This study examines urban collective transport policy in the city planning of three European countries under the Socialist Bloc in the 1950s and 1960s. The main aim is to account for the success of the private car in approaches to urban infrastructure and to understand how this affected tramway system planning. This then leads to a new perspective in understanding the conflict between the adoption of transport vehicles: The diversity of argument in tramway planning has been analysed using official publications, professional literature, and the urban and transport plans of the three case study cities. It results that planning solutions prioritised more national and local conditions, their logic and the singularity of their characteristics over the specific principles related to the ideology of the communist regimes.
GARF, fund А314, inventory 3, file 4744, “Dokumenti po Razrabotke, Ispitaniyu i Vnedreniyu Novoi Tekhniki”, volume 2.
2.
GARF, fund А-314, inventory 3, file 8590, “Perepiska TK KPSS i Sovet Ministrov RSFSR po Voprosam tramvaino-trolleibusnogo Khozyaistva”, volume 4, 1967.
3.
Gosudarstvenni Archiv Ekonomiki, fund 5, inventory 5, file 69, “Proekt Postanovleniya Soveta Ministrov SSSR ob Uluchshenii Obslujivaniya Naseleniya Gorodskim Transportom”, 14 May 1963.
4.
Gosudarstvenni Arkhiv Rosiiskoi Federatcii (hereafter GARF), fund A-314, inventory 3, file 8589, “Perepiska TK KPSS i Sovet Ministrov RSFSR po Voprosam tramvaino-trolleibusnogo Khozyaistva”, volume 3, 1967.
5.
Magdeburg City Archive, Fotobestand Hochbauamt, 29273-75.
6.
Magdeburg City Archive, Kartensammlung, KS_I_277, Plan Magdeburg und Umgebung, June 1953.
7.
Magdeburg City Archive, 46_02326, Büro für Verkehrsplanung des Rates des Bezirkes Magdeburg, “Generalverkehrsplan Magdeburg”, 1969, 6.
8.
Magdeburg City Archive, Sammlung Lück, unknown photographer, 1970s.
9.
Ostrava city Archive (Archiv města Ostravy), Městský Národní Výbor Ostravy, 154. 24, W. Wolný, “Směrný Plán Města Ostravy: Doprava”, 1958–1960.
10.
State Archive of Oryol Region, fund P-15, inventory 2, file 41, “Spravka o Rabote Tramvaya v Gorode Orle”, 1956, 102.
11.
State Archive of Oryol Region, fund Р-2577, inventory 1, file 359, “O Razmeshenii v Plane Orla Stroitelstva na 1959–1965 gody”, 1959, 509, 514.
12.
State Archive of Oryol Region, fund Р-2577, inventory 1, file 450, “Upravlenie Glavnogo Arkhitektora Goroda Orla”, 1961, 36.
13.
State Archive of Oryol Region, fund 2577, inventory 1, file 457, “Zonalnoe Soveshanie po Voprosam Perspektiv Razvitiya Goroda Orla”, 23–24 June 1963.
14.
State Archive of Oryol Region, fund 7081, “Komsomolskaya street in the mid of the 1960s”.
15.
The German Federal Archives, fund DM1, inventory 51, file M306, Der Hauptabmessungen des Vierachsegen Strassenbahn Kurzgelenktriebwagen KT4D des Einer Wagenkastenlange 17.0 m (Praha: ČKD Tatra Smíchov, 1969).
16.
Thomas Adams, Recent Advances in Town Planning (New York NY: Macmillan Company, 1932), transl. L.M. Perchik, Noveishie Doctizheniya v Planirovke Gorodov (Moskva: Izdatelstvo Vsesoyuznoi Akademii Arkhitekturi, 1935), 211, 249.
17.
Akademiya Arkhitekturi SSSR, Planirovka i Zastroika Gorodov (Moskva: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatelstvo po Stroitelstvu i Arkhitekture, 1956), 72.
18.
Vladimir Aleksandrovich Cherepanov, Transport v Gradostroitelstve (Moskva: Izdatelstvo Literaturi po Stroitelstvu, 1964).
19.
Gerhard Bauer, Straßenbahn Archiv: Raum Cottbus, Magdeburg, Schwerin, Rostock(Berlin:
Verlag für Verkehrswesen, 1986), 48.
20.
