The Criminal Procedure (Insanity and Unfitness to Plead) Act,1991

Abstract

Procedures relating to Insanity and Fitness to Plead are reviewed with special emphasis on the problems encountered with previous legislation.

The introduction of the new Criminal Procedure (Insanity and Unfitness to Plead) Act 1991, on 1 January 1992, offered greater discretion in the disposal of these defendants, but fell short of many of the recommendations made by those advocating reform. As yet, too few cases have passed through the courts to highlight particular deficiencies in the unreformed parts of the Act, but the benefits are already apparent. Finally, some of the potential pitfalls of supervision and treatment orders and other disposals are discussed and an insanity case, dealt with under the new legislation, is presented.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Emmins

(1986) Unfitness to plead: thoughts prompted by Glenn Pearson's case. Crim. Law. Rev. 604–18.

Grubin

D. H.

(1991) Regaining fitness: patients found unfit to plead who return for trial. J. For. Psychiat. 2, 139–51.

Home Office and DHSS Report of the Committee on Mentally Abnormal Offenders (the Butler Report). Cmnd. 6244. London, HMSO.

Larkin

E. P.

Collins

P. J.

(1989) Fitness to plead and psychiatric reports. Med. Sci. Law, 29, 26–32.

MacKay

R. D.

(1990a) Fact and fiction about the insanity defence. Crim. Law. Rev. 247–55.

MacKay

R. D.

(1990b) Insanity and fitness to stand trial in Canada and England: A comparative study. J. For. Psychiat. 1, 277–303.

Savage

H. S.

(1981) The relevance of the fitness to stand trial: provisions of persons with mental handicap. Can. Bar Rev. 59, 319–36.

Smith

J. C.

Hogan

(1988) Criminal Law. 6th ed. London, Edinburgh, Grune.

Walker

(1968) Crime and Insanity in England. Vol. 1: The Historical Perspective. Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press.

10.

White

(1992) The Criminal Procedure (Insanity and Unfitness to Plead) Act. Crim. Law. Rev. 4–14.