We present the case of a 60-year-old male, with a long history of epilepsy, who was discovered submerged and unconscious in a small thermal whirlpool bath. The circumstances were forensically reviewed to include examination of clinical data and an autopsy with toxicological analysis. The conclusion was that “warm” hydro-therapy had contributed more than “hot” mud-therapy to the onset of epilepsy which led to accidental drowning, notwithstanding the deceased’s treatment with the long-lasting, poly-drug antiepileptic therapy. Further, we analysed the Italian medical indications of wellness centres for patients with epilepsy or other diseases.
RyanCADowlingG.Drowning deaths in people with epilepsy. Can Med Assoc J1993;
148: 781--784.
2.
TomsonTWalczakTSillanpaaM, et al.
Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy: a review of incidence and risk factors. Epilepsia2005;
46: 54–61.
3.
NashefL.Sudden unexpected death in epilepsy: terminology and definitions. Epilepsia1997; 38: S6--8.
4.
AnnegersJF.United States perspective on definitions and classifications.Epilepsia1997;
38: S9–S12.
5.
SatishchandraPShivaramakrishanaALaiaperumalVG, et al.
Hot-water epilepsy: a variant of reflex epilepsy in southern India.Epilepsia1988;
29: 52–56.
6.
SavinthaMRKrishnamurthyBAshokDA, et al.Self-abortion of attacks in patients with hot water epilepsy. Indian Pediatr2007;
44: 295--298.
7.
BebekNGürsesCGokyigitA, et al.
Hot water epilepsy: clinical and electrophysiologic findings based on 21 cases. Epilepsia2001;
42: 1180–1184.
8.
PatelMSatishchandraPAravindaH, et al.
Hot water epilepsy: phenotype and single photon emission computed tomography observations.Ann Indian Acad Neurol2014;
17: 470–472.
9.
YalçinADToydemirHEFortaH.Hot water epilepsy: clinical and electroencephalographic features of 25 cases. Epilepsy Behav2006; 9: 89–94.
10.
IoosCFohlenMVilleneuveN, et al.
Hot water epilepsy: a benign and unrecognized form.J Child Neurol2000;
15: 125–128.
11.
SatishchandraPSinhaS.Hot-water epilepsy: from bench to bedside.Ann Indian Acad Neurol2013;
16: 137–143.
12.
RajathPSrinivasaVBasavanthappaSP, et al.
Hot water epilepsy: a form of reflex epilepsy – from infancy to adolescence.J Neurosci Rural Pract2015;
6: 607–609.
13.
AppavuBFoxJLittleR, et al.
Seizures induced by exiting water: a unique form of reflex epilepsy.Neurologist2017;
22: 196–198.
14.
SzymonowiczWMeloffKL.Hot water epilepsy.Can J Neurol Sci1978;
5: 247–251.
15.
KowacsPAMarchioroIJMda SilvaEBJr, et al.
“Hot-water epilepsy”, “warm-water epilepsy”, or bathing epilepsy? Report of three cases and considerations regarding an old theme. Arq Neuropsiquiatr2005;
63: 399–401.
16.
FurterMGermerottTThaliMJ.Spa-drain entrapment complicated by suspicions of nonaccidental trauma and epilepsy onset.Pediatrics2011;
128: e1008–e1012.
17.
Fernè F, Karagulle Z, Solimene U, et al. FEMTEC -- FoRST joint project with cooperation of ISMH and WHO. Hydroglobe-definition of a global framework for hydrotherapy. Essentials from the final report, 2013.
18.
SimplicioSGuglielmiRCastaldoS, et al.Rischi e benefici nell’indirizzo delle cure termali per il paziente cardiopatico. Giornale Italiano di cardiologia Pratica, Aprile-Giugno 2013.
19.
Coordinamento Generale Medico-legale INPS. Avvio dell’attività di accertamento ai fini della concessione di cure balneo termali in regime di assicurazione generale obbligatoria. Messaggio n. 1274 del 21 March 2017.
