This study synthesized the literature on the rates of referral for intervention or assessment of students from three racial groups: Caucasian, African American, and Hispanic. Ten studies, published or unpublished, that presented frequency counts for the population and the referred sample for at least one school district yielded 44 comparisons. For comparisons between African American and Caucasian students, the mean risk ratios comparing the referral rates were significantly different from zero. No significant differences were found between the referral rates of Hispanic students and Caucasian students. Implications, limitations, and directions for future research are presented.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
References marked with an asterisk (*) indicate studies included in the meta-analysis .
2.
Anderson, J., Hollinger, D., & Conaty, J. (Spring 1993). Re-examining the relationship between school poverty and student achievement. ERSSpectrum, 11(1), 21—31.
3.
Anderson, M.G. (1994). Perceptions about behavioral disorders in African American cultures and communities. In R. Peterson & S. Ishii-Jordan (Eds.), Multicultural issues in the education of students with behavioral disorders (pp. 93—104). Cambridge, MA: Brookline Books.
4.
*Andrews, T.J., Wisniewski, J.J., & Mulick, J.A. (1997). Variables influencing teachers' decisions to refer children for school psychological assessment services. Psychology in the Schools, 34, 239—244.
5.
*Argulewicz, E., & Sanchez, D. (1983). The special education evaluation process as a moderator of false positives. Exceptional Children, 49, 452—454.
6.
Artiles, A.L., & Trent, S.C. (1994). Overrepresentation of minority students in special education: A continuing debate. The Journal of Special Education , 27, 410—437.
7.
Assistance to states for the education of children with disabilities: Final regulations, 64Fed. Reg.12, 405—412, 672 (March 12, 1999).
8.
Bahr, M.W., Fuchs, D., Stecker, P.M., & Fuchs, L.S. (1991). Are teachers' perceptions of difficult-to-teach students racially biased?School Psychology Review, 20, 599—608.
9.
Berlin, J.A., Laird, N.M., Sacks, H.S., & Chalmers, T.C. (1989). A comparison of statistical methods for combining event rates from clinical trials. Statistics in Medicine, 8, 141—151.
10.
Carlson, P.E., & Stephens, T.M. (1986). Cultural bias and identification of behaviorally disordered children. Behavioral Disorders , 11, 191—199.
11.
Chinn, P.C., & Hughes, S. (1987). Representation of minority students in special education classes. Remedial and Special Education, 8(4), 41—46.
12.
Collier, C., & Hoover, J.J. (1987). Sociocultural considerations when referring minority children for learning disabilities. Learning DisabilitiesFocus, 3(1), 39—45.
13.
Coutinho, M.J., & Oswald, D.P. (1998). Ethnicity and special education research: Identifying questions and methods. Behavioral Disorders, 24, 66—73.
14.
Crew, R.F. (1999). School based budget reports: Fiscal year 1998-1999 . New York: Board of Education of the City of New York.
15.
Darley, J.M., & Gross, P.H. (1983). A hypothesis-confirming bias in labeling effects . Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 44, 249—256.
16.
Del'Homme, M., Kasari, C., Forness, S.R., & Bagley, R. (1996). Prereferral intervention and students at-risk for emotional or behavioral disorders. Education and Treatment of Children, 19(3), 272—285.
17.
Diana v. State Board of Education, No. C-7037 RFP, 1970 U. S. Dist. Court, Northern District of California, consent decree.
18.
*Diment, K.A. (1998). Identification of seriously emotionally disturbed students: An ethnic comparison of maladaptive behaviors at both point of referral and eligibility (Doctoral dissertation, University of Minnesota , 1998). Dissertation Abstracts International , 59, 2341.
19.
Dunn, L.M. (1968). Special education for the mildly mentally retarded: Is much of it justifiable?Exceptional Children, 23, 5—21.
20.
Dunn, L.M., & Markwardt, F.C. , Jr. (1970). Peabody individual achievement test. Circle Pines, MN: American Guidance Service.
21.
*Farrell, W., Olson, J., Malloy, W., & Boykin, W. (1983). Discrimination in educational placement and referral . Integrated Education, 21, 120—123.
22.
Finn, J.D. (1982). Patterns in special education placement as revealed by the OCR survey. In K. A. Heller, W. Holtzman, & S. Messick (Ed.), Placing children in special education: A strategy for equity (pp. 322—381). Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
23.
Fleiss, J.L. (1994). Measures of effect size for categorical data. In H. Cooper & L. V. Hedges (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis (pp. 245— 260). New York: Russell Sage Foundation .
24.
Forness, S.R., & Knitzer, J. (1992). A new proposed definition and terminology to replace “serious emotional disturbance” in Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. School Psychology Review, 21, 12—20.
25.
Gerber, M.M., & Semmel, M.I. (1984). Teacher as imperfect test: Reconceptualizing the referral process. Educational Psychologist, 19(3), 137—148.
26.
Glass, G.V., & Hopkins, K.D. (1996). Statistical methods in education and psychology (3rd ed.). Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
27.
Gnys, J.A., Willis, W.G., & Faust, D. (1995). School psychologists' diagnosis of learning disabilities: A study of illusory correlation. Journal of School Psychology , 33(1), 59—73.
