Deaths occurring among agitated or violent individuals subjected to physical restraint have been attributed to positional asphyxia. Restraint in the prone position has been shown to alter respiratory and cardiac physiology, although this is thought not to be to the degree that would cause asphyxia in a healthy, adult individual. This comprehensive review identifies and summarizes the current scientific literature on prone position and restraint, including experiments that assess physiology on individuals restrained in a prone position. Some of these experimental approaches have attempted to replicate situations in which prone restraint would be used. Overall, most findings revealed that individuals subjected to physical prone restraint experienced a decrease in ventilation and/or cardiac output (CO) in prone restraint. Metabolic acidosis is noted with increased physical activity, in restraint-associated cardiac arrest and simulated encounters. A decrease in ventilation and CO can significantly worsen acidosis and hemodynamics. Given these findings, deaths associated with prone physical restraint are not the direct result of asphyxia but are due to cardiac arrest secondary to metabolic acidosis compounded by inadequate ventilation and reduced CO. As such, the cause of death in these circumstances would be more aptly referred to as “prone restraint cardiac arrest” as opposed to “restraint asphyxia” or “positional asphyxia.”
ReayDTFlignerCLStilwellAD, et al.
Positional asphyxia during law enforcement transport. Am J Forensic Med Pathol1992;
13: 90–97.
2.
BellMDRaoVJWetliCV, et al.
Positional asphyxiation in adults. Am J Forensic Med Pathol1992;
13: 101–107.
3.
BelvisoMDe DonnoAVitaleL, et al.
Positional asphyxia. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2003;
24: 292–297.
4.
OʼHalloranRLLewmanLV.Restraint asphyxiation in excited delirium. Am J Forensic Med Pathol1993;
14: 289–295.
5.
O’HalloranRLFrankJG.Asphyxial death during prone restraint revisited. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2000;
21: 39–52.
6.
StrattonSJRogersCBrickettK, et al.
Factors associated with sudden death of individuals requiring restraint for excited delirium.Am J Emerg Med2001;
19: 187–191.
7.
PollanenMSChiassonDACairnsJT, et al.
Unexpected death related to restraint for excited delirium: a retrospective study of deaths in police custody and in the community. CMAJ1998;
158: 1603–1607
8.
KunzSPordardottirSRunarsdottirR.Restraint-related asphyxia on the basis of a drug-induced excited delirium. Forensic Sci Int2018;
288: e5–e9.
9.
AikenFDuxburyJDaleC.Deaths in custody: role of restraint. Learn Disabil Q2011;
2: 178–190.
10.
HuetherJ.The inquest into the death of Stephanie Jobin. OACAS J2003;
47.
MengA-Y.Ormrod Lecture October 2019: police restraint – causes of death. Med Sci Law2020;
60: 227–233.
14.
ShkrumMJRamsayDA. Asphyxia. In: Forensic pathology of trauma: common problems for the pathologist. Totowa: Humana Press, 2007, pp.65–66.
15.
TumranNKAmbadeVNDixitPG.Compression asphyxia in upright suspended position. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2014;
35: 80–82.
16.
SavaserDChanTC. Positional and restraint asphyxia. In: Ross D and Vilke G (eds) Guidelines for investigating officer-involved shootings, arrest-related deaths, and deaths in custody. New York and London: Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2017, pp. 149–162.
17.
MichaudA.Restraint related deaths and excited delirium syndrome in Ontario (2004–2011). J Forensic Leg Med2016;
41: 30–35.
18.
Aiken F, Duxbury J, Dale C Deaths in custody, the role of restraint. Journal of Learning Disabilities and Offending Behaviour 2011; 2(4): 178–190.
19.
HallCVotovaKHeydC, et al.
Restraint in police use of force events: examining sudden in custody death for prone and not-prone positions.J Forensic Leg Med2015;
31: 29–35.
20.
RossDLHazlettMA.A prospective analysis of the outcomes of violent prone restraint incidents in policing.Forensic Res Criminol Int J2016;
2: 16–24.
21.
Di MaioTGMaioVJ.Excited delirium syndrome cause of death and prevention. 1st ed.
Boca Raton, FL:
Taylor & Francis, 2006, pp.7–31, 35–37.
22.
BarnettRStirlingCPandyanAD.A review of the scientific literature related to the adverse impact of physical restraint: gaining a clearer understanding of the physiological factors involved in cases of restraint-related death.Med Sci Law2012;
52: 137–142.
