Celebrities’ Memorial Afterlives: Obituaries,Tributes,and Posthumous Gossip in the Romanian Media Deathscape

Abstract

Cross-culturally, dead are protected from posthumous negative evaluations by the universal “nil nisi bonum” precept that governs the ethics within the community of mourners. In this study, we set out to test the observance of this injunction against posthumous gossiping in the Romanian public deathscape. Obituaries and other posthumous articles (N = 1,148) were collected that covered the deaths of 63 celebrities who passed away between 2013 and 2016. Materials were gathered from the digital archives of three Romanian news sources (a news agency, a “quality” newspaper, and a tabloid), published one week after the moment of death. The findings show that 22% of the articles do contain negative evaluations of the deceased. The percentage rises to 36.4% if we restrict the sample to only those celebrities with a controversial anthumous reputation (19 of 63). These results indicate that celebrities are not spared from critical assessments after they pass away.

Keywords

death obituary analysis gossip celebrity media

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Actorul Mihai Bendeac, reacţie-şoc după moartea Mitropolitului Banatului: “Acest porc să ardă în Iad!” [Actor Mihai Bendeac, a shock-reaction after the death of the Archbishop of Banat: “This pig should burn in hell!”]. (2014, September 29). Gândul. Retrieved from http://www.gandul.info/magazin/actorul-mihai-bendeac-reactie-soc-dupa-moartea-mitropolitului-banatului-acest-porc-sa-arda-in-iad-13354228.

Alfano, M., Higgins, M., & Levernier, J. (2017). Identifying virtues and values through obituary data-mining. The Journal of Value Inquiry. doi:10.1007/s10790-017-9602-0.

Amato

J. A.

(1993) Death and the stories we don’t have. Monist 76(2): 252–269.

Barnes

J. A.

(1987) The gentle art of necrology. The Cambridge Journal of Anthropology 12(1): 52–69.

Bendeac, mesaj șocant despre Mitropolitul Banatului, decedat aseară: “Un porc, o creatură sinistră” [Bendeac, a shocking message about the Archbishop of Banat, died last night: “This pig, a sinister creature.”]. (2014, September 29). Libertatea. Retrieved from http://www.libertatea.ro/monden/vedete-de-la-noi/bendeac-mesaj-socant-despre-mitropolitul-banatului-decedat-aseara-un-porc-o-creatura-sinistra-1074811.

Bingham, J. (2016, June 6). Falling birth rates could spell end of the West–Lord Sacks. The Telegraph. Retrieved from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/06/06/falling-birth-rates-could-spell-end-of-the-west—lord-sacks/.

Boorstin

D. J.

(1962) The image: A guide to pseudo-events in America, New York, NY: Harper & Row.

Bourdieu

(1984) Distinction: A social critique of the judgement of taste, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Brown

D. J.

(1991) Human universals, New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

10.

Ce a spus presupusa “amantă” Adelina Popovici, despre relaţia cu Corneliu Vadim Tudor [What did the alleged “mistress” Adelina Popovici had to say about her relationship with Corneliu Vadim Tudor?]. (2014, September 21). Libertatea. Retrieved from http://www.libertatea.ro/monden/ce-a-spus-presupusa-amanta-adelina-popovici-despre-relatia-cu-corneliu-vadim-tudor-9442.

11.

Cele mai haioase momente cu Vadim Tudor. Tribunul era slobod la gură şi înjura ca la uşa cortului [The funniest moments with Vadim Tudor. The tribune had a potty mouth and used to swear through a two-inch board.]. (2014, September 15). Libertatea. Retrieved from http://www.libertatea.ro/ultima-ora/cele-mai-haioase-momente-cu-vadim-tudor-tribunul-era-slobod-la-gura-si-injura-ca-la-usa-cortului-video-11446.

12.

Chaunu, P., & Suffert, G. (1976). La peste blanche. Comment éviter le suicide de l’Occident [The white plague. How to avoid the suicide of the West.]. Paris, France: Editions Gallimard.

13.

Chesterton

G. K.

(1908) Orthodoxy, San Francisco, CA: Ignatius Press/John Lane.

14.

Corneliu Vadim Tudor a murit [Corneliu Vadim Tudor has died]. (2014, September 14). Gândul. http://www.gandul.info/corneliu-vadim-tudor-a-murit-14712357.html.

15.

Driessens

(2013) The celebritization of society and culture: Understanding the structural dynamics of celebrity culture. International Journal of Cultural Studies 16(6): 641–657.

16.

Engle Marry

(1997) Rethinking gossip and scandal. In: Klein

D. B.

(ed.) Reputation: Studies in the voluntary elicitation of good conduct, Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, pp. 47–74.

17.

Feinberg

Willer

Keltner

(2012) The virtues of gossip: Reputational information sharing as prosocial behavior. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 102(5): 1015–1030.

18.

