The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of critical thinking instruction on music listening skills of fifth-grade students as measured by written responses to music listening. The researcher compared instruction that included opportunities for critical thinking (Critical Thinking Instruction, CTI) with parallel instruction without critical thinking opportunities (Activity-Based Instruction, ABI). The same music teacher delivered both instructional treatments concurrently in a series of sixteen 45-minute classroom lessons. Two randomly assigned, intact classes of participants (n = 41 and 40) made up the CTI and ABI treatment groups, respectively. Three independent judges scored participants’ pretest and posttest responses using a researcher-designed instrument. Using a multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA), the researcher found a significant test by treatment interaction. The post hoc analysis indicated that while the CTI participants scored higher on the posttest as compared with the pretest, ABI participants demonstrated no significant differences by test. Readers should note the larger than expected standard deviations when considering the positive effects of the CTI treatment. Implications include recommendations for future research and for designing music listening lessons to incorporate critical thinking skills in classroom music instruction.
AbeJ. (2009). Words that predict outstanding performance. Journal of Research in Personality, 43, 528–531. doi:10.1016/j.jrp.2009.01.010
2.
AndersonL. W.KrathwohlD. R. (Eds.). (2001). A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. New York, NY: Longman.
3.
BailinS. (1998). Critical thinking in drama education. Research in Drama Education, 3, 145–153. doi:10.1080/1356978980030202
4.
BambergerJ. (1991). The mind behind the musical ear. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
5.
BambergerJ. (2000). Developing musical intuitions. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
6.
BeethovenJ.DavidsonJ.Nadon-GabrionC. (1988). World of music. Morristown, NJ: Silver Burdett and Ginn.
7.
BlairD. V. (2007). Musical maps as narrative inquiry. International Journal of Education & the Arts, 8. Retrieved January 4, 2008, from http://www.ijea.org/v8n15/
8.
BlairD. V. (2008). Do you hear what I hear? Musical maps and felt pathways of musical understanding. Visions of Research in Music Education, 11. Retrieved May 14, 2009, from http://www-usr.rider.edu/~vrme/v11n1/index
9.
BloomB. S. (1956). A taxonomy of educational objectives. New York, NY: Longmans.
10.
Boal-PalheirosG. M.HargreavesD. J. (2001). Listening to music at home and at school. British Journal of Music Education, 18, 103–118. doi:10.1017/S0265051701000213
11.
BrophyT. S. (2000). Assessing the developing child musician. Chicago, IL: GIA Publications.
12.
BundraJ. I. (1993). A study of music listening processes through the verbal reports of school-aged children (Doctoral dissertation, Northwestern University, 1993). Dissertation Abstracts International, 55, 01A.
13.
CampbellP. S.Scott-KassnerC. (2006). Music in childhood. Stamford, CT: Schirmer.
14.
CassidyJ. W. (2001). Listening maps: Undergraduate students’ ability to interpret various iconic representations. Update: Applications of Research in Music Education, 19, 15–19. doi:10.1177/87551233010190020104
15.
ChoksyL.AbramsonR. M.GillespieA. E.WoodsD.YorkF. (2001). Teaching music in the twenty-first century. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
16.
CrookE.ReimerB.WalkerD. S. (1981). Silver Burdett music. Morristown, NJ: Silver Burdett.
17.
D’AngeloE. (1971). The teaching of critical thinking. Amsterdam: B. R. Bruner, N. V.
18.
DavidsonL.ScrippL. (1988). Young children’s musical representations: Windows on cognition. In SlobodaJ. A. (Ed.), Generative processes in music: The psychology of performance, improvisation, and composition (pp. 195–230). Oxford: Clarendon Press.
19.
EnnisR. H. (1962). A concept of critical thinking. Harvard Educational Review, 32, 81–111.
20.
EnnisC. (1991). Discrete thinking skills in two teachers’ physical education classes. The Elementary School Journal, 91, 473–486. doi:10.1086/461670
21.
FinnasL. (1989). How can musical preferences be modified? A research review. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 102, 1–59.
22.
FlowersP. J. (1984). Attention to elements of music and effect of instruction in vocabulary on written descriptions of music by children and undergraduates. Psychology of Music, 12, 17–24. doi:10.1177/0305735684121002
23.
FlowersP. J. (1990). Listening: The key to describing music. Music Educators Journal, 77, 21–23. doi:10.2307/3397876
24.
