Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

A one-year prospective study comparing Section 136 patients (39) and the severe Section 2 or 4 patients (29) of the Mental Health Act 1983 in a hospital with inner London catchment areas. The assessments were clinical, nurses' ratings and socio-demographic.

The results showed that clinical and nursing ratings did not differentiate the two groups. Most social/demographic data showed similar trends with both groups being disadvantaged but Section 136 patients slightly more so. The differences were smaller than anticipated, suggesting a recent shift of patients admitted under Section 2 or 4 towards a more socially disadvantaged position.

In conclusion, police did not overuse Section 136. Our comparison suggests: (a) police may underuse Section 136, and (b) Section 136 acts as a valuable ‘back-up’ for those patients who would otherwise fail to benefit from the Mental Health Act.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bouras

Trauer

Watson

J. P.

(1982) Ward environment and disturbed behaviour Psych. Med. 12, 809–19.

Dunn

Fahy

(1987) Section 136 and the police. Bull. Royal Coll. Psychiat. 11, 224–5.

George

H. R.

(1972) A study of police admissions to psychiatric hospitals. MD Thesis: University of London.

Gostin

(1975) A Human Condition: Volume 1: Special report published by MIND (National Association for Mental Health).

Ineichen

Harrison

Morgan

H. G.

(1984) Psychiatric hospital admissions in Bristol: 1. geographical and ethnic factors. Br. J. Psychiat. 145, 600–11.

Kelleher

M. J.

Copeland

J. R. M.

(1972) Compulsory psychiatric admissions by the police: a study of the use of Section 136. Med. Sci. Law. 12, 220–4.

Kent

D. A.

(1972) Police admissions to two English hospitals. Acta Psychiat. Scand. 48, 1, 78–83.

Mental Health Act of England and Wales (1959)

Mental Health Act of England and Wales (1983)

10.

Overall

J. E.

Gorham Dr (1962) The Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale. Psychological Reports 10, 799–812

11.

Rassaby

Rogers

(1987) Psychiatric referrals from the police: variations in disposal at different places of safety. Bull. Royal Coll. Psychiat. Vol II: 78–81.

12.

Rollin

H. L.

(1965) Unprosecuted mental abnormal offenders. BMJ, I, 831–5.

13.

Rollin

H. R.

(1969) The Mentally Abnormal offender and the Law. Pergamon Press: Oxford.

14.

Sims

A. C. P.

Symonds

R. L.

(1975) Psychiatric referrals from the police. Br. J. Psychiat. 127, 171–8.

15.

Szmukler

G. I.

Bird

A. S.

Button

E. J.

(1981) Compulsory admissions in a London borough: social and clinical features and a follow up. Psych. Med. 11, 617–36.

16.

Webster

Dean

Kessel

(1987) Effect of the 1983 Mental Health Act on the management of psychiatric patients. BMJ. 295, 1529–32.

17.

World Health Organisation (1978) Mental Disorders. Glossary and guide to their classification in accordance with the ninth revision of the international classification of diseases. WHO, Geneva.

Police May Underuse Section 136

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References