Christoph Bernhardt,
“Längst Beerdigt und Doch Quicklebendig: Zur Widersprüchlichen Geschichte der ‘Autogerechten Stadt’”, Zeithistorische Forschungen/Studies in Contemporary History14 (2017), 526–40.
21.
Elke Beyer, “Planning for Mobility: Designing City Centres and New Towns in the USSR and the GDR in the 1960s”, in LewisH. Siegelbaum (ed.), The Socialist Car: Automobility in the Eastern Bloc (
Ithaca NY:
Cornell University Press, 2011), 71–91.
22.
Otto Blum, Gutachten Inwieweit ist der Ersatz von Strassenbahnen im Stadtinnern Durch Omnibus Zulässig? (Hannover: Technische Hochschule Hannover, approx. 1930), 37.
23.
Otto Blum, Städtebau, zweite, umgearbeitete Auflage (
Berlin:
Verlag von Julius, 1937), 230.
24.
Otto Blum, Hermann Potthoff and Kurt Risch, Straßenbahn und Omnibus im Stadtinnern (
Jena:
Verlag von Gustav Fischer in Jena, 1942), 6.
25.
Yves Boquet,
“The Renaissance of Tramways and Urban Redevelopment in France”, Miscellanea Geographica – Regional Studies on Development21:1 (2017), 5–18.
26.
Álvaro Costa and Ruben Fernandes,
“Urban Public Transport in Europe: Technology Diffusion and Market Organization”, Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice46:2 (2012), 269–84.
27.
Andrew H. Dawson, Planning in Eastern Europe (
New York NY:
Routledge Revivals, 2015), 300.
28.
Deutsche Bauakademie, Stadtzentren. Beitrage zur Umgestaltung und Neuplanung (
Berlin:
Deutsche Bauinformation, 1967), 83–84.
29.
Dopravní Podnik Města Ostravy, U Divadla Zd. Nejedlého, k 70 Výročí Založení Městske Dopravy v Ostravě (
Ostrava:
DPMO, 1969).
30.
Ivan Semyonovich Efremov, Troleibusy. Teoria, Konstrukciya i Raschet (
Moskva:
Vysshaya Shkola, 1969), 15.
31.
Martin Emanuel,
“Constructing the Cyclist: Ideology and Representations in Urban Traffic Planning in Stockholm, 1930–70”, The Journal of Transport History33:1 (2012), 67–91, here 159.
32.
György Enyedi,
“Specific Urbanization in East-Central Europe”, Geoforum21:2 (1990), 163–72, here 166.
33.
Thomas S. Fedor, Patterns of Urban Growth in the Russian Empire During the Nineteenth Century (
Chicago IL: The University of Chicago,
Department of Geography Research Paper, 1975), 175.
34.
Gregor Feindt, “Making and Unmaking Socialist Modernities: Seven Interventions into the Writing of Contemporary History on Central and Eastern Europe”, in Raphael Lutz and Doering-Manteuffel Anselm (eds), Nach dem Boom: Perspektiven auf die Zeitgeschichte seit 1970 (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 2012), 133–54.
35.
Hans Glissmeyer,
“Der städtische Verkehr – Eine Schwerpunktaufgabe für Forschung und Praxis”, Die Strasse10:1 (1969), 68.
36.
Antonín Honzik, Mezinárodní Konference o Vývoji Městské a Příměstské Kolejové Dopravy po Roce 1970 (Praha: ČKD Praha, 1967).
37.
Emanuel Hruška, Dopravní Síť v Krajinném Řešení (
Praha:
Ústav pro Stavbu Měst při M.A.P., 1934), 63.
38.
International Union of Architects (IUA),Construction and Reconstruction of Towns (
Moscow:
State Building and Architecture Publishing House, 1958), 12.
39.
František Jansa, Městské Dráhy Elektrické, Volume II (Bratislava: Vysoká Škola Dopravná v Žiline v Slovenskom Vydavateľstve Technickej Literatúry, 1967), 150, 247.
40.
Werner Kaleschky, Magdeburger Verkehrsanlagen (
Magdeburg:
Stadtplanungsamt, 1998), 46.
41.
Christopher Kopper, “Why the ‘Los Angelization’ of German Cities Did Not Happen: The German Perception of U.S. Traffic Planning and the Preservation of the German City”, in KopperChristopherMoraglioMassimo (eds), The Organization of Transport: A History of Users, Industry, and Public Policy (
New York NY:
Routledge, 2015), 108.