FlowersP. J. (2000). The match between music excerpts and written descriptions by fifth and sixth graders. Journal of Research in Music Education, 48, 262–277. doi:10.2307/3345398
25.
FlowersP. J. (2002). What was that? Talking about what we hear in music. Update, 21, 42–51.
26.
FowlerC. (1996). Strong arts, strong schools. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
27.
FrithS. (2007). Taking popular music seriously. Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing.
28.
GallM. D.WardB. A.BerlinerD. C.CahenL. S.WinneP. H.ElashoffJ. D.StantonG. C. (1978). Effects of questioning techniques and recitation on student learning. American Educational Research Journal, 15, 175–199. doi:10.2307/1162459
29.
HaackP. (1969). A study in the development of music listening skills of secondary school students. Journal of Research in Music Education, 17, 193–201. doi:10.2307/3344325
30.
HaackP. (1980). The behavior of music listeners. In HodgesD. A. (Ed.), Handbook of music psychology (pp. 141–182). Lawrence, KS: National Association for Music Therapy.
31.
HaackP. (1992). The acquisition of music listening skills. In ColwellR. (Ed.), Handbook of research on music learning and teaching (pp. 451–465). New York, NY: Schirmer Books.
32.
HaganM. T. (1971). The structural method of teaching music listening, grades kindergarten through nine (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Washington University.
33.
HalpernD. F. (1998). Teaching critical thinking for transfer across domains. Dispositions, skills, structure training, and metacognitive monitoring. American Psychologist, 53, 449–455. doi:10.1037//0003–066X.53.4.449
34.
HartshornW. C. (1957). The role of listening. In NelsonH. (Ed.), Basic concepts in music education: 57th yearbook of the National Society of the Study of Education (pp. 261–291). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago.
35.
HeddenS. (1981). Music listening skills and music listening preferences. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 65, 16–26.
36.
HeddenS. (1990). What have we learned about building student interest?Music Educators Journal, 77, 33–35. doi:10.2307/3397879
37.
HerbergerR. (1983). Presenting a method of analyzing mental and emotional processes in secondary school students while they are listening to music. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 75, 40–47.
38.
HuntM. (1982, May12). Do you know how you think?Minneapolis Star and Tribune, p. 13A.
39.
JohnsonD. C. (2003a). Fifth-grade instrumentalists’ descriptions of music. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 158, 81–95.
40.
JohnsonD. C. (2003b). The effect of critical thinking instruction in music listening on fifth-grade students’ verbal descriptions of music (Doctoral dissertation, University of Arizona, 2003). Dissertation Abstracts International, 65, 01A.
41.
JohnsonD. C. (2006). Listening and thinking: A pilot study. Visions of Research in Music Education, 7. Retrieved January 4, 2008, from http://users.rider.edu/~vrme/v7n1/index.htm
42.
KahnJ.TobinR.MasseyA.AndersonJ. (2007). Measuring emotional expression with the Linguistic Inquiry and Word Count. The American Journal of Psychology, 120, 263–286. doi:10.2307/20445398
43.
KerchnerJ. L. (2000). Children’s verbal, visual, and kinesthetic responses: Insight into their music listening experience. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 146, 31–50.
44.
KerchnerJ. L. (2005). A world to know and feel: Exploring children’s verbal, visual, and kinesthetic responses to music. In MansM.LeungB. (Eds.), Music in schools for all children: From research to effective practice. Proceedings of the 14th International Seminar of the Music in the Schools and Teacher Education Commission. Granada, Spain: University of Granada Press.
45.
KerchnerJ. L. (2009). Drawing middle-schoolers’ attention to music. In KerchnerJ.AbrilC. (Eds.), Music experience throughout our lives (pp. 183–198). Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
46.
KimJ.C.S. (1993). The art of creative critical thinking. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
47.
KnowlesM. (1980). The modern practice of adult education (Rev. ed.). Chicago, IL: Follett.
48.
KurfissJ. G. (1988). Critical thinking: Theory, research, practice, and possibilities (Report No. 2). Washington, DC: Association for the Study of Higher Education. (ASHE-ERIC Higher Education)
49.
LevinowitzL. M. (1989). Informal music instruction as readiness for learning sequence activities. In WaltersD. L.TaggartC. C. (Eds.), Readings in music learning theory (pp. 74–83). Chicago, IL: GIA Publications.
50.
MENC–The National Association for Music Education. (1994). The school music program: A new vision. Reston, VA: Author.