28.
*Gottlieb, J., & Alter, M. (1994). An analysis of referrals, placement, and progress of children with disabilities who attend New York City public schools. New York: New York University. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 414372)
29.
Gregory, M. (1977). Sex bias in school referrals. Journal of School Psychology, 15, 5—8.
30.
Gresham, F.M., MacMillan, D.L., & Bocian, K.M. (1997). Teachers as “tests”: Differential validity of teacher judgments in identifying students at-risk for learning difficulties. School Psychology Review, 26, 47—60.
31.
Gresham, F.M., Reschly, D.J., & Carey, M.P. (1987). Teachers as “tests”: Classification accuracy and concurrent validation in the identification of learning disabled children. School Psychology Review, 16, 543—553.
32.
Guadalupe Organization v. Tempe Elementary School District No. 3, No. 71-435, 1973. U. S. Dist. Court, District of Arizona, consent decree.
33.
Hale-Benson, J. (1986). Black children: Their roots, culture, and learning styles. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
34.
Harry, B. (1992). Cultural diversity, families, and the special education system: Communication for empowerment. New York : Teachers College Press.
35.
Harry, B., & Anderson, M.G. (1994). The disproportionate placement of African American males in special education programs: A critique of the process. Journal of Negro Education, 63, 602—619.
36.
Hecht, S.A., & Greenfield, D.B. (2001). Comparing the predictive validity of first grade teacher ratings and reading-related tests on third grade levels of reading skills in young children exposed to poverty. School Psychology Review, 30, 50—69.
37.
Heller, K. A., Holtzman, W. H., & Messick, S. (Eds.). (1982). Placing children in special education: A strategy for equity. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
38.
Hilliard, A.G. (1992). Behavioral style, culture, and teaching and learning . Journal of Negro Education, 61, 370—377.
39.
Hodgkinson, H.L. (1995). What should we call people? Race, class, and the Census for 2000. Phi Delta Kappan, 77, 173—179.
40.
Hyde, E.M. (1975). School psychologist referrals in an inner-city school. Psychology in the Schools, 12, 412—420.
41.
Individuals with Disabilities Education Act of 1990, 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq .
42.
Kastner, J., & Gottlieb, J. (1991). Classification of children in special education: Importance of pre-assessment information. Psychology in the Schools, 28, 19—27.
43.
Kauffman, J.M. (1999). How we prevent the prevention of emotional and behavioral disorders. Exceptional Children, 65, 448—468.
44.
Kavale, K.A., & Forness, S.R. (1999). Effectiveness of special education. In C. R. Reynolds & T. B. Gutkin (Eds.), The handbook of school psychology (3rd ed., pp. 984—1024). New York: Wiley.
45.
Kennedy, M.M., Jung, R.K., & Orland, M.E. (1986). Poverty, achievement, and the distribution of compensatory education services. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 293902)
46.
Kleinbaum, D.G., Kupper, L.L., Muller, K.E., & Nizam, A. (1998). Applied regression analysis and other multivariable methods (3rd ed.). Pacific Grove, CA: Duxbury Press.
47.
Lambert, M.C., Puig, M., Rowan, G.T., Lyubansky, M., & Winfrey, T. (1998). Adult perspectives on behavior and emotional problems in African American children. Manuscript submitted for publication.
48.
Langer, E.J., & Abelson, R.P. (1972). A patient by any other name . . .: Clinical group differences in labeling bias. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 42, 4—9.
49.
Lanier, J.E. (1975). Teachers' attitudes toward students'race, socio-economic status, sex, and classroom behavior on their referral to an educable mentally retarded program (EMR). Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Florida, Gainesville.
50.
*Lietz, J., & Gregory, M. (1978). Pupil race and sex as determinants of office and exceptional educational referrals. Education Research Quarterly , 3, 61—66.
MacMillan, D.L., & Reschly, D.J. (1998). Overrepresentation of minority students: The case for greater specificity of the variables examined. The Journal of Special Education, 32, 15—24.
53.
*Masica, K. (1996). The relationships between gender, race, behavior, abilityachievement discrepancies, and eligibility for learning disabilities services among urban elementary students (Doctoral dissertation, Ohio State University, 1996). Dissertation Abstracts International, 57, 4261.
54.
McIntyre, T. (1992). A primer on cultural diversity for educators. Multicultural Forum, 1(1), 6 & 13.
55.
Meece, J.L., & Kurtz-Costes, B. (2001). Introduction: The schooling of ethnic minority children and youth. Educational Psychologist , 36, 1—7.
56.
Mehan, H., Hertweck, A., & Miehls, J.L. (1986). Handicapping the handicapped. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
57.
Mercer, C.D., Jordan, L., Allsopp, D.H., & Mercer, A.R. (1996). Learning disabilities definitions and criteria used by state education departments. Learning Disability Quarterly , 19, 217—232.
58.
Mercer, J.R. (1973). Labeling the mentally retarded. Berkeley: University of California Press.
59.
Nisbett, R.E., & Ross, L. (1980). Human inference: Strategies and shortcomings of social judgment. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
60.
