Previous research has indicated that psychopathy is associated with high levels of institutional misconduct and high attrition rates in therapeutic communities. However, most of this work has been conducted with North American populations. In the present study, data is presented on institutional behaviour and time in therapy for 104 inmates admitted to Grendon Therapeutic Prison. The results indicated that high scores on the Hare Psychopathy Checklist Revised were significantly associated with failure to progress from the assessment unit onto a therapy wing and the number of adjudications and security information reports. A trend was found for psychopathy to be associated with shorter periods in therapy, but this just failed to reach significance. The results confirm previous research on the association between psychopathy and institutional misconduct and provide some support for the association between psychopathy and early termination of treatment in therapeutic communities. A number of methodological issues are discussed.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndrewsD. (1995) The psychology of criminal conduct and effective treatment. In: McGuireJ. (ed.) What Works: Reducing Reoffending.Chichester, Wiley.
2.
BlackburnR. (1996) Psychopathy and personality disorder: implications of interpersonal theory. In: CookeD.ForthA.E.NewmanJ.HareR.D. (eds) International Perspectives on Psychopathy. Issues in Criminological and Legal Psychology24, 18–23.
3.
ClarkD. (2000) The use of the Hare PCLR to predict offending and institutional misconduct in the English prison system. Prison Research and Deuel. Bull.9, 10–14. (Available from: Planning Group, Room 622, Abell House, John Islip Street, London SW1P 4LH).
4.
CookeD.J. (1995) Psychopathic disturbance in the Scottish prison population: Cross-cultural generalizability of the Hare Psychopathy Checklist. Psychol. Crime and Law2, 101–18.
5.
CookeD.ForthA.E.NewmanJ.HareR.D., (eds) (1996) International Perspectives on Psychopathy. Issues in Criminol. and Legal Psychol.24.
6.
CullenE. (1993) The Grendon Reconviction Study, Part 1. Prison Service J.90, 35–7.
7.
CullenE. (1997) Can a prison be a therapeutic community? The Grendon template. In: CullenE.JonesL.WoodwardR. (eds) Therapeutic Communities for Offenders.Chichester, Wiley.
8.
CullenE.JonesL.WoodwardR. (1997) (eds) Therapeutic Communities for Offenders.Chichester, Wiley.
9.
DolanB.CoidJ. (1993) Psychopathic and Antisocial Personality Disorders, Treatment and Research Issues.London, Gaskell, Royal College of Psychiatrists.
10.
GendersE.PlayerE. (1995) Grendon: a Study of a Therapeutic Prison.Oxford, Clarendon Press.
11.
GrannM. (1998) Personality Disorder and Violent Criminality: A Follow-Up Study with Special Reference to Psychopathy and Risk Assessment.Stockholm, Karolinska Institute, Department of Clinical Neuroscience and Family Medicine.
12.
GunnJ.RobertsonG.DellS.WayC. (1978) Psychiatric Aspects of Imprisonment.London, Academic Press.
13.
HareR.D. (1991) Manual for the Hare Psychopathy Checklist Revised.Toronto, Multi Health Systems.
14.
HareR.D.McPhersonL.M. (1984) Violent and aggressive behaviour by criminal psychopaths. Int. J. Law and Psychiat.7, 35–50.
15.
HarrisG.T.RiceM.E.CormierC.A. (1991) Psychopathy and Violent Recidivism. Law and Human Behaviour15, 625–37.
16.
HobsonJ.ShineJ. (1998) Measurement of psychopathy in a UK prison population referred for long-term psychotherapy. Brit. J. Criminol.38, 504–61.
17.
HobsonJ.ShineJ.RobertsR. (2000) How do psychopaths behave in a Prison Therapeutic Community. Psychology, Crime and Law6, 139–54.
18.
Home Office (1996) HM Prison Service Sex Offender Treatment Programme: Core Programme Manual.London, Home Office.
19.
HughesG.V.HogueT.E.HollinC.R.ChampionH.J. (1997) First-stage evaluation of a treatment programme for personality disordered offenders. J. Forens. Psychiat.8, 515–27.
20.
JonesM. (1962) Social Psychiatry in the Community, in Hospitals and in Prisons.Springfield, Illinois, Charles Thomas.
21.
JonesM. (1982) The Process of Change.Boston, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
22.
MarshallP. (1997) A Reconviction Study of HMP Grendon Therapeutic Community, Research Findings 53.London, UK Home Office Research and Statistics Directorate.
23.
McGuireJ., (ed.) (1995) What Works: reducing reoffending. Guidelines from research and practice.London, Wiley.
24.
MillerQ.J. (1982) Preliminary Considerations of Psychological Test/retest Scores and their Bearing upon Criminal Reconviction.Grendon Underwood, Grendon Psychology Unit Report, Series D, No. 13.
25.
NewtonM. (1973) Progress of follow-up Studies and Comparison with Non-patients carried out at HMP Oxford.Grendon Underwood, Grendon Psychology Unit Report, Series A, No. 15.
26.
NewtonM. (1998) Changes in measures of personality, hostility and locus of control during residence in a prison therapeutic community. Legal and Criminol. Psychol.3, 209–23.
27.
OgloffJ.P.RWongS.GreenwoodA. (1990) Treating Criminal Psychopaths in a Therapeutic Community Programme. Behav. Sci. and the Law8, 81–90.
28.
Prison Service (1995) Prison Service Discipline Manual.Prison Service.
29.
RossR.FabianoE. (1985) Time to Think: A cognitive model of delinquency presentation and offender rehabilitation.Johnson City, Institute of Social Sciences and Arts.
30.
SerinR. (1995) Treatment responsivity in criminal psychopaths. Forum on Corrections Research7, 23–6.
31.
ShineJ.HobsonJ. (1997) Construct validity of the Hare Psychopathy Checklist Revised. J. Forens. Psychiat.8, 546–61.
32.
SleapH. (1979) Goal attainment scaling. An introduction and some limited findings. In: ShineJ.ShineJ. (ed.) (2000) A Compilation of Grendon Research.HMP Grendon, Research and Development Department, pp. 173–82.
33.
WarrenF. (1994) What do we mean by a ‘Therapeutic Community’ for offenders?Therapeutic Communities15, 312–18.
34.
WongS. (1984) Criminal and Institutional Behaviours of Psychopaths. Programmes Branch Users Report.Canada, Ottowa, Ontario: Ministry of the Solicitor General of Canada.
