Mental health courts offer access to community-based care for defendants with psychiatric disorders, including posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). However, limited information is available on how judges make treatment decisions about evidence-based practices. In this qualitative study, we interviewed mental health court judges to evaluate: (1) perspectives toward the role of PTSD in criminal behavior; (2) knowledge about evidence-based practice for PTSD; (3) treatment decisions for defendants with PTSD; and (4) treatment decisions for defendants at risk for suicide, a common comorbidity with PTSD. We hypothesized that mental health court judges would report low familiarity with evidence-based practices for PTSD despite wide recognition of the impact of trauma on criminal behavior. Methods: Mental health court judges (N = 11, 60% women, 60% between 50–59 years) were recruited from 7 states in the US and completed a demographics questionnaire and semi-structured qualitative interview that was transcribed and double-coded. Results: Judges in mental health court unanimously agreed that PTSD is highly prevalent among their defendants, but that they had not having received formal education about evidence-based practices for PTSD. They reported relying on their team members to provide recommendations for treatment planning and viewed their role as the enforcer of the treatment teams’ suggestions. Finally, judges also reported that suicide prevention is an important consideration and that there is a need for universal suicide risk assessments. Conclusions: These findings have implications for continuing education among judges in mental health court, and we recommend mandated training to increase awareness of evidence-based practices for PTSD and suicide prevention.
WilsonJAWoodPB. Dissecting the relationship between mental illness and return to incarceration. J Crim Justice2014; 42: 527–537.
7.
AndersonREGeierTJCahillSP. Epidemiological associations between posttraumatic stress disorder and incarceration in the National Survey of American Life. Crim Behav Ment Health2016; 26: 110–123.
8.
JäggiLJMezukBWatkinsDC,et al.The relationship between trauma, arrest, and incarceration history among Black Americans: findings from the National Survey of American Life. Soc Ment Health2016; 6: 187–206.
9.
BowenRARogersAShawJ. Medication management and practices in prison for people with mental health problems: a qualitative study. Int J Ment Health Syst2009; 3: 24.
10.
HassanLSeniorJFrisherM,et al.A comparison of psychotropic medication prescribing patterns in east of England prisons and the general population. J Psychopharmacol Oxf Engl2014; 28: 357–362.
11.
KjelsbergEHartvigP. Too much or too little? Prescription drug use in a nationwide prison population. Int J Prison Health2005; 1: 75–87.
12.
PatelRSavridesICahalanC, et al. Cognitive impairment and functional change in COVID-19 patients undergoing inpatient rehabilitation. medRxiv2021; 44: 285–288. DOI: 2021.03.15.21253637.
13.
AdamsonVGibbsMMcLaughlinD. Evaluation of the improving access to psychological therapies for offenders programme at HMP Lincoln: a three year prospective cohort study. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol2015; 26: 185–201.
14.
BelenkoSHillerMHamiltonL. Treating substance use disorders in the criminal justice system. Curr Psychiatry Rep2013; 15: 14.
15.
NunnAZallerNDickmanS,et al.Methadone and buprenorphine prescribing and referral practices in US prison systems: results from a nationwide survey. Drug Alcohol Depend2009; 105: 83–88.
16.
TaxmanFSPerdoniMLHarrisonLD. Drug treatment services for adult offenders: the state of the state. J Subst Abuse Treat2007; 32: 239–254.
17.
DeHartDShapiroCCloneS. “The pill line is Longer than the chow line”: the impact of incarceration on prisoners and their families. Prison J2018; 98: 188–212.
18.
LambieIRandellI. The impact of incarceration on juvenile offenders. Clin Psychol Rev2013; 33: 448–459.
Bureau of Justice Assistance. Improving responses to people with mental illnesses: the essential elements of a mental health court. Council of State Governments Justice Center, 2007.
21.
McNielDEBinderRL. Effectiveness of a mental health court in reducing criminal recidivism and violence. Am J Psychiatry2007; 164: 1395–1403.
22.
MooreMEHidayVA. Mental health court outcomes: a comparison of Re-arrest and Re-arrest severity between mental health court and traditional court participants. Law Hum Behav2006; 30: 659–674.
23.
HoneggerLN. Does the evidence support the case for mental health courts? A review of the literature. Law Hum Behav2015; 39: 478–488.
24.
BaranyiGCassidyMFazelS,et al.Prevalence of posttraumatic stress disorder in prisoners. Epidemiol Rev2018; 40: 134–145.
25.
PrinsSJ. The prevalence of mental illnesses in U.S. State prisons: a systematic review. Psychiatr Serv Wash DC2014; 65: 862–872.
26.
MachisaMTChristofidesNJewkesR. Structural pathways between child abuse, poor mental health outcomes and male-perpetrated Intimate Partner Violence (IPV). PLoS One2016; 11: e0150986.
27.
SmithKZSmithPHViolantiJM,et al.Posttraumatic stress disorder symptom clusters and perpetration of intimate partner violence: findings from a U.S. Nationally representative sample. J Trauma Stress2015; 28: 469–474.
28.
McFallMFontanaARaskindM,et al.Analysis of violent behavior in Vietnam combat veteran psychiatric inpatients with posttraumatic stress disorder. J Trauma Stress1999; 12: 501–517.
29.
