Fatalities from acute compression have been reported with soft-drink vending machine tipping, motor vehicle accidents, and trench cave-ins. A major mechanism of such deaths is flail chest but the amount of force required is unclear. Between the range of a safe static chest compression force of 1000 N (102 kg with earth gravity) and a lethal dynamic force of 10–20 kN (falling 450 kg vending machines), there are limited quantitative human data on the force required to cause flail chest, which is a major correlate of acute fatal compression asphyxia.
Methods
We modeled flail chest as bilateral fractures of six adjacent ribs. The static and dynamic forces required to cause such a ribcage failure were estimated using a biomechanical model of the thorax. The results were then compared with published historical records of judicial “pressing,” vending machine fatalities, and automobile safety cadaver testing.
Results and conclusion
The modeling results suggest that an adult male requires 2550 ± 250 N of chest-applied distributed static force (260 ± 26 kg with earth gravity) or 4050 ± 320 N of dynamic force to cause flail chest from short-term chest compression.
KarchSBBraveMAKrollMW. On positional asphyxia and death in custody. Med Sci Law2016; 56: 74–75.
2.
SathyavagiswaranLRogersCNoguchiTT. Restraint asphyxia in in-custody deaths. Medical examiner’s role in prevention of deaths. Leg Med (Tokyo)2007; 9: 88–93.
3.
K. Glatter and S. B. Karch, “Positional asphyxia: inadequate oxygen, or inadequate theory?. Forensic Sci Int 141, 201-2, May 10 2004.
4.
ChanTCVilkeGMNeumanT. Restraint position and positional asphyxia. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2000; 21: 93–93.
5.
TrnkaJGesickiMSusloR. Death as a result of violent asphyxia in autopsy reports. Adv Exp Med Biol2013; 788: 413–416.
6.
FernandoTByardRW. Positional asphyxia without active restraint following an assault. J Forensic Sci2013; 58: 1633–1635.
7.
HayashiTBuschmannCCorrensA. Fatal positional asphyxia. Forensic Sci Med Pathol2012; 8: 470–472.
8.
ByardR. Issues in the classification and pathological diagnosis of asphyxia. Aus J Forensic Sci2011; 43: 27–38.
9.
SauvageauABoghossianE. Classification of asphyxia: The need for standardization. J Forensic Sci2010; 55: 1259–1267.
10.
ConroyCStanleyCEastmanAB. Asphyxia: A rare cause of death for motor vehicle crash occupants. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2008; 29: 14–18.
11.
ByardRWWickRGilbertJD. Conditions and circumstances predisposing to death from positional asphyxia in adults. J Forensic Leg Med2008; 15: 415–419.
12.
VelmahosGCVassiliuPChanLS. Influence of flail chest on outcome among patients with severe thoracic cage trauma. Int Surg2002; 87: 240–244.
13.
VegaRSAdamsVI. Suffocation in motor vehicle crashes. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2004; 25: 101–107.
14.
AhmedZMohyuddinZ. Management of flail chest injury: Internal fixation versus endotracheal intubation and ventilation. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg1995; 110: 1676–1680.
15.
MichalewiczBAChanTCVilkeGM. Ventilatory and metabolic demands during aggressive physical restraint in healthy adults. J Forensic Sci2007; 52: 171–175.
16.
CosioMQTaylorGW. Soda pop vending machine injuries: An update. J Orthop Trauma1992; 6: 186–189.
17.
ChampaJRHennrikusWLGerardiJA. Four cases of injury involving soda vending machines. J Orthop Trauma1989; 3: 64–67.
18.
CosioMQ. Soda pop vending machine injuries. JAMA1988; 260: 2697–2699.
19.
El-JawahriRELaituriTRKimAS. Further validation of age-dependent FE models of a mid-sized male thorax. SAE Int J Passenger Cars-Mechanical Syst2012; 5: 552–566.
20.
Zhou Q, Rouhana SW and Melvin JW. Age effects on thoracic injury tolerance. SAE Technical Paper, 1996.
21.
Kuppa SM and Eppinger RH. Development of an improved thoracic injury criterion. SAE Technical Paper, 1998.
22.
ByardRWWickRSimpsonE. The pathological features and circumstances of death of lethal crush/traumatic asphyxia in adults – a 25-year study. Forensic Sci Int2006; 159: 200–205.
23.
SklarDPBaackBMcFeeleyP. Traumatic asphyxia in New Mexico: A five-year experience. Am J Emerg Med1988; 6: 219–223.
24.
McKenzieA. “This Death Some Strong and Stout Hearted Man Doth Choose”: The practice of peine forte et dure in seventeenth- and eighteenth-century England. Law History Rev2005; 23: 279–312.
25.
Kroell CK, Schneider DC and Nahum AM. Impact tolerance and response of the human thorax II. In: Stapp Car Crash Conference Proceedings, 1974.
26.
VanaPGNeubauerDCLuchetteFA. Contemporary management of flail chest. Am Surg2014; 80: 527–535.
27.
YoungWBudynasR. Roark’s Formulas for Stress and Strain, 7th ed. New York City, NY: McGraw Hill, 2002, pp. 211–215.
28.
LaurinLPJobinVBellemareF. Sternum length and rib cage dimensions compared with bodily proportions in adults with cystic fibrosis. Can Respir J2012; 19: 196–200.
29.
CarterDRHayesWC. Bone compressive strength: The influence of density and strain rate. Science1976; 194: 1174–1176.
30.
YoganandanNPintarFA. Biomechanics of human thoracic ribs. J Biomech Eng1998; 120: 100–104.
31.
KentRLessleyDSherwoodC. Thoracic response to dynamic, non-impact loading from a hub, distributed belt, diagonal belt, and double diagonal belts. Stapp Car Crash J2004; 48: 495–519.
32.
Murakami D, Kobayashi S, Torigaki T, et al. Finite element analysis of hard and soft tissue contributions to thoracic response: Sensitivity analysis of fluctuations in boundary conditions. SAE Technical Paper, 2006.
MushJA true report of the life and martyrdom of Mrs. Margaret Clitherow. In: MorrisJ (ed). The Troubles of Our Catholic Forefathers Related by Themselves, London: Burns and Oates, 1877, pp. 432–432.
35.
KroellCThoracic response to blunt frontal loading. In: Society of AutomotiveEngineers (ed). The Human Thorax-Anatomy Injury and Biomechanics, Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers, 1976, pp. 67–67.
36.
BaubinMKollmitzerJPomaroliA. Force distribution across the heel of the hand during simulated manual chest compression. Resuscitation1997; 35: 259–263.
37.
OschatzEWunderbaldingerPSterzF. Cardiopulmonary resuscitation performed by bystanders does not increase adverse effects as assessed by chest radiography. Anesth Analg2001; 93: 128–133.
38.
KrischerJPFineEGDavisJH. Complications of cardiac resuscitation. Chest1987; 92: 287–291.
39.
MallNABuchowskiJZebalaL. Spine and axial skeleton injuries in the National Football League. Am J Sports Med2012; 40: 1755–1761.
40.
GillJRLandiK. Traumatic asphyxial deaths due to an uncontrolled crowd. Am J Forensic Med Pathol2004; 25: 358–361.
41.
HopkinsIPountneySHayesPCrowd pressure monitoring. In: SmithRADickieJ (eds). Engineering for Crowd Safety, Elsevier, 1993, pp. 389–398.
42.
Seabrook J. Crush point: When large crowds assemble, is there a way to keep them safe? New Yorker Feb 2011, p.32–38.