23.
LevitskyM.Pulmonary physiology. 4th ed.
New York:
McGraw Hill, 1995. pp.14–17, 44–45, 163–
182, 226–232.
24.
ChanTCNeumanTClausenJ, et al.
Weight force during prone restraint and respiratory function. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2004;
25: 185–189.
25.
MichalewiczBAChanTCVilkeGM, et al.
Ventilatory and metabolic demands during aggressive physical restraint in healthy adults. J Forensic Sci2007;
52: 171–175.
26.
SloaneCChanTCKolkhorstF, et al.
Evaluation of the ventilatory effects of the prone maximum restraint (PMR) position on obese human subjects.Forensic Sci Int2014;
237: 86–89.
27.
RoegglaGRoegglaHMoserB, et al.
Cardiorespiratory consequences of the hobble restraint.Acad Emerg Med1999;
6: 1076–1077.
28.
ChanTCVilkeGMNeumanT, et al.
Restraint position and positional asphyxia. Ann Emerg Med1997;
30: 578–586.
29.
VilkeGMChanTCNeumanT, et al.
Spirometry in normal subjects in sitting, prone and supine positions. Respir Care2000;
45: 407–410.
30.
CaryNRBRobertsCACumminARC, et al.
The effect of simulated restraint in the prone position on cardiorespiratory function following exercise in humans. J Physiol2000;
525: 30P–31P.
31.
ParkesJ.Sudden death during restraint: do some positions affect lung function?Med Sci Law2008;
48: 137–141.
32.
MeredithCTaslaqSKonOM, et al.
The cardiopulmonary effects of physical restraint in subjects with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. J Clin Forensic Med2005;
12: 133–136.
33.
BarnettRHansonPStirlingC, et al.
The physiological impact of upper limb position in prone restraint. Med Sci Law2013;
53: 161–165.
BruscascoVCrapoRVirgoG, et al.
ATS/ERS Task Force: standardization of lung function Testing. Eur Respir J2005;
26: 720–735.
36.
KrollMWStillGKNeumanTS, et al.
Acute forces required for fatal compression asphyxia: a biomechanical model and historical comparisons.Med Sci Law2017;
57: 61–68.
37.
KnollMWBraveMAKleistSR, et al.
Applied force during prone restraint. Is officer weight a factor?Am H Forensic Med Pathol2019;
40: 1–7.
38.
McArdleWDKatchFIKatchVL.Exercise physiology: nutrition, energy, and human performance.
Baltimore:
Wolters Kluwer Health, 2015, pp.200, 264, 286–301, 337.
39.
MunshiLDel SorboLAdhikariNKJ.Prone position for acute respiratory distress syndrome. A systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Am Thorac Soc2017;
14.
40.
GuérinCReignierJRichardJ-C, et al.
Prone positioning in severe acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med2013;
368: 2159–2168.
PeterssonJAxMFreyJ, et al.
Positive end-expiratory pressure redistributes regional blood flow and ventilation differently in supine and prone humans.Anesthesiology2010;
113: 1361–1369.
43.
RossJBraunwaldE.Studies on Starling’s law of the heart. Circulation1964;
30: 719–727.
44.
SacknerMASchnabelTGLewisDH.Effect of restriction of venous return on the hemodynamics of normal persons and patients with congestive heart failure. Am J Cardiol1964;
13: 782–789.
45.
VaratMFowlerNAdolphRJ.Cardiac output response to exercise in patients with inferior vena caval ligation.Circulation1970;
42: 445–453.
46.
HigashiHYoshiiTInabaS, et al.
Life-threatening shock due to inferior vena cava filter thrombosis. Hear lung Vessel2015;
7: 263–265.
47.
SavaserDJCampbellCCastilloEM, et al.
The effect of the prone maximal restraint position with and without weight force on cardiac output and other hemodynamic measures.J Forensic Leg Med2013;
20: 991–995.
48.
PumpBTalleruphuusUChristensenNJ, et al.
Effects of supine, prone, and lateral positions on cardiovascular and renal variables in humans. Am J Physiol Integr Comp Physiol2002;
283: R174–R180.
49.
HoJDDawesDMMooreJC, et al.
Effect of position and weight force on inferior vena cava diameter – implications for arrest-related death. Forensic Sci Int2011;
212: 256–259.
50.
KrauskopfAMayerhoeferMOberndorferF, et al.
