Psychiatric Probation Orders: Failed Provision or Future Panacea?

Abstract

The psychiatric probation order has been a sentencing option for the courts for over fifty years. Many authors have lamented its underuse and described the inability of psychiatric and probation services to work together in a collaborative and effective way. The aim of this study was to describe probationers who had passed through Elliott House, a specialist bail and probation hostel for mentally disordered offenders.

A retrospective case note review of all individuals who have been resident at Elliott House as a condition of a probation order was conducted. The individuals were mostly young, single men with a severe mental illness and comorbid substance misuse. As a group their previous contact with psychiatric services was irregular. A probation order at Elliott House appeared to provide social support and stability along with a period of regular psychiatric treatment and follow-up. The results suggest that psychiatric probation orders, if properly managed, can be a useful tool for both health and probation services in the short term.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Armitage

Berry

(1987) Statistical Methods in Medical Research, 2nd ed. Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications.

Bowden

(1978a) A psychiatric clinic in a probation office. Brit. J. Psychiat. 133, 448–51.

Bowden

(1978b) Men remanded into custody for medical reports: The outcome of the treatment recommendation. Brit. J. Psychiat. 132, 332–8.

Department of Health and Home Office. (1992) Review of Health and Social Services for mentally disordered offenders and others requiring similar services. London, HMSO.

Edwards

(1982) Psychiatric probation orders: perceptions of probationer-patients, probation officers and psychiatrists. Master's thesis, University of Surrey.

Geelan

Griffin

Briscoe

(1989/99) A profile of residents at Elliot House, the first bail and probation hostel for mentally disordered offenders. Health Trends 30(4), 101–5.

Gibbens

Soothill

Way

(1981) Psychiatric treatment on probation. Brit. J. Criminol. 21(4), 324–34.

Harding

Cameron

(1999). What the probation officer expects from the psychiatrist. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 5, 463–70.

HM Inspectorate of Probation. (1993) Probation Orders with Requirements for psychiatric treatment: Report of a thematic Inspection. London, Home Office.

10.

Home Office (1973) Powers of Criminal Courts Act 1973. London, HMSO.

11.

Home Office (1991) Criminal Justice Act 1991. London, HMSO.

12.

Home Office (1994) Probation Statistics England and Wales 1993. London, Home Office.

13.

Home Office (1998) Probation Statistics England and Wales 1997. London, Home Office.

14.

Home Office and Department of Health and Social Security (1975) Report of the committee on mentally abnormal offenders. London, HMSO.

15.

Lewis

(1980) Psychiatric probation orders: roles and expectations of probation officers and psychiatrists. Cambridge, Institute of Criminology.

16.

McInnes

Richardson

Davies

(2000) Probation Orders with conditions of psychiatric treatment — a descriptive study. Poster presentation at the Annual Meeting of the Royal College of Psychiatrists.

17.

Nadkarni

Chipchase

Fraser

(2000) Partnership with probation hostels. A step forward in community psychiatry. Psychiat. Bull. 24, 222–4.

18.

Neeleman

Mikhail

(1997) A case-control study of GP and patients related variables associated with non-attendance at new psychiatric outpatients' appointments. J. Ment. Health 6(3), 301–6.

19.

Woodside

(1971) Probation and psychiatric treatment in Edinburgh. Brit. J. Psychiat. 118, 561–70.