Fergusson

(1999) Death and the press. In: Glover

(ed.) The Penguin book of journalism, Harmondsworth, England: Penguin, pp. 148–160.

19.

Foot

D. K.

(2002) Voodoo and apocalyptic demography—Conceptual and methodological issues. Canadian Journal on Aging 22(1): 147–151.

20.

Fowler

(2005) Collective memory and forgetting. Components for a study of obituaries. Theory, Culture & Society 22(6): 53–72.

21.

Fowler

(2007) The obituary as collective memory, New York, NY: Routledge.

22.

Gabler, N. (2001). Toward a new definition of celebrity. Retrieved from The Norman Lear Center, Annenberg School of Communication, University of Southern California website: https://learcenter.org/pdf/Gabler.pdf.

23.

Hendricks

C. D.

(1973) Defining the situation: Reflection of life styles in funeral eulogies. OMEGA – Journal of Death and Dying 4(1): 57–63.

24.

Heynderickx

P. C.

Dieltjens

S. M.

(2016) An analysis of obituaries in staff magazines. Death Studies 40(1): 11–21.

25.

Kastenbaum

Peyton

Kastenbaum

(1977) Sex discrimination after death. OMEGA – Journal of Death and Dying 7(4): 351–359.

26.

Kurzman, C., Anderson, C., Key, C., Lee, Y. O., Moloney, M., Silver, A., & VanRyn, M. W. (2007). Celebrity status. Sociological Theory, 25(4), 347–367.

27.

Laertius

(1959) Lives of eminent philosophers Vol. I, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

28.

Langer

(1998) Tabloid television: Popular journalism and the “other news.”, Abingdon, England: Routledge.

29.

Leonard

L. G.

Toller

(2012) Speaking ill of the dead: Anonymity and communication about suicide on MyDeathSpace.com. Communication Studies 63(4): 387–404.

30.

Maddrell

Sidaway

J. D.

(2010) Introduction: Bringing a spatial lens to death, dying, mourning and remembrance. In: Maddrell

Sidaway

J. D.

(eds) Deathscapes: Spaces for death, dying, mourning and remembrance, Farnham, England: Ashgate, pp. 1–16.

31.

Makey, R. (2013, April 10). Taboo on speaking ill of the dead widely ignored online after Thatcher’s death. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/10/taboo-on-speaking-ill-of-the-dead-widely-ignored-online-after-thatchers-death/.

32.

Moremen

R. D.

Cradduck

(1999) “How will you remember me after you die?” Gender discrimination after death twenty years later. OMEGA – Journal of Death and Dying 38(4): 241–254.

33.

“Nu avem nicio sursă de venit.” Soţia lui Vadim, probleme cu banii după moartea lui Vadim. Ce l-a rugat pe Becali [“We have no source of income.” Vadim’s wife, financial problems after Vadim’s death. What did she ask Becali?]. (2014, September 16). Libertatea. Retrieved from http://www.libertatea.ro/ultima-ora/nu-avem-nicio-sursa-de-venit-sotia-lui-vadim-probleme-cu-banii-dupa-moartea-lui-vadim-ce-l-a-rugat-pe-becali-11020.

34.

Plutarch (1959). Plutarch’s lives (Vol. I, T. E. Page, Ed.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

35.

Popescu, C. T. (2013, January 3). Moartea domnului Nicolaescu [The death of mister Nicolaescu]. Gândul. Retrieved from http://www.gandul.info/puterea-gandului/moartea-domnului-nicolaescu-10426080.

36.

Radu Banciu, afirmaţii şocante după moartea lui Corneliu Vadim Tudor. “În politică, el nu trebuia să existe. În rest, ce a făcut în presă … este doar maculatură” [Radu Banciu, shocking assertions after Corneliu Vadim Tudor’s death. “In politics, he shouldn’t have existed. Otherwise, what he did in the press … is just wastepaper]. (2014, September 15). Gândul. Retrieved from http://www.gandul.info/radu-banciu-afirmatii-socante-dupa-moartea-lui-corneliu-vadim-tudor-in-politica-el-nu-trebuia-sa-existe-in-rest-ce-a-facut-in-presa-este-doar-maculatura-14712797.html.

37.

Rojek

(2001) Celebrity, London, England: Reaktion Books.

38.

Rowe

(2011) Obituary for the newspaper? Tracking the tabloid. Journalism 12(4): 449–466.

39.

Rusu

M. S.

(2017) The posthumous condition of gossip: Death and its reputational benediction. Journal of Comparative Research in Anthropology and Sociology 8(1): 17–42.

40.

Starck

(2006) Life after death: The art of the obituary, Melbourne, VIC: Melbourne University Press.

41.

Turner

(2012) Understanding celebrity, 2nd ed. London, England: Sage.

42.

Verdery

(2013) Secrets and truth. Ethnography in the archive of Romania’s secret police, Budapest, Hungary: Central European University Press.