Recent instruction from the Department of Health requires the institution of an independent inquiry into all cases of homicide committed by those who have been in contact with the psychiatric services. The background to this instruction is explored briefly within the context of more general concerns about violence and homicide, and the advantages and disadvantages of such inquiries are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ApplebyL.ShawJ.AmosT. (1997) National Confidential Inquiry into Suicide and Homicide by People with Mental Illness. Br. J. Psychiat.170, 101–2.
2.
Avon Health Authority (1997) Summary of the Report of the Inquiry into the Care and Treatment of Ms B. Avon Health Authority, November, p. 37.
3.
Association of Chief Officers of Probation (1994) Guidance on Management of Risk and Public Protection. London, ACOP.
4.
Blom-CooperL. (1993) Public inquiries. In: FreemanM.HappleB. (eds) Current Legal Problems. Oxford, Oxford University Press, p. 20.
5.
Blom-CooperL.HallyH.MurphyE. (1995) The Falling Shadow: One Patient's Mental Health Care: 1978–1993. London, Duckworth.
6.
Blom-CooperL.GroundsA.GuinanP.ParkerA.TaylorM. (1996) The Case of Jason Mitchell: Report of the Independent Panel of Inquiry. London, Duckworth.
7.
BottomsA. (1995) The philosophy of punishment and sentencing. In: ClarksonC.MorganR. (eds) The Politics of Sentencing Reform. Oxford, Clarendon Press.
8.
BrowneK.D. (1993) Violence in the family and its links to child abuse. Ballière's Clinical Paediatrics.
9.
ClothierC. (1996) Ruminations on inquiries. In: PeayJ. (ed.) Inquiries After Homicide. London, Duckworth.
10.
CohenS. (1972) Folk Devils and Moral Panics. London, McGibbon and Kee.
11.
CoidJ. (1994) The Christopher Clunis Inquiry. Psychiat. Bull.18, 449–52.
12.
CrawfordL.DevauxM.FerrisR.HaywardP. (1997) The Report into the Care and Treatment of Martin Mursell. London, Camden and Islington Health Authority.
13.
Department of Health (National Health Service Executive) (1994a) Guidance on the Discharge of Mentally Disordered People and Their Care in the Community. HSG/94/27, London.
14.
Department of Health (National Health Service Executive (1994b) Guidelines to Health and Social Services Authorities. HSG/94/27, London.
15.
Department of Health (1996) The Health of the Nation: Building Bridges. February, London, Ch.5.
16.
DixonK.GulliverA.ReedJ.RhysM. (1997) Report of the Inquiry Team following a Homicide by a Service User in April 1996. Bromley Health Authority, Southeast London Probation Service and London Borough of Bromley (Social Services and Housing).
17.
DyerJ.A.T. (1998) Treatment in the community in the absence of consent. Psych. Bull.22, 73–6.
18.
EastmanN. (1996) Inquiry into homicides by psychiatric patients: systematic audit should replace mandatory inquiriesBMJ.313, 1069–71.
19.
FaulknerD. (1997) Interview with J. O'Sullivan. The Independent 12 March, p. 26.
20.
FeeleyM.SimonJ. (1992) The new penology: notes on the emerging strategy of corrections and its implications. Criminology30, 449–75.
21.
GreenwellJ.ProcterA.JonesA. (1997) Report of the Inquiry into the Treatment and Care of Gilbert Kopernik-Steckel. Croydon Health Authority, Surrey.
22.
GroundsA. (1997) Commentary on ‘Inquiries: who needs them?’Psychiat. Bull.21, 134–5.
23.
Home Office, Department of Health and Welsh Office (1995) National Standards for the Supervision of Offenders in the Community. London, Home Office.
24.
Home Office (1996) Criminal Statistics: England and Wales. Cm. 3421. London, HMSO, p. 83.
25.
KershawC.RenshawG. (1996) Statistics of Mentally Disordered Offenders: England and Wales. Home Office Statistical Bulletin 20/96. 2.10.96. London, Home Office Research and Statistics Directorate, pp. 11, 18, 23.
26.
LinghamR.CandyJ.BrayJ. (1996) Report of the Inquiry into the Care and Treatment of Raymond Sinclair. West Kent Health Authority and Kent County Council Social Services.
27.
MastersB. (1985) Killing for Company: The Case of Dennis Nilsen. London, Cape.
28.
MastersB. (1993) The Shrine of Jeffrey Dahmer. London, Hodder and Stoughton.
29.
MastersB. (1996) ‘She Must Have Known’: The Trial of Rosemary West. London, Doubleday.
30.
MelzerD. (1997) Public Health, Epidemiology and Forensic Psychiatry. Unpublished paper presented to Cropwood Conference, Institute of Criminology, Cambridge University, 21 March.
31.
MuidjenM. (1997) Inquiries: who needs them?Psychiat. Bull.21, 132–3.
32.
PeayJ. (1996) (ed.) Inquiries After Homicide. London, Duckworth.
33.
PetchE.BradleyC. (1997) Learning the lessons from homicide inquiries: adding insult to injury. J. Forens. Psychiat.8, 161–84.
34.
PrinsH. (1995a) Offenders, Deviants or Patients? (2nd edn). London, Routledge.
35.
PrinsH. (1995b) ‘I've got a little list’ (Koko: Mikado). But is it any use? Comments on the forensic aspects of ‘supervision registers’ for the mentally ill. Med. Sci. Law35, 218–24.
36.
PrinsH. (1996a) Risk assessment and management in criminal justice and psychiatry. J. Forens. Psychiat.7, 42–62.
37.
PrinsH. (1996b) Mental Health Review Tribunals: developing good practice. Tribunals3, 5–6.
PrinsH.Backer-HoistT.FrancisE.KeitchI. (1993) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into the Death in Broadmoor Hospital of Orville Blackwood and A Review of the Deaths of Two Other Afro-Caribbean Patients: Big, Black and Dangerous?London, Special Hospitals Service Authority.
40.
RederP.DuncanS. (1996) Reflections on child abuse inquiries. In: PeayJ. (ed.) Inquiries After Homicide. London, Duckworth.
41.
RitchieJ.H.DickD.LinghamR. (1994) Report of the Inquiry into the Care of Christopher Clunis. London, HMSO.
42.
RockP. (1996) The inquiry and victims' families. In: PeayJ. (ed.) Inquiries After Homicide. London, Duckworth.
43.
SheppardD. (1996) Learning the Lessons (2nd edn). London, Zito Trust.
44.
SoothillK. (1993) The serial killer industry. J. For. Psychiat.4, 341–54.
45.
Steering Committee of the Confidential Inquiry into Homicides and Suicides by Mentally Ill People. (1994) Preliminary Report. London, Royal College of Psychiatrists.
46.
Steering Committee of the Confidential Inquiry into Homicides and Suicides by Mentally Ill People. (1996) Final Report. London, Royal College of Psychiatrists.
47.
TidmarshD. (1997) Psychiatric risk, safety cultures and homicide inquiries. J. Forens. Psychiat.8, 138–51.
48.
WansellG. (1996) An Evil Love: The Life of Frederick West. London, Headline Books.
49.
WoodJ.AshmanM.DaviesCLloydH.LockettK. (1996) Report of the Inquiry into the Care of Anthony Smith. Southern Derbyshire Health Authority and Derbyshire County Council.