42.
Hans Krüger, Klaus-Jürgen Richter and Rudolf Stuhr, Der städtische Nahverkehr in der DDR (
Berlin:
Transpress, VEB für Verkehrswesen, 1961), 212.
43.
Alexandr Kulakov and Konstantin Trofimenko, “Transport Planning and Transport Modelling”, in BlinkinMikhailKonchevaElena (eds), Transport Systems of Russian Cities, Transportation Research, Economics and Policy(Cham:
Springer International Publishing AG, 2016), 1–37, here 12.
44.
P.A. Kurenkov and S.G. Kobzar, Transport pri Planirovke Gorodov (
Moskva & Leningrad:
Glavnaya Redakciya Stroitel’noi Literaturi, 1937).
45.
Landeshauptstadt Magdeburg, Stadtplanungsamt Magdeburg, Städtebau in Magdeburg 1945–1990. Planungen und Dokumente (
Magdeburg:
Landeshauptstadt Magdeburg, Büro für Öffentlichkeitsarbeit und Protokoll, 1998), 63.
46.
Fritz Lehner, “Straßenbahn und Omnibus im Stadtinnern”, Verkehrstechnik23:23 (1942), 337–9, here 337.
Heinz Michalk, “Einige Probleme der Generalbebauungsplanung in Magdeburg”, in Deutsche Bauakademie (ed.),Generalbebauungsplanung de Städte der DDR (
Berlin:
Deutsche Bauinformation, 1969), 52.
49.
Alois Mikuškovic, Technika Stavby Měst (
Praha:
Klub Architektů v Praze, 1933), 100.
50.
Jesús Mirás,
“The Spanish Tramway as a Vehicle for Urban Shaping: La Coruña, 1903–1962”, Journal of Transport History26:2 (2005), 20–37.
51.
Massimo Moraglio, “Shifting Transport Regimes: The Strange Case of Light Rail Revival”, in Christopher Kopper and Massimo Moraglio (eds), Organization of Transport: A History of Users, Industry and Public Policy (New York NY: Routledge International Studies in Business History, 2015), 155–72.
52.
Ondřej Mulíček and Daniel Seidenglanz, “Public Transport in Brno: From Socialist to Post-Socialist Rhythms”, in Tauri Tuvikene, Wladimir Sgibnev and Carola S. Neugebauer (eds), Post-Socialist Urban Infrastructures (London: Routledge, 2019), 158–77.
53.
Jiří Musil, “Why Socialist and Post-socialist Cities are Important for Forward Looking Urban Studies”, European Science Foundation Conference, Forward Look on Urban Science, Helsinki, 26–28 May 2005.
Dejan Petkov, “The Uneven Path of Tramway Development in England”, in PetkovDejan (ed.), Tramway Renaissance in Western Europe (
Wiesbaden:
Springer VS, 2020), 229–95.
60.
Vyacheslav Konstantinovich Petrov and Vasilii Georgievich Sosyantz, Gorodskoi Transport (
Moskva & Leningrad:
Izdatelstvo Narkomjoza RSFSR, 1939), 16–17.
61.
Ivan Plicka and Jaroslav Vandas, “Betreffend Stadtverkehrsmittel – Straßenbahnen und Obusse”, Internationales Symposium, Prag, 19–27 Juni 1965.
62.
Alexei Aleksandrovich Polyakov, Organizatziya Dvijeniya i Planirovka Ulitc (Moskva: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatelstvo Literatury po Stroitelstvu i Arkhitekture, 1953), 236.
63.
Colin G. Pooley and Jean Turnbull,
“Coping with Congestion: Responses to Urban Traffic Problems in British Cities c.1920–1960”, Journal of Historical Geography31 (2005), 78–93.
64.
John Pucher,
“Capitalism, Socialism, and Urban Transportation: Policies and Travel Behavior in the East and West”, Journal of the American Planning Association56:3 (1990), 278–96.
65.
Bodo-Lutz Schmidt,
“Intensivierung der Instandhaltungsprozesse an Straßenbahn Fahrzeugen”, Kraftverkehr9 (1977), 166–67, here 166.
66.
Barbara Schmucki, “Cities as Traffic Machines: Transport and the City After World War II”, in DivallColinBondWinstan (eds), Suburbanizing the Masses: Public Transport and Urban Development in Historical Perspective (
Aldershot:
Ashgate, 2003), 149–71.
