The presence of 47, XYY genotype has stimulated much debate as to whether these men are more likely to indulge in criminal and violent behaviour than 46, XY males. Two cases of XYY men who had committed murder are described, and the current literature regarding criminality and psychopathology in XYY males is reviewed. It is important that Forensic Psychiatrists with XYY patients are aware of these issues as the link between XYY genotype and criminality may be raised in court.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
ClarkG. R.TelferM. A.BakerD.RosenM., (1970) Sex Chromosomes, Crime and Psychosis. Am. J. Psych.126, 1659–63.
2.
DorusE.DorusW.TelferM. A.LitwinS.RichardsonC., (1976) Height and Personality Characteristics of 47, XYY Males in a Sample of Tall Non-Institutionalised males. Br. J. Psych.129, 564–73.
3.
HookE. B. (1973) Behavioural Implications of the Human XYY Genotype. Science179, 139–50.
4.
HunterH. (1977) XYY Males. Br. J. Psych.131, 468—77.
5.
NielsenJ.ChristiansenA. L. (1974) Thirty Five Males with Double Y Chromosome. Psychol. Med.4, 28–37.
6.
NoelB.DupontJ. P.RevilD.DussuyerI.QuackB. (1974) the XYY syndrome: reality or myth?Clin. Gen.5, 387–94.
7.
SandbergA. A.KoepfG. P.IsaharaT.HauschkaT. S. (1961) An XYY human male. Lancet2, 488–9.
8.
SchiaviR. C.TheilgaardA.OwenD. R.WhiteD. (1984) Sex chromosome anomalies, hormones and aggressivity. Arch. Gen. Psychiat.4193–9.
9.
TheilgaardA. (1983) Aggression and the XYY personality. Int. J. Law and Psychiat.6, 413–21.
10.
WitkinH. A.MednickS. A.SchulsingerF.BakkestromE.ChristiansenK. O.GoodenoughD. R.HirschornK.LundsteenC.OwenD. R.PhilipJ.RubinD. B.StockingM. (1976) Criminality in XYY and XXY men. Science193, 547–55.
