The issue of diminishment of responsibility is discussed by a ‘layman’ both generally and more specifically in relation to the Sutcliffe case. Legal, psychiatric and social aspects are considered in the context of the present constraints of the law as are some proposals for reform.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BlairD. (1971) Life Sentence then Suicide. Med. Sci. Law 11, 162–179.
2.
BluglassR. (1980) Psychiatry, the Law and the Offender—Present Dilemmas and Future Prospects. Seventh Denis Carroll Memorial Lecture, Croydon, Institute for the Study and Treatment of Delinquency, (page 10).
3.
JudgeB. Clapham (1981) Introducing Psychological Evidence in the Courts: Impediments and Opportunities, In: Lloyd-Bostock S. Psychology in Legal Contexts: Applications and Limitations. London, MacMillan.
4.
ClarkeM. J. (1975) The Impact of Social Science on Conceptions of Responsibility. Br. J. Law and Society2, 32–44.
5.
Criminal Law Revision Committee (1980) Offences Against the Person. Cmnd 7844, London, HMSO.
6.
FaulkM. (1976) A Psychiatric Study of Men Serving Sentences in Winchester Prison. Med. Sci. Law16, 244–251.
7.
FitzgeraldE. (1981) Is the System Fair to the Likes of Peter Sutcliffe? Guardian, 25.5.81.
8.
FoucaultM. (1978) About the Concept of the ‘Dangerous Individual’ in 19th Century Legal Psychiatry. Int. J. Law and Psychiat. 1, 1–18.
9.
GlueckB. (1918) A Study of 608 Admissions to Sing Sing Prison. Mental Hygiene2, 85–151.
10.
WilliamsJ. E. Hall (1980) Legal Views of Psychiatric Evidence. Med. Sci. Law20, 276–282.
11.
HamiltonJ. R. (1981) Diminished Responsibility. Br. J. Psychiat.138, 434–436.
12.
HawardL. R. C. (1981) Forensic Psychology. London, Batsford (Chapters 18, 19 and 20).
13.
Home Office and DHSS (1975) Report of the Committee on Mentally Abnormal Offenders (Butler Committee). Cmnd. 6244. London, HMSO.
14.
Home Office and DHSS (1975) Butler Committee. Op. Cit. p. 243.
15.
Home Office (1979) Criminal Statistics for England and Wales. 1978. Cmnd. 7670, London, HMSO.
16.
JacobsF. G. (1971) Criminal Responsibility. London, Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
17.
KahnJ. H. (1971) Uses and Abuses of Child Psychiatry: Problems of Diagnosis and Treatment of Psychiatric Disorder. Br. J. Med. Psychol.44, 229–238.
18.
KloekJ. (1969) Schizophrenia and Delinquency: The Inadequacy of our Conceptual Framework, In: de RueckA. V. S.PorterR. (Eds) The Mentally Abnormal Offender. London, J. and A. Churchill (for CIBA Foundation).
19.
OltmanJ. E.FriedmanS. (1941) A Psychiatric Study of One Hundred Criminals. J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.93, 16–41.
20.
PrinsH. A. (1980) Offenders. Deviants or Patients. London, Tavistock.
SmithR. (1980) Scientific Thought and the Boundary of Insanity and Criminal Responsibility. Psychol. Med.10, 15–23.
23.
ThompsonC. B. (1937) A Psychiatric Study of Recidivists. Amer. J. Psychiat.94, 591–604.
24.
WalkerN. (1968) Crime and Punishment in Britain. Edinburgh University Press.
25.
WestD. J. (1965) Murder Followed by Suicide. London, Heinemann.
26.
ZeegersM. (1978) The Many-Headed Psychiatrist. Int. J. Law and Psychiat. 1, 167–181. Reprints are available from: Herschel A. Prins, Director, School of Social Work, University of Leicester, 107 Princess Road (East), Leicester LE1 7LA.