TaftCTKaloupekDGSchummJA, et al.Posttraumatic stress disorder symptoms, physiological reactivity, alcohol problems, and aggression among military veterans. J Abnorm Psychol2007; 116: 498–507.
30.
DonleySHabibLJovanovicT, et al.Civilian PTSD symptoms and risk for involvement in the criminal justice system. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law2012; 40: 522–529.
31.
SaxonAJDavisTMSloanKL, et al.Trauma, symptoms of posttraumatic stress disorder, and associated problems among incarcerated veterans. Psychiatr Serv Wash DC2001; 52: 959–964.
32.
FuentesCM. Nobody’s child: the role of trauma and interpersonal violence in women’s pathways to incarceration and resultant service needs. Med Anthropol Q2014; 28: 85–104.
33.
HonoratoBCaltabianoNCloughAR. From trauma to incarceration: exploring the trajectory in a qualitative study in male prison inmates from north Queensland, Australia. Health Justice2016; 4: 3.
34.
CusackKJonasDEFornerisCA, et al.Psychological treatments for adults with posttraumatic stress disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Rev2016; 43: 128–141.
35.
PowersMBHalpernJMFerenschakMP,et al.A meta-analytic review of prolonged exposure for posttraumatic stress disorder. Clin Psychol Rev2010; 30: 635–641.
36.
American Psychological Association. Clinical practice guideline for the treatment of Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) in Adults: (501872017-001) [Internet]. American Psychological Association, https://doi.apa.org/get-pe-doi.cfm?doi=10.1037/e501872017-001 (2017, cited 6 August 2021).
37.
Department of Veterans Affairs, Department of Defense. VA/DOD clinical practice guideline for the management of posttraumatic stress disorder and acute stress disorder. Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense, 2017, p. 200.
38.
RoundfieldKDLangJM. Costs to community mental health agencies to sustain an evidence-based practice. Psychiatr Serv Wash DC2017; 68: 876–882.
39.
PortilloSRudesDSTaxmanFS. The transportability of contingency management in problem-solving courts. Justice Q2016; 33: 267–290.
40.
Judicial Education Department. Pennsylvania continuing judicial education board of judges [Internet], https://www.pacjeb.org/ (2020, cited 6 August 2021).
41.
AaronsGAWellsRSZagurskyK,et al.Implementing evidence-based practice in community mental health agencies: a multiple stakeholder analysis. Am J Public Health2009; 99: 2087–2095.
42.
VisCMolMKleiboerA, et al.Improving implementation of eMental health for mood disorders in routine practice: systematic review of barriers and facilitating factors. JMIR Ment Health2018; 5: e9769.
43.
SaldañaJ. The coding manual for qualitative researchers. 3rd edition. London, UK: Sage, 2016.
44.
PiperABerleD. The association between trauma experienced during incarceration and PTSD outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Forensic Psychiatry Psychol2019; 30: 854–875.
45.
RuglassLMEspinosaASykesKM,et al.Direct and indirect effects of cumulative trauma, PTSD, and substance use disorder on probability of arrest among lower income African American and Latina women. Race Justice2018; 8: 126–153.
46.
GlantzTHarrisonJCableA. Trauma and recidivism: informing assessment and treatment options for incarcerated men. Int Rev Mod Sociol2017; 43: 95–118.
47.
HundtNEHelmASmithTL,et al.Failure to engage: a qualitative study of veterans who decline evidence-based psychotherapies for PTSD. Psychol Serv2018; 15: 536–542.
48.
WainbergMLScorzaPShultzJM, et al.Challenges and opportunities in global mental health: a research-to-practice perspective. Curr Psychiatry Rep2017; 19: 28.
49.
VA/DOD clinical practice guideline for the management of posttraumatic stress disorder and acute stress disorder, 2017, p. 200.
50.
LinehanM. Dialectical behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder. Theory and method. Bull Menninger Clin1987; 51: 261–276.
51.
BrownLAZangYBenhamouK, et al.Mediation of suicide ideation in prolonged exposure therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder. Behav Res Ther2019; 119: 103409.
52.
Reiss-BrennanBBrunisholzKDDredgeC, et al.Association of integrated team-based care with health care quality, utilization, and costJAMA2016; 316: 826–834.
53.
BrownLAArmeyMASejourneC,et al.Trauma history is associated with prior suicide attempt history in hospitalized patients with major depressive disorder. Psychiatry Res2016; 243: 191–197.
54.
BarkerEKõlvesKDe LeoD. Management of suicidal and self-harming behaviors in prisons: systematic literature review of evidence-based activities. Arch Suicide Res2014; 18: 227–240.
55.
TartaroCRuddellR. Trouble in mayberry: a national analysis of suicides and attempts in small jails. Am J Crim Justice2006; 31: 81–101.
56.
ZhongSSeniorMYuR, et al.Risk factors for suicide in prisons: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Public Health2021; 6: e164–e174.
57.
HayesLM. National study of jail suicide: 20 years later. J Correct Health Care Off J Natl Comm Correct Health Care2012; 18: 233–245.
58.
FranklinJCRibeiroJDFoxKR, et al.Risk factors for suicidal thoughts and behaviors: a meta-analysis of 50 years of research. Psychol Bull2017; 143: 187–232.
59.
HenninkMKaiserBN. Sample sizes for saturation in qualitative research: a systematic review of empirical tests. Soc Sci Med2022; 292: 114523.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