51.
MeyersC. (1986). Teaching students to think critically. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
52.
NorrisN. D. (2004). The promise and failure of progressive education. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Education.
53.
O’BrienJ. P. (1987). The listening experience. New York, NY: Schirmer Books.
54.
OlsonI. (2000). The arts and critical thinking in American education. Westport, CT: Bergin & Garvey.
55.
PaulR. W. (1993). Critical thinking: How to prepare students for a rapidly changing world. Santa Rosa, CA: Foundation for Critical Thinking.
56.
PerskyH. R.SandeneB. A.AskewJ. M. (1998). The NAEP 1997 arts report card. Washington, DC: Office of Educational Research and Improvement, National Center for Education Statistics, Department of Education.
57.
PetressK. (2004). Critical thinking: An extended definition. Education, 124, 461–466.
58.
RedfieldD. L.RousseauE. W. (1981). A meta-analysis of experimental research on teacher questioning behavior. Review of Education Research, 51, 237–245. doi:10.2307/1170197
59.
ReeseS. (1980). Polanyi’s tacit knowing and music education. Journal of Aesthetic Education, 14, 75–89. doi:10.2307/3332452
60.
ReimerB. (2003). A philosophy of music education: Advancing the vision (3rd ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
61.
RichardsonC. P. (1998). The roles of the critical thinker in the music classroom. In WoodfordP. G. (Ed.), Studies in music: Vol. 17. Critical thinking in music: Theory and practice (pp. 107–120). Ontario, Canada: The University of Western Ontario.
62.
RodriguezC. X.WebsterP. R. (1997). Development of children’s verbal interpretative responses to music listening. Bulletin of the Council for Research in Music Education, 134, 9–30.
63.
SheldonD.DeNardoG. (2005). Comparisons of higher-order thinking skills among prospective freshmen and upper-level preservice music education majors. Journal of Research in Music Education, 53, 40–50. doi:10.2307/3345605
64.
SimsW. (1990). Sound approaches to elementary music listening. Music Educators Journal, 77, 38–42. doi:10.2307/3397880
65.
SmialekT. W.BoburkaR. R. (2006). The effect of cooperative listening exercises on the critical listening skills of college music appreciation students. Journal of Research in Music Education, 54, 57–72. doi:10.2307/3653455
66.
SternbergR. J. (1985). Critical thinking: Its nature, measurement, and improvement. In LinkF. R. (Ed.), Essays on the intellect (pp. 45–65). Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum.
67.
SwanwickK.TillmanJ. (1986). The sequence of musical development: A study of children’s composition. British Journal of Music Education, 3, 305–339. doi:10.1017/S0265051700000814
68.
TabaH. (1966). Teaching strategies and cognitive functioning in elementary school children. San Francisco, CA: San Francisco State College.
69.
TaitM.HaackP. (1984). Principles and processes of music education. New York, NY: Teachers College Press.
70.
TausczikY.PennebakerJ. (2010). The psychological meaning of words: LIWC and computerized text analysis methods. Journal of Language and Social Psychology, 29, 24–54. doi:10.1177/0261927X09351676
71.
Ten DamG.MoniqueV. (2004). Critical thinking as a citizenship competence: Teaching strategies. Learning and Instruction, 14, 359–379.
72.
UpitisR. (1990). This too is music. Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
73.
UpitisR. (1992). Can I play you my song?Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
74.
WebsterP.RichardsonC. P. (1993). Asking children to think about music. Arts Education Policy Review, 94, 7–11.
75.
WegnerE. (1989). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press.
76.
WeikartP. S. (1982). Teaching movement and dance. Ypsilanti, MI: The High/Scope Press.
77.
WhiteheadA. N. (1967). The aims of education and other essays. New York, NY: Free Press. (Original work published 1929)
78.
WigginsJ. (2001). Teaching for musical understanding. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
79.
WilenW. W.CleggA. A. (1986). Effective questions and questioning: A research review. Theory and Research in Social Education, 14, 153–161.
80.
WilliamsonS. J. (2005) “My music”: The music making and listening experiences of seventh and eighth graders not enrolled in school music ensembles (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Washington, Seattle, WA.
81.
WillisS. (1992). Teaching thinking: Educators shift emphasis from recall to reasoning (ASCD Curriculum Update). Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.
82.
WoodfordP. G. (1995). Critical thinking in music. Canadian Music Educator, 37, 36–40.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
