We undertook a retrospective analysis of deaths that took place in prisons in Milan between 1993 and 2017, by identifying cases from a total of 24,101 autopsies that were performed at the Section of Forensic Medicine of the University of Milan. From the archives of this institution, we found 227 autopsy reports relating to deaths that had taken place in one of Milan’s three detention facilities. These deaths were divided into two types: natural deaths (n=135; 59.5%) and violent deaths (n=92; 40.5%). The groups have different characteristics: while natural deaths mostly resulted from cardiovascular diseases, suicides were mainly the result of hanging. Further, people who died by suicide often had a history of psychiatric disease and/or drug abuse, and over a quarter of them had previous suicide attempts and/or had declared suicidal intentions. This study confirms the need for good quality healthcare services for prisoners, given that they remain a population at high risk of early death.
AA. VV. La Costituzione Italiana. Milano: Garzanti Editore, 2018, pp. 1–92.
2.
WangmoTRuizGSinclairJ, et al.
The investigation of deaths in custody: A qualitative analysis of problems and prospects.J Forensic Leg Med2014;
25: 30–37.
3.
RuizGWangmoTMutzenbergP, et al.
Understanding death in custody: A case for a comprehensive definition.J Bioeth Inq2014;
11: 387–398.
4.
FazelSBenningR.Natural deaths in male prisoners: A 20-year mortality study. Eur J Public Health2006;
16: 441–444.
5.
TibulloA.Salute e carcere.Arch Pen2017;
2: 1–22.
6.
ÜnalVÖzgün ÜnalEÇetinkayaZ, et al.
Custody and prison deaths autopsied in Istanbul between 2010 and 2012.J Forensic Leg Med2016;
39: 16–21.
7.
Opitz-WelkeALehmannMSeidelP, et al.
Medicine in the Penal System. Dtsch Arztebl Int2018;
115: 808–814.
8.
CrowleyDCullenWLambertJS, et al.
Competing priorities and second chances: A qualitative exploration of prisoners’ journeys through the hepatitis C continuum of care.PLoS One2019;
14: e0222186.
9.
BannanCLLynchPAConroyEP, et al.
Point-of-care testing for HIV in an Irish prison setting: Results from three major Irish prisons.Int J STD AIDS2016;
27: 950–954.
10.
FordLTBergJD.Analytical evidence to show letters impregnated with novel psychoactive substances are a means of getting drugs to inmates within the UK prison service.Ann Clin Biochem2018;
55: 673–678.
11.
LinesR.The right to health of prisoners in international human rights law.Int J Prison Health2008;
4: 3–53.
12.
FazelSGrannMKlingB, et al.
Prison suicide in 12 countries: An ecological study of 861 suicides during 2003–2007.Soc Psychiatry Psychiatric Epidemiol2011;
46: 191–195.
13.
WobeserWLDatemaJBechardB, et al.
Causes of death among people in custody in Ontario, 1990–1999. CMAJ Can Med Assoc J J de l’Assoc Medicale Can2002;
167: 1109–1113.
14.
AbbottPMaginPLujicS, et al.
Supporting continuity of care between prison and the community for women in prison: a medical record review.Aust Health Rev2017;
41: 268–276.
15.
HeideSChanT.Deaths in police custody.J Forensic Leg Med2018;
57: 109–114.
16.
Istituto Nazionale di Statistica (ISTAT). Annuario Statistico Italiano 2018 – Sanità e Salute. 2018; 4: 117–153, www.istat.it/it/files/2018/12/C04.pdf. (accessed 21 February 2020).
17.
YoungJTHeffernanEBorschmannR, et al.
Dual diagnosis of mental illness and substance use disorder and injury in adults recently released from prison: A prospective cohort study. Lancet Public Health2018;
3: e237–e248.
18.
PetersenJKunzeSThielA, et al.
Deaths in Hamburg prisons 1996–2012: Recommendations on suicide prevention in prison custody. Arch Kriminol2017;
239: 73–86.
19.
ReischTHartmannCHemmerA, et al.
Suicide by hanging: Results from a national survey in Switzerland and its implications for suicide prevention.PLoS One2019;
14: e0220508.
20.
GrimaldiLDe GiorgioFMasulloM, et al.
