This paper examines trends in the instability of personal incomes in Britain in
terms of changes in the transitory variance and in volatility, measures that
have received much recent attention in research about the USA. It is shown that,
although US measures have trended upwards over the past two decades, there is no
such trend in Britain between the early-1990s and the mid-2000s. Explanations
for these differences are discussed.
AbowdJ.CardD.
(1989), ‘On the covariance structure of
earnings and hours changes’,
Econometrica, 57, pp.
411–45.
2.
BakerM.
(1997), ‘Growth-rate heterogeneity and
the covariance structure of life-cycle earnings’,
Journal of Labor Economics, 15, pp.
338–75.
3.
BakerM.SolonG.
(2003), ‘Earnings dynamics and inequality
among Canadian men, 1976–1992: evidence from longitudinal income tax
records’, Journal of Labor
Economics, 21, pp.
289–321.
4.
BartelsC.BönkeT.
(2010), ‘German male income volatility 1984 to
2008: trends in permanent and transitory income components and the role of
the welfare state’, unpublished paper, Berlin, Department of
Economics, Free University.
5.
BeachC.M.FinnieR.GrayD.
(2010), ‘Long-run inequality and
short-run instability of men's and women's earnings in
Canada’, Review of Income and
Wealth, 56, pp.
572–96.
6.
BiewenM.
(2005), ‘The covariance structure of East
and West German incomes and its implications for the persistence of poverty
and inequality’, German Economic
Review, 6, pp.
445–69.
7.
BlundellR.EtheridgeB.
(2010), ‘Consumption, income and earnings
inequality in Britain’, Review of Economic
Dynamics, 13, pp.
76–102.
8.
ChamberlainG.HiranoK.
(1999), ‘Predictive distributions based
on longitudinal earnings data’, Annales
d'Économie et de Statistique, 55/56,
pp. 211–42.
9.
CunhaF.HeckmanJ.NavarroS.
(2005), ‘Separating uncertainty from
heterogeneity in life cycle earnings’, Oxford
Economic Papers, 57, pp.
191–261.
DevicientiF.
(2011), ‘Estimating poverty persistence
in Britain’, Empirical Economics,
40, pp.
657–86.
14.
DickensR.
(2000), ‘The evolution of individual male
earnings in Great Britain: 1975–95’,
Economic Journal, 110, pp.
27–49.
15.
DuncanG.J.
(1983), ‘The implications of changing
family composition for the dynamic analysis of family economic
wellbeing’, In AtkinsonA.B.CowellF.A.
(eds), Panel Data on Incomes, Occasional Paper No. 2,
London, ICERD, London School
of Economics, pp.
203–39.
GottschalkP.MoffittR.A.
(1994), ‘The growth of earnings
instability in the U.S. labor market’,
Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,
2–1994, pp.
217–72.
21.
GottschalkP.MoffittR.A.
(2009), ‘The rising instability of U.S.
earnings’, Journal of Economic
Perspectives, 23, pp.
3–24.
22.
GuvenenF.
(2009), ‘An empirical investigation of
labor income processes’, Review of Economic
Dynamics, 12, pp.
58–79.
23.
HackerJ.S.
(2004), ‘Privatizing risk without
privatizing the welfare state: the hidden politics of social policy
retrenchment in the United States’, American
Political Science Review, 98, pp.
243–60.
24.
HackerJ.S.
(2008), The Great Risk Shift (revised
and expanded edition). Oxford,
Oxford University Press.
25.
HackerJ.S.JacobsE.
(2008), ‘The rising instability of American
family incomes, 1969–2004. Evidence from the Panel Study of Income
Dynamics’, Briefing Paper #213, Washington DC,
Economic Policy Institute, http://www.epi.org/content.cfm/bp213.
26.
HaiderS.J.
(2001), ‘Earnings instability and
earnings inequality of males in the United States:
1967–1991’, Journal of Labor
Economics, 19, pp.
799–836.
27.
HauseJ.C.
(1980), ‘The fine structure of earnings
and the on-the-job training hypothesis’,
Econometrica, 48, pp.
1013–29.
28.
House of Commons Treasury Committee
(2006), The Administration of Tax Credits.
Sixth Report of Session 2005–06, Volume 1 (Report, together with formal
minutes), HC 811–1, London, The Stationery Office.
29.
JenkinsS.P.
(2011), Changing Fortunes: Income Mobility and Poverty
Dynamics in Britain, Oxford,
Oxford University Press.
30.
KalwijA.S.AlessieR.
(2007), ‘Permanent and transitory wages
of British men,1975–2001: year, age and cohort
effects’, Journal of Applied
Econometrics, 22, pp.
1063–93.
31.
KeysB.J.
(2008), ‘Trends in income and consumption
volatility, 1970–2000’, In JolliffeD.ZiliakJ.
(eds), Income Volatility and Food Assistance in the United
States, Kalamazoo MI,
Upjohn Institute for Employment Research,
pp. 11–34.
32.
LillardL.WeissY.
(1979), ‘Components of variation in panel
earnings data: American scientists,
1960–1970’, Econometrica,
47, pp.
437–54.
33.
LillardL.WillisR.
(1978), ‘Dynamic aspects of earnings
mobility’, Econometrica,
46, pp.
985–1012.
34.
MaCurdyT.
(1982), ‘The use of time series processes
to model the error structure of earnings in a longitudinal data
analysis’, Journal of Econometrics,
18, pp.
83–114.
35.
MeghirC.PistaferriL.
(2004), ‘Income variance dynamics and
heterogeneity’, Econometrica,
72, pp.
1–32.
36.
MeghirC.PistaferriL.
(2010), ‘Earnings, consumption and lifecycle
choices’, Working Paper 15914, Cambridge MA, National Bureau
of Economic Research, http://www.nber.org/papers/w15914.
37.
MoffittR.A.GottschalkP.
(2002), ‘Trends in the transitory
variance of earnings in the United States’,
Economic Journal, 112, pp.
C68–73
38.
MoffittR.A.GottschalkP.
(2008a), ‘Trends in the transitory variance of
male earnings in the U.S., 1991–2003: preliminary evidence from LEHD
data’, Working Paper 696, Boston MA, Economics Department,
Boston College, http://fmwww.bc.edu/ec-p/wp696.pdf.
39.
MoffittR.A.GottschalkP.
(2008b), ‘Trends in the transitory variance of
male earnings in the U.S., 1970–2004’, Working Paper
697, Boston MA, Economics Department, Boston College, http://fmwww.bc.edu/EC-P/WP697.pdf.
40.
MoffittR.A.GottschalkP.
(2011), ‘Trends in the covariance
structure of earnings in the U.S.: 1969–1987’
(‘Rediscovered Classics’ section reproduction of Johns Hopkins
University working paper from 1995), Journal of
Economic Inequality, 9, pp.
439–59.
41.
RamosX.
(2003), ‘The covariance structure of
earnings in Britain, 1991–1999’,
Economica, 70, pp.
353–74.
42.
ShinD.SolonG.
(2011), ‘Trends in men's earnings
volatility: what does the Panel Study of Income Dynamics
show?’, Journal of Public Economics,
95, pp.
973–82.
43.
StevensA.H.
(1999), ‘Climbing out of poverty, falling
back in: measuring the persistence of poverty over multiple
spells’, Journal of Human Resources,
34, pp.
557–88.
44.
WalkerR.
(2005), Social Security and Welfare: Concepts and
Comparisons, Milton Keynes,
Open University
Press/McGraw-Hill.