67.
Barbara Schmucki,“Fashion and Technological Change Tramways in Germany After 1945”, Journal of Transport History31:1 (2010), 1–24.
68.
Iliya Vladimirovich Shpakov,
“Istoriya Proektirovaniya Otechestvennikh Sochlenennikh Tramvainikh Vagonov na Ust-Katavskom Vagonostroitelnom Zavode imeni S. M. Kirova”,Gramota4:71 (2013), 212–14.
69.
Iliya Vladimirovich Shpakov and Pavel Vladimirovich Zyuzin, “Sostoyanie Otrasli Gorodskogo Elektrotransporta v RSFSR v konce 1980: Problemi y Perspektivi”, in A. Tretyakov (ed.), Kraevedcheskie Zapiski, Sbornik Statei (Kursk: Investsfera, 2016), 61–68.
70.
Andrei Evgenievich Stramentov and Mikhail Samuilovich Fishelson, Gorodskoe Dvijenie (Moskva: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatelstvo Literature po Stroitelstvu, Arkhitekture i Stroitelnym Materialam, 1963), 32–40.
71.
Sergei Tarkhov, Empire of the Trolleybus, Volume 1, Russia (London: Rapid Transit, 2000).
72.
Sergei Tarkhov, Istoriya Orlovskogo Tramvaya Unpublished book, (Orel, 1998), 192.
73.
Kevin D. Tennant,
“Profit or Utility Maximizing? Strategy, Tactics and the Municipal Tramways of York, c. 1918–1935”, Journal of Management History23:4 (2017), 401–22.
74.
Harmut H. Topp, “Renaissance of Trams in Germany – Five Case Studies”, Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers: Journal of Rail and Rapid Transit, Part F 212:3 (1998), 223–33.
75.
Jaroslav Vaněček, Stavba Měst (
Praha:
České Vysoké Učení Technické, 1934), 79.
76.
Volksstimme, “Streit um die Strassenbahn in der Jakobstraße”, 8 November 1961.
77.
Vsesoyuznoe Soveshanie po Gradostroitelstvu SSSR (Moskva: Gosudarstvennoe Izdatelstvo Literatury po Stroitelstvu, Arkhitekture i Stroitelnym Materialam, 7–10 June 1960), 120, 140.
78.
Henry Watson, Street Traffic Flow (London: Chapman and Hall, 1933), transl. N.V. Reshetnikov and M.P. Sheremetievskii, Ulichnoe Dvijenie (Moskva & Leningrad: Gostranstechizdat, 1938).
79.
Jean-Pierre Wolff,
“Les Tramways En Allemagne: Permanence et Adaptabilité des Réseaux de Tramways”,Transports Urbains 1:120 (2012), 10, 62.
80.
Glenn Yago, The Decline of Transit. Urban Transportation in German and US Cities 1900–1970 (
Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2006).
81.
Kimberly E. Zarecor,
“Infrastructural Thinking: Urban Housing in Former Czechoslovakia from the Stalin Era to EU Accession”, Architecture Publications9 (2013), 73.
82.
Michaela Závodná, Koleje a Město. Problematika Městské Kolejové Dopravy ve Vybraných Moravských a Slezských Městech v Letech 1850–1918 (
Ostrava:
Bohumír Němec – Veduta, 2016), 161–64.
83.
Richard Zelezny, “Tramway-oriented Development: What Results in What Context? Comparative Approach between France and the Czech Republic”, Conference, Transportation Research Arena, Paris – La Défense, France, April 2014.
Abram Khaimovich Zilbertal, Problemy Gorodskogo Passajirskogo Transporta (
Moskva & Leningrad:
Gosudarstvennoe Transportnoe Izdatelstvo, 1937), 232–34.
86.
Karel Zmija, “Doprava a Komunikace v Ostravě”, in BartošJosefDohnalMiloň (eds), Ostrava: Sborník Příspěvků k Dějinám a Výstavbě Města (
Ostrava:
Profil, 1985), 303.
87.
Karel Zmija, “Reshenie Problemi Gorodskogo Transporta v Ostrave v Budushie Gody” [International Conference on the Development of Urban and Suburban Transport in the Period After the 1970] (Praha: ČKD Praha, 1967), 9.