Suicide by pencil. J Forensic Sci2005;
50: 913–914.
21.
RossiRSuadoniFPieroniL, et al.
Two cases of acute propane butane poisoning in prison.J Forensic Sci2012;
57: 832–834.
22.
GahrtonCWestmanGLindahlK, et al.
Prevalence of viremic hepatitis C, hepatitis B, and HIV infection, and vaccination status among prisoners in Stockholm County.BMC Infect Dis2019;
19: 955.
23.
FreedmanAMKaplanHISadockBJ.Emergenze psichiatriche – Suicidio. In: FreedmanAMKaplanHISadockBJ (eds) Trattato di psichiatria.
Padova:
Piccin Editore Nuova Libraria, 1984, pp.926–930.
24.
Sentenza CEDU 8 gennaio 2013.
25.
Consiglio Europa, Comitato dei Ministri. Nuove regole penitenziarie: Approvate dal Comitato dei Ministri dei 46 Stati europei l’11 gennaio 2006. Sapere 2000. Roma 2007.
26.
Guarcia-GuerreroJVera-RemartinezEJ and
Planelles Ramos MV. Causes and trends of mortality in a Spanish Prison (1994–2009). Rev Esp Salud Pubblica2011;
85: 245–255.
27.
Miguel-AriasDPereiro- GòmezCBermejo-BarreraAM.Deaths from acute drug reactions in Galician (Spain) prisons (2001–2010). Rev Esp Sanid Penit2017;
19: 49–56.
28.
RadeloffDLemppTRaufA, et al.
Suicide and suicide tendencies in adolescent detainees. Z Kinder Jugendpsychiatr Psychother2016;
44: 9–18.
29.
BaybuttMDoorisM and
Farrier A. Growing health in UK prison settings.Health Promot Int2019;
34: 792–802.
30.
DuthèGHazardAKenseyA, et al.
Suicide among male prisoners in France: A prospective population based study. Forensic Sci Int2013;
233: 273–277.
31.
GoudardALalandeLBertinC, et al.
Sleep disorders and therapeutic management: A survey in a French population of prisoners.J Correct Health Care2017;
23: 193–202.
32.
ChassagneAGodardACretinE, et al.
The collision of inmate and patient: End-of-life issues in French prisons. J Correct Health Care2017;
23: 66–75.
33.
MartiIHostettlerURichterM.End of life in high-security prisons in Switzerland.J Correct Health Care2017;
23: 32–42.
34.
SakelliadisEIVlachodimitropoulosDGGoutasND, et al.
Forensic investigation of suicide cases in major Greek correctional facilities. J Forensic Leg Med2013;
20: 953–958.
35.
AasebØWOrskaugGErikssenJ.Deaths in Norwegian police cells from 2003 to 2012. Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 2014;
134: 291–294.
36.
Halden. Available at: www.liberties.eu (accessed 5 September 2019).
37.
PattersonEJ.The dose-response of time served in prison on mortality: New York State, 1989–2003.Am J Public Health2013;
103: 523–528.
38.
Il carcere secondo la Costituzione: XV rapporto di Antigone sulle condizioni di detenzione. Available at: www.antigone.it/ (accessed 15 September 2019).
39.
Morire di carcere: Dossier 2000–2019. Available at: www.ristretti.it/ (accessed 20 October 2019).
40.
GrassiSMandarelliGPolaccoM, et al.
Suicide of isolated inmates suffering from psychiatric disorders: When a preventive measure becomes punitive.Int J Legal Med2018;
132: 1225–1230.
41.
MauerM.Mass imprisonment and the disappearing voters. In: MauerMChesney-LindM (eds) Invisible punishment: The collateral consequences of mass imprisonment.
New York:
New Press, 2002, pp.50–58.
42.
CinosiEMartinottiGDe RisioL, et al.
Suicide in prisoners: An Italian contribution. Open Criminol J2013;
6: 18–29.
43.
PhillipsJPadfieldNGelsthorpeL.Suicide and community justice.Health Justice2018;
21: 6–14.
44.
KreagerDAKruttschnittC.Inmate society in the era of mass incarceration.Annu Rev Criminol2018;
1: 261–283.
