Computerized Vs. Conventional Remedial Instruction for Learning-Disabled Pupils

Abstract

Recent advances in microelectronics and computer software have rekindled enthusiasm for applications of computer-assisted instruction (CAI). The more salient features of CAI are highly compatible with the major instructional and curricular principles recommended for learning-disabled children. To assess the relative effectiveness of computerized over conventional remedial methods with handicapped learners, 205 learning-disabled first- through sixth-grade children were assigned to either a mathematics CAI or spelling CAI treatment group or to a conventional-instruction control group. After 1 school year, posttest achievement indices were gathered through individually administered and group-administered standardized tests. Posttest performance was covaried for initial group differences in pretest achievement, IQ, and time in remedial instruction. Separate repeated-measures analyses for individually assessed and group-assessed achievement indicated that gains for the 3 groups were essentially equivalent. It was found that certain popular achievement measures may be insensitive to achievement gains in the learning disabled.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Atkinson, R.C. Computerized instruction and the learning process. American Psychologist, 1968, 23, 225-229.

Caldwell, R.M. , & Rizza, P.J. A computer-based system for reading instruction for adult non-readers . AEDS Journal, 1979, 12, 155-162.

Chiang, A. Demonstration of the use of computer-assisted instruction with handicapped children. Arlington, Va.: RMC Research Corp., 1978. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 166 913)

Cook, T.D. , & Campbell, D.T. Quasi-experimentation: Design & analysis issues for field settings. Chicago: Rand McNally, 1979.

Edwards, J. , Norton, S. , Taylor, S. , Weiss, M. , & Dusseldorp, R. How effective is CAI? A review of the research . Educational Leadership, 1975, 11, 147-153.

Gearheart, B.R. Teaching the learning disabled. St. Louis: Mosby, 1976.

Greenwald, A.G. Within-subjects designs: To use or not to use? Psychological Bulletin, 1976, 83, 314-330.

Hallworth, H.J. , & Brebrer, A. Computer assisted instruction and the mentally handicapped: Some recent developments . AEDS Proceedings, 1978, 131-134.

Jamison, D. , Suppes, P. , & Wells, S. The effectiveness of alternative instructional media: A survey. Review of Educational Research, 1974, 44, 1-67.

10.

Nelon, F.M. An evaluation of computer-assisted vocabulary instruction with mentally retarded children. Syracuse, N.Y.: Syracuse City School District, 1972. ( ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 090 964)

11.

Reynolds, C. , & Gentile, J.R. Measuring growth in education. Psychology in the Schools , 1978, 15, 62-65.

12.

Suppes, P. , Fletcher, J.D. , Zanotti, M. , Lorton, P.V. , & Searle, B.W. Evaluation of computer-assisted instruction in elementary mathematics for hearing-impaired students. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford Institute for Mathematical Studies in Social Science , 1973. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 084 722)

13.

Thorndike, R.L. , & Hagen, E.P. Measurement and evaluation in psychology and education (4th ed.). New York: Wiley, 1977.

14.

Visonhaler, J.F. , & Bass, R.K. A summary of ten major studies on CAI drill and practice. Educational Technology, 1972, 12, 29-32.

15.

Vitello, S.J. , & Bruce, P. Computer-assisted instructional programs to facilitate mathematical learning among the handicapped. Journal of Computer-Based Instruction , 1977, 4, 26-29.

16.

Wallace, G. , & McLaughlin, J.A. Learning disabilities: Concepts and characteristics . Columbus, Ohio: Merrill, 1979.

17.

Watkins, M.W. Microcomputer-assisted instruction with learning disabled students . Proceedings of the ninth annual Math/ Science Conference - Arizona State University, 1981, 2, 2.164-2. 172.

18.

Watkins, M.W. , Johnson, L. , & Bloom, L. The Math Machine. Phoenix, Ariz.: SouthWest EdPsych Services, 1981. (a)

19.

Watkins, M.W. , Johnson, L. , & Bloom, L. The Spelling Machine. Phoenix, Ariz.: SouthWest EdPsych Services, 1981. (b)

20.

Wiederhold, J.L. , Hammill, D.H. , & Brown, V. The resource teacher: A guide for effective practice. Boston: Allyn & Bacon, 1978.

21.

Chambers, J.A. , & Bork, A. Computer assisted learning in U.S. secondary/elementary schools (Research Report No. 80-03). Fresno: California State University, July 1980.

22.

Winters, J.J. , Hoats, D.L. , & East, M.J. The instructional use of CAI in the education of the mentally retarded . Paper presented at the World Congress on Future Special Education , Stirling, Scotland , June-July 1978.

23.

Sandals, L.H. Computer assisted applications for learning with special needs children. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, April 1979.