Does weight force application to the lower torso have an influence on inferior vena cava and cardiovascular parameters?Am J Emerg Med2008;
26: 603–607.
51.
BackofenJE.Hemodynamic changes with prone position during general anesthesia. Anesth Analg1985;
64: 194–194.
52.
SudheerPSLoganSWAteleanuB, et al.
Haemodynamic effects of the prone position: a comparison of propofol total intravenous and inhalation anaesthesia.Anaesthesia2006;
61: 138–141.
53.
YokoyamaMUedaWHirakawaM, et al.
Hemodynamic effect of the prone position during anesthesia.Acta Anaesthesiol Scand1991;
35: 741–744.
54.
EdgcombeHCarterKYarrowS.Anaesthesia in the prone position.Br J Anaesth2008;
100: 165–183.
55.
JettéMSidneyKBlümchenG.Metabolic equivalents (METS) in exercise testing, exercise prescription, and evaluation of functional capacity.Clin Cardiol1990;
13: 555–565.
HoJDDawesDMNelsonRS, et al.
Acidosis and catecholamine evaluation following simulated law enforcement ‘use of force’ encounters.Acad Emerg Med2010;
17: e60–e68.
58.
HickJLSmithSWLynchMT.Metabolic acidosis in restraint-associated cardiac arrest. A case series.Acad Emerg Med1999;
6: 239–243.
59.
HalliwillJRSieckDCRomeroSA, et al.
Blood pressure regulation X: what happens when the muscle pump is lost? Post-exercise hypotension and syncope. Eur J Appl Physiol2014;
114: 561–578.
60.
Van HoorenBPeakeJM.Do we need a cool-down after exercise? A narrative review of the psychophysiological effects and the effects on performance, injuries and the long-term adaptive response.Sports Med2018;
48: 1575–1595.
61.
NeumarRWOttoCWLinkMS, et al.
American Heart Association guidelines for cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care. Part 8: Adult advanced cardiovascular life support. Circulation2010;
122: S729–767.
62.
FabreAShepardMN.Sudden adult death syndrome and other non-ischaemic causes of sudden cardiac death. Heart2006 Mar;
92(3):316–320
63.
NeumanT.Positional and restraint asphyxia. In: RossDLChanTC (eds) Sudden deaths in custody.1st ed.
Totowa:
Humana Press, 2006, pp.39–57.
64.
KrexiLGeorgiouRKrexiD, et al.
Sudden cardiac death with stress and restraint: the association with sudden adult death syndrome, cardiomyopathy and coronary artery disease.Med Sci Law2016;
56: 85–90.
65.
OtahbachiMCevikCBaghureS.Excited delirium, restraints, and unexpected death. A review of pathogenesis. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2010;
31: 107–112.
66.
Eckart, R. Shry E. Burke A. et al. Sudden death in young adults: an autopsy-based series of a population undergoing active surveillance. J Am Coll Cardiol Sept 2011; 58(12): 1254–1261.
67.
BehrERDalageorgouCChristiansenM, et al.
Sudden arrhythmic death syndrome: familial evaluation identifies inheritable heart disease in the majority of families. Eur Heart J2008;
29: 1670–1680.
68.
KrollMWWalcottGPIdekerRE. The stability of electrically induced ventricular fibrillation. In: 34th Annual International Conference of IEEE EMBS, San Diego, CA, 28 August–1 September 2012. New York: IEEE Press, 2012.
69.
TruhlarADeakinCDSoarJ, et al.
European Resuscitation Council guidelines for resuscitation 2015: Section 4. Cardiac arrest in special circumstances. Resuscitation2015;
95: 147–200.
70.
ChanPSMcNallyBTangF, et al.
Recent trends in survival from out-of-hospital cardiac arrest in the United States. Circulation2014;
130: 1876–1882.
71.
NolanJPLaverSRWelchCA, et al.
Outcome following admission to UK intensive care units after cardiac arrest: a secondary analysis of the ICNARC Case Mix Programme Database. Anaesthesia2007;
62: 1207–1216.
72.
StrommerEMLeithWZeegersMPThe role of restraint in fatal excited delirium: a research synthesis and pooled analysis. Forensic Sci Med Pathol2020;
16: 680–692.
73.
DijkhuizenLGKubatBDuijstWL.Sudden death during physical restraint by the Dutch police. J Forensic Leg Med2020;
72: 101966.
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
