available at https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-workforce-england-and-wales-31-march-2022/police-workforce-england-and-wales-31-march-2022#promotions-joiners-and-leavers (Accessed 10th October 2022).

40.

Gov.uk (2023) Police workforce, England and wales: 31 March 2023. [Online]. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/police-workforce-england-and-wales-31-march-2023/police-workforce-england-and-wales-31-march-2023#promotions-joiners-and-leavers (Accessed 28th July 2023).

41.

Grint

(2005) Problems, problems, problems: the social construction of leadership. Human Relations 58(11): 1467–1494.

42.

Hallenberg

Cockroft

(2017) From indifference to hostility: police officers, organizational responses and the symbolic value of ‘in-service’ higher education in policing. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 11(3): 273–288.

43.

Heslop

(2011) The British police service: professionalisation or ‘mcdonaldization’? International Journal of Police Science and Management 13(4): 312–321.

44.

Honess

Clarke

(2023) ‘It’s not “uni” work, it’s essential learning to be a police officer’: examining the higher education elements of police education qualifications framework programmes. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 17: paad023.

45.

House of Commons Home Affairs Committee (2017) College of Policing: Three Years on. London: House of Commons.

46.

Humphreys

Einstein

(2003) Nothing new under the sun: transformational leadership from a historical perspective. Management Decision 41(1): 85–95.

47.

Hunter

Neubert

Perry SJ , et al. (2013) Servant leaders inspire servant followers: antecedents and outcomes for employees and the organization. The Leadership Quarterly 24(2): 316–331.

48.

Janis

(1971) Groupthink. Psychology Today 5(6): 84–90.

49.

Lambert

(1986) Police Powers and Accountability. London: Croom Helm.

50.

Latif

Jan

Shaheen

(2013) Association of training satisfaction with employee development aspect of job satisfaction. Journal of managerial sciences 7(1): 159–178.

51.

Lian

Huai

Farh

J-L

, et al. (2020) Leader unethical pro-organizational behavior and employee unethical conduct: social learning of moral disengagement as a behavioral principle. Journal of Management 48(2): 350–379.

52.

Loftus

(2009) Police Culture in a Changing World. 1st edition Oxford: Oxford Academic.

53.

Marenin

(2004) Police training for democracy. Police Practice and Research 5(2): 107–123.

54.

Murray

(2002) Police culture: a critical component of community policing. Australian Journal of Forensic Sciences 34: 57–71.

55.

Neyroud

(2010) Review of Police Leadership and Training. London: H M Government.

56.

NPCC (2015) Policing Vision 2025. London: National Police Chiefs Council.

57.

NPCC (2018) Chief Constable Preparation, Selection, Tenure and Retirement in the ‘New Landscape of Policing’. London: NPCC.

58.

Panzarella

(2003) Leadership myths and realities. In: Adlam

Villiers

(eds) Police Leadership in the 21st Century: Philosophy, Doctrine and Developments. Winchester, UK: Waterside Press, 119–133.

59.

Paoline

(2003) Taking stock: toward a richer understanding of police culture. Journal of Criminal Justice 31(3): 199–214.

60.

Peach

Clare

(2017) Global citizenship and critical thinking in higher education curricula and police education: a socially critical vocational perspective. Journal of Pedagogic Development 7(2): 46–57.

61.

Potter

(2023) Policing Insight | Force’s new entry route could save ‘100,000 hours of police time’ – but move away from degrees comes under fire. [Online]. Available at https://policinginsight.com/feature/forces-new-entry-route-could-save-100000-hours-of-police-time-but-move-away-from-degrees-comes-under-fire/ (Accessed 26th September 2023).

62.

Quigley

LaFrance

(2017) Political pressure and kaufman’s cycles in the office of police and crime commissioner. Law Enforcement Executive Forum 17(1): 1–13.

63.

R v. The Metropolitan Police Commissioner ex parte Blackburn (1968) Court of appeal.

64.

Ramshaw

Silvestri

Simpson

(2019) Police Leadership: Changing Landscapes. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave MacMillan.

65.

Reiner

(1992) Chief Constables: Bobbies, Bosses or Bureucrats? Oxford: Oxford University Press.

66.

Rowley

(2024) Commissioner reflects on officers being caught in the middle of public debate. [Online]. Available at: https://news.met.police.uk/blog_posts/commissioner-reflects-on-officers-being-caught-in-the-middle-of-public-debate-117874 (Accessed 23rd March 2024).

67.

Rutherford

(1993) Criminal Justice and the Pursuit of Decency. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

68.

Savage

(2016) Whistleblowing in the police service: developments and challenges. European Journal of Current Legal Issues 22(1): Online.

69.

Scarman

(1981) The Brixton Disorders, 10-12 April 1981: The Scarman Report : Report of an Inquiry. London: Home Office.

70.

Scott

(1998) ‘Performance culture’: the return of reactive policing. Policing and Society 8(3): 269–288.

71.

Smith

(1993) Outcome-related performance indicators and organizational control in the public sector. British Journal of Managament 4: 135–151.

72.

Smith

(2016) Policing in austerity: time to go lean? International Journal of Emergency Services 5(2): 174–183.

73.

St Johnston

(1978) One Policeman's Story. Chichester: Barry Rose.

74.

Sutherland

(2020) Crossing the Line: Lessons From a Life on Duty. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.

75.

Tajfel

(1978) The achievement of inter-group differentiation. In: Tajfel

(ed) Differentiation between Social Groups. London: Academic Press, 77–100.

76.

Talbot

(2000) Performing ‘performance’—A comedy in five acts. Public Money & Management, 20(4), 6368 -.

77.

Tannenbaum

Schmidt

(1973) How to choose and leadership pattern. Harvard Business Review 51: 162180.

78.

Tschohl

(1998) Empowerment ‐ the key to quality service. Managing Service Quality: An International Journal 8(6): 421425.

79.

Tyson

Charman

(2023) Leaving the table: organisational (in)justice and the relationship with police officer retention. Criminology and Criminal Justice. Online First.

80.

Uhl-Bien

(2006) Relational leadership theory: exploring the social processes of leadership and organizing. The Leadership Quarterly 17(6): 654–676.

81.

University of Derby (2021) First cohort of police constables in the country graduate from University of Derby. [Online]. Available at https://www.derby.ac.uk/news/2021/first-cohort-of-police-constables-in-the-country-graduate-from-university-of-derby/ (Accessed 26th September 2023).

82.

University of Derby (2022) New training programme for military service leavers launched. [Online]. Available at: https://www.derby.ac.uk/news/2022/new-training-programme-for-military-service-leavers-launched-/ (Accessed 3rd October 2023).

83.

Verma

(n.d.) The loss of IPLDP during a changing workforce. [Online]. Available at: https://touch.policeoracle.com/news/article.cfm?id=107496 (Accessed 5th October 2022).

84.

Watkinson-Miley

Cox

Deshpande

(2022) A new generation of police officers: experiences of student officers undertaking the police constable degree apprenticeship in one UK police force. Policing: A Journal of Policy and Practice 16(1): 122–134.

85.

White

(1952) Groupthink. Fortune 114–117.

86.

Williams

Norman

Rowe

(2019) The police education qualification framework: a professional agenda or building professionals? Police Practice and Research: International Journal 20(3): 259–272.