O'Reilly, C., Northcraft, G.B., & Sabers, D. (1989). The confirmation bias in special education eligibility decisions. School Psychology Review, 18, 126—135.
61.
Oswald, D.P. (1995). Identification of special education students with mental retardation: Correlates of state child-count data. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 4, 389—397.
62.
Oswald, D.P., Coutinho, M.J., Best, A.M., & Singh, N.N. (1999). Ethnic representation in special education: The influence of school-related economic and demographic variables. The Journal of Special Education, 32, 194—206.
63.
Patton, J.M. (1997). Disproportionate representation in gifted programs: Best practices for meeting this challenge. In A. J. Artiles & G. Zamora-Duran (Eds.), Reducing disproportionate representation of culturally diverse students in special and gifted education (pp. 59—86). Reston, VA: The Council for Exceptional Children.
64.
Patton, J.M. (1998). The disproportionate representation of African Americans in special education: Looking behind the curtain for understanding and solutions. The Journal of Special Education, 32, 25—31.
65.
Puig, M., Lambert, M.C., Rowan, G.T., Winfrey, T., Lyubansky, M., Hannah, S.D., et al. (1999). Behavioral and emotional problems among Jamaican and African American children, ages 6 to 11: Teacher reports versus direct observations. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders , 7, 240—250.
66.
Raudenbush, S.W. (1994). Random effects models. In H. Cooper & L. V. Hedges (Eds.), The handbook of research synthesis (pp. 301—322). New York: Russel Sage Foundation.
67.
Reschly, D.J. (1988). Minority mild mental retardation overrepresentation: Legal issues, research findings, and reform trends. In M. Wang, M. Reynolds, & H. Walberg (Eds.), Handbook of special education: Research and practice (Vol. 2, pp. 23—41). Oxford, England: Pergamon.
68.
Reschly, D.J. (1997). Disproportionate minority representation in general and special education: Patterns, issues, and alternatives. Des Moines: Iowa Department of Education.
69.
Reschly, D.J., & Wilson, M.S. (1990). Cognitive processing vs. traditional intelligence: Diagnostic utility, intervention implications, and treatment validity. School Psychology Review, 19, 443—458.
70.
Rong, X.L. (1996). Effects of race and gender on teachers' perceptions of the social behavior of elementary students. Urban Education , 31, 261-290.
71.
Rosenthal, R. (1991). Teacher expectancy effects: A brief update 25 years after the Pygmalion experiment. Journal of Research in Education, 1, 3—12.
72.
Serwatka, T.S., Deering, S., & Grant, P. (1995). Disproportionate representation of African Americans in emotionally handicapped classes. Journal of Black Studies , 25, 492—506.
73.
Serwatka, T.S., Dove, T., & Hodge, W. (1986). Black students in special education: Issues and implications for community involvement. NegroEducation Review , 37, 17—26.
74.
Shinn, M.R., Tindal, G.A., & Spira, D.A. (1987). Special education referrals as an index of teacher tolerance: Are teachers imperfect tests?Exceptional Children , 54, 32—40.
75.
Snyder, M., & Gangestad, S. (1983). Hypothesis-testing processes. In J. Harvey, W. Ickes, & P. Kidd (Eds.), New directions in attribution research (pp. 43—65). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
76.
*Speece, D., & Cooper, D. (1990). Ontogeny of school failure: Classification of first-grade children. American Educational Research Journal , 27, 119—140.
77.
Spring, J.H. (1997). The American school 1642-1996 (4th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
78.
*Tyler, D., & Manzo, D. (1999). Intervention/prevention grant evaluation 1996-1998 (Report No. E&R 99.16). Raleigh, NC: Wake County Public Schools System. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED 431811)
79.
U.S. Department of Education. (2000). Twenty-second annual report to Congress on the implementation of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. Washington, DC: Author.
80.
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Civil Rights. (1994). Elementary and secondary school civil rights compliance report. Washington, DC: Author.
81.
U.S. Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement. (1998). The schools and sta fing survey (SASS) and teacher followup survey (TFS) CD-ROM: Electronic codebook and public-use data for three cycles of SASS and TFS [CD-ROM data file]. Washington, DC: National Center for Educational Statistics . (NCES 98-312)
82.
Wechsler, D. (1974). Wechsler intelligence scale for children—Revised . New York: Psychological Corp.
83.
Weisz, J.R., Suwanlert, S., Chaiyasit, W., Weiss, B., Achenbach, T.M., & Trevathan, D. (1988). Epidemiology of behavioral and emotional problems among Thai and American children: Teacher reports for ages 6-11. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 30, 471—484.
84.
*Wisniewski, J.J., Andrews, T.J., & Mulick, J.A. (1995). Objective and subjective factors in the disproportionate referral of children for academic problems. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 63, 1032—1036.
85.
Ysseldyke, J.E., & Algozzine, B. (1983). LD or not LD: That's not the question!Journal of Learning Disabilities, 16, 29-31.
86.
Zucker, S.H., & Prieto, A.G. (1977). Ethnicity and teacher bias in educational decisions. InstructionalPsychology, 4, 2—5.
