This paper examines the diversion of the mentally disordered offender against a background of the treatment of the mentally disordered in general. Some myths about incarceration are explored and the proposal is made that diversion is not a new idea. Finally, caution is expressed in the espousal of diversion in an uncritical fashion.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BeanP.BingleyW.BynoeI.FaulknerA.RassabyE.RogersA. (1991) Out of Harm's Way. London, MIND.
2.
BowdenP. (1978) Men remanded in custody for medical reports: the selection for treatment. Br. J. Psychiat.32, 320–31.
3.
BowdenP. (1993) New directions for service provision: a personal view. In: WatsonW.GroundsA. (eds) The Mentally Disordered Offender in an Era of Community Care: new directions in provision. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
4.
BynoeI. (1993) The Role of Criminal Justice Agencies in the Diversion of Mentally Disordered Offenders. Briefing Paper in Mental Health Foundation Conference Pack on Diversion, Care and Justice, Blackrod, Lanes, June 1993.
5.
CarsonD. (1992) Holding the patient to account at the gate-keeping stage. Crim. Behav. and Ment. Hlth.2, 224–33.
6.
Code for Crown Prosecutors (No Date), London.
7.
CoidJ. (1991) Psychiatric profiles of difficult/disruptive prisoners. In: BottomleyK.HayW. (eds) Special Units for Difficult Prisoners. Hull, Centre for Criminology and Criminal Justice, Hull University.
8.
ChiswickD. (1990) Applied criminology. Curr. Op. in Psychiat.3, 754–7.
9.
CookeD.J. (1991) Treatment as an alternative to prosecution: offenders diverted for treatment. Br. J. Psychiat.158, 785–91.
10.
Department of Health (1992a) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Complaints About Ashworth Hospital. Parts I and II. Cmnd. 2028 I and II, (Chairman Sir Louis Blom-Cooper, QC). London, HMSO.
11.
Department of Health (1992b) Statistical Bulletin2 (7), London, HMSO.
12.
Department of Health and Home Office (1992) Review of Health and Social Services for Mentally Disordered Offenders and Others Requiring Similar Services (Chairman, Dr. John Reed). Final Summary Report. Cmnd. 2088. London, HMSO.
13.
Department of Health and Welsh Office (1993) Mental Health Act, 1983: Code of Practice. London, HMSO.
14.
Felix (1985) Life of St Guthlac, (ed. ColgraveB.) Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Quoted in Roth and Kroll. p. 100.
15.
FowlesA. (1993) The mentally abnormal offender in the era of community care. In: WatsonW.GroundsA. (eds) The Mentally Disordered Offender in an Era of Community Care: new directions in provision. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
16.
GostinL. (1985) Introduction: a policy overview. In: GostinL. (ed) Secure Provision: a review of special services for the mentally ill and mentally handicapped in England and Wales. London, Tavistock.
17.
GroundsA. (1991a) The mentally disordered in prison. The Prison Service J.81, 29–40.
18.
GroundsA. (1991b) The mentally disordered in the criminal justice process: some research and policy questions. In: HerbstK.GunnJ. (eds) The Mentally Disordered Offender. London, Mental Health Foundation and Butterworth-Heinemann.
19.
GroundsA. (1991c) The transfer of sentenced prisoners to hospital 1960–1983 — a study in one special hospital. Br. J. Criminol.31, 54–71.
20.
GroundsA. (1992) Lecture based upon an unpublished report presented to Forensic Psychiatry Section meeting of Royal College of Psychiatrists, 15 February, York.
21.
GunnJ.MadenA.SwintonM. (1991a) Treatment needs of prisoners with psychiatric disorders. BMJ303, 338–41.
22.
GunnJ.MadenA.SwintonM. (1991b) Mentally Disordered Prisoners. London, Home Office.
23.
GunnJ.RobertsonG.DellS.WayC. (1978) Psychiatric Aspects of Imprisonment. London, Academic Press.
24.
HeatheringtonT. (1989) Prosecution in The Public Interest. London, Waterlow.
