Can Intangible Investment Explain the UK Productivity Puzzle?

Abstract

This paper investigates whether intangibles might explain the UK productivity puzzle. We note that since the recession: (a) firms have upskilled faster than before; (b) intangible investment in R&D and software has risen whereas tangible investment has fallen; and (c) intangible and telecoms equipment investment slowed in advance of the recession. We have therefore tested to see if: (a) what looks like labour hoarding is actually firms keeping workers who are employed in creating intangible assets; and (b) the current slowdown in TFP growth is due to the spillover effects of the past slowdown in R&D and telecoms equipment investment. Our main findings are: (a) measured market sector real value added growth since the start of 2008 is understated by 1.6 per cent due to the omission of intangibles; and (b) 0.75 per cent per annum of the TFP growth slowdown can be accounted for by the slowdown in intangible and telecoms investment in the early 2000s. Taken together intangible investment can therefore account for around 5 percentage points of the 16 per cent productivity puzzle.

Keywords

Intangible investment productivity

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acheson

(2011), ‘Quality-adjusted labour input: new quarterly estimates for 1993 to 2009 and annual estimates from 1970’, Economic and Labour Market Review, April, available at www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/icp/quality-adjusted-labour-input-experimental-/new-quarterly-estimates-for-1993-to-2009-and-annual-estimates-from-1970/index.html.

Acheson

Franklin

(2012), ‘Quality-adjusted labour input: estimates to 2010’, available at www.ons.gov.uk/ons/dcp171766_266826.pdf.

Adams

J.D.

, Black

G.C.

, Clemmons

J.R.

Stephan

P.E.

(2005), ‘Scientific teams and institutional collaborations: evidence from U.S. universities, 1981–1999’, Research Policy, 34, 3, pp. 259–85.

Basu

, Fernald

J.G.

Kimball

M.S.

(2006), ‘Are technology improvements contractionary?’, The American Economic Review, 96, 5, December, pp. 1418–48.

Broadbent

(2012), ‘Productivity and the allocation of resources’, speech given at Durham Business School, available at: www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/speeches/2012/speech599.pdf.

Corrado

C.A.

(2010), ‘Communication capital, Metcalfe's Law, and U.S. productivity growth’, paper prepared for the conference, Cornucopia Quantified, May 21–22.

Corrado

, Hulten

Sichel

(2005), ‘Measuring capital and technology: an expanded framework’, in Corrado

, Haltiwanger

and Sichel

(eds), Measuring Capital in the New Economy, National Bureau of Economic Research Studies in Income and Wealth, 65, pp. 11–45, The University of Chicago Press.

Dale

(2011), ‘Productivity and monetary policy’, speech given at the South Tyneside Manufacturing Forum, available at: www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/speeches/2011/speech519.pdf.

Ding

, Levin

, Stephan

Winkler

(2010), ‘The impact of information technology on scientists’ productivity, quality and collaboration patterns’, Management Science, 56, 9, pp. 1439–61.

10.

Disney

, Jin

Miller

(2013), ‘The productivity puzzles’, in The IFS Green Budget 2013.

11.

Fernald

(2010), ‘A quarterly, utilization-adjusted series on total factor productivity’, FRBSF Working Paper.

12.

Disney

, Jin

Miller

(2012), ‘Productivity and potential output before, during, and after the Great Recession’, Working Paper Series 2012–18, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco.

13.

Goodridge

, Haskel

Wallis

(2012a), ‘UK innovation index: productivity and growth in UK Industries’, Nesta Working Paper 12/09, available at www.nesta.org.uk/publications/working_papers/assets/features/uk_innovation_index_productivity_and_growth_in_uk_industries.

14.

Goodridge

, Haskel

Wallis

(2012b), ‘Spillovers from R&D and other intangible investment: evidence from UK industries.

15.

Goodridge

, Haskel

Wallis

(2013), ‘The contribution of the internet and telecommunications capital to UK market sector growth, forthcoming and available on request.

16.

Griliches

(1973), ‘Research expenditures and growth accounting’, in Williams

(ed.), Science and Technology in Economic Growth, Cambridge, New York, Macmillan.

17.

Hughes

Saleheen

(2012), ‘UK labour productivity since the onset of the crisis – an international and historical perspective’, available at www.voxeu.org/article/labour-productivity-and-global-crisis-historical-perspective.

18.

Martin

Rowthorn

(2012), ‘Is the British economy supply constrained? A renewed critique of productivity pessimism’, available at www.cbr.cam.ac.uk/pdf/BM_Report3.pdf.

19.

ONS (2012a), ‘The productivity conundrum, interpreting the recent behaviour of the economy’, available at www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/elmr/the-productivity-conundrum/interpreting-the-recent-behaviour-of-the-economy/art-interpreting-the-recent-behaviour-of-the-economy.html.

20.

ONS (2012b), ‘The productivity conundrum, explanations and preliminary analysis’, available at www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/elmr/the-productivity-conundrum/explanations-and-preliminary-analysis/art-explanations-and-preliminary-analysis.html.

21.

ONS (2013), ‘Micro-data perspectives on the UK productivity conundrum’, available at www.ons.gov.uk/ons/rel/icp/microdata-perspectives-on-the-uk-productivity-conundrum/january-2013/micro-data-perspectives-on-the-uk-productivity-conundrum.html.

22.

Weale

(2012), ‘The labour market, productivity and inflation’, speech given at the Manchester Economics Seminar, Manchester, available at: www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/speeches/2012/speech621.pdf.