The assessment of a suspect's fitness to be interviewed by the police is becoming an increasingly important part of a police surgeon's workload. This paper discusses the assessment in terms of the various factors that may render a person prone to providing an involuntary or false confession and proposes an aide memoire to assist the examining doctor.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BaldwinJ.McConvilleM. (1980) Confessions in Crown Court Trials. Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure, Research Study No. 5.London, HMSO.
2.
BennettT. (1998) Drugs and crime: the results of research on drug testing and interviewing arrestees. Home Office Research Study 183.London, Home Office.
3.
CarpenterJ. A.RossB.M. (1965) Effect of alcohol on short-term memory. Quarterly J. of Studies on Alcohol26, 561–79.
4.
ClarkeM.D.B. (1991) ‘Fit for Interview’?The Police Surgeon40, 15–18.
5.
DavisonS.E.ForshawD.M. (1993) Retracted confessions: through opiate withdrawal to a new conceptual framework. Med. Sci. Law33, 285–90.
6.
DavisonS.E.GossopM. (1999) The management of opiate addicts in police custody. Med. Sci. Law39, 153–60.
7.
GallJ.A.FreckeltonI. (1999) Fitness for interview: current trends, views and an approach to the assessment procedure. J. Clin. Forens. Med.6, 213–23.
8.
GudjonssonG.H. (1989) Compliance in an interrogation situation: a new scale. Personality and Individual Differences10, 535–40.
9.
GudjonssonG. (1992) The Psychology of Interrogations, Confessions and Testimony.Chichester, John Wiley & Sons.
10.
GudjonssonG.H. (1995) The Vulnerabilities of Mentally Disordered Witnesses. Med. Sci. Law35, 101–6.
11.
GudjonssonG. (1995) ‘Fitness for interview’ during police detention: a conceptual framework for forensic assessment. J. Forens. Psychiat.6, 185–97.
12.
GudjonssonG. (1997) Interrogative suggestibility - can it be recognised in custody? In: NorfolkG.A. (ed). Fit to be Interviewed by the Police.Harrogate, Association of Police Surgeons.
13.
GudjonssonG.ClareI.RutterS.PearseJ. (1993) Persons at Risk During Interviews in Police Custody: The Identification of Vulnerabilities. The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice, Research Study No. 12. London, HMSO.
14.
InbauF.E.ReidJ.E. (1962) Criminal Interrogation and Confessions.Baltimore, Williams and Wilkins.
15.
IrvingB. (1980) Police Interrogation. A Case Study of Current Practice. Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure, Research Study No 2.London, HMSO.
16.
IrvingB.L.McKenzieI.K. (1989) Police Interrogation: The Effects of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act.London, The Police Foundation.
17.
LeoR.A. (1992) From coercion to deception: the changing nature of police interrogation in America. Crime, Law and Social Change18, 35–59.
18.
LishmanW.A. (1987) Organic Psychiatry. The Psychological Consequences of Cerebral Disorder. (2nd ed.). Oxford, Blackwell Scientific Publications.
19.
LoftusE.F. (1980) 'Did I really say that last night?' Alcohol, marijuana and memory. Psychol. Today92, 42–56.
20.
LyallI.HollandA.J.StylesP. (1995) Incidence of persons with a learning disability detained in police custody. A needs assessment for service development. Med. Sci. Law35, 61–71.
21.
MayouR.A. (1987) Emotional reactions to disorders. In: WeatherallD.J.LedinghamJ.G.G.WarrellD.A.WarrellD.A. (eds) Oxford Textbook of Medicine (2nd ed.). Oxford, Oxford University Press.
22.
MostonS.StephensonG.M.WilliamsonT.M. (1992) The effects of case characteristics on suspect behaviour during police questioning. Br. J. Crim.32, 23–40.
23.
MurphyG.ClareI.C.H. (1998) People with learning disabilities as offenders or alleged offenders in the UK criminal justice system. J. Royal Soc. Med.91, 178–82.
24.
NorfolkG.A. (1996) Fitness to be interviewed and the appropriate adult scheme: a survey of police surgeons' attitudes. J. Clin. Forens. Med.3, 9–13.
25.
NorfolkG.A. (1997a) ‘Fitness to be interviewed’ - a proposed definition and scheme of examination. Med. Sci. Law37, 228–34.
26.
NorfolkG.A. (1997b) Fit to be interviewed - a police surgeon's perspective. In: NorfolkG.A. (ed.) Fit to be Interviewed by the Police.Harrogate, Association of Police Surgeons.
27.
NorfolkG.A. (1999) Physiological illnesses and their potential for influencing testimony. Med. Sci. Law39, 105–12.
28.
PearseJ.GudjonssonG.H. (1996) Police interviewing techniques at two south London police stations. Psychol., Crime and Law3, 63–74.
29.
PearseJ.GudjonssonG.H. (1999) Measuring influential police interviewing tactics: A factor analytic approach. Legal and Crim. Psych.4, 221–38.
30.
PearseJ.GudjonssonG.H.ClareI.C.H.RutterS. (1998) Police interviewing and psychological vulnerabilities: predicting the likelihood of a confession. J. Comm. Appl. Soc. Psychl.8, 1–21.
31.
PenttilaA.TenhuM. (1976) Clinical examination as medicolegal proof of alcohol intoxication. Med. Sci. Law16, 95–103.
32.
PilcherJ.J.HuffcuttA.I. (1996) Effects of sleep deprivation on performance: A Meta-Analysis. Sleep19, 318–26.
33.
RixK.J.B. (1997) Fit to be interviewed by the police?Advances in Psychiatric Treatment3, 33–40.
34.
RogersD.J.StarkM.M.HowittJ.B. (1995) The use of an alcometer in clinical forensic practice. J. Clin. Forens. Med.2, 177–83.
35.
RybackR.S. (1970) Memory, alcohol, and the law. JAMA213, 1497–8.
36.
SigurdssonJ.F.GudjonssonG.H. (1994) Alcohol and drug intoxication during police interrogation and the reasons why suspects confess to the police. Addiction89, 985–97.
37.
StarkM.M. (1994) Management of drug misusers in police custody. J. Roy. Soc. Med.87, 584–7.
38.
SullivanJ.B.HauptmanM.BronsteinA.C. (1987) Lack of observable intoxication in humans with high plasma alcohol concentrations. J. Forens. Sci.32, 1660–5.
39.
TruittE.B. (1975) Marihuana vs. alcohol: a pharmacologic comparison. Advances in Exper. Med. and Biol.56, 291–309.
40.
WalkleyJ. (1987) Police Interrogation. A Handbook for Investigators.London, Police Review Publication.
41.
YuilleJ.C.TollestrupP.A. (1990) Some effects of alcohol on eyewitness memory. J. Applied Psychol.75, 268–73.
42.
ZacnyJ.P. (1996) Should people taking opioids for medical reasons be allowed to work and drive?Addiction91, 1581–4.
43.
ZimbardoP.G. (1967) The psychology of police confessions. Psychol. Today1, 17–27. CASES R v. Warickshall (1783) 1 Leach C.C. 263.
