Abstract
The restraint of patients is one of the important aspects of the regime in psychiatric hospitals. It has been an issue in hospitals over the years because it interferes with the personal freedom of patients. Most recently it was one of the matters raised in X NHS Foundation Trust v RH [2024] EWCOP 150. This paper aims to add to the awareness of it by looking at what it means, the forms it may take and the justifications for it. It is concluded that restraint of patients is controversial but reasonable and necessary at times in the interests of the patient’s own health/safety or that of others.
Keywords
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
X NHS Foundation Trust v RH
([2024 ] EWCOP 150).
2.Department of Health (2015 ) Mental Health Act 1983 Code of Practice.
3.Department for Constitutional Affairs (2007 ) Mental Capacity Act 2005 Code of Practice.
4.King’s College Hospital NHS Foundation Trust v TTN [2024 ] EWCOP 1.
5.
A Hospital NHS Foundation Trust v Ms KL and Mrs KLS
[2023 ] EWCOP 59.
6.
Robinson
PH
(1982 ) Criminal Law Defenses: A Systematic Analysis, 82 Colum. L. Rev. 199: 229–232.
7.
Dressier
J
(1984 ) New Thoughts About the Concept of Justification in the Criminal Law: A Critique of Fletcher's Thinking and Rethinking, 32 UCLA L. Rev. 61: 66.
8.
Lewis-Ranwell v G4S Ltd. & Ors
. [2024 ] EWCA Civ 138.
9.
R v Rose
(1884 ) 15 Cox 540.
10.
R v Duffy
[1967 ] 1 QB 63.
11.
R v Palmer
[1971 ] AC 814.
12.
Dudley v Stephens
(1884 ) 14 QBD 273.
13.
Southwark London Borough Council v Williams
[1971 ] Ch 734.
14.
Re F (Mental patient sterilisation)
[1990 ] 2 AC 1.
15.
Re A
[2001 ] Fam 149.
16.
Pountney v Griffiths
([1976 ] AC 314; [1975] 3 WLR 140; [1975] 2 All ER 881.
17.
R v MHAC
, ex p. Smith (Times , 18-5-98).
18.
R v Broadmoor Special Hospital Authority
, ex parte S (The Times , 17 February 1998 ).