25.
Home Office (1991a) AM Prison, Brixton. Report by H.M. Chief Inspector of Prisons. London, Home Office.
26.
Home Office (1991b) Custody, Care and Justice, The Way Ahead for the Prison Service in England and Wales. London, HMSO.
27.
Home Office and Department of Health (1991) Review of Health and Social Services for Mentally disordered Offenders and Others Requiring Similar Services. Reports of the Community Advisory Group and the Prison Advisory Group. London, Home Office and Department of Health.
28.
Home Office and Department of Health and Social Security (1975) Report of The Committee on Mentally Abnormal Offenders. Cmnd. 6244 (The Butler Committee). London, HMSO.
29.
JamesD.V.HamiltonL.W. (1991) The Clerkenwell Scheme — assessing efficacy and cost of a psychiatric liaison service to a Magistrates' Court. BMJ303, 282–5.
30.
JosephP. (1992) Psychiatric Assessment at the Magistrates' Court. London, Home Office and Department of Health.
31.
JosephP. L. A.PotterM. (1993) Diversion from custody (i) Psychiatric assessment at the Magistrates' Court, and (ii) Effect on hospital and prison resources. Br. J. Psychiat.162, 325–30 and 330–34.
32.
LloydM.G.BénézechM. (1991) Criminal Responsibility in the French Judicial System. J. For. Psychiat.2, 281–94.
33.
MustillM. (1991) The Mentally Disordered: a Call for Thought. London, King's Fund Centre, 2 May.
34.
NACRO (1992) Revolving Doors: report of the telethon inquiry into the relationship between mental health and criminal justice. London, National Association for the Care and Resettlement of Offenders.
35.
NACRO (1993) Mental Health Advisory Committee. Policy Paper 1. Community Care and Mentally Disturbed Offenders. London, National Association for the Care and Resettlement of Offenders.
36.
ParkerE. (1980) Mentally disordered offenders and their protection from punitive sanction. Internat. J. Law and Psychiat.3, 461–9.
37.
ParkerE. (1985) The development of secure provision. In: GostinL. (ed) Secure Provision: a review of special services for the mentally ill and mentally handicapped in England and Wales. London, Tavistock.
38.
PenroseL. S. (1939) Mental disease and crime: an outline for a study of European statistics. Br. J. Med. Psychol.18, 1–15.
39.
PrinsH. (1991) Mental abnormality and criminality: an uncertain relationship. Med. Sci. Law30, 247–58.
40.
PrinsH. (1993) The people nobody owns. In: WatsonW.GroundsA. (eds) The Mentally Disordered in an Era of Community Care: new directions in provision. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
41.
RogersA.FaulknerA. (1987) A Place of Safety. London, MIND.
42.
RollinH. (1993) A hundred years ago. Br. J. Psychiat.162, 575.
43.
RothM.KrollJ. (1986) The Reality of Mental Illness. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
44.
ScottJ. (1993) Homelessness and mental illness. Br. J. Psychiat.162, 314–24.
45.
ScottP.D. (1975) Has Psychiatry Failed in the Treatment of Offenders'?London, Institute for the Study and Treatment of Offenders.
46.
ScullA. (1984) Decarceration: community treatment and the deviant: a radical view (second edition). Cambridge, Polity Press.
47.
SmithJ.DonovanM. (1990) The prosecution of psychiatric in-patients. J. For. Psychiat.1, 379–83.
48.
SwintonM. (1991) Prisons, Hospitals and the Mentally Abnormal Offender. Cur. Op. in Psychiat.4, 661–1.
49.
TeplinL. A.PruettN. S. (1992) Police as street-corner psychiatrist: managing the mentally ill. Int. J. Law and Psychiat.15, 139–56.
50.
WoodSir John (1988) Relations with the police and the public and with overseas police and judicial authorities. In: Hall WilliamsJ. E. (ed) The Role of the Prosecutor: Report of the International Criminal Justice Seminar held at The London School of Economics and Political Science. January 1987. Aldershot, Avebury.
